Soul Use previewtime 46473 like in the other difficulties.
Taiko Enable countdown!
Kiiwa Enable countdown! I'm going to ask you to remove this spinner again. All difficulties should start at the same position and have the countdown enabled. You can place a beat here (00:08:735) instead of the spinner.
Normal 01:26:512 (5,6) - Spacing between these two slider is far too wide.
You are missing some skin elements: you require a circle-overlay, approach circle, spinner approach circle. copy the defaults in if you wish, otherwise a player's custom skin will look strange.
Normal 01:15:130 (1,2) - these sliderends are not snapped, causing a tick to show up. disliked the higher sv and lower distance snap but ok
Soul ignoring the silly spacing 00:26:400 (2,3) - stack these on the end of the slider with 0 distance snap and grid off. 01:07:542 - useless timing line
James2250 EDIT: Double-checked it over with Shiirn. As well as the unrankable elements I would try and get a few more mods on Soul to try and keep the spacing slightly more consistent, there are some thrown in jumps like 00:27:230 (1,2,3,4) and 01:34:337 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) which could confuse the player. (Also I agree with Shiirn the distance snap on Normal really doesn't fit and makes it much harder to play)
01:55:441 (3,4) - in case that players use default skin, its too hard to see following notes, http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/209858 this is the easiest diff in the mapset. also, almost of beginners use default skin, i think. therefore, recommend to change some formation.
01:58:037 - unnecessary inherited point
01:58:050 - ^
00:17:982 (6,8) - kinda ugly imo
00:49:520 (4) - Add a clap to the end of this slider
00:57:345 (4) - Add a clap here?
01:05:408 - no note? felt it wired when test playing
01:40:739 (4) - Add a clap to the end of this slider?
01:42:162 (3) - move 2nd way point to 2grid left
01:48:565 (4) - add a clap here?
01:58:287 (1) - ^
00:10:157 - this part is lacking some hitsounds imo. also, As there is beat, it would be better to add a note with a clap here
00:13:951 - ^
00:17:745 - ^
00:21:539 - ^
00:30:787 (5) - Add new combo
00:38:257 (6,7,8) - This rhythm is kinda confusing and unexpected. because its not following anything
00:49:757 - Add a note with a clap here?
00:53:077 (5) - Add new combo
00:54:026 (9) - Add a clap here?
00:56:634 (4) - ^
00:59:479 - same as 00:10:157 -
00:59:954 (2,2) - its kinda ugly to me, how about stacking the end of these sliders?
01:14:418 (1) - i think this note is unnecessary. not following anything
01:26:512 (1) - Remove new combo
01:27:223 (4) - Add new combo
01:31:254 (5) - ^
01:39:554 (6) - ^
01:39:791 (1) - Remove new combo
01:40:739 (1) - Add a clap to the end of this slider? it will sound good imo.
01:42:399 (4) - Add new combo
01:45:245 (8) - Add a clap here?
01:48:565 (1) - ^
01:55:441 (1) - change to a stream? cuz there are beats.