Baby Alice - Pina Colada Boy (Nightcore Mix) · forum

galvenize

Joined June 2010

galvenize 2011-05-07T17:47:40+00:00

[Easy]

ok

[Normal]

ok!

[Samah's]

How about increasing OD by one like Gio's diff?

01:19:716 (6) - Starting a new combo here would be advised.

[Gio's]

Slider tick rate 1?

01:49:663 (9) - Suggestion: x0.5 speed on this slider?
02:01:875 (x) - a triplet here would make it sound better
02:02:937 (6) - this triplet doesn't sounds good tho xd.
02:17:592 (6) - Spacing

[Insane]

Mmh, looks ok.

kanpakyin

Global Moderator

4,231 posts

Joined June 2010

kanpakyin 2011-05-07T17:49:00+00:00

Too many diff.

[General]

I think Lead in 2500 is enough.
No source?

[Easy]

00:00:920(1)-A finish here would be nice.
00:03:468(3.1.2)-Here has a inconsistent spacing but not a big problem..
00:09:412(3)-Add a whistle here!
01:20:778(x)-I prefer add a note here..Well depends on you.
01:47:964(1)-Remove new combo here.
02:21:946(x)-Add a note here due to accent point.also add a fnish here if you change it.
02:26:831(4)-How about add a whistle here?

[Normal]

01:07:1859(1)-Add a finish at the beginning?
02:26:831(4)-How about add a whistle here?

Good.

[giO's Hard]

Rename it to Insane.
00:09:415(8.9)-Don't stack here...Feel weird during gameplay.
00:20:672(4.5.6)-Don't reduce spacing suddenly!If you want to do that at least add some new combo to remain it.
00:24:070(4.5)-^ (Won't write this again)
01:56:884(x)-Unused grren line.Remove it.
002:01:875(x)-Add a note here?
02:02:937(5)-Remove it?

[Samah's Hard]

Why these hard seems like insane D:
00:38:300(4)-Don't change the slider speed here :< It's unnecessary
00:44:247(x)-Yolume +10%?
01:28:424(x)-^ Same.
02:20:247(1)-C1 finish might better then this.
02:26:831(4)-How about add a whistle here?

[Insane]

00:30:866(1.2.3.4)-Increase the spacing a little bit?I think that's more fun.
00:44:459(6-10)-A little bit ugly.
01:59:220(1.2.3.4)-Would you make this square more regulaily?
02:26:831(4)-How about add a whistle here?

Good map..

Aleks719

osu! Alumni

2,436 posts

Joined May 2010

Aleks719 2011-05-07T17:49:06+00:00

All diffs
02:26:831 (x) - add whistle at this point (last beat in song) in all diffs x)

Insane
00:37:238 (4) - imo, looks pretty :

SPOILER

01:21:415 (4) - ^
02:05:592 (1) - imo, looks pretty :

SPOILER

02:07:291 (1) - ^

Samah's Hard
00:59:964 (4) - End at red tick sounds bad, make slider 1/2 longer?
01:01:663 (4) - ^
01:06:760 (5) - ^
01:08:459 (4) - ^
01:19:716 (5,6) - pretty confused antijump

giO's Hard
Set slider-tick rate 1

Normal
01:03:787 (6) - add note

Easy
nothing

Star

IceBeam

osu! Alumni

1,957 posts

Joined December 2009

IceBeam 2011-05-07T17:50:22+00:00

Hi Andrea!

[Easy]
00:58:689 - I'd continue 00:55:291 (1) spinner up to this time. There's only1-beat space between spinner and circle,but hitting slider is much easier then hitting circle for beginners.

[Normal]
01:49:663 (5) - I'd add finish here.

[giO's Hard]
00:12:601 (4) - Sounds off to me,cut this slider at 00:12:813?
00:27:468 (7) - Sounds weird to me..I think you shouldn't use 00:27:574 (blue tick) here.
00:41:061 (1,2) - 1 grid left (lvl3) for both.It'll be symmetrical.
01:11:645 (7) - Same suggestion about reverse-slider.
01:25:238 (1,2) - 1 grid right (lvl3) both.
01:49:663 (9) - Finish?
01:56:884 - Use lower volume/soft section for this note..it's too rough and loud

02:02:937 (5) - Plays/sounds bad to me..I'd remove it.
02:17:274 (5,6) - Spacing between them looks much farther then in the rest of the map..not a big deal,but looks like a mistake.

[Samah's Hard]
Probably blue tick is overused and don't really like all these sudden slowdowns.
01:20:141 - Add a note?

[Insane]
Perfect to me.

Starring~

chungskale

120 posts

Joined December 2009

chungskale 2011-05-07T17:51:59+00:00

hi ><!
i am not so good at modding so give only some feeling during i play

Feels good

and i like the loli bg pic XD

comfortable Easy and Normal, i can't spot any mistakes

[Insane]

01:29:061 (10) - perfectly curve maybe better.
02:22:371 (3) - i feel better if changing this slider into notes

[giO's Hard]

00:20:672 (4,5,6) - fine but i prefer to do jump more, you may ignore this
01:05:273 (6) - maybe delete this and change 01:05:061 (5) - into slider end at 01:05:273 (6) - ?

[Samah's Hard]

like this diff

Ekoro

3,456 posts

Joined March 2010

Ekoro 2011-05-07T17:59:54+00:00

Haï' :3

[Easy]

00:14:937 (1) - Look ugly D: Maybe like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560600:59:114 (2) - ^ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/85611

[Normal]

Looks good ~

[giO's Hard]

Don't like anti-jumps , maybe stacks it' ?Like :
00:20:672 (4,5,6) - ~00:22:371 (4,5) - ~00:24:070 (4,5) - ~01:04:849 (4,5,6) - ~ 01:06:548 (4,5) - ~01:08:247 (4,5) - ~

Okay let's see ~
00:41:061 (1,2) - Looks awful ;_; Maybe like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8561300:42:760 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/85614 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8561501:25:238 (1,2) - ^ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8561601:26:937 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/85618 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8561901:56:884 - 01:59:220 - Insert break here?

[Samah's Hard]

01:06:760 (5) - Hard to read' , maybe like this : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8562401:08:459 (4) - ^ Just copy-paste 01:06:760 (5) ~

[Insane]

Cute diff' ~
01:47:964 (3,4) - huh , hard to read. Maybe like this : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/85628

That's all.

Star !

Andrea

Beatmap Nominator

16,650 posts

Joined August 2008

Topic Starter

Andrea 2011-05-07T23:24:32+00:00

Thanks so much everyone for all the help!

Most of the suggestions has been applied.

Tenshi-nyan

1,482 posts

Joined September 2010

Tenshi-nyan 2011-05-08T11:49:56+00:00

Wahwah, don't you think that the BG pic is a little too ecchi? She's basicly not wearing anything

is dat Fujiwara no Mokou? :>

but since it's Nightcore it's of course all okey-dokey.

Just... you know... wanted to tell ya,

Andrea

Beatmap Nominator

16,650 posts

Joined August 2008

Topic Starter

Andrea 2011-05-08T18:14:12+00:00

There isn't anything of suggestive on it, though

So I guess it's fine~

And yeah, it's Mokou :>

Vicho

887 posts

Joined May 2009

Vicho 2011-05-08T22:50:56+00:00

star~

dkun

osu! Alumni

4,486 posts

Joined August 2009

dkun 2011-05-08T23:46:11+00:00

I like me some Pina Coladas, man!

-Lennox-

640 posts

Joined September 2010

-Lennox- 2011-05-08T23:49:32+00:00

Small IRC mod~

nimi

978 posts

Joined April 2010

nimi 2011-05-09T01:17:06+00:00

piña colada <3
kay, i gotta agree with you that this one is pretty fun, andrea XD including your mapset, specially insane diff.
well well, here goes a star. and whoa, this bg o-o
~~damn this purple spinner approach circle ;_;~~

Krisom

osu! Alumni

2,867 posts

Joined April 2009

Krisom 2011-05-09T01:43:05+00:00

I lol'd at the narrator at the start/end, I guess it must be even funnier for me because I understand what he says (and with a nightcore pitch everything sounds funny)

General-
· Use "SliderBorder : 200,200,200" to match the hitcircle overlay color on the slider border? Looks much better this way imo.
· I'm not sure if that BG is permissible, but I am sure that it doesn't fits much with the song. I mean, Piña Colada is about party, about the beach, and about fun (and the song reflects it quite well), and that BG seems to be about shyness, bed, and covering herself with whatever is close to her XD. Can you find a better one?
· I know the original skin doesn has these, but you might want to add an spinner-spin, spinner-clear and spinner-osu so that it won't conflict with other sets (looks kinda awkward with my green set at least), maybe make the default ones in a grayscale?

Easy-
00:55:291 (1,1) - Spinner too close to circle for the easiest diff :P
01:39:468 (1,1) - ^

Normal-
01:43:291 (1,2) - These curves look a tad weird, what about this?

Gio's Hard-
AR-1? I mean, all the other settings are kinda easier, and ar 7 seems like it'd fit this map too.
00:08:990 (7,8,9) - Maybe you could unstack these 3?
00:03:681 (4,5) - I found (5) hard to read as a 1/4, I think I'd be better if you repositioned this note.
01:49:663 (9) - No. Please don't use x0.5 slowdowns if there are no sliderticks to tell the difference between a slowdown or a 1/2 slider, specially in such a fast paced song. Either make the slidertick 1 or use another custom speed.
02:17:061 (4,5,6) - These sliders made no sense to me rhythmically.

Samah's Hard-
00:38:300 (4) - Same as Gio's, don't use x0.5 slowdowns like this if there is no way to tell if this is a 1/2 slider or a slowdown. Change this on all the similar slowdowns.
01:06:548 (4,5) - Please avoid stacks like these, with snaking sliders off, it's hard to tell where does the slider begins.
01:08:247 (3,4) - ^
This diff... ...was so.... ...fun to playyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

Insane-
I'd avoid doing the copypaste in the second chorus JUST for the not-symmetrycal patterns near the end, this is to avoid making the copy-paste so obious :P
S-So f-fun, I-I c-can't h-h-hold it >///////////////< *plays again*

osu needs more alcoholic drinks, tequila alone is not enough for these guys XD
Let me know when you're done~

Samah

423 posts

Joined May 2010

Samah 2011-05-09T02:21:11+00:00

Krisom wrote:
This diff... ...was so.... ...fun to playyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

<3

Edit: IRC modding.

Last edited by Samah 2011-05-09T08:48:46+00:00, edited 1 time in total.

Andrea

Beatmap Nominator

16,650 posts

Joined August 2008

Topic Starter

Andrea 2011-05-09T06:08:51+00:00

Krisom wrote:
I lol'd at the narrator at the start/end, I guess it must be even funnier for me because I understand what he says (and with a nightcore pitch everything sounds funny)

General-
· Use "SliderBorder : 200,200,200" to match the hitcircle overlay color on the slider border? Looks much better this way imo. // Cool, Fixed.
· I'm not sure if that BG is permissible, but I am sure that it doesn't fits much with the song. I mean, Piña Colada is about party, about the beach, and about fun (and the song reflects it quite well), and that BG seems to be about shyness, bed, and covering herself with whatever is close to her XD. Can you find a better one? // I really love this one, I want to keep it >.<
· I know the original skin doesn has these, but you might want to add an spinner-spin, spinner-clear and spinner-osu so that it won't conflict with other sets (looks kinda awkward with my green set at least), maybe make the default ones in a grayscale? // Nice idea, Fixed.

Easy-
00:55:291 (1,1) - Spinner too close to circle for the easiest diff // Fixed.
01:39:468 (1,1) - ^ // Fixed.

Normal-
01:43:291 (1,2) - These curves look a tad weird, what about this? // Fixed.

Gio's Hard-
AR-1? I mean, all the other settings are kinda easier, and ar 7 seems like it'd fit this map too. // Fixed.
00:08:990 (7,8,9) - Maybe you could unstack these 3? // Fixed.
00:03:681 (4,5) - I found (5) hard to read as a 1/4, I think I'd be better if you repositioned this note. // Fixed.
01:49:663 (9) - No. Please don't use x0.5 slowdowns if there are no sliderticks to tell the difference between a slowdown or a 1/2 slider, specially in such a fast paced song. Either make the slidertick 1 or use another custom speed. // Fixed.
02:17:061 (4,5,6) - These sliders made no sense to me rhythmically. // Fixed.

