1. MBomb's Platter (2,77 stars, 137 notes)
2. Salad (1,97 stars, 78 notes)
3. Zura's Cup (1,48 stars, 61 notes)

Krfawy wrote:

Moim zdaniem: BPM 143.110, offset - 161.

Mam nadzieję, że nie zwaliłem. ;_;

PS.: Nie, nie są randomowe. XD

KatamuShadowPie wrote:

Hi, I modding only cup. You shouldn't use patterns with dash. In this places, distance is too big:
00:02:257 - 00:02:886
00:02:886 - 00:03:515
00:13:786 (3,4,5) (too hard for cup)
00:18:817 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - (sometimes I can't catch this)

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

Zura's Cup

00:00:789 (2) - Move this to 288, whilst it's possible without dashing it's very annoying to do without dashing. Well i Decreased it a bit
00:02:257 (4) - Make this an NC. Done
00:05:401 (3) - Move this to x:320, 00:06:030 (4) - to x:224 and 00:06:449 (5) - to x:144. Nope
00:08:336 (5) - NC. I Don't Think It fits
00:09:803 (2) - Move to x:288, and move 00:10:223 (4) - to x:304, and 00:10:432 (5) - to x:208. I Did some Changes there xD
00:19:342 (6) - Remove this note. I Move it Here 00:09:803 (2) - It Looks Better Now
00:20:599 (2) - Move this to x:400. No its better with that Spacing But i Move the Slider End to x : 448
00:21:752 (5) - NC. Not There ... But i Changed it After it here 00:23:429 -
00:25:526 (6) - ^ Yup Done

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

Got asked to do a mod.

Salad

00:08:546 (5) - Move this to x:224.
00:11:690 (6) - NC.
00:12:529 (8) - Move this to x:208.
00:15:045 (6) - NC.
00:16:932 (1) - Make this a 1/2 slider repeating once.
00:18:818 (1) - Move this to x:352.
00:19:866 (6) - Change to a 1/2 slider, and then a 1/2 slider on the 2nd 1/1, and then a circle on the last 1/1.
00:23:640 (9) - NC.
00:26:155 (2,3,4,5,6) - Move this whole section to the left so that 00:26:155 (2) - is on x:384.
00:26:994 (6) - Remove this note and have the spinner start here instead. I am not sure about that but k
rest done as you said

Ok done

snowball112 wrote:

Heya o/ random mod because why not.

Zura's Cup

IMPORTANT:Your note density is very high. Too high.This is not okay. I feel like you should not use 1/4 spaced notes at all and use only few of 1/2. Nope (I Meant to Make it a Bit Hard Because Cups Are like Other Diffs For example we Found ( Easy Rains and Challenging Rains ) So ...And Since there is no need to dash it's still Considered a Cup that Helps Newbies to Gain More Readability etc Which will help them to improve)
- You should nerf the density of stuff like:
- 00:05:401 (3,4) Well 2 times Asked to Decrease Spacing here ... So i Agree
- 00:18:817 (3,4,5) etc. No It's Not That Hard
Even if there is not much movement, you have to bear in mind that new players will not be familiar with reading a lot of notes. Then this Diff Will help them to Improve their Readability Without Dashing xD

- SV 1.6 is pretty high considering this is a cup. Maybe use 1.4 instead? No I Already Decreased it Once

- I think it is not necessary for you to include changes in the SV multiplier Its necessary in That Sections

- I feel like you should move 00:07:078 (1) and 00:07:498 (3) a bit to the left. I feel like newer players will miss here. Somehow Deal with it

- Remove 00:20:599 (2). This does not look pretty and the back-and-forth here does not fit well in my opinion. No i Won't Ignore that Sound its important but i Decreased the spacing of That Note

Also for all diffs maybe reduce hitsound volume a bit? 80% works fine in my opinion. 100% feels a bit too loud.

That's all from me. Good luck ^^

snowball112 wrote:

Heya o/ random mod because why not.

Salad

- I don't think it's a good idea to use the spinner 00:03:515 (1). This is because of two reasons:
1. You have instruments you can map to.
2. Your map is so short that I think it's good to have only the final spinner and notes everywhere else to be more fun in general.

- I think the two sliders 00:00:161 (1,2) would be better if you don't curve them as much.

- 00:09:595 (1,2) These sliders just feel weird because you have the slider ends on the strong beats. Maybe move things around to have a single note at 00:09:595 and start sliders on the white ticks following that? Would sound better in my opinion. You've done similar things before this point, so this suggestion applies to those as well, for example 00:07:079 (1).

- I feel like you should move 00:17:561 (2) to the left before the following slider because it flows better in my opinion.

Also for all diffs maybe reduce hitsound volume a bit? 80% works fine in my opinion. 100% feels a bit too loud.

That's all from me. Good luck ^^

DragonSlayer96 wrote:

mod request on #ctb or a poke mod, I cant remember anymore

General

Tags conflict across the difficulties done

Take out the countdown and letter box throughout the difficulties done


Please set a preview point done


Take out Widescreen support also throughout the difficulties done

The mapset itself doesn't feel like it steps up right in difficulty when you try the different difficulties. Platter does seem more like a rain and the Salad is more on the high end of what I expect it to be, but Cup is generally what I expect off of a cup

DragonSlayer96 wrote:

mod request on #ctb or a poke mod, I cant remember anymore

General

Tags conflict across the difficulties

Take out the countdown and letter box throughout the difficulties

Please set a preview point

Take out Widescreen support also throughout the difficulties

Cup

00:05:401 (3,4) - too hard to go from one to the other on a cup level map
00:06:449 (5,1) - ^
00:07:078 (1,2,3,4) - please reduce the distance on these I think my Noob skill would be Able to Catch it After Some Tries
00:20:495 (1,2,3) - too hard for a cup difficulty

The mapset itself doesn't feel like it steps up right in difficulty when you try the different difficulties. Platter does seem more like a rain and the Salad is more on the high end of what I expect it to be, but Cup is generally what I expect off of a cup

snowball112 wrote:

Heya o/ random mod because why not.

MBomb's Platter

- Similar to salad: don't use a spinner like 00:10:847 (1). You have instruments here and I think it's more fitting if you only use the final spinner. I feel like you're taking away from the map's potential otherwise. - Yeah I wasn't sure about this anyway.

- My main concern with this diff is from the beginning up until 00:06:864 (2). Yes the 1/4 fits. However it might be better for emphasis and structure of your diff if you do not map out all the 1/4 and have a bit of 1/2 in between to create a bit of variety which would be more fun to play in my opinion. For example, you could remove 00:00:262 (2) and 00:00:471 (4) and have a bit of back-and-forth movement within that 1/2. I just think that it might look nicer and be more fun to play if you put a bit more structure into the intro, - I prefer mapping it in 1/4, the sliders, I feel are enough emphasis on the 1/2.

That's all from me. Good luck ^^