OK I'll bite.
/in
/in
forum
Debatable Mafia: Game Over! Town PRs survives!
posted
Total Posts
381
hi
/in
EDIT:
/out
I have another game starting soon. I will not have time to keep up with both!
PM me if you guys end up filling most spots. Depending on if/when this starts, I might be able to play.
EDIT:
/out
I have another game starting soon. I will not have time to keep up with both!
PM me if you guys end up filling most spots. Depending on if/when this starts, I might be able to play.
DismalRayne pls
/in
Also is it just me, or this setup is kinda scum-favorable?
Also is it just me, or this setup is kinda scum-favorable?
/in
/in
One more
Topic Starter
I asked CB and he said to change Cop to 2-shot cop so I dunno.........rEdo wrote:
/in
Also is it just me, or this setup is kinda scum-favorable?
I remember we talked a lot about changing the setup to be less completely broken, but I don't remember where we ended at at all.
Topic Starter
I'm still up for further balancing if you can come up with ideas on how to =PCalignoBot wrote:
I remember we talked a lot about changing the setup to be less completely broken, but I don't remember where we ended at at all.
I would add a X-Shot Day Doctor as a balance against the 1-Shot Dayvig. The Doc could choose his target during the pre-game/Night (in case scum tries to Daykill right in the beginning of the Day) but also be able to change it at any time during the Day.
More like a 1-shot Bulletproof.
Topic Starter
1VT position replaced by 1-Shot BP because it seemed better for me and CB apparently did a pro disappearing act in IRC so I can't discuss with him. Will however change to X-Shot doctor if more ppl prefer it.DakeDekaane wrote:
More like a 1-shot Bulletproof.
1-shot Bulletproof sounds more reasonable to me.
Hey guys, I'd like to give this a try. Haven't played this slow paced forum version of Mafia yet, though.
/in?
/in?
Hell yes. Here we go.
Topic Starter
Roles PM sent. Confirmation phase starts now. Confirm in thread.
Some funny things to note:
I derped up on mafia PM and forgot to send the partner's name. Obviously I resent another PM.
I have given up on even trying to place URL in role PMs
If you did not receive your role PM. Please PM me.
Game will officially starts when 7/9players confirm.(tbh you can start without my notice if 7/9confirms because I'm going to sleep now)
Some funny things to note:
I derped up on mafia PM and forgot to send the partner's name. Obviously I resent another PM.
I have given up on even trying to place URL in role PMs
If you did not receive your role PM. Please PM me.
Game will officially starts when 7/9players confirm.(tbh you can start without my notice if 7/9confirms because I'm going to sleep now)
Confirmed via PM already accidentally, but alright. Confirming.
conf
This is a confirmation post
7 confirmed, we can unofficially start.
/insert Confucius picture here
Topic Starter
zap!
Setsuen the self-aligned self warrior has been killed
Day 1 has started. Deadline will end on Sunday 9:20a.m(GMT +8)
Setsuen the self-aligned self warrior has been killed
Day 1 has started. Deadline will end on Sunday 9:20a.m(GMT +8)
Vote: CalignoBot
Very well started.
Very well started.
Vote: NH
:^)
:^)
Go on and make an event so that i'll be insta scum readed again, cause you know scums want that
omg SNB why you vot Caligno m8? feel much pressure? CB pinned scum to the wall, SNB caught red-handed, gg wp easy game
also, Claim: Mafia 1-Shot Vig
also, Claim: Mafia 1-Shot Vig
Topic Starter
Setsuen wrote:
Votecount 1.1
With 9Alive, it takes 5 to lynch
StaticNoiseBird[1]-CalignoBot
CalignoBot[1]-StaticNoiseBird
NoHitter[1]-BRBP
Gumica[1]-Drezi
rEdo[0]
fartownik[0]
DakeDekaane[0]
Drezi[1]-rEdo
Not voting:NoHitter,fartownik,DakeDekaane,Gumica
You lie man, CC: Mafia 1-Shot Vig.fartownik wrote:
omg SNB why you vot Caligno m8? feel much pressure? CB pinned scum to the wall, SNB caught red-handed, gg wp easy game
also, Claim: Mafia 1-Shot Vig
farto is town guys!
