ngl i am confused since it would be circles but i feel like the angle/distance to aim for 01:22:072 (6) - is decent for emphasis. i dont think the chord change is so pronounced that it necessarily is bad to do it my way >.<
though ill think about this maybe cause maybe something can be cooked with 2 circles idk
ehhh i see what you mean but honestly i think if i removed slider 00:10:488 (4) - id more likely want to just make it a circle plus slider so thats it like 00:14:943 (3,4,5) - but i dont really want to mess with that ngl. maybe im wrong idk
i randomly look at latest pending/wip maps and click on ones that look like they could be interesting (i.e. not 8 star spam, usually stuff like 4* maps)
(I doubt a BN would reject this map on the basis of this one slider and would prob tell me to change it if they agreed with you, so let me keep this slider a little while longer 🙏
do i actually have to remove this 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 ?
i thought it kind of fits since this whole map is kind of wacky so its not that crazy to have something like this and the held vocals are kind of significant and loud
can i just appeal to wait until this set maybe gets BNs to look at it cause I feel like everytime I change something based on a modder's feedback, I change something that BNs might not have an issue with and then I end up nerfing my map for nothing
yeah reopen if you really feel like it but I think this slider fits in this style of map. in a more simpler map style, it makes sense to follow everything in the rhythm down to a T, however I feel like there is more leeway with maps that look like this
this one is just my opinion, but i just prefer it like this, especially the visuals
ofc there is a small jump for emphasis but I really don't like the movement going down and then moving cursor all the way up just to go back down again (?)
idk if that makes
no because i like having something to fill in the gaps between the sliders,
true i understand the vocal part but it feels awkward have that random gap when the other two have a circle after and imo would be nicer.
this is a very subjective opinion and cant put into words that great
no because this kinda nitpicky, it's different, but not enough imo to warrant making it a diff slidershape or making it into circles to ruin visuals of the copy paste mirror type pattern
in a different scenario, maybe i'd take your thought into account but i think this is still fine
Nah its fine, I'll just apply most them instead of waffling on and making some excuse that I "just prefer it like this" or "its my style" because honestly it's a bit tedious and I wasnt expecting so many mods. For instance, with this rhythm mod, my response would've just been that I kind of just like the way it plays and how the pattern looks.
(I mapped this whole thing in less than a day so I didnt start making every rhythm and pattern with some well thought out idea in mind, I just went with the flow and mapped whichever way felt right to me)
Also I get the feeling that if I apply every one of the mods that forces me to change rhythm/pattern, the mods will accumulate and my map will eventually look like the biggest pile of crap.
maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan, can noone give me a break ;_;
this map gonna the most boring thing if i remove/change everything
also btw i'm not actually stupid, i know main vocals is what i "should be following" , I just didn't feel like it because i thought it would kinda fit
i'll uuuuuuuuuuuh, maybe remove it idk
I wanted to be unique ^_^
Also, I'm pretty sure it would have been boring if i just did the shorter ones since it wouldn't be anything special compared to the rest of the kiai. ofc if BNs are interested in the set, I can remove the slider and just map it normal if they don't like it lol
i personally want to see the opinion of actual BNs or someone who i'd consider to be more proficient at mapping, since as you said, its only just your opinion so who knows, maybe the diff is not quite as bad!
never give up! 💪💪💪
im a failure, apologies
(I let the set owner know that they didn't have to use my diff they didnt want to before i even made the map!!!!)
(also i know its a very simple song but the set owner seemingly wanted me to make a map something a bit like this. sure it isn't perfect i guess but what can we do at the end of the day ;_; )
i see what you mean but i dont want to make this a jump fest, but i can definitely see this being a point a bn would def not like as much.
not gonna change rn if not necessary but alternatives i have in mind are:
. make sliders way faster so its giga hard to go back and forth
. spam 1/4 sliders as jumps essentially but this would be a huge diff spike, even i were to do it with circles instead
conclusion: true, but if it works...
nahhhhh, this is fine imo
let bns decide whether its really needs to be more readable
i agree it can be a bit misleading but i feel like if you paused for a second (i know you can't reasonably do so ingame whilst playing), you can tell which way the slider is likely to go
im not japanese but isnt it more like "se noh"?
also nah, feels much better ≠ better in this context (maybe id agree if i mapped this whole map more differently in general)
more contrast!!!
also if i want to be more specific, the " se noh " is kind of at a point where the melody stops and holds? idk any terminology but i just keep those in a slow sv state and then it release back into high sv as the melody resumes?
im torn on this but the "movement" feels nicer going up to down with that slider in my head because of the previous down to up movement from the slider at 01:00:090 (3) -
(i agree its a bit easy but id hope that the sudden increase in sv and the low spacing of 01:00:642 (4,5,6) - can make up for it by contrast?)
could change my mind later but maybe id change the slider shape to a wave or something cause im not sure the current slider shape works with ctrl+g visually imo. appreciate the idea
you're overthinking rn lol. i just placed the circles evenly cause it seemed good
moved the 00:55:857 (3) - a bit lower and a bit to the right but not as much as your ss
(discussed in dms, either im schizo or i dont see the problem with the position of 1 since its on the big white tick with the big sound! but im adding a circle at 00:49:691 since there is a sound there too)
for the 00:50:520 (1,2,3) - part, i dont want to overwhelm everything with just 1/4 sliders all the time. i end the previous section with two 00:49:783 (1,2) - and then a couple after at 00:51:808 (4,5) - . hard to explain my rationale, but id rather keep some jumps because i dont want to spam so many sliders all the time.
also for the flow change part in the ss, i might consider it but for now im fine with the climax there being that :/