Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Beatmaps
  3. Ranked Beatmaps (Archived)
  4. Beatmap Graveyard

Bad City - Fight As One

posted
Total Posts
22
Behon
Elite Mapper
1,380 posts
Here since the beginning
Topic Starter
Behon
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Saturday, June 29, 2013 at 6:54:44 PM

Artist: Bad City
Title: Fight As One
Source: The Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes
Tags: marvel superheroes iron man hulk thor captain america
BPM: 154
Filesize: 9522kb
Play Time: 00:55
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy (1.21 stars, 36 notes)
  2. Hard (4.4 stars, 90 notes)
  3. Normal (2.89 stars, 63 notes)
Download: Bad City - Fight As One
Download: Bad City - Fight As One (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Yes, I like this song. So sue me.
9/20: Fixed a slider DragonSparta had some problems with (along with some similar ones).
9/26: Made merchat7's suggested changes, tweaked and refined some note placement and slider shapes, and fine-tuned the timing a little.
10/5: Song seemed a bit loud compared to the hitsounds, so I lowered the volume of it. Please redownload if you got the song before today.
10/16: Made some of Byakugan249's changes.
3/5: Back from the dead! Changed slider tick rate in Normal & Hard, and changed the audio after noticing a volume drop towards the last part. Please do a full redownload.
3/13: Made changes suggested by Crimmi & B2IN.
6/7: Made changes suggested by TheVileOne.
6/10: Made some of the changes suggested by hichman and various other tweaks.
6/14: Made changes suggested by DarkSkyKnight.
8/11: Made changes suggested by DakeDekaane.
8/13: Made changes suggested by dubbadeni to Easy and Normal, and slowed down the sliders in Normal a little.
1/27: Made changes suggested by yurunneram & Guy.
2/25: Made changes suggested by Natsu.
4/3: Made changes suggested by -Bakari- and adjusted a lot of note placements in Easy.
5/11: Made some changes suggested by Kodora.
5/16: Made changes suggested by Sonnyc.
Last edited by Behon , edited 34 times in total.
Vergence
546 posts
Joined December 2009
Vergence

Hi~

Normal
00:35:252 (5) - Weird slider that has doesn't follow the flow of the song
_________________________
That's all I can find~
Good luck~
No need for mod4mod~
merchat7
1,673 posts
Joined December 2010
merchat7
From my queue

[General]

- Same difficulty setting (approach rate / hp drain / overall difficulty) for all difficulty? Reduce for Easy and Normal and increase a bit for Hard.
- Timing feel slightly off for me, check it.

Didn't notice anything else.

[Easy

- Try 2 hp drain 2 overall difficulty, 3 approach rate.
- Circle size 4 for easy :/ Can you remap to 3?]

00:18:586 (2,3,4) - Can you use a repeating slider instead? Confusing since (3) is on a red tick.
00:34:746 (1,2) - Slider instead, a bit more beginner friendly.
00:38:835 (1,2,3 1,2,3) - Copy and paste, try something different for this part.
00:47:402 (2,3) - Remove (3) and move (2) to the white tick or slider.
00:53:438 (2.3) - ^

I feel like i see the same pattern again and again and I don't see why you don't place note on white tick instead of red as they play better in an Easy.

[Normal]

- Try 4 hp drain / 4 od / 5 ar

00:15:276 (4) - Two sliders work better than a kick slider and allows for more interesting patterns.
00:21:506 (4) - ^
00:26:374 (1.2) - http://puu.sh/61XH better.
00:27:737 (3,4,5,6) Two sliders, or hitcircle <> repeating slider. 4 hit circle on a red tick doesn't feel right for me.

Your kick sliders can easily be replace with sliders / repeating slider + hit circle. Consider this for future maps.

[Hard]

- Try 7 ar, feel a lot better for me.

00:21:312 (4,5) - This instead http://puu.sh/61Ye, should fit with how you are mapping, but if possible try to rework this section a bit, add more curve and make it feel less linear.
00:24:816 (6.7.8 1.2.3.4.5.6) - Straight lines, make it more interesting.
00:38:835 (1.2) - http://puu.sh/61YF make slider better than in the picture.

Patterns could be more interesting.

It's a solid map, only one real problem which is same difficulty settings for all the difficulties. But, I feel you should try to rework the pattern and make it more interesting rather than straight lines and the likes. Thus, no star.

Good luck through.
YTYuyu
osu! Alumni
4,147 posts
Joined January 2011
YTYuyu
Yo modding this song because of ur request :)

Easy:
00:27:921(4,5) - move it 1 tick up for both

Normal:
00:19:165(3) - 1 grid up for the end point
00:47:963(6) - Make the slider like this http://puu.sh/76WP

Hard:
00:12:160(5) - 1 grid left for the end point

this is the best i can do. GL :D
B2IN
B2IN
[Easy]

00:21:492 (1,2) - beat : make this look ..as "00:15:457 (3,4)"
<move 00:21:687(1) / 00:22:466 (2)>

00:54:203 (4) - http://puu.sh/jLb2

[Normal]

noting


[Hard]

00:45:831 (3) - make curve slider


good luck ;) ;) ;)
Crimmi
1,947 posts
Joined June 2009
Crimmi
Modding,CrimmiStyle!!

From my mod resqueue!

[General]

I think you should shave that .08 off the BPM, and it sounds better too!

[Easy]

00:19:740 (4,5) - these notes feel a bit cluttered can you space them out a bit by a grid apart?
00:34:745 (1,2,3) - ^ Same here.
00:40:978 (1,2,3) - ^
00:44:078 (4,5) - ^
00:44:468 (5,6) - (6)? where did that came from, a mistake perhaps? because I thought that (5) was a slider which basically is not.
00:47:194 (2,3,4) - Put some spacing between these please.
00:50:309 (5,6) - ^
00:53:424 (2,3,4) - ^

[Normal]

~Nothing.

[Hard]

AR +1?

that's all i got on this map, good luck on getting it ranked :D
Behon
Elite Mapper
1,380 posts
Here since the beginning
Topic Starter
Behon
Manually bumping because hey, Avengers is in theaters in NA in less than a week! Let's get this puppy modded!
TheVileOne
osu! Alumni
8,431 posts
Joined March 2010
TheVileOne
Lets see what I can do.


Easy

Modder Comments

You simply must lower those difficulty settings. Use AR/OD 3 and Drain 4. The rest of this difficulties mod will be based on those settings. Hitsounds are decent, although those clap clap clap rhythms seem a bit odd to listen to. Changing the settings above, and the shapes of those sliders are the only things I really think you must do.

00:25:199 (2) - sounds empty. Might cut it as an Easy though. Then again I think it would be overall better if a note was there.
00:25:394 (2) - Move here 00:25:589 - It's a more playable beat. Then you should move the next slider here 00:26:368 -, end it here 00:27:147 -
00:35:134 (2) - remove clap?
00:35:524 (3) - Please change the shape of this slider. It doesn't look good. The same goes for any other sliders that look like this.
00:41:368 (2) - remove clap?

Normal

Modder Comment
Beat is solid, but the claps get in the way of the beat in my opinion. Of course I'm not going to force you to change them if you don't want to.

00:15:264 (4) - Ugh at these claps. Same thing goes for the other parts where it is just clap clap clap clap
00:21:498 (4) - Perhaps lessen this curve.
00:26:368 (1) - Replace clap at start and end with whistle instead
00:27:147 (2) - clap?
00:34:550 (2,3) - remove clap
00:40:784 (2,3) - ^ (It's throwing off my ability to hit them) Do the same for every stack you have clap clap, because it's nothing like the beat and it's misleading.
00:49:550 - Combo needs to start here. It just needs to.

Hard

Modder Comment
Claps are more tolerable, beat and symmetry is nice. There were a few things I found hard to read.

00:11:953 (4) - Turn grid snap off and put this in the center of the blanket slider.
00:16:823 - A note must go here I think, or you should just space out the notes instead, because it's hard to read when it's so high on the playing field.
00:17:407 (3) - Curves are a bit extreme. It breaks flow in my opinion.
00:43:316 (1) - This sounds like it needs to go here 00:43:219 -
00:50:719 (5,6) - The symmetry here bothers me. If you could do something else with the slider shapes.


Very nice mapset. The vocals in relation to the beat made it hard to read, but I can't blame you for that. You can have a star from me.
My Angel Kitteh
135 posts
Joined September 2011
My Angel Kitteh
Requested mod :3

Let's see~

[General]

Map is less that 1 minute and Kiai time takes half part of your map - seems strange.

[Easy]

00:22:862 feels empty - add circle, for example to the beginning of the slider
00:29:095 ^

[Normal]

00:11:953 add circle ?
00:13:316 ^
00:15:069 ^
00:18:966 ^
00:21:303 ^
00:24:420 and 00:24:615 ^
00:25:199 ^
00:29:290 ^
00:35:329 ^
00:38:641 ^
00:41:563 ^
00:43:316 ^
00:47:797 ^
00:54:030 ^


[Hard]

00:22:862 add circle

I am not sure if you will heed to my mod, anyways good luck with map :3
DarkSkyKnight
64 posts
Joined June 2012
DarkSkyKnight
[Easy]
00:18:576 (2,3,4) - feels awkward, but all right when i took a look at the distance spacing,..lol

that's why, i suggest the following changes:
00:18:576 (2,3,4) - change this to a repeating slider or a slider+circle etc.
00:21:498 (1,2) - change this to a slider because a beat on a red tick is awkward for beginners
00:34:745 (1,2) - this too to a slider
00:37:862 (4,5) - ^
00:40:978 (1,2) - ^

[Normal]
00:16:823 (1) - maybe move to x:480 y:144 because currently it's distance spacing is not correct VISUALLY
00:54:225 (1) - feels awkward

[Hard]
00:43:219 (1,2,3) - distance spacing feels wrong VISUALLY. move 2 and 3 a grid to the left maybe.

that's all i can do good luck :)
DakeDekaane
osu! Alumni
3,500 posts
Joined February 2012
DakeDekaane
Hi, mod time

[General]

If the bookmarks are there for no reason, delete them.

[Easy]

Nice flow, but having the notes on 1/2 can be a problem for Easy players, even I failed full combo on the 1st play, try keep notes on white ticks, here are some suggestions, keep the hitsounds
00:21:693 - Try this

00:24:810 - This

00:34:160 - This one

00:40:394 - This

00:45:849 - This

00:52:082 - And this too


Also you can try different combinations, but keep putting notes on white ticks on Easy.

[Normal]
00:11:953 - Add circle, it could see more difficult, but only do if following vocals.
00:13:121 - ^
00:15:069 - ^
00:18:966 - ^
00:21:303 - ^
00:25:199 - ^

[Hard]

00:43:316 (1) - Snap this to the red tick

I think that's all, good luck :3
Deni
Deni
From ★ ~ dubbadeni ' s Beginnner Modding Queue ~ ★
I'm a beginner, don't expect too much! ;)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

General

I didn't find much because they are both good difficulties! :)


Easy

00:27:537 Maybe try changing this part into something like this:

00:27:537 - 00:27:732 Slider
00:28:121 - 00:28:901 Slider

Normal

00:20:134 (1,2,3) - Maybe a bit too difficult for Normal?
00:43:316 (1,2,3) - ^
00:49:550 (1,2,3) - ^
yurunneram
682 posts
Joined January 2012
yurunneram
Ok~ I'll mod now ^^

Easy
Er... You might wana try circle size 5
00:15:459 (3,4) - Make it into a slider like 00:12:342 (3)

Normal
00:35:524 (5) - Make it end at 00:36:303

Hard
00:54:225 (5) - Make it end at 00:55:199

That's all ^^ Eh, oh yea. I PM-ed you something you should check
Guy
Former osu! Champion: 2014
2,049 posts
Joined March 2009
Guy
hi from my queue.

[Hard]

  • 　
  1. AR+1? I felt that better for me.
    　
  2. 00:16:433 (8) - move to x:80 y:112. To put it together at the position same as (6)
    SPOILER
    　
  3. 00:23:056 - add note. because you place note with this rhythm. (for example 00:16:823 (1) - )
    　
  4. 00:38:446 - add 1/2 slider? i think this pattern is match here.
    　
  5. 00:51:303 (6) - suggestion. change the end of slider for 00:51:888 - or add note 00:51:888 - . because I hear the voice of the vocal.
    　
  6. 00:54:225 (5) - slider end is 00:55:199 - . and add note 00:55:589 - .
[Normal]


  • 　
  1. omg, AR and OD6? You should change AR and OD to 5 or 4. i think that 4 is good.
    　
  2. HP-1 or 2
    　
  3. 00:35:524 (5) - slider end is 00:36:498 - . you set it for hard diff like that.
    　
  4. 0:43:511 (2) - 1/2 slider is better.
    　
  5. 00:47:991 (6) - more beautiful make blanket?
    SPOILER
[Easy]


