SkyDevil wrote:

Mod-a-lot

Easy
00:19:535 No stack please x3
01:09:078 1 grid up
01:15:420 le 3 grids up x3

[General]
키아이는 원래 룰이 화이트틱에서 시작하는거긴한데 님 노래 시작이 00:03:249 부터라..
오프셋을 00:03:249로 땡겨보심이 어떠신가요?

[suzutsukikanade's Easy]
01:05:135 (1) - not good (in easy mode)

[Yli's Normal]

OD +1

00:11:649 (1) - make curve slider

01:07:706 (1) - ^

01:29:477 (4) - nc

[SP's hard]

00:28:106 (1,5) - i don't recommend it

00:55:706 (5) - delete

00:55:877 (6) - move to here 00:55:706

[Insane]
00:41:477 (1) - 다른곳으로 옮기는 것도 나쁘지 않아보이네요 .오버랩은 아니지만 스핀이랑 노트 색도 비슷해서 플레이어가 헷갈릴수도 있으니까요(기본스킨 기준)

01:29:478 (7) - nc

Good luck

B2IN wrote:

[suzutsukikanade's Easy]
01:05:135 (1) - not good (in easy mode)

1. The kiai time in the end is inconsistent on suzutsukikanade's Easy and Yli's Normal. Have that match up with the rest of the difficulties.

1. 00:13:363 (3)-A kick-back slider like this on an Easy isn't really a recommendation. I suggesting replace this slider with two sliders perhaps? Like this.
2. 00:15:078 (1)-Well, a finish on the end of this slider would sound alright.
3. 00:17:135 (1)-A finish on the beginning would also sound alright here.
4. 00:54:849 to 01:11:649-Please put in a little more effort by adding in more claps. ): There are some parts that do sound like it should include claps.
5. 01:18:849 (1)-A finish on the beginning sure sounds fitting.

1. 00:14:392 (1)-A finish here sounds fitting.
2. 00:32:220 (4)-Don't mean to sound picky but try to blanket this slider around the approach circle from the previous note. You know, something like this perhaps?
3. 00:56:049 (1)-A finish on the end sounds fitting? Also, A new combo here doesn't look it belongs there. Consider removing it.
4. 00:57:249-A new combo here sure does it belongs there. o:
5. 01:05:135 (1)-A finish on the beginning would sound great here.
6. 01:05:820 (2)-Forgot to add a clap on the end?
7. 01:18:849 (1)-A finish here sure sounds fitting.

1. 00:53:992 (2)-A big kat here because this is where the chorus begins and you got to have a finish when the chorus starts, right? (:

1. SP really as no relation to the guest mapper's original name, which is dragonxcz. :/ I guess you have a thing for Scarlet Princess? But naming your difficulty after that than naming your difficulty by your original name can lead to an embarrassing situation in my opinion. I strongly suggest naming your difficulty after your original username. Also, when you do that, remove the "Scarlet Princess" text from the background for this difficulty and use a background like that with the text, you know?
2. 00:07:878 (5)-Forgot to add a finish on the end?
3. 00:59:478-Adding a new combo here would be fitting perhaps?
4. 01:00:335-Consider removing a new combo here.
5. 01:20:735 (6, 7)-The 7th note after a short 1/4 slider is kind of pushing it. ): I suggest moving the 7th note and add a repeat on the 6th slider.

1. 00:31:020 (9)-This comes out as a surprise after going through a kick-back slider. I suggest removing this note.
2. 01:03:763 (1, 2, 3)-A note triple here doesn't sound right and isn't fitting really. Consider turning this into a double. You know, something like this.

Roddie wrote:

General

1. The kiai time in the end is inconsistent on suzutsukikanade's Easy and Yli's Normal. Have that match up with the rest of the difficulties. Ended it as in hard, insane, and taiko

Yli's Normal

1. 00:14:392 (1)-A finish here sounds fitting. Done
2. 00:32:220 (4)-Don't mean to sound picky but try to blanket this slider around the approach circle from the previous note. You know, something like this perhaps? Fixed
3. 00:56:049 (1)-A finish on the end sounds fitting? Also, A new combo here doesn't look it belongs there. Consider removing it. Done
4. 00:57:249-A new combo here sure does it belongs there. o: Done
5. 01:05:135 (1)-A finish on the beginning would sound great here. Done
6. 01:05:820 (2)-Forgot to add a clap on the end? Oh, yeah, thanks
7. 01:18:849 (1)-A finish here sure sounds fitting. Done

That's about it. Call me back after you're doing looking through my mod post.

Roddie wrote:

SP's Hard

1. SP really as no relation to the guest mapper's original name, which is dragonxcz. :/ I guess you have a thing for Scarlet Princess? But naming your difficulty after that than naming your difficulty by your original name can lead to an embarrassing situation in my opinion. I strongly suggest naming your difficulty after your original username. Also, when you do that, remove the "Scarlet Princess" text from the background for this difficulty and use a background like that with the text, you know? - OK so you aren't first who don't understand it..
   I planned to buy supporter and then change name on "Scarlet Princess", and when it will dragonxcz's hard it will bad when I will another name..
   Ok so I won't buy supporter thanks to you^^
   
2. 00:07:878 (5)-Forgot to add a finish on the end? - Ok
3. 00:59:478-Adding a new combo here would be fitting perhaps? - Ok
4. 01:00:335-Consider removing a new combo here. - Ok
5. 01:20:735 (6, 7)-The 7th note after a short 1/4 slider is kind of pushing it. ): I suggest moving the 7th note and add a repeat on the 6th slider. - Ok

Roddie wrote:

Naryuga's Taiko Oni

1. 00:53:992 (2)-A big kat here because this is where the chorus begins and you got to have a finish when the chorus starts, right? (: - Fixed. Certainly I missed that >///<

Beuchi-chan wrote:

Hi old bubble!

[SK's Easy]
00:50:049 (1) - Being very nazi on this one but this shape just bugs me out too much, could you make it a bit more rounded please~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/300681 like this! Ok!

Beuchi-chan wrote:

Hi old bubble!

[Insane]
- This diff has a very weird usage of New Combos >:

00:13:192 (5) - I'm not Fixed~
00:15:420 (1) - This New Combo isn't necessary. Fixed~
00:19:020 (1) - ^ Fixed~
00:24:506 (4) - I don't think this jump fits at all here, maybe unstack (4,5) and follow the spacing? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/300736 okay~
00:29:306 (1) - Rotate the endpoint a bit to the top of the editor screen, that way you'll avoid the ugly overlap with 00:28:620 (4) - hitburst. rotated~ :3
00:44:392 (1) - Thie New Combo isn't necessary. Fixed~
00:45:763 (1) - ^ Fixed~
00:57:763 (1) - ^ Fixed~
00:59:992 (1) - The silent end of this slider sounds really weird, specially since this is the only place where you're doing this. I honestly think the normal hitsound doesn't sound that bad to make it silent deleted that 'v'
01:25:363 (1) - This New Combo isn't necessary. Fixed~

Fun map :3 Call me back when you're done with the fixes!