yangzd88 wrote:

[EZ]
00:00:639 (1) - remove whistle sliderside sound　Fixed
00:11:194 - clap　Fixed
00:30:083 - ^　Fixed
00:40:083 - normal-hit　Fixed
00:40:361 - ^　Fixed

[HD]
00:09:250 - vol=5　不懂這什麼意思
00:17:583 (1) - clap?　Fixed
00:34:250 - whistle?　Fixed
00:35:083 (2) - ^　Fixed
00:40:639 - vol-10　Fixed
00:46:472 - no clap　Fixed
00:59:250 (4) - remove whistle　Fixed

wow star　Thanks

Roddie wrote:

Hey there.

At first, when I read the source that said "Steins;Gate", I thought the grammar was wrong. Like I thought there was was suppose to be a space after the semicolon. But I've looked it up and I guess that's how it's shown. *sigh*　Yes, the grammar is wrong (Even the character in this anime said is wrong) lol, but that's how this anime named.

Anyway, here's my mod!

General

1. Haku's Normal has a different offset than the rest of the difficulties. After you fix the offset and resnapped all the notes on Haku's Normal, you'll notice that the timing points will be snapped correctly on the ticks in the time-line. It wasn't before with a different offset.　I think we need timing help a little, even though 639 is prefect to me.

Easy

1. 00:00:639 (1)-Add a whistle on the beginning? Or maybe add a finish on the beginning...　Fixed
2. 00:10:639 (3)-Add a clap on the end.　Fixed
3. 00:40:083 (4)-Add a clap on the beginning?　Fixed
4. 00:42:861 (4)-Make this symmetrical with 2?　This is symmetrical with 2 already ... I think.
5. 00:55:639 (4)-Add a finish on that reverse arrow?　Fixed

Hard

1. 00:34:250 (1)-I'm not really much of a fan of anti-jumps. Well, that's just my opinion anyway... If you want to leave it like that, that's fine but what I think it's best is to use the distance snap on it. So the player would be able to read the spacing properly, you know?　I tried to make this map a little tricky, otherwise my map would be too easy ;__;
2. 00:56:194 (4)-Add a finish on the beginning.　Fixed

And that's it. Here's a star for you.　Thanks

If you have any questions about my mod, let me know.　Sure.

winber1 wrote:

I just added the clap Roddie mentioned. Thanks for the mod and suggestions!

@yangzd88: I think it's rankable. and the song is going really slowly at that moment so you have a lot of time to think of what to do. If it turns out to be unrankable, I'll change it i guess. I actually have been thinking about whether or not i should change it. I decided to wait a while and see what people say about it

@Roddie: that stream is played by the drums. tho i can see why people wouldn't like it lol (but i like it D:)

[NM]
00:31:184 - clap
00:33:962 - finish?
00:41:740 - finish ; 00:42:295 (6) - clap

done only those, as the other were almost nosense ( clap-on-red, removing sensed finish, changing volume more from 100 to 110%... and making soft hitsound volume even smaller than it is

What's with the multiple kiai time sections on this difficulty? Like on 01:02:861, 01:05:083 and 01:11:750. In my opinion, I don't think those are fitting at all... Maybe it's best to remove them, man. they're so much sensed though, just used them in afterkiai Finishes, and it felt good.
00:55:639 (2)-Add a finish on the end.
01:22:500- It might be better if you end it on 01:27:305. Something seems wrong >.< I made that end at the point is because it follow the bell sounds ( whose volume goes lower till that point in which they can't be heard anymore)

• Do not overuse kiai time (general rule is one toggle per minute of playable length). Do not use kiai time just for fountains unless you are doing this extremely rarely. Kiai time is meant to accent chorus sections. You can toggle it off and on halfway through the chorus if that looks good, but using it constantly every 4-8 beats is just stupid.

Weezy wrote:

Haku's Normal
- As much as I like the multiple kiai time, its overusing it which is a no-no. I wanted to do the same for one of my maps but it was overusing it.

• Do not overuse kiai time (general rule is one toggle per minute of playable length). Do not use kiai time just for fountains unless you are doing this extremely rarely. Kiai time is meant to accent chorus sections. You can toggle it off and on halfway through the chorus if that looks good, but using it constantly every 4-8 beats is just stupid.

01:15:916 (4) - Line this up.
~realllllllly like this diff! Best map you made imo Haku

other diffs are fine
nice set here

Weezy wrote:

No kudos is needed, should have said that :T

winber1 wrote:

lol i'm at my friends house.
Easy fix (turned it into a spinner lol >_>)

i'll probably get a new computer sooner or later

Weezy wrote:

Haku's Normal
- As much as I like the multiple kiai time, its overusing it which is a no-no. I wanted to do the same for one of my maps but it was overusing it.

• Do not overuse kiai time (general rule is one toggle per minute of playable length). Do not use kiai time just for fountains unless you are doing this extremely rarely. Kiai time is meant to accent chorus sections. You can toggle it off and on halfway through the chorus if that looks good, but using it constantly every 4-8 beats is just stupid.

01:15:916 (4) - Line this up.
~realllllllly like this diff! Best map you made imo Haku

other diffs are fine
nice set here

Sir Minelli wrote:

Hello,


[General]

The name at the title is wrong. It should be Toki Tsukasadoru (with a space)　Fixed

A better Preview Point: 00:44:527 - Make sure to apply it in all difficulties.　Fixed

Normal has a higher slider velocity than hard. Consider increasing Hard's slider velocity, or decreasing normal's one.
Afterwards, make sure to recalculate slider lengths and to fix the spacing. This is not unrankable after all, but should be fixed unless there is a good reason not to.

