forum

[resolved] Auto/replay misses when commenting right before note [confirmed]

posted
Total Posts
15
Topic Starter
jemhuntr
Yes. osu! auto mod made a miss.

1. Play any map (I guess...?)
2. open up the discussions, and post a comment while osu! is playing
3. osu! would miss.

Screenie:
here's a screenshot. Notice the accuracy.
MillhioreF
This also happens with spectator mode if the host pauses or the replay buffers right before a note is hit. I'm not sure how possible it is to fix.
lolcubes
Did you minimize your osu! ?
Usually when you minimize osu! then auto will not spin on spinners and will make a miss. Not sure why though.
Archangel Tirael
Confirm it. I can reproduce this. It also reproducible in taiko. I fund this bug month ago, but forgot create thread. ._.
Rei Hakurei
in taiko you can click lalalalallala~ also ctb and mania 0ms-ness
cokeshawty

Rei_Fan49 wrote:

in taiko you can click lalalalallala~ also ctb and mania 0ms-ness
TheVileOne
I can replicate this. You need to time it just right though. Low priority though.
chelly
This doesn't bother me personally, but it happens to be a little bug I found accidentally.

You should know that when watching a replay, clicking "Show Discussion" and clicking the text box will pause the replay for you to type, right? But it just so happens that if you're watching a replay and "pause" the replay using this method at a certain time after an approach circle closes around a hit circle, the replay will register the note as a "Miss" or sometimes a "100" when it was supposed to be a 300.

Many players may not notice it, but there seem to be many things happening when a note is tapped during a replay. Based on what I have observed, hitting a note during a replay will trigger the following process:
SPOILER
• Approach circle is closing in
• The approach circle is fully closed, and the player taps the note perfectly
• The approach ring disappears, but the hit circle is still visible for a tiny period
• There is an almost unnoticeable delay. The points are being registered right now.

• The points are registered
• The whole hit circle disappears.
• A 300 is displayed

When this bug occurs, pausing the replay will interrupt the point registration and you won't get the full points you earned.
SPOILER
• Approach circle is closing in
• The approach circle is fully closed, and the note is tapped perfectly
• The approach ring disappears, but the hit circle is still visible for milliseconds
There is a delay before the whole note disappears. The points are being registered.
You pause the replay, thus interrupting the point registration.
• You resume the replay
• The points are not registered correctly
• The hit circle disappears.
• A Miss or 100 is displayed

How to reproduce:
1) Go to any replay (preferably one with an SS grade so you can easily catch the bug)
2) At any point of the replay where an approach circle is about to close onto a note or at the moment it does, pause the replay using the "Discussion" box method. This may be hard to pull off, but keep trying. Remember that the hit circle should be closed, but the points should be registering.
3) If done correctly, the hit circle should still be visible, but the approach circle should be gone.
4) Click anywhere outside the text box to "resume" the replay, and you'll find that the hit circle was not hit or hit off-time.
5) This can be done as many times as you wish throughout the map. This seems to work best with normal notes; sliders don't bug as much but it may happen.

Screenshots of the same replay are shown below:
SPOILER
Below, the note that my cursor is on was just hit, and the points are not yet fully registered. The replay is currently paused. Notice how the hit circle is still there but the approach ring is gone.

The next screenshot is of the same note right after I resumed. You can see I "missed" the note.

This is the ranking screen of the replay. I appear to have an SS grade, despite "missing" several notes throughout the replay.
zinckingeye
confirm

error in my replay(SS,100%)


KinkiN
Have the same issue
Hayden_old
its a slider break that's all
chelly

Hayden wrote:

its a slider break that's all
This bug affects every note, not just sliders. Even on replays with 100% SS (no slider breaks, no misses, no 100s, etc) the replay will fail to correctly show the points earned.
MillhioreF
Duplicate thread; however, the OP is very detailed and useful. I'll merge instead.
theowest
Just want to mention that this has always been happening ever since commenting on replays was implemented.
Ryu Sei
Yup. Bump it.
osu!topus missed it.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply