forum

Ryo (Supercell) - When The First Love Ends Feat. Hatsune Mik

posted
Total Posts
4
Topic Starter
mcwc2307
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Zing
Mod from my queue.

For my mods, green text represents suggestions, yellow are concerns, and red are immediate action points.

FUTSUU
SPOILER
Here, when I show you note selections, every character represents a half beat.

Recommended HP drain: 6.5

00:15:587 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22) - This entire first section lacks imagination. Indeed, it seems as if, for want of pieces to use, you've attempted to synthesize a dominant beat. You can help yourself out by mapping more to the lyrics - I like using k for higher pitches and d for lower ones. Example: for (1-4) you can use d-k-d-k-k instead of d---d-d-k like you have it.

00:28:587 (28,29,30) - There's no real dominant beat to justify (29).

00:31:253 (36,37,38,39,40,41) - Following my suggestions for pitch of lyric, you can also go for pitch of instrument. Following the instruments here would lead to this lineup being mapped dkk-dk-D instead of kkk-dd-K.

00:33:586 (44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - For (46-48) see my comments at 28:587. In addition, between (44-45) you've ignored a heavy snare hit; you can move (44) over a beat, and optionally turn it into a k, to remedy this.

00:38:586 (57,58,59) - Following my notes on pitch, this can be dkk instead of ddd.

00:42:253 (68,69,70,71,72) - I see you using red-tick hits to match the lyrics in other areas - why not here? Try kkdk-d- or k-kd-dk instead of k-ddd-k like you have.

00:52:920 (100,101,102,103,104,105) - Same here. Try k-dk-d-kd instead of k-ddd-d-k like you have.

01:19:586 (175,176,177) - (176) is practically a silent note. You also ignore the 1/4 roll going into the chorus - you can add a 1/2 burst to represent it. Try k---kkk instead of k-d-d-- like you have.

Rest of Kiai - look for opportunities to add more variety. It is perfectly okay at this difficulty to make bursts have both colors in them.

ONI
SPOILER
Here, when I show you note selections, every character represents a quarter beat.

Recommended OD: 5

00:38:253 (116,248) - This entire section, with few exceptions, follows a basic dxkx pattern. It's stupid simple, and very bland. Use melodic cues from the lyrics to spice it up at times.

01:22:086 (365,366,367,368) - This 1/1 break is hard to justify in an Oni. Try ddk-d-k instead of ddd---k like you have.

01:32:753 (432,433,434,435) - Same as above

01:36:920 (462,481) - The part here is oddly easier than the rest of the kiai, as if you copy-pasted from the Muzu and forgot to alter this part to make it harder. I would recommend keeping the intensity up in this part, like the rest of the kiai is.

01:56:086 (573,574,575,576,577,578) - Why did you do bursts here and not with (105-108)?
Topic Starter
mcwc2307
Thank you Zing! Really appreciate the mod! :D
Topic Starter
mcwc2307

Zing wrote:

Mod from my queue.

FUTSUU
SPOILER
Here, when I show you note selections, every character represents a half beat.

Recommended HP drain: 6.5

00:15:587 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22) - This entire first section lacks imagination. Indeed, it seems as if, for want of pieces to use, you've attempted to synthesize a dominant beat. You can help yourself out by mapping more to the lyrics - I like using k for higher pitches and d for lower ones. Example: for (1-4) you can use d-k-d-k-k instead of d---d-d-k like you have it.

00:28:587 (28,29,30) - There's no real dominant beat to justify (29).

00:31:253 (36,37,38,39,40,41) - Following my suggestions for pitch of lyric, you can also go for pitch of instrument. Following the instruments here would lead to this lineup being mapped dkk-dk-D instead of kkk-dd-K.

00:33:586 (44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - For (46-48) see my comments at 28:587. In addition, between (44-45) you've ignored a heavy snare hit; you can move (44) over a beat, and optionally turn it into a k, to remedy this.

00:38:586 (57,58,59) - Following my notes on pitch, this can be dkk instead of ddd.

00:42:253 (68,69,70,71,72) - I see you using red-tick hits to match the lyrics in other areas - why not here? Try kkdk-d- or k-kd-dk instead of k-ddd-k like you have.

00:52:920 (100,101,102,103,104,105) - Same here. Try k-dk-d-kd instead of k-ddd-d-k like you have.

01:19:586 (175,176,177) - (176) is practically a silent note. You also ignore the 1/4 roll going into the chorus - you can add a 1/2 burst to represent it. Try k---kkk instead of k-d-d-- like you have.

Rest of Kiai - look for opportunities to add more variety. It is perfectly okay at this difficulty to make bursts have both colors in them.

Okay. So i did the mod as you asked. But the diff is now 2.28 star diff. Isnt that not allowed by the ranking taiko critirea?
I heard it was supposed to be below 2.15
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply