forum

Ashley Tisdale and Lucas Grabeel - I Want it All

posted
Total Posts
48
Topic Starter
Mashley
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 05 April 2009 at 22:24:57

Artist: Ashley Tisdale and Lucas Grabeel
Title: I Want it All
Source: High School Musical 3
BPM: 143
Filesize: 2414kb
Play Time: 02:36
Difficulties Available:
  1. That's Better! (4.47 stars, 259 notes)
  2. Think Bigger! (1.91 stars, 69 notes)
  3. You're A Superstar! (By Wojjan) (4.84 stars, 334 notes)
Download: Ashley Tisdale and Lucas Grabeel - I Want it All
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
I have no idea why I mapped this. I don't even like High School Musical.

11th March '09 - Think Bigger completed, moved to pending.
12th March '09 - Did vytalibus' modding. THANKS VYTALIBUS! - Shinxyn told me to so snap it all, so I did. THANKS SHINXYN!
14th March '09 - Shinxyn told me to change it to 1/2 at first I thought he or she was insane but it turned out fine. THANKS AGAIN SHINXYN! Did Vexed's modding. THANKS VEXED! Did Shinxyn's modding. THANKS AGAIN AGAIN SHINXYN! :D
15th March '09 - Did Jeffro's modding. THANKS JEFFRO!
16th March '09 - Did Saturos-fangirl's modding. THANKS SATUROS-FANGIRL! Did flyboy87's modding. THANKS FLYBOY87!
17th March '09 - Did K2J's modding. THANKS K2J! Did Skyripper's modding. THANKS SKYRIPPER!
18th March '09 - Did some of Saturos-fangirl's modding. THANKS AGAIN SATUROS-FANGIRL!
19th March '09 - Turned the sound effects down a bit as Larto said. THANKS LARTO!
22nd March '09 - Added Kiai. Lots of short Kiais on That's Better and just one at the end on Think Bigger. Metroid gave me lots of spacing to do, but I just went through and spaced the whole thing. There shouldn't be amy problems with it now! THANKS METROID!
24th March '09 - Did Ichinitose's modding. THANKS ITCHINOTOSE!
25th March '09 - Did Zatoichi's modding. THANKS ZATOICHI!
27th March '09 - Did Kyocciola's modding. THANKS KYOCCIOLA!
28th March '09 - Did Ekaru's modding. THANKS EKARU! Added tons of whistles. Beatmap sounds even better now. :)
29th March '09 - Did Wojjan's modding. THANKS WOJJAN! Did Saturos-fangirl's modding. THANKS AGAIN AGAIN SATUROS-FANGIRL!
April Fools Day '09 - Did Sir_Minelli's modding. THANKS SIR_MINELLI!
3rd April '09 - Did whymeman's modding. THANKS WHYMEMAN!! Added You're A Superstar (by Wojjan). THANKS WOJJAN!! Made a few changes to Superstar, mosly hitsounds but I also changed the spinner at the end to 4 beats to make it more like the other difficulties.
4th April '09 - Did Shinxyn's modding. THANKS SHINXYN! Did Larto's modding. THANKS AGAIN LARTO! Yay bubble! Did minyeob's modding. THANKS MINYEOB!
5th April 2009 - Did RemmyX25's modding. THANKS REMMYX25!
vytalibus
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Topic Starter
Mashley
I think I did what you said to do. Thanks for the help! :) If anyone else wants to help then you are also awesome...
Shinxyn
I'd mod and give you a list... but... I can't with how its snapped atm.
I checked through both, and.... let's just say, you don't need to use 1/6.
The BPM is correct, and after checking through everything... here's what I highly suggest you do~

For BOTH diffs, changed your Beat Snap Divisor to 1/2 (yes, 1/2 is enough, no need for 1/6 or even 1/4).
Go under the Timing menu, (not where Compose, Design is.. where File, and Edit is... ) and when still in 1/2 snap, Resnap All Notes, and Recalculate Slider Lengths. Then go through both Diffs in 1/2 timing.
Vexed_old
That's Better Diff.

