forum

Newbie Game 14: Flavorless Mafia [Game Over]

posted
Total Posts
751
show more
Topic Starter
Zexion
Navizel replaces metal sonic1 effective immediately.
-[Jess]-

GuyInFreezer wrote:

So we got a mindless parroting here
So you think this is a mindless thought,I don't think meta will help to read out a people's mind of being town or scum.
Navizel
gay
Navizel
still at school
will post something later hopefully
Zaphkael
GIF this is osumafia lmao what do you expect
Navi is confscum cause he didnt say 'memes'
Sakura could you say things other than 'this is town' the whole game?
MB is townie to me, his reasoning and the way he does his effort is town.
Sad that sakura and navi had to draw scum this game

@mod: Ill be V/LA from 16-19 july. If I'm not back the 19th, it means my internet in China is shit and you'll have to replace me.
GuyInFreezer
But it's the fact she asked, implying she didn't know why I was being scumread, and then scumread me.
It actually doesn't imply that. Rather, she wanted to know why Tsukasa was voting you, which means she was attempting to read Tsukasa.

Meta can work well with multiple other things as well, but on it's own, it is terrible to base reads off of.
So just your personal opinion.

I've always seen sheeping as a scummy thing to do.
This doesn't answer my question. I didn't ask you about what you think about sheeping. I asked you about whether beeboy is more subjective to sheeping as town or scum, aka his behavior.

Using your standards to judge someone's behavior won't get you very far in the game of mafia (especially the textbook standards).
Not everyone think the same way as you do, and not everyone acts the same way as you do.
Mafia is a very flexible game, and failing to recognize that is a major reason of why the useless tunneling and massive TvT happens. Because they fail to recognize that different players play different ways, they attempt to judge others based on how they play, which prevents an effective communication and ultimately prevents from understanding what the fuck each other is talking about.

"Because I see a certain behavior as certain alignment, I will continue to persue it that way" is a terrible mindset to bring on to a mafia game.
GuyInFreezer
I'm going to take a break from this game today
Sakura

Zaphkael wrote:

Sakura could you say things other than 'this is town' the whole game?
Sure:
There's 2 scum on Navi/Jess/Frost
You're welcome
beeboy123

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

I've always seen sheeping as a scummy thing to do.
Are these the horrible scum tells you use to scum read me every game?
beeboy123

Sakura wrote:

Zaphkael wrote:

Sakura could you say things other than 'this is town' the whole game?
Sure:
There's 2 scum on Navi/Jess/Frost
You're welcome
Nah.
Sakura
"But Sakura, how are you coming to those scumreads"
PoE
"But Sakura, how are you arriving at that PoE"
p/5312498

Any more questions?
beeboy123
Frostings town posting tho.
beeboy123
Although I have no idea how he plays as scum
beeboy123
I have roughly arrived at the same POE but I am not feeling strongly about Tsukasa (literally sheeping GIF).
But Frostings is town posting.
Sakura

beeboy123 wrote:

I have roughly arrived at the same POE but I am not feeling strongly about Tsukasa (literally sheeping GIF).
But Frostings is town posting.
Read his ISO (Frostings) on Greatest Idea Mafia 3 and tell me what you think.
I'm open to being wrong about him, regardless he's the weakest of my townreads right now.
Frostings
Unvote
Navizel
Some of the posts are about past games and mafiascum and I can't follow
halp
Topic Starter
Zexion
Votecount 1.7
-[Jess]- [3] - GuyInFreezer, Sakura, beeboy123
- Magic Bomb - [1] - Tsukasa
Zaphkael [1] - Navizel
Sakura [1] - Zaphkael
GuyInFreezer [0] -
Navizel [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
Tsukasa [0] -
Frostings [0] -

No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [3] - - Magic Bomb -, -[Jess]-, Frostings
With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

Please tell me if you see any mistakes.
Deadline for Day 1 is Wendnesday, 20th July 2:00 AM UTC.
beeboy123

Sakura wrote:

beeboy123 wrote:

I have roughly arrived at the same POE but I am not feeling strongly about Tsukasa (literally sheeping GIF).
But Frostings is town posting.
Read his ISO (Frostings) on Greatest Idea Mafia 3 and tell me what you think.
I'm open to being wrong about him, regardless he's the weakest of my townreads right now.
As far as I can see he wasn't scum hunting he was just declaring people's alignments in that game.
Navizel
I never understood how Magic Bomb townread Jess in the first place
Sakura irks me. Care to explain all the "this is town" and your vote reasons? Either I didn't read carefully enough or I didn't see them at all.
I don't like beeboy at all.

Zaphkael wrote:

Navi is confscum cause he didnt say 'memes'
gay memes
Also I can't be assed with the meta shit. I can't even remember anything from the last game fuck you guys ;)
Navizel

Sakura wrote:

"But Sakura, how are you coming to those scumreads"
PoE
"But Sakura, how are you arriving at that PoE"
p/5312498

Any more questions?
does that include sheeping
Navizel
I don't feel any townness towards Frostings this game hmmm
Tsukasa
Where the hell is Jess?
beeboy123
Navi can you explain your scum read on me or do you not actually have any plans to push me?
Sakura
Feel free to ask me about any read.
Not like that helps your alignment :)
Sakura
but yeah, FMPoV if you're town, then Frostings scum, and Jess is scum in either scenario.
Everyone else is just way too townie.
beeboy123
Idk Sakura I am still skeptical of you because you won that one game 2 years ago. /s
Navizel

beeboy123 wrote:

Navi can you explain your scum read on me or do you not actually have any plans to push me?
huh
I'm still -somewhat- neutral on you. I just stated that I don't like you at all.
Navizel
By the way, I don't like you for sheeping. It was annoying.
Sakura

Navizel wrote:

By the way, I don't like you for sheeping. It was annoying.
But sheeping is like the best thing ever.
How else am i going to get AI reactions from ppl if i dont vote together with others? XD
beeboy123
^ What Sakura said sheeping isn't bad play at all.
beeboy123
Especially when I am sheeping a top town read who can read people better then I can.
Navizel
xd
GuyInFreezer

Tsukasa wrote:

Where the hell is Jess?
Vote her to summon
Frostings
this game is a little hard for me :(
I've actually never not had a terrible scum read that I followed for the rest of the day, so I don't really know what to do here :oops:

I have a lingering suspicion of Sakura, but I don't want to vote her yet because of personal reasons

mb seems relatively town in that he's getting annoyed easily (I think he'd be more enthusiastic as scum ;) )

Haven't been paying much attention to others, though I'm looking out for Navi because he seemed unenthusiastic about joining and I know he doesn't like playing scum :^)
Also I feel like ms1 didn't contribute much to town while he was here
Frostings
also reading through ms1's ISO and read this for the first time:

metal sonic1 wrote:

context: i caught him as a 1-shot unlynchable scum in sakura's game (here, obviously) that ended less than a week ago, but because of the fact that he was unlynchable once, it created a strong fakeclaim for him to slip past me and win the game. the fact of the matter was that I caught him the first time based on pure reads, but he did win.
Holy shit LOL pure gold :) :)
Sakura
It may also be a byproduct of him getting apathetic because of getting PoE'd out.

I'm more confident in a Navi/Jess scumteam now.
Frostings
Hi Jess. I need two names from you: one who you think is town, and one who you think is scum

Don't be shy :)
Navizel

Frostings wrote:

though I'm looking out for Navi because he seemed unenthusiastic about joining and I know he doesn't like playing scum :^)
really
when was I last scum though I don't remember.p sure it depends if I'm in the mood to play mafia at all
Tsukasa
I kinda dropped my read on MB a bit with nav's though
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply