Cleaned up the thread. Please keep the memes for reddit, guys. Let's only post stuff that helps the mapper.

further adjusted some patterns, added a slidertick hitsound for the slow slider

the black SB disappears during the spinner which is kind of d (only an issue w/ transparent spinners)
if anyone knows how to fix this please let me know

this map is plagued with inconsistencies, i'll see if i can get around to modding it

without it getting ranked tomorrow or something

Following up, wtf is that mod reply, neither did you repsond to sugeestions you did not apply nor to the ones you did and leaving it with "things not mentioned were addressed in some way or another" is just an easy opt out.

til inconsistencies regardless of them being intentional or not r BAD

viptwo wrote:

this map is plagued with inconsistencies, i'll see if i can get around to modding it

without it getting ranked tomorrow or something

Following up, wtf is that mod reply, neither did you repsond to sugeestions you did not apply nor to the ones you did and leaving it with "things not mentioned were addressed in some way or another" is just an easy opt out.

opt out of what? you'd rather see him post a wall of fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed?

the point of replying like this is to only give a reply to things that need reasoning. if he ignored parts of fiery's mod, fiery is free to come here and call him out on it.

deetz wrote:

viptwo wrote:

this map is plagued with inconsistencies, i'll see if i can get around to modding it

without it getting ranked tomorrow or something

Following up, wtf is that mod reply, neither did you repsond to sugeestions you did not apply nor to the ones you did and leaving it with "things not mentioned were addressed in some way or another" is just an easy opt out.

opt out of what? you'd rather see him post a wall of fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed?

the point of replying like this is to only give a reply to things that need reasoning. if he ignored parts of fiery's mod, fiery is free to come here and call him out on it.

Every mapper is supposed to respond to a mod appropriately, that includes stating why you have/havent applied something from a mod.

viptwo wrote:

viptwo wrote:

this map is plagued with inconsistencies, i'll see if i can get around to modding it

without it getting ranked tomorrow or something

Following up, wtf is that mod reply, neither did you repsond to sugeestions you did not apply nor to the ones you did and leaving it with "things not mentioned were addressed in some way or another" is just an easy opt out.

Every mapper is supposed to respond to a mod appropriately, that includes stating why you have/havent applied something from a mod.

Since when is every mapper supposed to respond proper to a mod? The modding system is informal at best and shouldn't be treated as otherwise——nor should it ever be. If you don't understand a map, then don't bother making suggestions to the map; if you do, then expect the worst.

can i keep this around and quote you on this byfar? it'll be useful as a catch-all excuse when i want to bullshit aside criticism on my more experiemental maps

byfar wrote:

http://puu.sh/sgXoX/6546cc1a02.png

Ok?
I don't consider not replying at all as "say what needs to be said in order to explain yourself" but ok.

Anyways, let's keep this discussion to proper mods and proper mod-replies again, that would be nice, yes.

I may have gotten a 37 on my factoring polynomials test, but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize that the majority of discussion taking place is unhelpful and pointless in furthering the map to a qualified state. This whole Code of Conduct thing can be resolved quite easily in PM, but all of you loudmouths want to make yourselves known to the world by posting it in the thread instead. Instead of posting useless text about "waah RLC didn't reply to my mod", try asking him in PM to specify what he changed / why he didn't. Even then, I'm pretty sure RLC replied to it just fine, and in fact, most people reply to mods like that anyways. People are just trying to find ways to charge RLC with doing something wrong to create more pointless drama around this map. As desperate-kun and bonsai said, let's only post stuff that helps the mapper. Thanks!

In my personal opinion your (RLC) new diff "consistent" far outranks the old diff and in my (Sing) opinion, should be put up for "approval" instead.