01:04:50 (5,6) - fix spacing
01:52:12 (7,8) - fix spacing
01:52:47 (8,9) - Move both notes ahead 1 tick.
00:41:529 Remove break and reinsert via break buttonfor correct placement.
00:55:06 (4) - New combo
00:57:15 (2) - New combo
00:58:20 (4) - New combo
01:03:03 (1) - New combo
01:03:87 (3) - New combo
01:04:50 (5) - New combo
01:04:92 (6) - Remove 6 and 7 and insert Slider in it place. Just a suggestion. I think it would work out better. If not 7 is a bit out of place it looks like.
01:04:50 (5) - New combo also for 6 and 7 sliders.
01:31:98 (7) - New combo
01:37:85 (4) - New combo
01:47:508 Remove break and re-insert. These breaks look like they may not have re-snapped.
01:52:54 (8) - New combo
01:57:787 POINT IN FACT, just remove all breaks and re-insert. :/
02:02:61 (4) - New combo
02:07:85 (1) - New combo
02:08:27 (1) - New combo
02:11:00 (3) - New combo
02:11:84 (5) - New combo
02:14:36 (3) - New combo
02:17:71 (1) - New combo
02:18:55 (3) - New combo
02:21:07 (4) - New combo
02:21:49 (5) - New combo
02:23:59 (5) - NC
02:24:43 (6) - NC
02:25:27 (7) - NC
02:27:78 (1) - NC
02:31:14 (1) - NC
02:31:98 (3) - NC
02:35:34 (1) - NC for 1 2 3 and 4

Thats all im doing for now.... I have a headache. new combos are needed. you may need one less or one more than i listed give or take but you get the idea.
Shinxyn
That's Better
00:17:29 (5) - align with (1) from same combo
00:26:94 (1) - shorten this by 1/2
00:50:65 (3,4) - slope it better/space it better
00:52:33 (5,6,7) - Confusing cuz the rest of beats match vocal, so change it or New combo
00:55:06 (4,1) - switch the combo here (4 becomes 1, and that 1 becomes 2)
00:56:31 (1) - extend by 1/2 or add a beat right after it (my opinion)
00:57:36 (2) - ^
01:04:71 (x) - add note here?
01:12:26 (1) - align with (7)?
01:18:34 (1) - Hmm, I think this would be better with a hitsound
01:20:44 (7,8,9) - I don't like how this part suddenly strays away from rest of combo
01:28:62 (1,2,3,4) - for this part, use 1/4 to match the music
01:37:85 (1,2,3,4) - align with (3)?
01:44:57 (1) - try not to overlap like this
01:52:47 (1,2) - THIS PART ISN'T SNAPPED!!
02:07:22 (1) - Don't have this covered a bit
02:14:57 (2) - have slider look more like 02:13:73 (2), so (1) and (3) don't overlap as much
02:22:54 (1) - try not to overlap like this

Think Bigger
00:41:63 (x) - the break's off
00:48:13 (1,2,3) - move 1/2 back
00:50:23 (4) - move back 1/2 and extend 1/2
01:04:08 (2,3) - the claps seem weird, either rid of them or add clap to end of 1
01:19:18 (1) - extend by 1/2
01:22:96 (x) - the map ended... so get rid of this break..

Just general parts I thought needed work, and... you need to recheck spacing for both diffs, some parts aren't evenly spaced as other (and I'm quite certain you didn't mean to). But yea, aside from people not looking at this because where it came from, the maps done well. -Stars-
Topic Starter
Mashley
Wow, someone actually said my map is well done. I feel so freakin' special! :)
Jeffro
00:49:18 (1,2,3,4) - This isn't distance snapped and if it is.. Well it would be 0.85 xD

00:57:15 (1,2, 1) - Not distance snapped.

00:59:67 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Not distance snapped too. It's fine to use different values sometime but not in the same combo please xD

Ensure your distance snap button is on.

The part before "red carpet" could be better so I fixed that for you. Attached a .osu file you can look at to copy paste it into your existing map :)

I'm sure there are more distance space issues so try to fix that.

Starred for being an awesome map!

Download: Ashley Tisdale and Lucas Grabeel - I Want it All (Agent Spin Here) [Better supersound XD].osu
Yuukari-Banteki
Just a friendly reminder that what I say is mostly *suggestion* on how to possibly improve your map and not a *command* that you change your map!

[Think Bigger!]
00:17:29 (3) - spacing feels wide here
00:18:76 (1) - line this up with the end of 3
00:33:87 (1) - start this 1/2 later
00:54:01 (1) - line this up with the previous slider
00:57:15 (1) - ^
01:12:26 (1) - line this up with 5


[That's Better!]
00:18:34 (1) - line this up with 5
00:57:36 (2,1) - overlap looks messy
01:01:56 (6) - spacing?
01:04:50 (1) - line up with 2
01:08:69 (1) - line up with 4
01:29:15 (4) - imperfect stacking
01:31:98 (1) - line this up vertically with 6?
01:53:38 (2) - spacing?
02:11:00 (1) - note is completely and illegally hidden
02:11:84 (1) - ^
flyboy87
[Think Bigger!]
17:822 (3) - Extend to 17:927
51:703 - Adding a note here sounds good
58:836 (2) - Shift this to 58:626

[That's Better!]
20:025 (1) - Move this slider down 1 grid
39:116 (1) - I feel that this slider looks confusing...
1:28:522 (1) - Remove this and place it in 1:28731. Remove the slider as well as it doesn't fit that part very well. I'm not good in explaining it in words, so... here's a screenshot. Notice that I use the 1/6 snap divisor

1:34:710 - Clap sound overload @___@
2:24:431 (1) - Move this slider 4 grids to the right
2:25:270 (1) - And move this 2 grids to the right
2:28:417 (3) - Move this to 2:28:626

I don't watch High School Musical, but this is a nice song, lol!

Star~
Topic Starter
Mashley
I did most of your modding flyboy, apart from a few things that I felt didn't benefit from changing. Thanks for the star! ^_^

K2J
Pretty good; the more varied spacing is exciting, but it, of course, can be confusing:

[Think Bigger!]
00:32:61 (1) - I feel like hitting this early, for some reason.
00:37:43 (1) - Maybe you could do some other direction with this one than with the other two so the user knows it might be a different repeat length?
00:58:83 (2) - This whole section feels odd, but with practice I think it's fine. This beat in particular throws me off.

[That's Better!]
00:32:61 (1) - Same as above; I hit this early for some reason. Maybe the jump is making me overestimate when the beat will be?
00:57:36 (2) - This (and its predecessor) aren't symmetric. I know they are symmetric when you account for each other, but it still caught my eye.
01:28:52 (1,2,3,4,1) - I think this should all be shifted one blue tick to the right. Sorry if that contradicts what someone told you earlier...
02:35:34 (1,2,3,4) - Isn't this overdoing it a bit?

Very engaging - star.
Topic Starter
Mashley
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Skyripper
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Jeffro
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Yuukari-Banteki
Just a friendly reminder that what I say is mostly *suggestion* on how to possibly improve your map and not a *command* that you change your map!

[Think Bigger!]
00:17:29 (3) - this is too far from 2
00:37:43 (1,1) - stack
01:12:26 (1,2) - ^


[That's Better!]
00:56:31 (1,1,2) - line these up
01:07:64 (4,1,2,3,4) - stack
01:28:55 (1,2,3,4,1) - snap


otherwise pretty good, I'd suggest looking for a BAT soon
Jeffro
01:28:55 (1,2,3,4,1) - snap
That means its still on the wrong time. It should be on 01:28:62
Larto
Pretty nice map. I actually kinda like the song ;3


Overall:
Sounds a bit more quiet, they overtone the music.

Otherwise, this is close to rank!






EDIT: HOLY FUCK, MY 1000TH POST IS ON A HSM MAP. AM I GAY OR WHAT


Larto, you don't have to ask, actually.
Topic Starter
Mashley
Done! Thanks for checking out my map Larto. Congratulations on your 1000th post. :lol:
Larto
Fuuuuuuuuck, I totally didn't notice:

- Inherit all the sections.

- Make the preferred skin "User's choice"
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply