forum

777minus111 - bonus level 2

posted
Total Posts
80
show more
ziin

Nharox wrote:

"Terribly overmapped" ... yeah right.
"yeah right" is a sarcastic comment, so I will elaborate a little bit.

Overmapping refers to putting notes where they do not exist in the background.

00:01:144 (2,3,1) - these, for example, are overmapped. There is nothing in the music to suggest that you can put a note here.

Crack did a very good job on this map and didn't place any notes over silence like you did.

Now you can go on and on about how this is your style: it doesn't change the fact that what I am saying is correct. Now does me being correct matter? Probably not. You can get this map ranked as it is. There are many osu players who do not mind overmapping to this degree. But you also might not have done it on purpose (you didn't actually listen to the song when you mapped it, or thought that this was the only way to make it interesting), which is why I'm pointing it out.

Also, please reconsider hitsounds on the 1/8 sliders, or some other way to differentiate between the middle note which isn't in the music. You could also lower the volume of that note instead. If you still won't do it, could you tell me why you won't do it?
Topic Starter
Kert
Let me put my 2 cents in

While I certainly agree that Nharox's diff is overmapped, I can't say that I don't like it
I really hate when someone puts tons of unneded notes to, let's say, a slow anime op/ed song just to make an Insane diff or whateva
But this is another kind of song and Nharox did a good job here I think. It feels like it's a kind of remix of the original song with it's own new catchy rhythms and all that
Zelos
So relaxing.

Folder:
Sparkly clean.

General:
Use the same slidertick rate for all difficulties. (Preferably tick rate 2 because it sounds nicer. Like Nharox's)

Dusk:
01:37:519 (2) - grab the 3rd slider grid point and move it to the right so that the slider becomes symmetrical and even.
01:39:019 (1) - ^

Nharox's Nightfall:
Saw nothing wrong here.

Midnight:
01:50:644 (6) - Not good. This is touching the HP bar.

Star for such a lovely song.
Topic Starter
Kert
Fixed everything, except tickrate, because I don't like how ticks would sound in my diff
Thanks.
Charles445
General
Offset feels a bit early, maybe +5 on it
I think gray isn't a good choice for a combo color, try a semi dark purple
soft-sliderslide and soft-sliderslide2 are empty files. Make them the silence sound from the Custom Hitsound Library, located here viewtopic.php?p=164927
Nharox's Nightfall has a different background color than the other difficulties (this is pretty much a deprecated feature so you probably don't need to change it)
A lot of the map feels overmapped, as in some beats aren't actually matching sounds in the song.

Dusk
01:17:644 - Add hitcircle, it matches the previous part
01:42:019 (1,2,3) - I don't like this setup here, you get them moving with the 1 to 2, then stop them in place for the 2 to 3. If you move the 3 above the 2 it would make it more readable and fun.
01:45:019 (1,2,3) - ^^

Nharox's Nightfall
The finishes in this difficulty are too loud, make them quieter.
Feels very overmapped but it's not a bad difficulty at all.

Midnight
Either do Tickrate 2 here or do Tickrate 1 on Nharox's Nightfall.
The whistles feel slightly random, maybe make them more consistent?
01:12:019 - This slowdown is very unexpected because it looks just like the previous sliders. I recommend making the slider velocity change only 0.75x.
01:16:519 (1) - Consider removing this new combo.
01:17:644 - If you make the above 0.75x, then this speed up will also be clearer.
Fantastic ending, I love those claps.


It's a cute mapset.
Topic Starter
Kert
2Charles445
General
Offset feels a bit early, maybe +5 on it - I was given different offsets many times, I think it's fine as it is now
I think gray isn't a good choice for a combo color, try a semi dark purple - Done
soft-sliderslide and soft-sliderslide2 are empty files. Make them the silence sound from the Custom Hitsound Library, located here viewtopic.php?p=164927 - Done

Dusk
01:17:644 - Add hitcircle, it matches the previous part - I think it's not needed here
01:42:019 (1,2,3) - I don't like this setup here, you get them moving with the 1 to 2, then stop them in place for the 2 to 3. If you move the 3 above the 2 it would make it more readable and fun. - Yay. Remapped
01:45:019 (1,2,3) - ^^

Midnight
Either do Tickrate 2 here or do Tickrate 1 on Nharox's Nightfall.
The whistles feel slightly random, maybe make them more consistent? - I think they are fine.
01:12:019 - This slowdown is very unexpected because it looks just like the previous sliders. I recommend making the slider velocity change only 0.75x. - Great idea. Fix'd
01:16:519 (1) - Consider removing this new combo. - Done
01:17:644 - If you make the above 0.75x, then this speed up will also be clearer.
Fantastic ending, I love those claps. :3


It's a cute mapset. - Kawaiiiii
Thanks!
Nharox will post later
MoodyRPG
Dusk
00:03:019 (3) - Maybe new combo?
00:15:019 (3) - ^

Nharox's Nightfall
AR: -1?
00:27:019 (5) - New combo
00:37:519 (1,2) - More symetric with (4)

Midnight
00:03:019 (3) - Maybe new combo?
00:31:519 (3) - ^
02:12:019 (7) - ^

Good map CracK,i really enjoy playing this map

Star
Topic Starter
Kert
2MoodyRPG
Midnight
00:03:019 (3) - Maybe new combo?
00:31:519 (3) - ^ Added this one
02:12:019 (7) - ^ I tend not to place new combos on big white ticks in the last combo of any map.. For an unknown reason I like it this way more
Thanks!
I am happy when someone enjoys the maps I've made
NoHitter
Rechecked and bubbled.
Good luck.
phonic
Hi

from #modreqs


[General]
  1. Lead-in - Please unify it with 2000
  2. Only Nharox's Nightfall is different in a combo color. Please unify it

[Midnight]

  1. HP+1?
  2. 01:30:769 (3) - add new combo
  3. 01:50:081 (4) - add new combo?
  4. 00:48:019 (1) - add finish?
  5. 01:12:019 (1) - It is finish first?
  6. 02:12:019 (7) - add finish

    I felt it to be lonely because there was little hit sound

Nharox's Nightfall

  1. AP-1 OR-1?
  2. 00:11:269 (2) - 1 gird left 1 gird up
  3. 00:45:019 (5) - It is difficult in this degree of difficulty
  4. 00:50:644 (x) - Add Note
  5. 00:52:144 (5) - Add new combo?
  6. 00:56:644 (x) - Add Note?

    It is a pleasant map :)

Dusk

  1. 00:15:019 (3) - Add new combo?
  2. 01:40:519 (2) - 01:39:019 (1) - I must not make と same form?

    Placement was fair

Give me Kudosu
Elly-chan
;~;.. get this ranked soon, if you have trouble finding a MAT to rebubble IF you pop your bubble over the above mod i'll be sure to help you! >o<
Topic Starter
Kert
2phonic
Hi Hello

from #modreqs


[General]
  1. Lead-in - Please unify it with 2000 It's the same 1989 lead-in in all diffs. I think it's fine
  2. Only Nharox's Nightfall is different in a combo color. Please unify it Nharox disagreed with changing the colours.

[Midnight]

  1. HP+1? If I increase drain most people will probably fail, before the speed up part
  2. 01:30:769 (3) - add new combo Nope. Because 01:24:769 (3) - doesn't have it too
  3. 01:50:081 (4) - add new combo? Nope
  4. 00:48:019 (1) - add finish? It will sound harsh if I add it D:
  5. 01:12:019 (1) - It is finish first? ^
  6. 02:12:019 (7) - add finish There is a finish here already!

    I felt it to be lonely because there was little hit sound I would say too many loud hitsounds will kill this calm song ;w;

Dusk

  1. 00:15:019 (3) - Add new combo? Nope. It goes in the same group of 4 objects, like at 00:03:019 (3) -
  2. 01:40:519 (2) - 01:39:019 (1) - I must not make と same form? I didn't understand this, but I think it's okay like it is.

    Placement was fair

Give me Kudosu It's harsh to ask like that. But I am still giving you the kudosu, because of Lead-in which I will possibly have to fix later, before ranking.
Haruhi_sama
.
Garven
The maps look good. The main thing I'm seeing is that there's a huge difficulty jump from Easy -> other two diffs. Considering how solid these maps are already, I'm thinking adding something in between these to even the spread out won't be too much of a problem for ya.
Topic Starter
Kert
Mapping 2 minutes is definetly not an easy task for me D:
Especially when almost all my maps are 1 minute straight and I'm a very slow mapper
But I'll see what I can do ;_;
Garven
Call me back when it's ready then. Thanks for making the effort. :D
Topic Starter
Kert
Ugh, finally finished the diff~
Garven
[Dusk, Twilight, Midnight]
Try to add a spinner so that the high scores don't get stagnated.

[Twilight]
00:48:019 (1) - Do you think you can tone down these parts a little bit? Might be a little tough for a Normal level of play.
02:00:019 (1) - ^
Topic Starter
Kert
Added spinners for Dusk and Twilight
+made Twilight easier
Garven
Rebubbled!
IceBeam
irc modded
no log orz

changelog:
- added a break (01:36:019 - 01:48:019) in Dusk
- re-arranged 01:06:956 (3,4,5,6) and changed 2 short spinners to 1 long 01:45:019 (1) in Twilight
- fixed stacking issue 00:51:769 (4,5) in Nharox's Nightfall
- fixed silent sliders 00:28:519 (2,3,1,2) in Midnight

ranked!
ziin
a crepuscular huzzah.
thOnz
congrats
Shohei Ohtani
wtf is thOnz's avatar.

Also, gj. I'm hoping the title is supposed to be lowercase :>
Topic Starter
Kert
Thank you!
And yes, CDFA. link
Ulysses
Grats!Kert!!!!
AIR315
Congratz

;)
Dino99
Gratz!!!!!~~~~~~
Please sign in to reply.

New reply