eldnl wrote:

u need a ctb diff but there are too many diffies and you are so close to the bubble :<

Byakugan249 wrote:

eh? do i get kd since you and other mappers applied some of my suggestions?

wmfchris wrote:

[2ana and climbb]
01:31:564 - you didn't put duplets elsewhere and it sounds poorly in a quiet section here.
There's a hihat sound then IK just follow it. I think it's suitable.
01:46:967 - ^ the dkd don't fit the 1/1 vocal, and there's a clear accent at the last which does not fit with dkd
I'm following thee drum not the vocal, so I think that's ok.
03:03:418 - I highly recommed to avoid 1/4 patterns as they stick to much with the coming notes and may mislead players seriosuly
Change a little bit. It should be more playable now.
03:06:142 - finish according to the accent
No change here, cuz there is no any cymbal or other strong drum sound.

後面的5連串有變化 相比起來前面的dkkkk dkkkk dkkkk略怪

change a little, the whole pattern seems ok to me.

maybe you'll want a bit more taiko mod <_<

fartownik wrote:

[Gu's Hard]

This is not a Hard for sure. That gives us 4 Insane diffs, you know what it means. Insane?why do you think so.just this song is high BPM.if I move this beats and jumps to a song which is low BPM.then It plays easier,why we need to design all hard diff as one diffculty?high BPM is already a challenge itself.I can't do it much easier.It's a real hard diff for this song,I'm sure.
00:30:999 - Why exactly is the music going down on the volume here? Fix this if there's no reason at all.fixed others
01:05:838 - It would be nice if you add something here. A circle, slider, anything. Free space is just not what the player expects.no
03:04:244 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - You might not see it but the spacing here should change according to the music. The space between all the beats is different so it should be same in the playfield.If you see them carefully.their spacings are not the same.though It shows nearly the same like 1.0x 1.01x. 0.99x.

Byakugan249 wrote:

[SG's Normal]
Increase the HP and OR by 1. it'll flow a lot smoother to the song during gameplay. Good idea, it fits the difficulty spread better.
00:14:218 (1) - for consistency purposes on easy, remove the NC on this note. The new combo is here to create a new combo every two measures. The first note doesn't fit in with the pattern so it gets its own combo.
00:24:218 - maybe add a circle, or remove (4) and add a 1/1 slider to follow vocals accurately? Eh, it's hard to make the spacing work if I do that. So I'll keep it for now.
00:27:121 (1) - replace the finish for a whistle. i don't hear anything climatic coming up like the cymbals, or the rise in vocals. Done.
00:28:734 (2) - replace the whistle for a clap. yes it matches in vocals, but it ruins the consistency in claps There was consistency in the claps? I think a whistle sounds better here.
00:29:702 (1,2,3,4) - switch the hitsounds for (1,3). if you want to keep the consistency, you should do this. it'll sound a lot nicer during gameplay. i also felt a bit uncomfortable when i hit (1,3). it sounds weird IMO.
00:37:444 (1,2,3) - similar as above, but same as 00:27:121, and replace the whistle for a clap on (2) to match the drums. the whistle doesn't fit with the part at all.
00:52:282 (4) - add a finish at the beginning. it goes well with that sound IMO. Okay.
01:05:508 - you should add a circle just to make sure that players don't hit the next note too early due to vocals, or remove (1) and replace it for a 1/1 slider. The spacing of this part should make it readable.
01:09:702 (3,4) - add finishes on these notes to match the cymbals in the song. I'll keep these the way they are now, because I don't want too many finishes in a row.
01:15:831 - same as easy. I prefer the way it is now.
01:27:766 (3) - the clap should be at the end, not at the repeat arrow. it sounds bad and it ruins the consistency in claps.
01:34:863 (2) - you can do 2 things: replace the whistle for a clap since you have a clap on the repeat arrow of (3), or add a clap with the whistle since you have a clap at the repeat arrow, and a whistle at the end of (3).
01:41:960 (1) - similar as above. add a finish with the clap to match the cymbals or replace the clap for a finish. same reason. Alright.
01:52:282 (1) - i don't remember you doing this at the 1st part before the kiai. make this repeat once and add a circle. with the 1/1 slider in effect and where that note is, players might get "too" nervous and might let go at the 2nd repeat. I think it's okay. The player has 646 ms to recognize the second repeat and it's a slow slider.
02:07:444 - same as 01:05:508.
02:18:089 - hmm in this case, add a circle here with a finish. the 1/1 slider would look bad if it's following the drums. anyways my reason is that it'll match the cymbals. Same here.
02:22:040 - *nazi* move the break back to the white tick. that's where the drums start. Tee hee, okay.
02:32:927 (5,6) - to follow the vocals a lot smoother, replace this for a 1/1 slider. it'll fit with the long pause in vocals. I think the current pattern is a bit neater, imagine it as a very slow stream for a Normal.
02:41:960 - similar as easy, but the circle isn't there, and same suggestions as easy. I think this is fine.
03:10:321 - maybe you can add a circle to follow the drums? Added for now.

Chewin wrote:

[General]
Rename the dksslqj Style in dksslqj's Style

[Easy]
00:50:354 (3) - I would use new combo here since there is a new vocal rhythm no. it's also consistent with 01:51:644 (2) -
01:05:515 (1) - Why don't you move this circle to 01:05:838? It's symmetric with 00:55:515 (1,2) and I think it fits much better the song for an easy diff. Or simply you could to add a circle after this one on the long white tick
01:39:386 (1) - Finish? no. it's not a single sentence to start (or end), just some middle point so don't really fit.
02:07:451 (1) - The same of point (2)? ...it's a Easy. maybe you mean stack the next 2 on this? then no because it still needs a move imo + stack is not that good in Easy diffs...
02:52:612 (1) - ^ ^
03:08:708 (2) - Move to x:336 y:264 for a better blanket k.

[SG's Normal]
00:50:354 (1) - Remove clap, it sounds bad D: ..sounds fine for me.
01:52:289 (1) - ^ on the repeat ..sounds fine for me.
This is awesome.

[0108]
01:03:096 (2,3,1,2) - Val wtf? Have you tried to play this piece? °-° This is really impossibile to read. ..i've seen him playing this a few times.
I tried to play it more times and to hit the 01:03:418 (1) after 01:03:257 (3) is impossible. I mean, you need to play it more times before to hit it..
The map is funny to play, but just I wrote above..

I want to bubble this ç_ç RANK PL0X <3

EDIT: OMG.. Bubbled, nvm. lol

- fixed break
- NC and hitsound fix