1. The Stars of Eternity (5.88 stars, 1321 notes)

1. fix audio bitrate, its still above 192
2. check aimod for unsnapped objects

1. 00:04:594 (2,3,4) - literally unplayable pls fix
2. 00:05:517 (1) - im pretty sure this sort of slider is unrankable since the path is pretty ambiguous as to whether it goes left or right even with the (barely noticable) offset that the slidertail has with the body
3. 00:07:978 (1) - this is the only long slider in the section that isnt entirely sharp, so ye
4. 00:13:824 (5,6) - ctrlg for spacing emphasis to 1 (and also because fast small triangles like this are kinda uncomfy imo lol)
5. 00:20:132 (3,4,5) - not enough spacing emphasis i feel, maybe stack this on the reverse arrow instead?
6. 00:47:363 (1,1) - angle shorter slider a bit towards the longer one so the flow is a bit more comfy like 00:44:901 (1,1) - i guess (sidenote: why don't you stack stuff like this instead like you did in the previous section for 1/4? doesnt have to be done, just an observation)
7. 00:58:440 (1,2,3) - nitpicky but not perfectlly centered
8. 01:06:747 (1) - maybe ctrl+g to keep the stack after 1/4 consistent (theyre the same sv you cant use the excuse that "the stuff unstacked were different sv")
9. 01:21:824 (1,2) - exposed
10. 01:36:286 (7,1,2,3,4) etc - not a fan of the sharp flow into the stream, kinda uncomfy
11. 02:13:517 (1,1) - why arent these mapped like 00:44:901 (1,1) - , theyre the same sort of sound
12. 03:56:901 - sv didnt seem slow enough to reflect the calmness of this section, maybe change but that's up to you since it plays fine either way
13. 04:13:517 (3,4) - aaaaaa
14. 04:16:594 (1,2) - are you unstacking these (^) on purpose (there's plenty of other places in this section where this pops up fix them thx)

newton- wrote:

hi, from queue
moca best girl No, Kasumi best girl
[general]

1. fix audio bitrate, its still above 192 Audio bitrate fixed, will fix the offset and timing points later.
2. check aimod for unsnapped objects Checked.

[ legacy]

1. 00:04:594 (2,3,4) - literally unplayable pls fix Hitcircle removed for note 3.
2. 00:05:517 (1) - im pretty sure this sort of slider is unrankable since the path is pretty ambiguous as to whether it goes left or right even with the (barely noticable) offset that the slidertail has with the body Slider is replaced with an alternative pattern.
3. 00:07:978 (1) - this is the only long slider in the section that isnt entirely sharp, so ye Not really a need to remove it, since it follows the rhythm flow.
4. 00:13:824 (5,6) - ctrlg for spacing emphasis to 1 (and also because fast small triangles like this are kinda uncomfy imo lol) Fixed.
5. 00:20:132 (3,4,5) - not enough spacing emphasis i feel, maybe stack this on the reverse arrow instead? Replaced with a hitcircle.
6. 00:47:363 (1,1) - angle shorter slider a bit towards the longer one so the flow is a bit more comfy like 00:44:901 (1,1) - i guess (sidenote: why don't you stack stuff like this instead like you did in the previous section for 1/4? doesnt have to be done, just an observation) Fixed, for the second section I did not stack the same because its a transition from fast to slow, as I prefer to use more simpler patterns on slower rhythm
7. 00:58:440 (1,2,3) - nitpicky but not perfectlly centered Fixed, didn't checked it before submitting it lol
8. 01:06:747 (1) - maybe ctrl+g to keep the stack after 1/4 consistent (theyre the same sv you cant use the excuse that "the stuff unstacked were different sv")Fixed, I had the idea of doing that but then I didnt implement that xd
9. 01:21:824 (1,2) - exposed Stacked
10. 01:36:286 (7,1,2,3,4) etc - not a fan of the sharp flow into the stream, kinda uncomfy Fixed.
11. 02:13:517 (1,1) - why arent these mapped like 00:44:901 (1,1) - , theyre the same sort of sound It does, but it transits from fast to slow,
    meanwhile the first section transits from slow to fast, so I prefer to use simple patterns.
12. 03:56:901 - sv didnt seem slow enough to reflect the calmness of this section, maybe change but that's up to you since it plays fine either way It should be slow actually, but since the vocals are following the rhythm itself so imo i'd just keep it
13. 04:13:517 (3,4) - aaaaaa fixed aaaaaaaaaaaaa
14. 04:16:594 (1,2) - are you unstacking these (^) on purpose (there's plenty of other places in this section where this pops up fix them thx)Definitely not haha, it's just that i forgot to check them lol

good luck! Thanks!

Hikan wrote:

hi, random
Saaya best girl no, tae best gril

general

seems gay! it sure is lol

a

due to your new mp3, the current offset should be somewhere at 634. You just need to do this, then Ctrl A the map and scale them to the new timing :wink: . So from now on, I will do timestamp it with the new offset (634 for me) 626 is pretty better for me imo, so i'd keep it 626, thanks for the effort
track override and slider border aren't relevant to the bg at all, at least try this It surely does,
the colors look similar thou
00:08:018 (1) - not curvy enough imo, bent it a bit? for me it's quite good enough somehow, or im just bad at doing slider art xd
00:11:403 (4,5) - dont really think it need that importance to be clicked there. 00:10:941 (2) - Take a look at this, it is not even a sound but you made it as clickable so that the drum after could be emphasised, meanwhile this 00:11:557 (5) - meh, not a sound as well but even have no reason to click that empty beat. I would rather you changed it (00:11:403 (4,5) - ) into a 1/2 slider, by that way players won't need to click that worthless circle. changed!
00:12:172 (2,3,4) - is this kind of undermapping style allowed o_o it seems that i overmapped... fixed!
00:20:326 - have you ever thought about put a circle there? added!
00:22:787 (1,3) - eww blanket im a nazi blonket maker im sorry jkjk
00:28:326 (3) - Ctrl G would be better imo fixed
00:52:326 (1) - after those shocking matrix, you started new measure as a stack lul
lul
lul
please unstack it thanks. I myself didn't recognize while modding it until the third check please unstack lul fixed
00:54:480 (6,1) - halo overlap desu
01:02:172 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,1,2,1,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - I see pp is raining in my kokoro aahh spacing reduced, i'd miss those jumps
01:06:480 (1) - why dont just a short spam, doesn't it will emphasis more? Otherwise if you prefer this, I would recommend you to Ctrl G, because it leaded to the outside against the next object, in case you can't imagine what is my english . fixed
02:35:018 (1,1) - same ^ fixed
01:28:480 (2,3,1,2,3) - tbh this flow is a bit hard somehow flow fixed, now it looked easier smh
01:30:941 (2,3,4) - try this https://puu.sh/vy0YM/45469036f8.png
01:52:634 (1) - ewww looks weird no its not , but i changed it anyways.
02:14:634 (5,1) - dont stack downbeat if you need its intensity
oh wait you can still stack it if you add a object here 02:14:710 - , since I heard a triplet updated to triplet
02:28:326 (1,2) - didn't saw that, fixed
03:10:172 (1) - actually this is like wtf to me https://puu.sh/vy1qt/fd4907c2c5.png it was meant to be like that somehow, but i'd prefer it this way.
03:50:710 - 03:50:249 - map? 03:50:634 (6,7) - why there is a double click here Dx
Also I would like to set the preview point at 03:52:095 - because that part is the calmest to me, but it is up to you for me its like the girls are at the peak of the concert soo i decide to put at the end of the chorus.
04:11:710 (1) - no sound, why did you map :d , I hear it really overmapped and you should remove that tbh it sounds like it does, removed it
04:31:403 (1,1) - overlap yet desu fixed
04:44:941 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - space stream? xdxd not really a need to increase but, i prefer it this way imo :3
05:01:557 (3,4,5,6,7) - pretty sure this part is 1/3 , change the rhythm pls (2 of 1/3 reverse sliders would be fine) fixed!
there are some points look the same with which I pointed, so I wont mod it anymore, just take a look at that and consider it yo. i updated most of the flaws, thanks

nice. thank you very much :3

For Osuology, thank you so so much for your kind comments! I appreciate that alot !