Sing wrote:

In my personal opinion your (RLC) new diff "consistent" far outranks the old diff and in my (Sing) opinion, should be put up for "approval" instead.

thank mr. viptwo

moving on

moving on

i forgot that this is 2016 and scorev2 exists so i've killed the 1/4 sliders starting on blue ticks

... if bss will just let me update

01:49:342 (5,1) - blanket is fukd gud job rlc

some nit pick

02:25:624 (2) - i think u shud stack at 1 ~.~ the pitch is same
02:49:263 - missing circle (?)
03:07:719 (2) - the only circle after 3/4 that is not overlapped on this section hmm
03:30:651 (4,2) - since its the same element why not make (2) as 1/4 sliders too
03:29:551 (1) - dont need nc i guess , put here 03:33:321 (6) - instead looks more consistent
03:43:687 (4) - nc here the violin splits by group of 3 and 03:44:630 (4,1) - swap nc
04:12:902 (1) - hax it to blue looks good i think .. since it was pink before also its the most special slider in the map
good contrast could fit

....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

bub 2

2016-11-15 17:48 Ascendance: kill yourself

this is y ur not a bn

RLC wrote:

2016-11-15 17:48 Ascendance: kill yourself

this is y ur not a bn

will ascendance ever stop flaming people
find out next time on loctav's wild ride

Re-nomination #1, good luck!

thanks!

bubel

01:27:509 (2,3) - floowww, it not pretty good between 2 and 3, ctrl+g on 2?
01:40:075 (4,5) - same as above, how about 3/4 here
02:32:378 (1) - imo it will make some affect for reading

really something
no kd if u want

Rizia wrote:

01:27:509 (2,3) - floowww, it not pretty good between 2 and 3, ctrl+g on 2? changed this a little
01:40:075 (4,5) - same as above, how about 3/4 here i made it weak like this because the backing in the music cuts out at 01:40:232 - and 01:40:546 - . the reason i did 01:35:048 (4,5,6) - differently is because the kiai just started so i wanted it to be stronger
02:32:378 (1) - imo it will make some affect for reading fixed

thanks!

Seems like there've actually been quite a few things changed in this map after initially being bubbled right away, huh?

qw3e4

Bonsai wrote:

Seems like there've actually been quite a few things changed in this map after initially being bubbled right away, huh?

haha very witty

but if you were a tad wittier you might consider 1) the nature of things being ""fixed"" and 2) the cumulative effect of such changes across the span of two weeks

edit: im only being an ass because your post serves literally no purpose except to say "case in point," which isn't even valid

Salt is bitter.

oh no he changed things that must mean the map was made better by my passive-aggressive and pointless comments i feel so much better now

nice! map!

#2

thank you!

why is it taking so long to rank this?

salt is salty

wtf is wrong with your tastebuds `L _`

nice map btw! glad you changed the background to my edit !! <-- constructive comment so my comment doesnt get wastelanded

we fixed some unrankable issues
(hitsounds with delay and also hitsounds being too short)

so... rebubbling

#2

thanks again :d

here's proof your beatmap is massive good

donger

gratz

Good job

Gratz

gratz

how it doesn't egggs

nerd

Desperate-kun wrote:

memes for reddit

mo-...... more?



01:04:263 (2) - This is 1/6 not 1/8, the most strongest beats are 01:04:263 - here 01:04:315 - here and 01:04:368 - here, not how you have it now.

CanadianBaka wrote:

01:04:263 (2) - This is 1/6 not 1/8, the most strongest beats are 01:04:263 - here 01:04:315 - here and 01:04:368 - here, not how you have it now.

that was pointed out on the first page; 1/8 is correct...

I still hear 1/6, but I don't think arguing would help.



Godo job

no dued u donut undRESTAND I CHekd in ABELTON ok??

No u (rlc isnt srs btw but i also hear the snaps rlc is saying)

Star Shooter
216 posts
Offline Send private message United States

No kudosu yet.
2 months ago
I'm sorry, but this is excessive. In less than 2/10ths of a second, you make the player go almost entirely across the screen, with AR9.4 and OD9. No, this is not okay. I get that this is 177bpm with a relatively low SV, but that still doesn't mean you should you 10+ DS. I can't even remember seeing that outside of VERY slow songs or TAG maps. This is neither, and considering the sound mapped, it makes no sense when compared to the next combo. So, you made a jump with less than a 1/10th of a second gap that large because...? This is a jump all the way across the screen with a comfy 84ms to react with. There's no possible musical justification for this. This is overmapping. WAY overmapping. There is NOTHING warranting this, considering how tame the riffs here are. This is many things: Overmapped, ugly, and needless. I'm listening to the same instruments as you, and nothing is there that warrants you doing this with such distance. Okay, that part of the song is barely of any note whatsoever. Stop putting in these jumps just because you feel like it. This is just a mess. There's a big difference making compact streams and basically testing the limits of the stack leniency. This looks absolutely terrible. Clean it up a bit. These are very clearly overmapped. Disgustingly so. Same deal. Just because a computer can flawlessly do it does not mean you should slap it everywhere. I am convinced you did this solely to bump up SR. There is never any reason to do crap like this. Nothing musically, especially. Same deal. Same deal. Same deal. This part is so tame, and yet you act like you're mapping speedcore. Stop doing ridiculous things just to raise SR! Same deal. Again, stop taking tame parts and acting like they can justify obscene jumps. This is the simplest chord, and you put a jump clear across the screen for no reason other than the fact that you could. Stop with EVERYTHING like this. Not only are none of these called for, but the whole thing looks like a mess. Same deal. You can at least try and make these presentable. This is REALLY bad. Stop doing this. Make actual patterns instead of deliberate raises of SR. Same deal. This is an awful design. Fix it. You did this for SR. I heard the music. You did this just to increase the SR. Nothing here has any redeeming value. Redo it all. All you did here was put down notes on totally random areas. Gut this. I'm not joking. This is the absolute worst pattern you have EVER done. This is the epitome of overmapping, and you know it! The note progression is not that overly dramatic. This jump is just atrocious. You're rolling through streams, and then you decide a jump with nearly a DS of 12 is needed. Revolting. Congrats, you made a jump with 24.16 DS just because you could. Most troll maps I have don't come close to that. This is vile. Stop doing these things. You did the same thing here. What is wrong with you?

Finally done with that piece of worthless junk. Crap, RLC, when you started making things like Aitakatta Sora and Kimi ni Pierrot, I actually started getting my hopes up that you were finally going to break out of your terrible TV size stage and start cranking out truly admirable maps. Even though can you understand me? raised a red flag or two, I still had high hopes. And then this self-indulgent pretentious abomination gets vomitted onto the site. This is not only your worst map, but possibly the worst map I have ever seen. Why? Others were bad as satire, ignorance, age, or inexperience. You qualify for none of these categories, you have no excuse. Believe me, I have nothing against japanese music, be it anime, rock or pop. And I have no problem with someone in the osu community championing the genre as a flagship of broadening horizons. What I do have a problem with is that you, the person championing it, have absolutely no respect for the music or its structure. At the slightest strum of a guitar or hit of a snare drum, you are more than happy to start disregarding the music and just throwing ugly and pointless jumps where you just make the distance and position anywhere you feel like, no matter how awful the end result is. This vulgar excuse for a map reeks of every stupid and arrogant Sotarksism the community has had to bear witness to: Extreme jumps with no musical reasoning, sky high DS at random times, streams that just decide to jump to some random part of the playing field with no warning, buckshot spread patterns with no cohesive structure, streams that space out to absurd degrees, rampant abuse of SV changes and BPM modification to cover up lazy mapping, slider jumps that clearly are just cases of Ctrl+H and Ctrl+J abuse, and worst of all, using the music genre as your own little shield to justify every little moment of "I map like this because fuck you, I'm Sotarks" you can stuff in your pathetic and self-subservient maps. Stop using songs as canvases for your abhorrent "artistry", stop using your cult of personality to force your lazy work on others, and stop thinking that maps are good just because a computer designed to perfectly perform with flaw can manage to beat it.

also change ur diffname ho ly

you forgot to change other instances of "sotarks" to "rlc"

meme could've been better 6/10

LOL FeelsBadMan

godamiit when I try to post a meme it fails