1. Easy (1.29 stars, 157 notes)
2. Hard (2.68 stars, 423 notes)
3. Insane (2.79 stars, 429 notes)
4. Normal (1.74 stars, 226 notes)

PuttyPrincess wrote:

i really liked it!! it flowed well and it's really fun to play especially to such a good song!! The only thing i could suggest (that you don't have to do if you don't want to) is to make more difficulties maybe? c: Other than that, it's awesome!!!

Dominto wrote:

one issue i see is for anyone who isn't using widescreen, the video will look odd and cropped. not sure if that's your intention to do though

MisticEye wrote:

please, You gotta finish this beatmap! It looks very good.

BTW, video ain´t working.

kajiyatta wrote:

M4M
[General]
Inconsistence Widescreen Support, you should fix it. Didn't realize that, fixed!
Remove Letterbox? If it's intension, it's no problem. Done.
Delete "mystery" in Tags, it's contained from music name so it doesn't need. Fixed.
[Normal]
AR4 would be fine because this song is low BPM and it's a easiest diff, so for newbie it looks difficult.
Placement
Use distant snap on every note, it's a Normal diff and there is no Easy diff, so for newbie changing distance from note to note is really confused.

Wiki

If you don't have an Easy, you want to make it so that newbies can still play your map easily.

00:49:445(1,2) This 1/2 stack doesn't recommend for the easiest diff, it's suddenly appeared so newbie would be confused.

Ok, stopped.
I hope you remake this diff, and if you do that I'll again check on this diff. I'll think on the normal for a while. Thank you for the feedback about it.
[Hard]
Placement
00:15:945(3) Add NC here to be same Insane. Done.
00:57:695(59 Move like this and make a blanket? there are a lot of similar placements so it looks suitable. I don't like how the blanket looks here.

SPOILER

01:03:445(1,2,3,4,1) It looks a bit odd flow for me, set same height or move consistent upliner movement better. e.g.) Fixed.

SPOILER

03:30:445(2) Move thi note a bit right like this, and the placement looks like nice triangle. Fixed.

SPOILER

03:43:445(3) You placed a note away on the previous same part at 01:19:445, but in this part it's so nearly from previous note. I know it's a last note, but try to put this note away better. Changed spacing to 1.5x to make it consistent.
Rhythm
01:36:945(3) Sounds weird because you don't pick the vocal at 01:37:195, I don't suppose it ie better to ignore this point. I think this part is fine as is.
Hit Sound
[Insane]
Placement
00:08:445(2) Liner slider better than curved one to be symmetrical placement with (1). Done.

SPOILER

01:10:445(2) CTRL+G would be better to make a same pattern. I like how this is placed.
01:16:945(3) Just move this slider on the left at 3 grids, current spacing is a bit narrow and seems not good.Changed Spacing
01:19:445(5) Why this spacing is ×0.8? It looks a bit confused so just set ×1.0 better. Fixed
03:43:969(4,5) ^ Fixed
01:36:945(3) The end tick of slider is off-screen, I suppose you can place this slider in the grid. Fixed.
01:39:195(6) Bent this slider's direction for next note, and the flow would be nice. I think it's fine as is.

SPOILER

Rhythm
03:00:945(2,3,4) I suppose 1/1 reverse slider would be better than current one, the vocal has keeping on this part but not emphasized, Fixed.

SPOILER

Hit Sound

Well designed mapset except Normal, I can't find big problem.
Good luck.

Xelasto wrote:

Hello

Normal

00:43:945 (1) - Give more time for the player to re-orient themselves, this is normal after all. This spinner is long enough that it shouldn't take anyone by surprise.
00:49:445 (2,3) - I suggest not stacking them, especially since they're timed oddly ( but nevertheless, correctly) I'm in the process of making an Easy, so these shouldn't be too hard now that this won't be the easiest difficulty of the set.
01:54:445 (6) - NC? I'm trying to keep the NC's consistent throughout the map somewhat. I think it's fine as is.
02:02:445 (5,6) - I suggest not stacking them, especially since they're timed oddly ( but nevertheless, correctly) Same as stated before.
02:03:945 (1) - End spinner earlier. (more time to find mouse) Again, these shouldn't give people too much trouble since I placed the notes close to the center of the spinner.
03:06:945 (5) - NC? A new combo wouldn't fit here.
03:07:945 (1) - ^
Very good normal song btw ^.^

