13:50 *Garven is editing (Ryu* - Starmine (pop'n mixxx))[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/31002]
13:50 <Garven> : I'm assuming 5 Button is a Normal?
13:50 <Sushi> : 5buttons would morre be like an easy/normal
13:51 <Sushi> : more *
13:51 <Garven> : Felt like a normal in the first 18 seconds, hehe
13:51 <Garven> : 00:05:390 (1) - Just the 4 repeat slider and the 00:12:976 (1) - note really soon after a spinner got me wary
13:51 <Garven> : Just wanted to check before I start doing my easy-rant :P
13:53 <Sushi> : I see
13:54 <Garven> : Just in general the short repeating sliders with more than one repeat are hard to figure out when they end - especially for new players
13:54 <Garven> : Aaand notes soon after the spniner are tough for new players since it takes time to re-aim
13:54 <Garven> : I remember my noob days when I spun with reckless abandon trying to score all those sweet bonus points
13:55 <Garven> : Totaly lost my cursor every time, haha
13:55 <Sushi> : Yeah, I see the concept, let me try to change that a bit
13:57 <Garven> : Whoa
13:57 <Garven> : 01:22:287 (2,1) -
13:57 <Garven> : That can't have been intentional
13:57 <Sushi> : LOLWTF
13:57 <Sushi> : ah, I know what happened xD
13:58 <Sushi> : Ctrl H+J solves it all :U
13:58 <Garven> : Ahaha
13:58 <Garven> : Love the way the slider ticks line up in that diff btw.
13:59 <Garven> : Though I wonder - with all those custom hit sounds, I'm surprised you didn't take out the sliderslide for quieter parts like 00:13:666 (1) -
13:59 <Garven> :
14:00 <Sushi> : removing the sliderslide would have been quite problematical
14:00 <Garven> : Mm, ah well.
14:00 <Sushi> : as I'm using all the sets, removing it for the quiet part also means removing it in a normal part
14:01 <Garven> : If you do some green line spam it'd work ;)
14:02 <Sushi> : :U
14:03 <Garven> : The re-kiais feel kind of redundant. There isn't much of a pause/feeling of a new pulse into a new round of the chorus imo
14:03 <Sushi> : for the 5B , at 00:05:390 (1) -
http://puu.sh/5NVb14:04 *Garven gives thumbs up
14:04 <Garven> : Normal: 01:12:287 (2) - whistle on slider slide D:
14:05 <Sushi> : ow
14:05 <Garven> : Love the effect with the volume on that last spinner though
14:05 <Sushi> : ;)
14:05 <Garven> : Overall kind of tough, but all your maps are kinda tough ;)
14:05 <Sushi> : xD
14:07 <Sushi> : for the spinner in 5B :
http://puu.sh/5NVQ14:08 <Garven> : In muzukashii: 01:14:356 (13) - Should be fine, yeah
14:08 <Garven> : Oops, heh
14:08 <Garven> : Spinner thing should be fine
14:08 <Garven> : Muzu: those finishes during the soft part kinda stuck out
14:09 <Sushi> : I kinda liked the effect of the finish hitsound in the soft part (using the taiko hs)
14:10 <Garven> : Mm, okay. It just kind of .. felt weird since there wasn't much of any sort of emphasis coming from the music at all
14:10 <Garven> : In Hyper: 00:36:769 (4,5) - I kind of expected these to be reversed considering how you started the combo
14:11 <Garven> : May have to adjust the combo afterward though if you do change it for flow purposes
14:12 <Sushi> : Not sure, I find that inverting them makes it a little "brutal"
14:12 <Garven> : Hmm, true
14:13 <Garven> : It plays kind of unnaturally for me as-is though. :/
14:13 <Garven> : Maybe something like this?
http://puu.sh/5NWR14:13 <Garven> : Only not as crude :P
14:13 <Sushi> : that could work
14:16 <Sushi> :
http://puu.sh/5NXi not sure about the reaction of players towards the change of spacing, though
14:16 <Sushi> : It should be fine as the previous notes are sliders, it kinda makes some "illusion"
14:16 <Garven> : You might be able to bump 00:34:356 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5) - up a few grids to give more room
14:17 <Sushi> : just one grid :U
14:17 <Garven> : :<
14:18 <Garven> : EX ate me for breakfast
14:18 <Garven> : Good stuff
14:18 <Sushi> : xD
14:19 <Garven> : I'm sure Oni will as well
14:19 <Sushi> : :p
14:19 <Garven> : autoplay gogo
14:20 <Garven> : Aaah, it's so nice to hear a good sounding taiko
14:21 <Garven> : Don't get those very often. Good job.
14:21 <Sushi> : ;)
14:22 <Garven> : 5 Button: 00:06:769 (2) - whistle on slider slide? It doesn't sound too bad on this one, but I dunno if it was intentional
14:24 <Sushi> : Yeah kinda intentional
14:24 <Garven> : Kinda huh? ;p
14:24 <Garven> : I wonder if we can simplify a couple rhythms in 5b so we can bump the star rating down a touch
14:25 <Garven> : Like changing 01:04:011 (3,6) - to just single circles cut it down a bit without touching the difficulty at all
14:26 <Sushi> : Hmmm, not very sure about it
14:26 <Garven> : Just did a lazy arrange like
http://puu.sh/5NZJ14:26 <Sushi> : oh well, that's supposed to be an easy
14:26 <Garven> : And it worked okay
14:26 <Sushi> : yeah, that's the change I was thinking about as well
14:27 <Garven> : You should link the skin that this map is requesting in the thread.
14:29 <Sushi> : huh
14:29 <Sushi> : oh my, I may have put something for testing something and not removing it
14:29 <Sushi> : gonna fix it xD
14:29 <Sushi> : yeah, totally forgot to remove something on just one diff
14:29 <Sushi> : and never noticed that as it was my own skin :U
14:29 <Garven> : Haha
