get rid of it before it lays eggs
forum
[Proposal] Silenced slider slide/tick hitsounds
posted
Total Posts
28
I actually wonder why this is not a thing yet.
Definitely yes.
Definitely yes.
yehaj
separate the blending stuff or something but otherwise yeah, agree this should be a guideline
just a normal user passing by
I don't want to see this change
YES PLEASE
yes
Hailie wrote:
yes
BIG agree
It's ok to have them as a guideline.
There are circumstances that silenced sliderticks and sliderslide are the best option.
So yeah, I agree with it. But make sure to don't make a full difficulty with both things silenced.
There are circumstances that silenced sliderticks and sliderslide are the best option.
So yeah, I agree with it. But make sure to don't make a full difficulty with both things silenced.
can agree that more flexibility should be given
Yes. It always make beatmaps sound weird.
please yes yes please
Topic Starter
ok as expected nobody's opposed
this is the wording for the future guideline:
so it basically includes the "exhaustive reasoning" allowed for breaking the guideline in the actual wording. moving to guidelines isnt gonna be a free pass to ignore it under all circumstances sorry
this is the wording for the future guideline:
- You should not silence both slider ticks and slider slides together. Silencing both for small sections or single objects can be appropriate, but doing so for a whole map will result in a disqualification.
so it basically includes the "exhaustive reasoning" allowed for breaking the guideline in the actual wording. moving to guidelines isnt gonna be a free pass to ignore it under all circumstances sorry
I don't see the reason as to why you can't silence the whole map. There are ranked sets that mute the slider slide and/or tick hitsounds of the entire map and it hasn't caused any problems and in my opinion, has made it audibly better.pishifat wrote:
ok as expected nobody's opposed
this is the wording for the future guideline:so it basically includes the "exhaustive reasoning" allowed for breaking the guideline in the actual wording. moving to guidelines isnt gonna be a free pass to ignore it under all circumstances sorry
- You should not silence both slider ticks and slider slides together. Silencing both for small sections or single objects can be appropriate, but doing so for a whole map will result in a disqualification.
Yes
Yes
Yes
I agree with Nitrous, some songs like https://osu.ppy.sh/s/549354 might be better to silence the slider slide and slider tick together for the whole map.Nitrous wrote:
I don't see the reason as to why you can't silence the whole map. There are ranked sets that mute the slider slide and/or tick hitsounds of the entire map and it hasn't caused any problems and in my opinion, has made it audibly better.
Topic Starter
- Frontier - wrote:
I agree with Nitrous, some songs like https://osu.ppy.sh/s/549354 might be better to silence the slider slide and slider tick together for the whole map.
i mean uhh that map doesn't even have sliders long enough to support sliderticks so being muted isn't relevant lol. if it had sliders longer than 1/1 they'd deserve unmuted ticks since there's sounds each beat
better to think of "slide and tick muted through the whole map" in terms of a map that has sliders with ticks throughout it, like anything with tick rate 2. if there's a bunch of ticks passing over sounds and they're all muted + sliderslide isn't present, you're doing something wrong
Topic Starter
moved, included in https://osu.ppy.sh/community/forums/topics/717741