forum

[proposal - metadata]About artist

posted
Total Posts
3
Topic Starter
SparkNights
Some musical works have more than 1 artists. But the separators between 2 artists in beatmaps even if ranked maps aren't unified.
  1. Some are "," (Such as Happy*Material),
  2. Some are "&" (Such as Impulse),
  3. And some are "x" (Such as Uchiage Hanabi).


While sorting your maps by artist in game, you may see some maps with same song have various written way. Such as "A&B" "A,B" "BxA".
  1. When there is a map of another song with the artist of "A,C", you may see the order "A,B" "A,C" "A&B", thus, maps of same song may be separated.
  2. If there is a map of a song with the artist of "B,A", you may see the order "A,B" "A1" "A2" "A3" ... "B,A", you can image how the maps of same song to be greatly separated while A=A, B=Z and A1,A2,A3...=B,C,D...


So It's time to unify the order of artists and the separator between 2 artists.
The best way to order artists is softing by the letter order A-Z. For example,
  1. Happy Halloween's artists was ordered incorrectly. Because of the artists Yuikonnu , Ayaponzu, As we all know, A is the former of Y, So Ayaponzu should be the former.
  2. Uchiage Hanabi's artist was ordered correctly for the artists DAOKO , Kenshi Yonezu. D is the former of K. So the map was ordered correctly


About separator, I suggest a template of
A , B

For example
Shimotsuki Haruka , Suzuyu ("Shimotsuki Haruka, Suzuyu" is wrong for lack of space)

Ayaponzu , Yuikonnu ("Yuikonnu , Ayaponzu" is wrong for wrong order)
DAOKO , Kenshi Yonezu

What you should notice is that there must be a space between each artist and the separator"," , which will be convenient for searching. And the template should also be used in Unromanisted Artist.
Based on "A , B" the key words are "A" and "B", but without space, the key words will become "A," or ",B" especially "A,B". while searching for A's works, the "A,B" works won't be found but "A , B" works can.
pishifat
ive added a comment about this to https://gist.github.com/Okorin/15b12769091f4f6750625a5572245ea8 because the metadata section of the rc will soon be replaced by this. those in charge of metadata will make a decision on this subject, so i'll be archiving the thread
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply