forum

Celebrity PYP Mafia (TOWN VICTORY!)

posted
Total Posts
1,214
show more
Salvage

NoHItter wrote:

Vote: Salvage

Care to explain why a lurker lynch would be better than lynching any of the other people?
You explained why lynching Chris and Sync would be a bad thing, but what about everyone else?

You didn't comment on Backfire or bmin even though their actions were somewhat suspicious.
Basically wanting to lynch a lurker when there are other "better" options?

Unless you're implying that lynching based on activity now has higher priority over lynching based on suspicions?
Looking at your statement regarding Wojjan, it seems that you would prefer lynching someone with a "null" read over someone who you find "suspicious" even if slightly.

Edit: Need to get back to class now




i have to go to uni right now but wtf is this?



i posted my thoughts about backfire and bmin on the last pages (even asked bmin to give his insight of the game cause this of that i thought of him) and i already stated why i think lynching lurkers it's better than lynching someone im not FULLY suspicious of



you not reading the game it's so mafia like, soooooooooo mafia like, i have to go anyways guys back later.
NoHitter
So basically Salvage, you would rather lynch someone who you have no read on than someone who you have even a little suspicion on?

That's bad play IMO.
Salvage
yes, i do think lurking its bad for town and it SHOULD be even worse for mafia (even tho right now it's a good tactic for mafia .. see how you defend it so badly)


that's my whole point on the thing, and it being a good mafia tactic over an awfull on town makes the person more suspicious than the other one




i really have to go now im getting late, back to u on like 3 or 4 hours.
NoHitter

Salvage wrote:

yes, i do think lurking its bad for town and it SHOULD be even worse for mafia
So you consider lurking a scum tell then?
IMO lurking is not a scum tell. Even town may lurk. (Case in point, dkun in Smalltown)

Also, "it SHOULD be even worse for mafia"?
What do you mean by that exactly?
Backfire
@DxS, Im sure you probably think I dont have problems but my family was threatened by someone as well as my school yesterday. I hardly posted at all. I want to relax after that, not sit here and read all this loop de loop bullshit.

@Sync, My roleclaim does seem fishy, and I realize that. I just need a little bit of time before I can do anything. If you give me the benefit of the doubt, who knows, maybe I'll get something that could really help town?
I don't know how it activates though, and thats the worst part :(
Salvage

NoHItter wrote:

Salvage wrote:

yes, i do think lurking its bad for town and it SHOULD be even worse for mafia
So you consider lurking a scum tell then?
IMO lurking is not a scum tell. Even town may lurk. (Case in point, dkun in Smalltown)

Also, "it SHOULD be even worse for mafia"?
What do you mean by that exactly?


with that it should be even worse for mafia i mean that lurking for town it's bad cause it confuses town and ur not contributing to the game BEING town so ur playing anti-town (it's not nessesary a scum tell, it's a scum action)



so if town doesn't lurk and contributes to the game then mafia shouldn't lurk either cause it would be really obvious, with that said if everyone contributes then it HELPS town, if you're town you can't be against it, if you're mafia then you have no other choice than to end up contributing



so if even after me expalining my train of thoughts again right now the people that are lurking keeps lurking then yes im up for they're lynch cause they're playing anti townish.
Chris_old
unvote

inb4 game stalls out and jinxy gets lynched anyways
Chris_old
why is there not a lot more claims

you guys are bad
Chris_old
7. JInxyjem - Motivator
8. Chris - Doctor
3. Sync - Cop
2. Backfire - Vanilla Town
1. Salvage
4. pieguy1372
5. Wojjan
6. bmin11
9. Rantai
10. DeathxShinigami
11. LunaticMara
12. NoHItter
Chris_old
vote: bmin
Chris_old
unvote vote dxs
bmin11
Watcher. Albert Einstein. Going to class see you later.
Chris_old
7. JInxyjem - Motivator
8. Chris - Doctor
3. Sync - Cop
2. Backfire - Vanilla Town
6. bmin11 - Watcher
1. Salvage
4. pieguy1372
5. Wojjan
6. bmin11 - Watcher
9. Rantai
10. DeathxShinigami
11. LunaticMara
12. NoHItter

so far we have

I protect Sync
bmin watches Sync
Jinxy motivates Sync
Salvage
chuck norris 1 shot bulletproof joat
Salvage
JOAT: tracker, cop, rolecop, doctor
Chris_old
really wow

now I'm starting to doubt these roleclaims

7. JInxyjem - Motivator
8. Chris - Doctor
3. Sync - Cop
2. Backfire - Vanilla Town
6. bmin11 - Watcher
1. Salvage - Bulletproof JOAT
4. pieguy1372
5. Wojjan
6. bmin11 - Watcher
9. Rantai
10. DeathxShinigami
11. LunaticMara
12. NoHItter
NoHitter

NoHItter wrote:

I don't even know who the hell dkun picked.
Adele, Commuter. I apparently can "disappear" on certain nights.
Chris_old
7. JInxyjem - Motivator
8. Chris - Doctor
3. Sync - Cop
2. Backfire - Vanilla Town
6. bmin11 - Watcher
1. Salvage - Bulletproof JOAT
12. NoHItter - Commuter
4. pieguy1372
5. Wojjan
9. Rantai
10. DeathxShinigami
11. LunaticMara

wojjan rantai dxs and mara mafia!

calling it now
Chris_old
well maybe 4 is too many but still

I'd suggest you cop Rantai salvage

or wojjan

don't need stronger players having influence if they're mafia

also everyone get your votes off of jinxy or vote dxs so they don't die
Salvage
wojjan is mafia imo i called it like 20 pages ago


do you want me to cop or rolecop her
Salvage
ok i'll cop her and we lynch mara, fair enough?
Chris_old

Salvage wrote:

wojjan is mafia imo i called it like 20 pages ago


do you want me to cop or rolecop her
yeah I kinda assumed that too

it's up to you I don't guess it really matters

role cop would probably be more effective if they don't claim
Chris_old
unvote vote mara
Salvage
unvote, vote LunaticMara
Chris_old
nohitter please vote mara friend

no one wants a motivator getting lynched
NoHitter
Unvote
Vote: Mara
Chris_old
7. JInxyjem - Motivator
8. Chris - Doctor
3. Sync - Cop
2. Backfire - Vanilla Town
6. bmin11 - Watcher
1. Salvage - Bulletproof JOAT
12. NoHItter - Commuter
4. pieguy1372
5. Wojjan
9. Rantai
10. DeathxShinigami
11. LunaticMara

Pieguy/Wojjan/Rantai/DxS/LunaticMara need to claim

Jinxyjem motivates Sync
bmin watches Sync
Chris protects Sync
Salvage scans Wojjan
Mara

LunaticMara wrote:

I will give you a free hat in TF2, if you write that book.
Start guessing.
Chris_old
tf2 spy

mafia
Mara
spy is a nice celebrity

wait
Salvage
you may as well vote for yourself if you're not gonna contribute anything or even roleclaim.




from my experience from mafia games before that 'anti massclaim' feature some hosts added massclaiming wins games cause fakeclaims get too obvious eventually so i don't have any problem with massclaiming since i believe there is no such feature in this game.
Mara
too fat to vote
Salvage
feel the pain of the slow death then
Mara
too much fat to feel the pain

feel the rage
Mara
someone should post that salvagerage.mp3 like right now
Chris_old
I really hope you're a roleblocker
Salvage
do you really think i would rage cause u can't defend urself?
Mara
no time to roleblock since I'm making the new episode
NoHitter
Mara's softclaiming Gabe Newell.
You do know that you might as well have claimed it out front?
Chris_old
still not a role though

also how did you know that
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply