wouldnt it be better to use lr2 or iidx or something as source in that case
Nao Tomori wrote:
wouldnt it be better to use lr2 or iidx or something as source in that case
FAMoss wrote:
cool, i agree
but sometimes bms songs repacked included remix, like LeaF did from touhou
does this can be solved the Source by from remixed came ?
example on several maps
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/897547 東方永夜抄 ~ Imperishable Night
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/592272 東方地霊殿 ~ Subterranean Animism.
Cherry Blossom wrote:
You cannot find any other alternative concerning source names unless you mention the event of the mapped song, and it could be more misleading, for example if you want to map a song like Sakuzyo feat. Nikki Simmons - Destr0yer which has currently "BMS" as source, you must use "G2R2018" as source instead, but using "BMS of fighters 2018" or "BOF2018" as source is also possible, there's no "common" source.
Cherry Blossom wrote:
i agree with what agu said : "BMS as a source looks clean and is already almost universally accepted". when you cannot find a viable alternative for each case, using an universal one for everything is, imo, the best.
Cherry Blossom wrote:
There is also a rule in RC which tells to use the original source for an arranged song, it happened to me once when i tried to rank this https://osu.ppy.sh/s/905158 because the original song comes from a BMS event, but the song itself definitely has no source.
pishifat wrote:
what im wondering is how this would be written in the ranking criteria though. saying "don't use bms as source" seems wrong when we don't have phrases like "don't use [YouTube/vimeo/niconico etc] as source" either
rc wrote:
Website or album names are not an acceptable source.