Ayatsugu_Otowa - Chouetsu Shite Shimatta Kanojo to Sore o Um · forums · community

Nwolf

Joined September 2012

Nwolf November 3, 2016 at 7:27:10 AM UTC

discord "log"

Nwerewolf - Yesterday at 3:38 PM
I don't get the purpose of a map that uses 2/1 and 4/1 only(edited)
when the Kantan is already that

it doesn't help spread as it's the lowest diff as well
otherwise the only complain I have about the set is that the beginning does not have kiai activated
-[ Dumpling ]- - Yesterday at 10:09 PM
I'll enable it when I have time then
Nwerewolf - Yesterday at 10:13 PM
ask GDers too

-[ Dumpling ]-

971 posts

Joined March 2013

Topic Starter

-[ Dumpling ]- November 3, 2016 at 8:57:56 AM UTC

sorry to nitpick I guess but there's some things I disagree here.

Ntiger wrote:
I don't get the purpose of a map that uses 2/1 and 4/1 only(edited)
when the Kantan is already that

have a ranked example of that. (i'm not looking at star difficulty at this point really since it means nothing to me in this case, as long as Beginner is represented as being easier than Kantan, i'm good with that.)

Ntiger wrote:
it doesn't help spread as it's the lowest diff as well

actually, I think the Beginner fits the role of a Kantan from other taiko mapsets that have more basic rhythms for a song (example: upbeat anime OP/ED with a singer's voice that is easily mapped to), compared to this song out of an actual rhythm game that has much more of a complex melody and rhythm to it. think of the Kantan as a Kantan+, only in this day and age we're obviously not going to use those diff names here.

Ntiger wrote:
otherwise the only complain I have about the set is that the beginning does not have kiai activated

~~I'll enable it when I have time then~~ non-issue for me but see what mappers say.

Nwolf

2,530 posts

Joined September 2012

Nwolf November 3, 2016 at 9:10:02 AM UTC

the beginning of the song is exactly the same as 00:55:983 - just that it's shorter.

also I don't get why TKS' diff is OD7 and the Oni is OD5.5, either make Oni OD6 or reduce TKS' OD to OD6.5 since the song is only 178 BPM and you have to suck a lot to get note lock on 1/8 triplets.

-[ Dumpling ]-

971 posts

Joined March 2013

Topic Starter

-[ Dumpling ]- November 3, 2016 at 2:43:58 PM UTC

Ntiger wrote:
the beginning of the song is exactly the same as 00:55:983 - just that it's shorter.

also I don't get why TKS' diff is OD7 and the Oni is OD5.5, either make Oni OD6 or reduce TKS' OD to OD6.5 since the song is only 178 BPM and you have to suck a lot to get note lock on 1/8 triplets.

about kiai - I don't think we are going to change it. I see what you think, but adding kiai at the start of the song somewhat implies that the start should be as intense as the part at 00:55:983 -, which shouldn't be the case (even if you say my diffs are identical at those parts, the lack of kiai is by design as a consistency with other diffs thing).

about OD - changed to 6 for Oni, that was my bad, didn't notice that Inner Oni had OD bumped up to 7.

Nwolf

2,530 posts

Joined September 2012

Nwolf November 4, 2016 at 8:55:26 AM UTC

choo choo

-[ Dumpling ]-

971 posts

Joined March 2013

Topic Starter

-[ Dumpling ]- November 4, 2016 at 8:56:12 AM UTC

honk

cdhsausageboy