Reverse Vote: far[color=#80000]TOWN[/color]ik
Well that was a fail tag 
Shit, me and farto already got busted? GG WP NO RE
Bad vibes.BRBP wrote:
Vote: NH
:^)
Unvote: Static Noise Bird
Vote: BRBP
Shoot: NH
Topic Starter
DakeDekaane reveals a gun and shoots NoHitter!DakeDekaane wrote:
Shoot: NH
The gun backfires and shoots DakeDekaane. Apparently it was a fabbed gun given by a fabricator. The mod decides to revive DD because this set-up is apparently scum-sided.
Okay back to the game.............and stop shooting fabbed guns TY.
If there is any mistakes please inform me.Setsuen wrote:
Setsuen wrote:
Votecount 1.2
With 9Alive, it takes 5 to lynch
StaticNoiseBird[0]
CalignoBot[1]-StaticNoiseBird
NoHitter[1]-BRBP
BRBP[1]-CalignoBot
Gumica[1]-Drezi
rEdo[0]
fartownik[1]-NoHitter
DakeDekaane[0]
Drezi[1]-rEdo
Not voting:,fartownik,DakeDekaane,Gumica
Unvote
Vote: DakeDekaane
Vote: DakeDekaane
Damn, way too many good things happen to scum...Setsuen wrote:
The mod decides to revive DD because this set-up is apparently scum-sided.
The mod just scumslipped GG no re
I'm not scumerino, pls no voterino (
(fuck smiley
I don't always suggest something stupid. I'm just normally opposed to the status quo way of doing this thing.BRBP wrote:
Still waiting for NH to suggest something stupid like a massclaim.
C'mon man, it's been 15 hours already, I know you want to.I can't sleep unless I get to know whether I was already caught by CB or if he's still in RVS.
Still finding a way to see if we can rig the setup for a town win though.
Topic Starter
Vote Count 1.3
With 9Alive, it takes 5 to lynch
StaticNoiseBird[0]
CalignoBot[1]-StaticNoiseBird
NoHitter[1]-BRBP
BRBP[1]-CalignoBot
Gumica[1]-Drezi
rEdo[0]
fartownik[1]-NoHitter
DakeDekaane[1]-rEdo
Drezi[0]
Not voting:,fartownik,DakeDekaane,Gumica
If there is any mistakes please inform me.
With 9Alive, it takes 5 to lynch
StaticNoiseBird[0]
CalignoBot[1]-StaticNoiseBird
NoHitter[1]-BRBP
BRBP[1]-CalignoBot
Gumica[1]-Drezi
rEdo[0]
fartownik[1]-NoHitter
DakeDekaane[1]-rEdo
Drezi[0]
Not voting:,fartownik,DakeDekaane,Gumica
If there is any mistakes please inform me.
lol wut.fartownik wrote:
The mod just scumslipped GG no re
@mod: if the Mafia Vigilante posts his kill action in the thread instead of PM, would it still work?
Topic Starter
no. I'm pretty sure sample PM said to PM me about the shot. <.<fartownik wrote:
@mod: if the Mafia Vigilante posts his kill action in the thread instead of PM, would it still work?
Oh farto gets town points for that question.
It'd be too stupid to post action in thread being a Mafia Dayvig, at least I'm happy we have smart scum between us.
also big FoS on rEdo
Topic Starter
BRBP wrote:
Requesting mod to prod drezi, SNB and gumica.
:^)
prodded.
Sorry, was gone for some time, and didn't have time to check this particular thread yet. But I'm here now.
@BRBP: farto and NH being scums together might be a bit far fetched, actually NH looks more like town to me, connecting himself to his scum buddy at this point already wouldn't make much sense imo.
@Dake: yeah that would be the natural deduction, not sure why you'd go ahead to state it explicitly in that case.
@Dake: yeah that would be the natural deduction, not sure why you'd go ahead to state it explicitly in that case.
Being this punctual on prods this early on? what are you? Alien v2 (reffering to last newbie), who wins by prodding others?
jkjk. Anyways, sorry for not responding within 24h, I was working at a job, so I didn't had any time avaliable for forum. :^)
jkjk. Anyways, sorry for not responding within 24h, I was working at a job, so I didn't had any time avaliable for forum. :^)
Not sure if it's BRBP's purpose, but I find him unusually town-looking.
hue
NH gets scumpoints for setting up for my eventual future death from the DayvigNoHitter wrote:
Oh farto gets town points for that question.
hue
inb4 NH actually dies.
Vote: rEdo
Vote: rEdo
K, because why not.
Claim: 1-Shot Bulletproof
Claim: 1-Shot Bulletproof
not sure if farto is still trolling or claiming for sure
No, I'm pretty sure I'm not leaving home for the next several days.BRBP wrote:
Gumica wrote:
Being this punctual on prods this early on? what are you? Alien v2 (reffering to last newbie), who wins by prodding others?
jkjk. Anyways, sorry for not responding within 24h, I was working at a job, so I didn't had any time avaliable for forum. :^)Thanks for contributing, see you again in 24 hours...Static Noise Bird wrote:
Sorry, was gone for some time, and didn't have time to check this particular thread yet. But I'm here now.
non-vt town... derp.
Topic Starter
They have Day chat for Day1 only.BRBP wrote:
Does scum have daychat?
Can doc target the same person every night?
Can doc target himself?
Yes
No.
If there is any mistakes please inform me.Setsuen wrote:
Vote Count 1.4
With 9Alive, it takes 5 to lynch
StaticNoiseBird[0]
CalignoBot[1]-StaticNoiseBird
NoHitter[1]-BRBP
BRBP[1]-CalignoBot
Gumica[1]-Drezi
rEdo[1]-DakeDekaane
fartownik[1]-NoHitter
DakeDekaane[1]-rEdo
Drezi[0]
Not voting:,fartownik,Gumica
next time I host another game, it might be 10P with 7towns,2mafia & 1alien who wins by probing/prodding everyone who's alive.BRBP wrote:
Thanks for contributing, see you again in 24 hours...
Scum vibes.DakeDekaane wrote:
Shoot: NH
Town vibes.rEdo wrote:
Unvote
Vote: DakeDekaaneDamn, way too many good things happen to scum...Setsuen wrote:
The mod decides to revive DD because this set-up is apparently scum-sided.
I'm not liking this post. The way his thoughts travel from sentence to sentence looks off.NoHitter wrote:
I don't always suggest something stupid. I'm just normally opposed to the status quo way of doing this thing.BRBP wrote:
Still waiting for NH to suggest something stupid like a massclaim.
C'mon man, it's been 15 hours already, I know you want to.I can't sleep unless I get to know whether I was already caught by CB or if he's still in RVS.
Still finding a way to see if we can rig the setup for a town win though.
I don't really agree, but this is town thinking. BRBP's post after this one is making me wary, though.BRBP wrote:
fartownik wrote:
@mod: if the Mafia Vigilante posts his kill action in the thread instead of PM, would it still work?Are you saying you didn't think of that question immediately when DD said "shoot: NH"?NoHitter wrote:
Oh farto gets town points for that question.
Whether the vig shot actually works or not when posted in thread makes no difference, you can't "test" it in any way since the real scum could just submit their action via PM, or even cancel it if the person being tested happens to be the scum vig.
Stop giving your scumbuddy town points
Explain yourself here.DakeDekaane wrote:
It'd be too stupid to post action in thread being a Mafia Dayvig, at least I'm happy we have smart scum between us.
Explain yourself here too.DakeDekaane wrote:
also big FoS on rEdo
Town posting.Drezi wrote:
@BRBP: farto and NH being scums together might be a bit far fetched, actually NH looks more like town to me, connecting himself to his scum buddy at this point already wouldn't make much sense imo.
@Dake: yeah that would be the natural deduction, not sure why you'd go ahead to state it explicitly in that case.
This looks too reserved to me. Not liking it.DakeDekaane wrote:
not sure if farto is still trolling or claiming for sure
Role fishing. Scummy.BRBP wrote:
I really can't see why real BP would spontaneously claim it D1 when nobody has any real town-reads on him. I can see why scum or non-VT town would claim it, though.
Would you like to explain that claim farto?
List of Players:
1.StaticNoiseBird --- Null
2.
3.NoHitter --- Null-Scum
4.BRBP --- Null-Scum
5.Gumica --- Null
6.rEdo --- Null-Town
7.fartownik --- Null-Town
8.DakeDekaane --- Scum
9.Drezi --- Town
Unvote: BRBP
Vote: DakeDekaane
1.StaticNoiseBird --- Null
2.
3.NoHitter --- Null-Scum
4.BRBP --- Null-Scum
5.Gumica --- Null
6.rEdo --- Null-Town
7.fartownik --- Null-Town
8.DakeDekaane --- Scum
9.Drezi --- Town
Unvote: BRBP
Vote: DakeDekaane
Oh yeah, I guess I still got my vote on CB.
Unvote
Unvote
CalignoBot - Aside from voting me for no reason on the very first post, no suspicions. Yet.
NoHitter - Haven't paid attention yet. Yet.
BRBP - Plays extreme-town, therefore might be anything.
Gumica - Nothing.
rEdo - Nothing here either.
fartownik - Suspicious claim (not referring to the mafia one btw) and a stupid damn question. Would suspect for both reasons.
DakeDekaane - Scumslipping for lols because nobody takes him seriously anyway. Would suspect.
Drezi - Hides in the shadows. Another "could be anything" case, at the moment.
NoHitter - Haven't paid attention yet. Yet.
BRBP - Plays extreme-town, therefore might be anything.
Gumica - Nothing.
rEdo - Nothing here either.
fartownik - Suspicious claim (not referring to the mafia one btw) and a stupid damn question. Would suspect for both reasons.
DakeDekaane - Scumslipping for lols because nobody takes him seriously anyway. Would suspect.
Drezi - Hides in the shadows. Another "could be anything" case, at the moment.
Oh and also, not sure why would BRBP ask about scum daychat, as if he knew about it, now that it exists. I don't think that's a common theme in mafia games, thus that's rather suspicious.
rEdo is scum for the mere fact of taking advantage of the mod "scumslip" to put a vote there, also for being a lurksack.
How did you reach that conclusion? Specifically talking about the first reason.
What makes rEdo's lurking worse than anyone else's lurking?
You didn't answer my other question.
What makes rEdo's lurking worse than anyone else's lurking?
You didn't answer my other question.
I dont buy that logic for suspecting rEdo either.
I'm leaning towards BRBP town for now, since this pro-town behavior would be hard to keep up as scum in the long run.
I'm leaning towards BRBP town for now, since this pro-town behavior would be hard to keep up as scum in the long run.
I'm still a complete newbie, so I guess I hadn't seen enough previously. Doesn't change the fact, that this really is the first time I see one, and you guessed it blindly.BRBP wrote:
I had daychat in most of the games I played as scum.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Oh and also, not sure why would BRBP ask about scum daychat, as if he knew about it, now that it exists. I don't think that's a common theme in mafia games, thus that's rather suspicious.
Who are you leaning on for scum atm.Drezi wrote:
I dont buy that logic for suspecting rEdo either.
I'm leaning towards BRBP town for now, since this pro-town behavior would be hard to keep up as scum in the long run.
Get used to that. It ain't anywhere different from any other games I played.BRBP wrote:
How is it any different from gumica (who I constantly see in "users browsing this forum")?DakeDekaane wrote:
rEdo is scum for the mere fact of taking advantage of the mod "scumslip" to put a vote there, also for being a lurksack.
Now give a better answer to DD's question. Using me as a escape goat is a bad example.
You.
1) That question
Feels forced is all, I see no reason for town to hurry my views based on what we have so far.
2) Your contribution looks pretty constructive at first sight, ends up being rather vague upon further inspection.
These points:
BRBP - his first quote you say is town thinking, but becomes null-scum right after that because of role fishing, this ends up being ambiguous in the end any way I look at it, why not offer a straight opinion right away?
rEdo - town vibes you say, well what you quoted is 100% neutral I'd say.
DD - scumcall outright just yet is too harsh in my eyes.
1) That question
Feels forced is all, I see no reason for town to hurry my views based on what we have so far.
2) Your contribution looks pretty constructive at first sight, ends up being rather vague upon further inspection.
These points:
NH and farto - all im seeing is some reaction testing, trolling around basically, yet one is null-scum, the other is null-town? pretty big contrast based on what we've seen so far.CalignoBot wrote:
List of Players:
3.NoHitter --- Null-Scum
4.BRBP --- Null-Scum
6.rEdo --- Null-Town
7.fartownik --- Null-Town
8.DakeDekaane --- Scum
BRBP - his first quote you say is town thinking, but becomes null-scum right after that because of role fishing, this ends up being ambiguous in the end any way I look at it, why not offer a straight opinion right away?
rEdo - town vibes you say, well what you quoted is 100% neutral I'd say.
DD - scumcall outright just yet is too harsh in my eyes.
I always find funny how everyone scumread me in the start of a game.
Check anyone else's reaction when voted.
Check rEdo's reaction when voted.CalignoBot wrote:
What makes rEdo's lurking worse than anyone else's lurking?
Check anyone else's reaction when voted.
Maybe it's by the things you post, perhaps? "Scumslipping" for lols and such, you know.DakeDekaane wrote:
I always find funny how everyone scumread me in the start of a game.
And then you find it even funny. Okay.
Actually, let's do this - I'm okay with flipping rEdo, since hes the most controversial person right now (CB and BRBP defending kinda, DD strongly accusing him).
Also he's the only one under accusation to be subtly defended in CB's analysis and DD who had been attacking him was scumread by him (pretty much for that reason only) , so it looks like a reasonable choice. While statistically we're most likely to lynch town D1, flipping someone passive, lurky or just simply scummy doesn't give as much info as someone who generated strong opposing opinions.
Unvote: Gumica
Vote: rEdo
Also he's the only one under accusation to be subtly defended in CB's analysis and DD who had been attacking him was scumread by him (pretty much for that reason only) , so it looks like a reasonable choice. While statistically we're most likely to lynch town D1, flipping someone passive, lurky or just simply scummy doesn't give as much info as someone who generated strong opposing opinions.
Unvote: Gumica
Vote: rEdo
And as usual, getting there after a few pages have been written.
You know, Dake, what is more interesting, is the fact that you voted me with an actual farfetched scumvibe after I voted in a semi-serious manner. My "the omgus is real" post was a real quick response to your vote after I got a notice via e-mail that there's a response in this thread. I believe it's always the best to throw even the littliest thought in the thread instead of "le prod dodging" when you don't have enough time to actually get into analysis.
farto's claim is obviously just to create WIFOM, I don't even know why BRBP tries to fish a role from him.
I don't like how CB reads my vote on DD as town behaviour, either.
The rest seems lurky and/or are taking the most neutral path there is.
You know, Dake, what is more interesting, is the fact that you voted me with an actual farfetched scumvibe after I voted in a semi-serious manner. My "the omgus is real" post was a real quick response to your vote after I got a notice via e-mail that there's a response in this thread. I believe it's always the best to throw even the littliest thought in the thread instead of "le prod dodging" when you don't have enough time to actually get into analysis.
farto's claim is obviously just to create WIFOM, I don't even know why BRBP tries to fish a role from him.
I don't like how CB reads my vote on DD as town behaviour, either.
The rest seems lurky and/or are taking the most neutral path there is.
Topic Starter
Scum slip when mod is WIFOM master who no one knows whether he is WIFOMing or not. #pro.DakeDekaane wrote:
rEdo is scum for the mere fact of taking advantage of the mod "scumslip" to put a vote there, also for being a lurksack.
If there is any mistakes please inform me.Setsuen wrote:
Vote Count 1.5
With 9Alive, it takes 5 to lynch
StaticNoiseBird[0]
CalignoBot[1]-StaticNoiseBird
NoHitter[1]-BRBP
BRBP[1]-CalignoBot
Gumica[0]
rEdo[2]-DakeDekaane,Drezi
fartownik[1]-NoHitter
DakeDekaane[1]-rEdo
Drezi[0]
Not voting:,fartownik,Gumica
Deadline will end in ~3days 23hr(Sunday 9:20am GMT +8)