forum

osu! Medical Mafia [Game Over!, Mafia Win]

posted 2014-08-07T17:38:50+00:00

Total Posts

499

Drezi

Joined January 2014

Drezi 2014-08-15T06:55:16+00:00

Guys you're jumping to conclusions too fast.

I did target you and if I'm jailer that would mean you couldn't protect Sakura, couldn't CPR/Quack kill her, and then you couldn't have NK-d her either, that's for sure. But it's very much possible that I'm NOT the jailer, and it was CTh or Sakura, or it's Beeboy/Sona, in which case, the other one could have been CPR/Quack too. You could also just be the Naive Doctor, which is a VT without any protection and it's still possible that you're in fact the Quack/CPR doctor, if CTh was or Sona is the Jailer since they targeted you last night.

Drezi

Joined January 2014

Drezi 2014-08-15T07:05:06+00:00

What's sure is that I CAN'T be Quack/CPR, since last day we established that I can only be Quack/CPR if Navi is the Jailer, and obviously Navi is not Jailer.

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-15T07:14:17+00:00

All I can say I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-15T07:14:35+00:00

All I can say is I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people*

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

AutoMedic

Joined April 2014

AutoMedic 2014-08-15T07:17:30+00:00

I hope this clears up something

Oh and by the way, we aren't sure yet what beeboy targeted last night.

NG ETNM SLT KZXF BZ MVZY
J QYGPSP EIM LYDQPYU XZHFZ
UPLE J ULJ SMEFSV

Drezi

Joined January 2014

Drezi 2014-08-15T07:32:02+00:00

Navizel wrote:
All I can say is I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people*

And how exactly do you know that?

AutoMedic

Joined April 2014

AutoMedic 2014-08-15T08:55:49+00:00

Drezi wrote:
Navizel wrote:
All I can say is I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people*
And how exactly do you know that?

And BOOM hits the bullet

NG ETNM SLT KZXF BZ MVZY
J QYGPSP EIM LYDQPYU XZHFZ
UPLE J ULJ SMEFSV

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T12:47:49+00:00

I targeted sona

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T13:11:30+00:00

We all targeted who we were supposed to.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T16:34:26+00:00

So I have been working on a list of who is what but I need this to be clarified before I can continue

@mod can another doctor save a CPR?

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Topic Starter

Zexion 2014-08-15T16:39:43+00:00

beeboy123 wrote:
So I have been working on a list of who is what but I need this to be clarified before I can continue

@mod can another doctor save a CPR?

What do you mean? CPR Doctors can be protected like any other player.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T16:45:18+00:00

@mod I meant a weak doctor ;-; woops, can a weak doctor be saved if they target scum but are targeted by a doctor?

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Topic Starter

Zexion 2014-08-15T16:46:24+00:00

beeboy123 wrote:
@mod I meant a weak doctor ;-; woops, can a weak doctor be saved if they target scum but are targeted by a doctor?

Yes, if a weak doctor targeted a scum player but at the same time a normal doctor protected the weak doctor, then it lives.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T18:29:12+00:00

Day 1 Targets

Drezi > beeboy
Navizel > Drezi
CTh > Navizel
Sonatora > Navizel
beeboy > No Target

Day 2 Targets
Bee>Sona>Bee

Drezi>Navi>Sakura>Drezi

And cannot be

Bee -Scum

Sona -
Navi -Doctor, CPR, Jailer
Drezi - Quack, CPR
Sakura - CPR, Quack

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Here is what I got using the current info.

Therefore I cannot be a kill role or else Sona would be dead unless one of us is a jailer and the other is CPR (as Navi, Drezi and Sakura cannot be CPR) but it is safe to assume CPR is dead.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T18:53:27+00:00

owo that was a work in progress hence all the missing parts I meant to save that as a draft I will to to make conclusions later

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T18:56:35+00:00

try*

Drezi

Joined January 2014

Drezi 2014-08-15T19:01:45+00:00

Except Navi can be CPR, who killed Sakura, if the NK was jailed.
Navi can be Doctor too, with me Jailing his protection.

The rest of your conclusions, I've said already. And why the hell would it be safe to assume the CPR/Quack is dead, when any of us could be it except me.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T19:17:41+00:00

Drezi wrote:
Except Navi can be CPR, who killed Sakura, if the NK was jailed.
Navi can be Doctor too, with me Jailing his protection.

The rest of your conclusions, I've said already. And why the hell would it be safe to assume the CPR/Quack is dead, when any of us could be it except me.

Because you are analyzing something that wasn't done.

I would have deleted that post if it was allowed

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T19:22:42+00:00

Navizel wrote:
All I can say I don't have the capability to kill but I can protect people

I was following this, btw I was going to ask why he thought this especially this part

Also of course I would add what you said yesterday about what could happen as that is what you do when you work as a team.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-15T19:26:05+00:00

Anyway I won't be on for awhile which is why I wanted to save my post as a draft so I didn't lose it. I will lurk on my phone though if you have anymore questions you want to ask me.

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Topic Starter

Zexion 2014-08-16T01:37:02+00:00

Votecount 3.01
Players needed to lynch: 3

Drezi - 1 - Sonatora - (L-2)
Sonatora - 1 - Navizel - (L-2)

Players not voting: beeboy123, Drezi

Please tell me if you see any mistakes.

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T02:53:32+00:00

hello

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T03:38:44+00:00

Navizel wrote:
hello

#avoiding questions

How do you know you aren't a kill role and not a naive doctor-

AutoMedic

Joined April 2014

AutoMedic 2014-08-16T03:44:54+00:00

Navizel wrote:
hello

trying to avert questions ain't gonna get you anywhere

UNVOTE for now

NG ETNM SLT KZXF BZ MVZY
J QYGPSP EIM LYDQPYU XZHFZ
UPLE J ULJ SMEFSV

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T04:47:32+00:00

because im not

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T04:48:04+00:00

let me check the pm again

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T04:48:43+00:00

yeah, im neither a naive doctor nor a kill doctor

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T04:49:52+00:00

Vote: Navi

Yay I didn't even need to finish my post

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T04:51:21+00:00

And why would I ask if the naive doctor is still alive if I'm a naive doctor?

And why is the Navi being a kill doctor a big deal anyway. If Navi really is a kill doctor, then what? He's still not a mafia goon.

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T04:51:49+00:00

See this bullshit

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T04:51:53+00:00

Welp you pm doesn't say what Doctor role you are so there is that.

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T04:52:20+00:00

Doctor = mafia

nice thinking

Unvote

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T04:52:56+00:00

your*

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T04:54:13+00:00

you're

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T04:55:00+00:00

Navizel wrote:
Doctor = mafia

nice thinking

Unvote

shhhh it will make sense soon

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2014-08-16T05:16:35+00:00

Navizel wrote:
let me check the pm again

Navizel wrote:
yeah, im neither a naive doctor nor a kill doctor

A message a doctor gets looks like this (taken from the rule section) no where it mentions what role you are.

Zexion wrote:
Hi, <PlayerName>!.

Welcome to Medical Mafia. You are a Town Doctor.

Its been a while since you've tackled the medical field. So long in fact, that you're not sure of your abilities right now! Lets just hope everything works for the best, at least its just an ordinary hospital, right?

Abilities:
"Protection": Each night phase, you may use a "protection" action on a player in the game. You're not exactly sure what you will do, though.
Win condition:
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T05:38:47+00:00

oh

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T05:39:03+00:00

well shit

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T05:42:51+00:00

doctor =/= mafia

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2014-08-16T06:03:53+00:00

I suck at this game holy shit

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Please sign in to reply.

390 / 499

›

›

›

›