Normal also has some kiai fountains that were placed after the kiai timing section, and that somehow fit the music / lyrics.
I'm pointing this in case you feel like adding them to the other difficulties as well.　Seems like that's not allowed, Weezy(a modder) asked a BAT about that already.


[Easy]

All good.　Thank you!

[Hard]

All good.　Thank you again ;D

Weezy wrote:

Makes no sense really? Pretty straight forward, don't use kiai time just for the fountains. Kiai time and pulsing are two different notions, one is to put emphasis on the chorus (kiai time and its stated both in the new and old guidelines, yeah take a look at it.) The second is just for flashing at certain spots (which is pulsing and that's what the epilepsy warning is for.) Kiai time was designed to compliment a chorus selection, NOT just for fountain use. Think of it that way, don't compare two things that have different use.

I'm just trying to help this get ranked easily. Asked a BAT and this is their response:

Normal has a higher tick rate when compared to Hard and Insane. Normal is a guest difficulty after all, so the mapper could have interpreted the music differently. Despite this, the mp3 is relaxing and slow, so you should consider lowering the tick rate value to be kept the same across all difficulties.

Normal has a higher slider velocity than hard. Consider increasing Hard's slider velocity, or decreasing normal's one.
Afterwards, make sure to recalculate slider lengths and to fix the spacing. This is not unrankable after all, but should be fixed unless there is a good reason not to.

Weezy wrote:

I had the same style on my map, as you did only 3 times, and it was not allowed. Seriously your being stubborn here, its unrankable, Your using it just for the fountains which is clearly says not to do >_>
Even ask other BATs, most likely they'll give the same answer as jerico did.

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

i'm a stubborn mapper, i know.
Just leaving it as it is now, as it can't be called a "abused" use of kiai (and it actually isn't callable "abusing" ) as there are 4 fountains that have some disatnces and aren't confusive ( as fountains don't cover circles or sliders ).

Sir Minelli wrote:

Hello again,

What HakuNoKaemi said is totally correcty.

For a more in-depht information about the correct use of the kiai timing, you can read this

Those kiai fountains do not distract and were placed correctly. Even though they might not look that awesome aesthetically speaking, they do fit the music and are not considered an abuse. This is why I did suggest to apply them to the other difficulties if desired.

The abuse and misuse of the kiai timing is unrankable. In this particular case, it's certainly not.

Good luck.

Komeiji Yuki wrote:

If SB is rankable but overusing kiai fountains is unrankable

Why not make Diff. specific SB ...

Anyway , star

咩咩~

Combo burst 500x768!!

The soft hitclap SUCKS. No need for it. Doesn't sound any better. ;_;

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

Combo burst 500x768!!

Template is 388X767, limit in width is 500. I do not see problems here...

The soft hitclap SUCKS. No need for it. Doesn't sound any better. ;_;

Listen to the song .-.
Soft - hitclap is the Reverbered like Clap in the start
Soft - hitfinish is the tom in the start
Soft - hitclap2 is the snare in the song.

So listen better while modding hitsounds

theowest wrote:

ok, but can I get a kudosu for my other helpful stuff? ;_;

Mithost wrote:

From my modding queue.

I wish I could say something that could be improved here, but this map is great. I have no problems with the maps, and I think it should be ranked already. I am giving you the star this map deserves.

Nymph_ wrote:

Hi Nymph here~ and request got from: Kanon's Mod Queue~

General:
BG1 seems to be a bit odd for me, for the proportion seems a bit strange, so maybe fix it a little ? Just need to increase the height imo.　I took the original one and cut off most of the background XD

Easy:
00:57:305 (5) - I don't really like nazi but this spacing is really a little ugly 　Moved a little, but still the pattern.
others fine~

Hard:
I suggest more soft-whistles on this diff, seems the hitsounds now is a little too simple.　Yes, it's simple, but I'll stay the same for now.
00:42:861 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Because seeing you changed to normal hitsound at here:00:42:861 (6), Then I suggest all of these using normal hitsound, and cancel the clap hitsounds. And consider add a volumn increasing here seems to be very nice.　That's not really what I want, but still thanks for the suggestion, instead of that, I increased the volumes only.
00:43:833 (3) - add note here　Fixed
01:16:194 (8) - finish instead of whistle?　Fixed

Good luck~

RinNa wrote:

:3

flatps wrote:

Star~

Leorda wrote:

Hello

General
* I'm not sure if Outro video is safe　It's prefectly safe.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Easy
00:31:194 (5) - Make sure the sliderbody is visible for easy diff, this will be easier to see for beginner player if you change this　Fixed
00:40:083 (4) - ^　I'll keep this for now
01:15:083 (3) - ^　^

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hard
* AR -1?　No, but thanks for your suggestion.

00:33:694 (6,1) - No anti-jump please　Fixed
00:40:083 (1) - I think this slider is pretty silly　Changed it to 2 circles.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

cya　Bye ;D

Rukarioman wrote:

General:
- BG1 has wrong aspect ratio. it should be 1024x768. At the moment it is at 1024x759.　I just deleted BG1.
- Why do you really need two different BGs? Got a good explanation?

Hard:
Use tick rate 2 like Normal did?　Fixed
00:33:694 (6,1) - Please get rid of that anti-jump. Plays and looks fairly bad.　Fixed

Easy was rather boring, in terms of rhythm but the other were pretty cool. Especially Insane. Gonna recheck this　I know my Easy is boring ;__; thanks for your mod.