  • 　
  1. 00:19:355 (3) - add whistle of slider end?
    　
  2. 00:48:186 (3) - remove clap?
that's all~
good luck ;)
Natsu
8,076 posts
Joined September 2012
Natsu
Hard:

00:12:927 move this to x:244 y:172 to fix distance problem
00:16:433 (8,1) - distance problems here too fix plz
00:24:420 (4,5,6) - i think this pattern look better:
SPOILER
00:37:277 remove whistle and add finish
00:55:784 reduce volume here to 15% maybe fit better imo (if you do this make it for all diff)

Normal:

00:27:732 (3,4,5,6) - this pattern look alot better on this way:
SPOILER
00:35:524 (5) - make it symetrical

Easy:

00:13:901 imo this look bad better move it to other place just saying
00:47:407 (2,3) - that look bad too 2 slider touching maybe 00:48:186 move this one to x:512 y:272 that fixt it

good luck :3
riffy
osu! Alumni
8,061 posts
Joined December 2010
riffy
Yo, I asked for some cool maps and gt this one from Kodora.

[General]
  1. Your hitsounds are too loud, imo. Try to reduce volume by 15-20%, I feel like it will fit with vocals/music much better.
  2. Disable letterbox during breaks, since you have no breaks i doesn't make any sense.
  3. You can use new way of creating sliders (youm know, 3 dots to create awesome circular-shaped slider) to improve your map a lot. Probably you want to refresh visual part of your style a bit. :3
[Easy]
  1. I can't say that CS4 is totally ok for [Easy], but as long as rhythm here is very simple and it fits with your patterns - it's ok. But please, think about CS3, it will make [Easy] diff more friendly for beginners!
  2. 00:24:810 (1) - why don't you end this slider at 00:25:589? I feel like it will fit with vocals MUCH better and also it will help you to keep rhythm more consistent. This is quite important for [Easy] diff.
  3. 00:29:485 (1) - I understand that this slideris consistent with other diffs and it firs here quite well. But how about something different? I'm pretty sure that sliders with two repeats are confusing for beginners. my idea see, if you like it or not.
  4. 00:55:784 - if you follow vocals, don't you feel like spinner should be started here?
[Normal]
  1. I'd recommend you to use AR5 here, it is more coomon for Normals. It fits with your SV better and it gives better flow. By the way, it is much more interesting to play this diff with AR5.
  2. 00:29:485 (1) - same as [Easy]. This slder is on each diff, so fix this slider in each diff to keep patterns consistent!
  3. 00:55:784 - if you follow vocals, don't you feel like spinner should be started here? same as Easy, just make sure that you keep patterns consistent. :3
[Hard]
  1. 00:29:485 (1) - same as other diffs.
    Note: with HP:6 it may hurt some low-skilled players because this slider is too long for this HP Drain rate :<
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I didn't like your sliders, to be honest. (It means that you can improve your map if you change some sliders into better-shaped ones). But you did a great job and I appreciate it! So, Good luck!
Kodora
Kodora
[General]

Hitsounds still too loud for me, i suggest you do it 10-15% more lower.
Disable Letterbox during breaks in all diffs, not only in Easy

[Easy]

Tickrate 1 fits better for me

00:19:355 (3) - Clap to the end?
00:34:550 (1) - Remove clap from reverse

[Normal]

00:15:264 (4) - Replace claps with whistles here
00:26:368 (1) - ^
00:27:732 (3) - nc follow music & pattern?
00:37:667 (2,3) - Replace claps with whistles
00:44:485 (4) - Try to silence slidertick here
00:47:017 (3,4) - Whistles here fits better than claps
00:49:550 (1,2,3) - ^
00:53:251 (3,4) - ^

[Hard]

00:18:576 (5) - NC follow pattern?


._. so short

Good luck with rank!
DX5536
437 posts
Joined September 2012
DX5536
I hope this shit help, I prefer the New Avengers more than the Avengers because there is Spidey and Woverine and Hawkeye as Ronin, epic :P

[Easy]
Maybe more circles?

[Normal]
00:29:485- Maybe instead of this repeat slider, you could add something like this


[Hard]
00:29:485- Maybe instead of this repeat slider you could add something like this


You are too pro for me to mod :cry:
/me runs into a corner while crying and read Avengers vs X-men (AvX)
Sonnyc
7,761 posts
Joined June 2008
Sonnyc
+1 for loud hit sound.

Easy:

-- Use tick 1? 2 sounds noisy and also this is the only diff you're using 2,,

00:15:459 (3) - Add whistle at the start, and the slide.
00:18:576 (2) - Delete Whistle.
00:25:978 (2) - Delete clap at the start.
00:29:485 (1) - Add a Finish at the start.
00:54:420 (3) - Delete Whistle at the end.

Normal:

00:24:030 (2) - Clap
00:27:147 (2) - ^
00:29:485 (1) - Finish at the start
00:34:550 (2,3) - 1 Grid right
00:35:134 (4) - 1 Grid left
00:35:524 (5) - 1 Grid down (for distance)

Hard:

00:16:823 (1) - Clap
00:28:121 (6) - Whistle
00:29:485 (1) - Finish at the start
00:32:991 (2) - Clap
00:35:524 (8) - Delete whistle at the end.
00:41:758 (7) - ^
00:40:394 (3) - Whistle!
bokito
76 posts
Joined July 2010
bokito
I'm a new modder If you thank i mod is bad that you can don't use my mod
[easy]
00:23:251 (2) - the head don't usy whistle
00:24:810 (1) - I think this is good-looking point
SPOILER
00:38:056 (3) - no whistle
00:52:082 (1) - Do you like this arrangement
SPOILER

[Normal]
00:15:264 (4) - The first exhumation of the arrow don't use whistile
00:16:823 (1) - The tail try to use finish ?
00:29:485 (1) - The second exhumation of the arrow try to use finish?

[Hard]
00:23:641 (3)
SPOILER
00:29:485 (1) - why don't in the first exhumation of the arrow add whistle?
00:43:511 (2) - add whistle?
00:45:459 (2) - clap?
P A N
2,354 posts
Joined December 2011
P A N
hi m4m from your queue.

[Easy]

00:19:355 (3) - make this curve can make it better for me
img
00:21:693 - try this maybe?
img
00:52:082 (1) - remake this slider and make it to this pattern, better for me
img

[Normal]

00:43:706 - add note
00:50:329 (4) - move to 344|288 looks better

[Hard]

00:54:225 - try this beat add finish at 00:54:420 also

GL :D
RikiH_
1,149 posts
Joined February 2011
RikiH_
hi

Easy

00:12:342 (3) - Uhm, make it symmetricl with the new algorhythm
00:17:017 (1) - Maybe a finish at the end is better than a whistle
00:25:978 (2) - ^
00:40:784 (1) - Put 2nd sliderpoint in 248|272, it's better
00:44:290 (3) - Remake it with new algorhythm
00:53:251 (2) - Put 2nd sliderpoint in 200|336, it's better
00:54:420 (3) - Finish at the beginning instead of clap?
00:55:589 - Add a note?

Normal

00:11:173 (2) - The pattern is a bit straight imo... Move this note 1 or 2 grids right
00:12:147 (4) - With the new algorhythm it's better maybe
00:15:264 (4) - It's only my opinion but I usually dislike sliders with two repeats. Make 2 sliders instead of one?
00:21:498 (4) - ^
00:24:030 (2) - Finish instead of clap?
00:35:524 (5) - It's a bit crooked...
00:41:758 (5) - This too, remake it with the new algorhythm
00:44:485 (4) - ^
00:47:991 (6) - ^

Hard

00:10:978 (2) - Straight patterns are a bit ugly, move this note 1 grid up or down
00:14:095 (2) - Move this 1 grid left or right for the same reason
00:20:329 (2) - Again! Move this 1 grid up or down
00:26:563 (2) - I think you understood what I'm trying to say, fix all patterns like this, please
00:29:485 (1) - Wouldn't be better with new algorhythm like this?
00:35:524 (8) - This is asymmetrical, people don't like asymmetrical sliders...
00:38:836 (1,2) - Add finish at the end of both sliders?
00:47:991 (8) - Again, new algorhythm

___________________________________

I hope it helps, good luck :)
BanchoBot
w00t p00t
34,832 posts
Here since the beginning
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
1 / 22