Hard

01:19:445 (6) - NC? A new combo wouldn't fit here.
01:48:695 (1) - I suggest making the entire slider bumpy This slider was done intentional to match the humming.
Up HP drain by 1 or 2
Up AR by 1 or 2
Up OD by 1 or 2 I think the difficulty settings are fine as is. I don't want too large of a gap between difficulties.
DARN IT!!! Why you make such a good hard mode!?! Makes modding hard

Insane

01:48:695 (1) - BUMPIER!! Again this was done intentionally to match the humming.

I suggest making it harder

....I just....Why you ask for mod if it's basically perfect. The flow, hitsounds, song options, and everything is perfect.

IMO This song is ready for ranked. Absolutely flawless (basically)

Wasabi wrote:

This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Sunday, May 24, 2015 at 12:40:58 PM

Artist: Mystery Skulls
Title: Ghost
Tags: mysteryben27, vivi, arthur, lewis, forever, isaiahdjstuff, koalacola, artsyfeathersartsyblog, heilos
BPM: 120
Filesize: 20786kb
Play Time: 02:13
Difficulties Available:

1. Easy (1.3 stars, 102 notes)
2. Hard (2.68 stars, 423 notes)
3. Insane (2.79 stars, 429 notes)
4. Normal (1.74 stars, 226 notes)

Download: Mystery Skulls - Ghost
Download: Mystery Skulls - Ghost (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Moved back to WIP while I work on Easy and (possibly) redo Normal. This time I might just not disappear and actually finish the map.

Kaivu wrote:

Hi, just dropping in for a mod. :3

Easy

01:37:945 (4) - Not sure if this was meant to be symmetrical but the control points don't match up on opposite sides - Fixed
01:43:945 (1) - Not completely symmetrical; control points don't match up on opposite sides - Fixed
01:59:945 (1,2) - You have a nice chance for a blanket here - Fixed
-->
02:15:945 (1) - I would move this down a square so it's horizontal with the previous circle - Fixed
02:21:445 (2) - Consider moving this so it's not underneath the slider. It's Easy so it might be hard for some people - Moved so it's stacking on top of the next slider now, should be easier to read.
02:29:445 (2) - Move up a square so it's horizontal with previous slider? - Fixed
02:31:945 (1) - ^ - Fixed
03:12:945 (1,2,3) - Blanket is off because slider is not symmetrical - Fixed
03:22:945 (3,1) - Blanket is off; fix second slider - Slider is meant to be symmetrical, not going for a blanket here.
03:39:945 (1,2) - Blanket is off - Fixed

Normal

02:00:945 (3,4) - Blanket is off because the first slider is not symmetrical - Fixed
02:19:945 (1) - Move this 2 squares to the left so it'll be symmetrical with the previous slider (and move the next two circles accordingly to keep your blanket) - Didn't do exactly as suggested, but I did fix these two sliders not being symmetrical.

Hard

00:25:695 (5) - The change from 1.0x distance spacing to 1.2x here looks really odd - I'm going to leave it as is for now since I made the slight distance change to put more emphasis on the vocals.
01:07:445 (7) - Maybe change the slider here a bit to match with the previous one?
-->
01:47:195 (5) - Not completely symmetrical; control points don't match up on opposite sides - Fixed

Insane

00:18:445 (2) - Change this so it matches with the slider before it - Fixed
-->
00:27:195 (4) - Not completely symmetrical; control points don't match up on opposite sides - Fixed
01:42:945 (4,5) - Blanket is off - Fixed

Other

I would heavily suggest making Insane harder or adding another difficulty. (Your Insane right now is below 3 stars too...) Hard and Insane felt almost the same to me when I testplayed them; there's only a 0.11 star difficulty difference between the two, and that's not a lot at all. - I'll look over Hard and consider redoing that difficulty completely as it's too similar to Insane. I'll move this back to WIP while I do so. Thank you for the feedback.

Fun maps otherwise! Couldn't really find any major problems; just nitpicking at symmetry and blankets haha XD

EDIT: Forgot to add pictures sorry ^_^;