1. o'boy (2,72 stars, 220 notes)
2. why you trippin' boy? (4,86 stars, 446 notes)

tan14007 wrote:

In My Opinion~♥

o'boy
- About 1:7:799 - 1:13:299 Notes Are Blocking Bora (Naaa Just kidding~ )
- Slider Tick Rate is too much… I think only 1 is ok.
- I think I need more break for this (if this is an easiest level for this song)
- I just don't like spinner at the end of this level

dubbadeni wrote:

From ★ ~ dubbadeni ' s Beginnner Modding Queue ~ ★
I'm a beginner, don't expect too much!
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General

You should explain what kind of difficulty "o'boy" and "why you trippin' boy?" is in your first post. - Thanks for pointing that out :3
I didn't find much because they're both great difficulties - Thanks

o'boy

00:56:299 (1) - New Combo - I don't really see the need to NC there ^^ I think it fits
03:05:299 (1) - This Slider looks boring. Why not trying to make something like this -> http://puu.sh/4iR6 or http://puu.sh/6LkY - Going to make it more interesting Decided to keep it as it is, couldn't really find a replacement that we thought would fit that part, instead we changed the pattern a little
03:07:965 (1) - ^ - ^

why you trippin' boy?

00:29:965 (1) - Why New Combo here? - It fits with the music ^^
00:58:965 (6) - This Circle is too high. It's touching the health bar, that's not allowed. - Fix'd
02:17:632 (6) - New Combo - Done
03:15:965 (1) - Why New Combo here? - Dunno ^^ Fix'd

Leorda wrote:

Hi there


[General]
* Your diff name makes players confuse about which is normal diff and hard diff. COnsider to change the diff name into difficulty name (e.g. "Normal", "Hard") - For now we'd like to keep it as it is ^^
* Don't forget to change the topic name, since you had change the title song - Done


[o'boy]
01:47:632 (2,1) - Swap new combo for your combo pattern? - Done
02:33:632 - This break space are really too long. I suggest you to map at 02:43:965, it's mappable - Done


[why you trippin' boy]
01:07:965 (2,3,4) - Oh, a cat face :3 (comment) - :3


That's all I got

1. I feel that offset is slightly early. Consider adding +10 or +5. But since this song is so full of vocals and unstable in timing, I can be wrong.
2. You totally must not use standart combo colors. They are too bright, odd and the red one is doubled (so sometimes I can't recognize where the combo is starting). If you use a bit more pale colors, the map itself will become prettier to look at, and will not be so epileptic on kiais. Try these:
   
   SPOILER

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 121,232,143
   Combo2 : 230,230,60
   Combo3 : 240,90,79
   Combo4 : 103,207,252

3. Hitsound suggestion: if you listen carefully (especially in "o'boy" diff), you will hear a clap sound at every short white tick: 00:15:299, 00:16:632 ... 01:11:299, 01:12:632, 01:13:965 and so on. You need to place claps there. Your clap is already taken so you can use custom finish for a usual clap sound or something.. If you don't want to to use many green lines, of course. But I definitely can hear a clap on every short white tick so yea, please rework hitsounds according to that.

1. 00:16:299 (5) - Moving this 1/4 earlier will fit the vocals much better. You probably try to fit drums, but please leave this for taiko maps; moving this sliders makes this map sound better.
2. 00:18:632 (6,7) - Moving these two together 1/4 later with the same reason as above. Just try it.
3. 00:20:299 (3) - I'm not sure if this slider fits here. It can fit the sound at 00:20:632 - 00:20:965 (such quiet drums), but in this way it is placed wrong.
4. 00:21:632 (4) - You need a note at 00:21:799. This vocal sound is dominating here, you must emphasize it. Don't make the rhythm so easy for this kind of map, it would be nice it you have tried to follow vocals better. The possible solution for this time is moving this slider 1/4 later and placing a note at 00:21:632, try it.
5. 00:22:965 (3) - The same.
6. 00:24:299 (4,5) - At this moment I began to hear something like synth at the background, but it is almost unnoticeable compared to vocals. You really must try to follow them :c (this part - the same suggestion as above)
7. 00:26:632 (5,6) - Try avoid touching. It looks odd imo.
8. 00:33:299 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - This is fine, but you almost always use stacking in other parts of the map like 00:37:965 (4,6,1,2) - so I would like to see the stacking here too.
9. 00:41:799 (4) - VERY unexpected thing. I've broke my combo here. Ctrl+R it. All upcoming patterns like this will be much easier if you show the rhythm here.
10. 00:46:632 - You need a note at this downbeat. There is a bass sound here and beginning the combo from the red tick sounds and plays weird.
11. 00:52:965 (4,5) - Rework the rhythm please. Delete (4), move (5) 1/4 earlier, add notes at 00:52:965 and 00:53:632.
    
    SPOILER

    
12. 00:55:632 (1,2) - This would break your nice pattern, but this is surely needed: move (2) 1/4 earlier and add a note at 00:56:299. Here is the possible solution (pay attention to playfield as well as to the timeline):
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 00:57:299 - Again: you miss downbeat. Piano and bass sound call for a note.
14. 00:57:965 (4,5) - Er, stack them?
15. 00:59:965 - To be honest, I'm not so sure with this downbeat sound. Starting combo from vocals is also fine, but adding a note here is still better.
16. 01:00:632 (4,5) - Same stack.
17. 01:04:965 (2) - Move it some grids down to avoid touching sliders please. Also try to move this note and 01:03:299 (1) - this slider to the center of the playfield.
18. 01:27:799 (3) - Try adding a long slider between 01:27:799 and 01:28:132, it fits vocal better. Screenshot (don't mind playfield, just timeline)
    
    SPOILER

    
19. 01:34:299 (5,6,7,8) - The rhythm here must be like this. Try placing sliders like in this screenshot by the way. Stacking their heads was confusing for me, again broke my combo.
    
    SPOILER

    
20. 01:37:465 (6,7,8) - Try deleting (6), placing a note instead (at 01:37:465) and moving (7) 1/4 earlier. Also copypaste (7) or (8) and Ctrl+H it, because now they are not symmetrical.
    
    SPOILER

    
21. 01:45:965 (5,1) - Not stacked correctly :s
22. 01:59:299 (3) - The rhythm must be like this:
    
    SPOILER

    
23. 02:17:632 (1,2,3,4) - Make the spacing consistent. 2-3 spacing is 1.0x while other are ~0.75x. Moving (3,4) down will help.
24. 02:19:965 (1,2,3) - You miss much notes with these sliders. They are too long and don't fit here :c
25. 02:20:965 (2) - Also this anti-jump orz... Remap this part please.
26. 02:28:299 (1,2,3,4) - The same as at 02:17:632
27. 02:47:299 (5) - End this slider at 02:47:632 and add a note at 02:47:799
28. 02:49:132 (3,4) - Make their x-coordinates be the same. I mean, place them on the same vertical.
29. 02:57:299 (2,3) - lolwtf, don't make this jump please D: It's ridiculous, you never used something similar03:05:299 (1,2) - before.
30. 03:05:299 (1,2) - Avoid touching again pls
31. 03:12:632 (7,1) - Here too, odd overlap. Rotating both sliders by something like -15° over their "Selection Center" origin would help.

1. 01:00:965 (3,4) - These sliders are upbeat afaik. They end on a heavier beat and sound weird. Try this:
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 01:13:632 (1,2,3,4,5) - The same here. Try moving sliders 1/2 later, filling the rest of the space with circles.
3. 01:21:299 (1) - Ohoh, big jump! This must not be in this Normal diff. Consider how can you reduce it. Removing one repeat from this and the next slider would work. you might need to rearrange the rhythm after this. Try this:
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 02:04:299 (1,2,3,1) - Nice idea but I'm not sure of it's playability. At least move 02:07:299 (1,2) - somewhere else, this anti-jump looks weird.
5. 02:45:465 (2,3) - Replace them with a slider. Red-tick rhythm is hard to play because it was never used before. Slider will clear this confusion.
6. 02:48:132 (2,3) - If you want to keep it consistent, replace it with a slider too. But if you want some variety, you can keep circles, because the rhythm is clear after previos similar pattern.
7. 02:49:299 (1) - Juuump, reduce it :s This slider is also kinda boring to play, try to separate in in two sliders.

grumd wrote:

— Overall

1. I feel that offset is slightly early. Consider adding +10 or +5. But since this song is so full of vocals and unstable in timing, I can be wrong. - I feel the offset is good as it is
2. You totally must not use standart combo colors. They are too bright, odd and the red one is doubled (so sometimes I can't recognize where the combo is starting). If you use a bit more pale colors, the map itself will become prettier to look at, and will not be so epileptic on kiais. Try these:
   
   SPOILER

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 121,232,143
   Combo2 : 230,230,60
   Combo3 : 240,90,79
   Combo4 : 103,207,252

   - Thanks for the combo colors :3
3. Hitsound suggestion: if you listen carefully (especially in "o'boy" diff), you will hear a clap sound at every short white tick: 00:15:299, 00:16:632 ... 01:11:299, 01:12:632, 01:13:965 and so on. You need to place claps there. Your clap is already taken so you can use custom finish for a usual clap sound or something.. If you don't want to to use many green lines, of course. But I definitely can hear a clap on every short white tick so yea, please rework hitsounds according to that. - We're already using a different clap pattern, adding hitsounds on every note wouldn't make much sense

Hard

— Mapping

1. 00:16:299 (5) - Moving this 1/4 earlier will fit the vocals much better. You probably try to fit drums, but please leave this for taiko maps; moving this sliders makes this map sound better. - I made these to fit the background music, and I think they fit better the way they are.
2. 00:18:632 (6,7) - Moving these two together 1/4 later with the same reason as above. Just try it. - ^
3. 00:20:299 (3) - I'm not sure if this slider fits here. It can fit the sound at 00:20:632 - 00:20:965 (such quiet drums), but in this way it is placed wrong. - Moved it to 00:20:632 -
4. 00:21:632 (4) - You need a note at 00:21:799. This vocal sound is dominating here, you must emphasize it. Don't make the rhythm so easy for this kind of map, it would be nice it you have tried to follow vocals better. The possible solution for this time is moving this slider 1/4 later and placing a note at 00:21:632, try it. - As I mentioned earlier, I am following the background music mostly in the beginning so I'd rather keep it the way it is. I tried the solution you provided, but I feel the way it is now makes more sense.
5. 00:22:965 (3) - The same. - ^
6. 00:24:299 (4,5) - At this moment I began to hear something like synth at the background, but it is almost unnoticeable compared to vocals. You really must try to follow them :c (this part - the same suggestion as above) - I can hear the instrumentals just fine ;; I'll keep it as it is for now.
7. 00:26:632 (5,6) - Try avoid touching. It looks odd imo. - Fix'd
8. 00:33:299 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - This is fine, but you almost always use stacking in other parts of the map like 00:37:965 (4,6,1,2) - so I would like to see the stacking here too. - A little variation is fine :3
9. 00:41:799 (4) - VERY unexpected thing. I've broke my combo here. Ctrl+R it. All upcoming patterns like this will be much easier if you show the rhythm here. - Ctrl+R'd it I decided change the pattern back after a little consideration, since I felt it was the best solution.
10. 00:46:632 - You need a note at this downbeat. There is a bass sound here and beginning the combo from the red tick sounds and plays weird. - Made that slider a repeat, with the bass at the slider tail
11. 00:52:965 (4,5) - Rework the rhythm please. Delete (4), move (5) 1/4 earlier, add notes at 00:52:965 and 00:53:632. - Done
    
    SPOILER

    
12. 00:55:632 (1,2) - This would break your nice pattern, but this is surely needed: move (2) 1/4 earlier and add a note at 00:56:299. Here is the possible solution (pay attention to playfield as well as to the timeline): - Done
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 00:57:299 - Again: you miss downbeat. Piano and bass sound call for a note. - Made it repeat and clap on slider tail, like Saten
14. 00:57:965 (4,5) - Er, stack them? - I think they're okay
15. 00:59:965 - To be honest, I'm not so sure with this downbeat sound. Starting combo from vocals is also fine, but adding a note here is still better. - Repeat slider with clap on slider tail added :3
16. 01:00:632 (4,5) - Same stack. - :3
17. 01:04:965 (2) - Move it some grids down to avoid touching sliders please. Also try to move this note and 01:03:299 (1) - this slider to the center of the playfield. - Done
18. 01:27:799 (3) - Try adding a long slider between 01:27:799 and 01:28:132, it fits vocal better. Screenshot (don't mind playfield, just timeline) - I feel that as it is, is better, since I am following both vocals and instrumental.
    
    SPOILER

    
19. 01:34:299 (5,6,7,8) - The rhythm here must be like this. Try placing sliders like in this screenshot by the way. Stacking their heads was confusing for me, again broke my combo. - Fix'd
    
    SPOILER

    
20. 01:37:465 (6,7,8) - Try deleting (6), placing a note instead (at 01:37:465) and moving (7) 1/4 earlier. Also copypaste (7) or (8) and Ctrl+H it, because now they are not symmetrical. - Done, done and done :3
    
    SPOILER

    
21. 01:45:965 (5,1) - Not stacked correctly :s - Oops xd
22. 01:59:299 (3) - The rhythm must be like this: - Made it like the picture.
    
    SPOILER

    
23. 02:17:632 (1,2,3,4) - Make the spacing consistent. 2-3 spacing is 1.0x while other are ~0.75x. Moving (3,4) down will help. - But the patterns are so kawaii ;; I'll keep them for now. Nvm, I think I misunderstood this the first time. Fix'd
24. 02:19:965 (1,2,3) - You miss much notes with these sliders. They are too long and don't fit here :c
25. 02:20:965 (2) - Also this anti-jump orz... Remap this part please. - I like these sliders so I decided to move them around a little but still have the same beat.
26. 02:28:299 (1,2,3,4) - The same as at 02:17:632 - Same answer ;;
27. 02:47:299 (5) - End this slider at 02:47:632 and add a note at 02:47:799 - Done
28. 02:49:132 (3,4) - Make their x-coordinates be the same. I mean, place them on the same vertical. - Done
29. 02:57:299 (2,3) - lolwtf, don't make this jump please D: It's ridiculous, you never used something similar before. Made it somewhat easier.
30. 03:05:299 (1,2) - Avoid touching again pls - Moved (1) down a grid.
31. 03:12:632 (7,1) - Here too, odd overlap. Rotating both sliders by something like -15° over their "Selection Center" origin would help. - Done

God, this modding is finally finished... Oh wait, another diff left D:

Normal

Mapping

1. 01:00:965 (3,4) - These sliders are upbeat afaik. They end on a heavier beat and sound weird. Try this: - I think it feels good as it is
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 01:13:632 (1,2,3,4,5) - The same here. Try moving sliders 1/2 later, filling the rest of the space with circles. - as above
3. 01:21:299 (1) - Ohoh, big jump! This must not be in this Normal diff. Consider how can you reduce it. Removing one repeat from this and the next slider would work. you might need to rearrange the rhythm after this. Try this: - I see no problems with "jumps" like this
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 02:04:299 (1,2,3,1) - Nice idea but I'm not sure of it's playability. At least move 02:07:299 (1,2) - somewhere else, this anti-jump looks weird. The auto stacking makes it look less weird imo
5. 02:45:465 (2,3) - Replace them with a slider. Red-tick rhythm is hard to play because it was never used before. Slider will clear this confusion. I tried using a slider there, doesn't look that pretty imo. And I think it's kinda readable in this situation
6. 02:48:132 (2,3) - If you want to keep it consistent, replace it with a slider too. But if you want some variety, you can keep circles, because the rhythm is clear after previos similar pattern. as above
7. 02:49:299 (1) - Juuump, reduce it :s This slider is also kinda boring to play, try to separate in in two sliders. as I mentioned before, and I like it the way it is

Okay fine... Good mapset, though this mod took so much time for me ;_;

Genkishi wrote:

Hi

[General]
-Disable Countdown Disabled
-Change the mp3 bitrate to 192 kps? (Im not really sure about this but if you do it the offset will be change) changing the bitrate wont make the quality better
-Nidert.png has a 200x58 size and Saten.png has 200x62..How about making the size equal? not really necessary though

[Normal]
02:04:299 (1,2,3) - Why the spacing become larger? I think that Normal's spacing should be consistent but anyway it plays nice It plays nice yeah so I'm keeping it

[Insane]
00:47:799 (5) - 1 grid down and 1 grid to the right fixed
01:01:132 (5) - How bout stacking this at (4)? stacked
01:49:465 (6) - Add new combo here done


That's All!

Good Map!!

Good Luck

SPOILER

SPOILER

SPOILER

SPOILER

140,192,108965,2,0,B|88:184|64:124|76:56|132:40,1,200,0|8

SPOILER

zeroclover wrote:

General

SISTAR19 - Ma Boy Dance ver. (Nidert) KILL this one in your map folder - Done


blablabla boy

better this diff name : "ma boy" - As we've said earlier, we'd like to keep the diff-names as they are.

00:45:965 (2,1) - seriously hard to see this, because 1/4 jump is more like 1/2 jump o_o
i just make random stary jump for this, maybe will work for you - Removed reverse, added note

SPOILER

00:50:965 (5,6) - make those slider more sexy, it s ugly because the curve - Remade that part

SPOILER

00:53:132 (5) - i think white tick(downbeat) must have a note seriously, and fit with clap hitsound - I'm sorry, but I don't agree. I think since I'm following the vocals in that whole sentence, it would be weird to suddenly put a note there. As it is right now I feel is better.
00:53:799 - need a circle - I don't think it will fit, and it would probably make it more confusing.
00:59:299 (8) - rotate ? - I think it works well as it is.

SPOILER

01:07:965 (2) - dont tell me u just look those boobs, its not a cat face really
01:45:965 (5) - snap to the grid - Done
01:48:965 (5,4) - - more neat slider? maybe - Will take your suggestion

SPOILER

(5) slider :

140,192,108965,2,0,B|88:184|64:124|76:56|132:40,1,200,0|8

(4) slider , just copy (5)'s
02:00:299 (5) - think this too close just not like previous spacing - Fix'd it so that it's the same distance.

wow, u just make a lyrics from your slider, very good - :D


o'boy

01:07:965 (1) - sexy

SPOILER

02:07:299 (1) - too close, maybe move far a bit - As I said earlier, since it plays nice, I'll keep it.
03:07:299 - add circle?? - I don't think an additional note here would fit.

~~
a little mod, because your map already sexy

shojimeguro wrote:

Normal
put spinner 02:41:103 added
03:07:106 - missing notes like I mentioned before, couldn't find a good place to place it
and try to put some sound effect to the beats

Hard
try to put some sound effect
well at least the beat seems to be in place

that's all i can mod
i hope your beatmap will be ranked!!!

1. 00:43:632 (1) - remove NC here, and NC on next note , follows vocals
2. 00:52:299 (1) - ^
3. 01:31:632 (1) - ^ (this nc change can follow instruments too)
4. 01:53:299 (1) - make neater blanket around 01:52:299 (3) - ? move middle point (3rd point) to x:344 y:284 and last point to x:432 y:200
5. 01:58:299 (1) - remove NC here, and NC on next note (follows instruments also)
6. 02:22:299 (1) - ^ (u should actually do this one b/c it is inconsistent with 02:14:299 (4,1) - )
7. 02:43:965 (1) - add whistle at beginning? o:
8. 02:46:632 (1) - ^
9. 02:48:132 (2,3) - lol they seem kind of far from 1..
10. 02:49:299 (1) - whistle at beginning

1. 00:03:965 (1,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - you should put whistles in the beginning part here like you did with the "o'boy" diff.
2. 00:56:632 (4,1) - jump between these 2 notes might be a little big
3. 01:03:299 (1,2,1,2,3,1) - i like this part x)
4. 01:12:965 (1) - remove NC and NC on next note
5. 01:14:465 (1) - remove NC (same line of vocal is still going, and its also inconsistent with 01:24:632 (3,4) - )
6. 02:35:965 (4) - whistle at end?
7. 02:39:632 (3) - whistle at beginning
8. 02:41:299 (4) - ^
9. 02:43:965 (1) - ^
10. 02:46:632 (3) - ^
11. 02:49:299 (4) - ^
12. 02:50:632 (3) - ^
    (for all these whistle suggestions, i thought it seemed a bit empty, and its to follow the single piano notes)
13. 02:56:965 (1) - remove NC and NC on next note

meiikyuu wrote:

sorry for the delay ><

o'boy

1. 00:43:632 (1) - remove NC here, and NC on next note , follows vocals - Done
2. 00:52:299 (1) - ^ - Done
3. 01:31:632 (1) - ^ (this nc change can follow instruments too) - Done
4. 01:53:299 (1) - make neater blanket around 01:52:299 (3) - ? move middle point (3rd point) to x:344 y:284 and last point to x:432 y:200 - Done
5. 01:58:299 (1) - remove NC here, and NC on next note (follows instruments also) - Done
6. 02:22:299 (1) - ^ (u should actually do this one b/c it is inconsistent with 02:14:299 (4,1) - ) - Done
7. 02:43:965 (1) - add whistle at beginning? o: - Done
8. 02:46:632 (1) - ^ - Done
9. 02:48:132 (2,3) - lol they seem kind of far from 1.. - I don't see anything wrong with it
10. 02:49:299 (1) - whistle at beginning - Done

why you trippin' boy?

1. 00:03:965 (1,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - you should put whistles in the beginning part here like you did with the "o'boy" diff. - Done
2. 00:56:632 (4,1) - jump between these 2 notes might be a little big - I think they're fine
3. 01:03:299 (1,2,1,2,3,1) - i like this part x) - Removed it. Thanks
4. 01:12:965 (1) - remove NC and NC on next note - Done
5. 01:14:465 (1) - remove NC (same line of vocal is still going, and its also inconsistent with 01:24:632 (3,4) - ) - Done
6. 02:35:965 (4) - whistle at end? - Done
7. 02:39:632 (3) - whistle at beginning - Done
8. 02:41:299 (4) - ^
9. 02:43:965 (1) - ^
10. 02:46:632 (3) - ^
11. 02:49:299 (4) - ^
12. 02:50:632 (3) - ^ - Fix'd all
    (for all these whistle suggestions, i thought it seemed a bit empty, and its to follow the single piano notes)
13. 02:56:965 (1) - remove NC and NC on next note

- Done


nice map, and k-pop <3 gl

pyransc wrote:

[General]
Remove the movie, ladies do not allow to focus ;;


[o'boy]
00:11:799 (2) - remove circle ? it's fine as it is
00:25:299 (1) - create somthing like this more symetrical http://puu.sh/Xs1A ? did something similar
00:30:632 (2) - create somthing like this more symetrical http://puu.sh/Xs3H ? as above
02:41:299 (1) - start here 01:41:132 You mean 02:41:132 , but that's on a red tick and I think it's better if it start on a white tick imo

[why you trippin' boy]
00:29:299 (5) - Imo whistle is better here
01:07:965 (2) - ^ on first circle
01:10:632 (2) - ^
01:18:632 (1) - ^
01:21:299 (2) - ^
The same way in second and third refren I don't really think whistles fit on the non-calm parts
sorry for my english.