DoKito wrote:

mod replies

Desperate-kun wrote:

DoKito wrote:

mod replies

While I agree with the content of your mod reply to mithew's mod, you shouldn't have responsed so rudly. He isn't an experienced modder yet so no need to blame him for pointing out things that aren't an issue to you.

I actually agree with 04:13:664 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,1) - being random, I didn't really notice it before. It's unclear to me (and seems unclear to pkhg and mithew too) what this stream is supposed to follow, as this section of the song seems purely 1/2 based. In other words, it seems really overmapped.
I think it fits into the map pretty well and sounds alright which is why I didn't notice it before, but you should probably fix this or provide an explanation why you mapped this stream here.

Feel free to call me back after this was explained better.

Peydey wrote:

haven't heard much about this map in a while. How's it doin lol

Smolboi wrote:

Noob modding for great justice

00:30:438 (4,5,1) - Don't feel like a stack fits here true
00:33:847 (1,2,3) - ^ this one fits tho
01:22:665 (1,2,3,4) - Maybe gradually reduce spacing instead of jumping straight to that nah. the music doesn't support that imo
01:39:710 (2) - Ugly slider, just go for a regular curve i like those tho
01:58:529 (6,7) - Just stack these on top of the slider nah
02:12:438 (2) - Another ugly slider D:
02:45:847 (1) to 03:03:301 (1) - holy fuck i love this part thanks
03:55:868 (4,5,6) - Not digging these square shaped steams i like them. curves only are boring
03:56:959 (4,5,6) - ^
03:58:323 (8,9,10) - ^
04:03:232 (16,1,2) - ^
04:09:232 (8,1,2) - ^
04:09:777 (8,1,2) - ^
04:46:323 (8,1,2) - ^
04:46:868 (8,1,2) - ^
05:14:209 (1) to 05:18:164 (2) - These back and fourths are a bit much don't ya think? nah. they are perfect
08:11:957 - Needs one more spinner guitar ends on this note tho. that's why there is no spinner

Good luck with ranking

SCANDiO wrote:

04:34:937 (1) - how you look to set at this moment kiai mode?
04:42:573 (1) - and at this moment stopped kiai mode.
I'm just asking.
03:50:482 (2) - https://puu.sh/sym5S.png i changed, cause it is better for a rhytm. :[
04:13:118 (1) - add, cause it is better, than stream https://puu.sh/syn31.png
And good well for set that long slider, but "long" is a "long", not big (https://puu.sh/synvt.png)
That's all. Good luck!~

Osuology wrote:

00:07:119 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Is this spread less for a buildup, or is it just that you decided to have less spacing even though here in the previous rhythms you did greater spacing? This is more to have a better transition into the next stream. That's why i decided to switch the spacings.

00:14:210 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - Any reason behind this either? Again mostly for some variety. I focussed on following the keyboard (?) or whatever is making those sounds.

00:22:938 (1,2,3,4) - Awfully difficult pattern to play, I realize streams are, but they aren't intensive on the aiming, versus these are. Trying something more snappy would be preferable. I don't see anything difficult about this pattern.

00:23:620 (2,3) - Reason to have jump between these? Doesn't seem like anything that I can hear that would warrant this. Not really a jump in my opinion

00:35:620 (6) - This is kinda undermapping, and considering this is a 8* map... idk even what to say if you are undermapping in a 8* map tbh LOL What exactly is undermapped here? The drum stopped playing. There is no half beat on this one.

00:38:210 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why straight flow? It's a little disruptive to the eyes, don't you think? If there isn't really anything outstanding about fast 1/4 beats, I like to vary with the shapes. Some like it, some hate it.

01:12:574 (3,4,5,6) - If you want to keep these as stacks, please stack the 1 and 2, I feel like this would make it a lot easier and better feeling. I think those stacks fit nicely as they are now.

01:39:301 (1) - eww slider tick snares (I just really hate these, nothing wrong with them probably)

01:47:210 (1) - Really weird NC, doesn't seem to make sense in the song Even if NCs are probly the easiest thing about mapping, I mostly fukk'em up bad. Pretty much all of my NCs are made through mods and stuff like this and even QATs and BNs didn't mention anything wrong with the combos, so I'll just stick with them

02:17:074 (1) - Why NC? Doesn't make sense with patterning. More of a visual NC

02:48:392 (3,1) - This is a little bit much, flow is contradictory. Should be a bit better now

03:54:027 (5,6) - NC both of these that way you have patterning that easily indicates what distance is between these ok

05:24:573 (3) - I don't see good reason for this slider, also jump between this and next hit circle is awkward, maybe change flow of slider or change to hit circle. The sliderend here doesn't matter tho. You snap from sliderstart to circle

05:44:959 (7) - This mostly blocks the reverse arrow, you need to do something else here. It doesn't completely block the reverse arrow. And second of all, experienced players will NEVER without a reason stop holding a 1/4slider in a stream. If a BN things this is necessary, I'll change it, but imo it is no big issue

05:58:937 (1) - I think this deserves a jump from the previous hit circle, so maybe you should make spacing bigger here. Nah. I want to put more emphasis on those triangles

06:07:118 (2,3,4) - Again this flow is really hard, it's not very easy for anyone to hit linear patterns. Made them a little bite more zig-zagged

Probably needs some polish in aesthetics and patterning (just polishing from mods, no remaps or anything) and then you'll be all good to go!

SCANDiO wrote:

qualified map of Screaming Japanese is a best gift on xristmas.

Desperate-kun wrote:

Rebubble #1

I still really like this map Hopefully it will make it this time.

Kroytz wrote:

I wanna know why Dkun thinks he's able to justifiable judge/nominate this. Not to be sounding offensive, it's a genuine question

Kroytz wrote:

I wanna know why Dkun thinks he's able to justifiable judge/nominate this. Not to be sounding offensive, it's a genuine question

Xexxar wrote:

01:37:801 (4) - why is this a slider when the white beat after has strong vocals. following the guitar here

04:26:482 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - why hit normal i didn't make the hitsounds. he probably has his reasons

04:49:937 (13,14,15,16,1) - you could probably make this look a bit more aesthetically pleasing i don't want to make the jump into this slider too big and tbh i think it looks pleasing already

06:09:846 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,2,1) - why hit normal
06:28:391 (1,1) - same

06:37:482 (1) - this isnt snapped properly, it is. talked with desperate about this

07:56:412 (1,2,3,4,1) - why such a sharp angle for no real change in sound. seems weird. i think it makes a good transition/ending for the streaming part.

08:05:412 (1,1,1,1) - y hit normal D:<

good luck with the map

Kroytz wrote:

I wanna know why Dkun thinks he's able to justifiable judge/nominate this. Not to be sounding offensive, it's a genuine question.