Samah's Hard-
00:38:300 (4) - Same as Gio's, don't use x0.5 slowdowns like this if there is no way to tell if this is a 1/2 slider or a slowdown. Change this on all the similar slowdowns. // Samah doesn't want to change them.
01:06:548 (4,5) - Please avoid stacks like these, with snaking sliders off, it's hard to tell where does the slider begins. // Fixed.
01:08:247 (3,4) - ^ // Fixed.
This diff... ...was so.... ...fun to playyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

Insane-
I'd avoid doing the copypaste in the second chorus JUST for the not-symmetrycal patterns near the end, this is to avoid making the copy-paste so obious // I wanna keep it like that if you don't mind :3
S-So f-fun, I-I c-can't h-h-hold it >///////////////< *plays again* // Thank you Krisom-sama for liking it >w<

osu needs more alcoholic drinks, tequila alone is not enough for these guys XD
Let me know when you're done~

Thanks for modding it <3

-myun-

66 posts

Joined March 2011

-myun- 2011-05-09T06:13:46+00:00

star

Phish_old

154 posts

Joined January 2011

Phish_old 2011-05-09T07:54:39+00:00

This map is so much fun to play

jericho2442

osu! Alumni

1,918 posts

Joined March 2009

jericho2442 2011-05-09T09:14:09+00:00

irc mod

SPOILER

09:26 <jericho2442> : jeri sliders in easy xD
09:27 <jericho2442> : 02:12:601 (1,2) - put the newcombo onto the (2)?
09:27 <jericho2442> : so the new combo starts on the start of the synth chorus
09:27 <jericho2442> : on easy
09:27 <osuplayer111> : fixed
09:27 <jericho2442> : that tiny suggestion
09:27 <jericho2442> : easy is perfect xD
09:28 <osuplayer111> : <3
09:29 <jericho2442> : lol getting mod requests while im modding >_<
09:29 <osuplayer111> : same xD
09:29 <osuplayer111> : always
09:30 <jericho2442> : xD
09:32 <jericho2442> : rofl normal is perfect as well
09:32 <osuplayer111> :

DDD
09:32 <jericho2442> : you give me nothing to mod xD
09:32 <osuplayer111> : same for you!
09:33 <jericho2442> : i do say though that giO's dont suit the set, it "would" be good to simplify the 1/4 in it, but thats a LARGE
09:33 <jericho2442> : change for a guest diff
09:34 <jericho2442> : hmmmm
09:34 <osuplayer111> : just let me remove some streams :3
09:34 <osuplayer111> : not the slider streams though
09:34 <jericho2442> : or you could up AR and OD 1 and name it insane i guess
09:34 <osuplayer111> : that works!
09:35 <jericho2442> : since i think you agree this dont feel like a hard xD
09:35 <osuplayer111> : done the change

09:35 <osuplayer111> : yea xD
09:35 <osuplayer111> : but I can keep AR8 on Samah's?
09:35 <jericho2442> : samah's felt like a Hard yea
09:37 <jericho2442> : kinda feels like a note needs to be here on giO's 01:24:495 -
09:37 <jericho2442> : dunno if you agree
09:38 <osuplayer111> : yeah added
09:38 <jericho2442> : and ima nitpick and say 01:47:327 (2) - needs to be strieght down
09:38 <jericho2442> : it curved as it is looks abit odd in the pattern xD
09:38 <osuplayer111> : 00:40:318
09:38 <osuplayer111> : here too
09:38 <jericho2442> : and yea
09:39 <osuplayer111> : done that too
09:39 <jericho2442> : 01:48:389 (4) - feels odd, maybe remove it, then put a newcombo on the note after
09:39 <jericho2442> : follows vocals a million times better then
09:39 <osuplayer111> : done
09:40 <jericho2442> : ok i guess this is fine, but the jumping i didnt really think suited such a soft part 01:50:725 (3,4,5,6) -
09:40 <jericho2442> : felt soo out of place
09:40 <osuplayer111> : will change
09:41 <osuplayer111> : fixed
09:41 <jericho2442> : 01:51:787 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - needs a newcombo in here somewhere to suit the current combo
09:41 <jericho2442> : pattern
09:41 <osuplayer111> : 01:53:273 (5) -
09:42 <jericho2442> : sure
09:42 <jericho2442> : meh remove this green line i guess 01:58:158 -
09:42 <osuplayer111> : volume increased
09:42 <osuplayer111> : 70 -> 80
09:42 <jericho2442> : oh i didnt even notice it xD
09:43 <osuplayer111> : xD
09:43 <osuplayer111> : 02:00:282 add a circle?
09:43 <osuplayer111> : and fix spacing
09:44 <jericho2442> : sure
09:44 <jericho2442> : modding your own song lololol

09:44 <osuplayer111> : xD
09:45 <jericho2442> : LOL up the OD on samah's abit xD
09:45 <jericho2442> : thats loooow

09:45 <osuplayer111> : I can't
09:45 <osuplayer111> : or star rating.....
09:46 <osuplayer111> : already same as my Insane
09:46 <jericho2442> : that rating is 4.9 anyway xD
09:46 <osuplayer111> : oh fuck, now Hard is HIGHER than giO's Insane!!!!
09:46 <osuplayer111> : >_<
09:46 *jericho2442 scratches head
09:47 <osuplayer111> : I have to reduce settings even more on Hard now D:
09:47 <osuplayer111> : xD
09:47 <osuplayer111> : HP -1
09:47 <osuplayer111> : HP 4 OD 5 D;
09:47 <osuplayer111> : and AR 8
09:47 <jericho2442> : hmm its the AR whats keeping it high i guess
09:47 <osuplayer111> : can't do anything else
09:47 <osuplayer111> : let me try
09:47 <osuplayer111> : -1 and still 4,88
09:47 <osuplayer111> : xD
09:47 <osuplayer111> : no change
09:48 <jericho2442> : also why you worry over that xD
09:48 <jericho2442> : star rating sucks
09:48 <osuplayer111> : yeah but I want to keep them on order
09:48 <osuplayer111> : I'm nazi xD
09:49 <jericho2442> : :/ well you kno i think the diff options suck as they are buuuut, lets check the map xD
09:49 <osuplayer111> : lolz
09:51 <jericho2442> : 01:45:309 (2) - remove on samah's i say
09:51 <jericho2442> : the triple feels out of palce
09:51 <jericho2442> : place*
09:52 <jericho2442> : i would say turn 01:46:902 (1) - into 2 1/2 notes as well
09:52 <jericho2442> : and 01:48:601 (1,2,3) - same
09:53 <osuplayer111> : asking him
09:53 <jericho2442> : except from that the map is great
09:54 <osuplayer111> : he agrees only with 2nd suggestion
09:54 <jericho2442> : well i can only try to make the map suit the song xD
09:54 <osuplayer111> : now Insane lolol
09:56 <jericho2442> : why cant they map like you do :<
09:57 <jericho2442> : and map calm parts calm
09:57 <osuplayer111> : <3333
09:57 <jericho2442> : juuuust one thing i found abit tricky 01:59:008 (3,1) -
09:57 <jericho2442> : has the same spacing as the ones before it
09:57 <osuplayer111> : YES
09:57 <osuplayer111> : trick on purpose <3333
09:57 <jericho2442> : hahaha
09:57 <osuplayer111> : since I'm a damned bastard

09:57 <jericho2442> : then i will leave it xD
09:58 <osuplayer111> : ok, fixing up SB

09:58 <jericho2442> : yuuuuup as TOTALLY expected, nothing to say about your diff >_<
09:58 <osuplayer111> : yay <3

also as we both knew that BG was way too risky so helped find a better BG xD
offset changed to 926

aaaanyway maps look good (andrea's insane <3)

soooo this floaty thing is yours :V

ShadowSoul

352 posts

Joined September 2010

ShadowSoul 2011-05-09T12:39:48+00:00

:3

Rucker

Former osu! Champion: #1

561 posts

Joined August 2009

Rucker 2011-05-09T15:43:31+00:00

Shiirn

2,896 posts

Joined August 2010

Shiirn 2011-05-09T19:03:47+00:00

Center the hitscores?

Seira Ichika

42 posts

Joined February 2009

Seira Ichika 2011-05-09T19:56:55+00:00

starrrrrrrr

!

James2250

osu! Alumni

4,059 posts

Joined July 2008

James2250 2011-05-09T20:06:43+00:00

Not a big fan of the background but its acceptable, everything else looks good
(@ Shiirn, Andrea prefers the hitbursts like that)

Ranked~

Shiirn

2,896 posts

Joined August 2010

Shiirn 2011-05-09T20:15:43+00:00

James2250 wrote:
Andrea prefers the hitbursts like that

skins should be for the player, but i digress, i don't play standard anyway.

Tenshi-nyan

1,482 posts

Joined September 2010

Tenshi-nyan 2011-05-09T20:46:18+00:00

~~ranked in 3 days, goddamn popular mappers~~

Aww you changed the BG. Gotta ninja the BG pic back to the old one.

Pretty nice map, would've been even cooler if you used the normal-hitfinish.wav with more consistence.

Anyway, GZ...

Andrea

Beatmap Nominator

16,650 posts

Joined August 2008

Topic Starter

Andrea 2011-05-09T20:48:01+00:00

Thanks everyone

PsychoSkill

403 posts

Joined November 2010

PsychoSkill 2011-05-09T22:55:51+00:00

I love this map <3