forum

Medical Mafia II - SCUM WIN

posted 2015-12-25T05:16:42+00:00

Total Posts

352

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-23T23:22:52+00:00

Vote Count 3.02

[0] Zexion --
[0] Xiz --
[0] beeboy123 --
[0] Navizel --
[0] Chamelo_Th --
[4] Lincolm -- Xiz, Chamelo_Th, Navizel (LYNCH)
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Zexion, beeboy123, Lincolm

The head nurse runs into the room, saying there's been a terrible incident in Room 145. "It's Doctor Lincolm sir!"
"the intern who was unconscious and couldn't speak for most of the day because of his idiopathic sudden onset congenital heart disease?"
"Yes sir, his LVAD wire we installed was cut!"
I walked into the room to see his LVAD wire was clearly cut. Curiously enough, the other interns surrounded his body, beeboy123 scissors in hand.
"What happened!"
"He was a phony doctor!" one intern shouted
"what proof did you have?"
"nothing but our wits and group desperation." Another said, beaming widely.
"oh my god..."
A look at his papers in the bag showed his true identity...
He was Lincolm, a Mafia Goon.
Well in that case, you earned a treat, your shifts are over. Go sleep in your on call rooms.
Night one starts now, deadlines for actions is 24 hours from now at 6:30PM EST January 23.

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-25T00:17:21+00:00

[intercom] GOOD MORNING VIETNAM! Get up outta here, the smell of blood is nauseating when it's been in a room for so long.
We found another...
(aside)wha- really?
So we found TWO dead bodies this morning.
First one was Navizel, a veritable Doctor.

It's now come to my attention that the body of Xiz, another veritable Doctor.

Autopsies show that the Cause of deaths were a peculiar incident involving a hammer and a pencil holder and blood loss resulting from a severed femoral artery.

Well, that's not my problem, I make boku bucks without you guys. Get to work, go bother your attending.

Vote Count 4.01

[0] Zexion --
[0] beeboy123 --
[0] Chamelo_Th --

[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Zexion, beeboy123, Chamelo_Th

3 alive makes 2 to a lynch.

Day 4 starts now, deadline for the day is January 29th, at 7:30PM

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Zexion 2016-01-25T00:29:26+00:00

This is really bad.

FTR, I targeted no one last night.

Also I have a good feeling who is the last scum.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T01:37:24+00:00

I knew I could kill people =D
(sorry Navi)

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T01:37:59+00:00

I am prob going to vote Chamelo_Th in the end but obv I am going to go and review the game first.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T01:41:35+00:00

Actually after quickly reviewing the ISOs idk. Zexion was my town read and the way Chamelo spoke about his night actions I genuinely believe he is town.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T01:46:42+00:00

Actually I think he is 100% town at this point since I just proved I am the Vig/CPR doc.
When I tried to target Navi he lived and the only other person to target him was Chamelo and he couldn't have possibly saved Navi that night as a scum.

Unless on N2 (I believe) someone else targeted Navi or I am the CPR doc and scum targeted Navi, but that second one doesn't add up because following the night actions I don't think it is possible for there to be another Vig/CPR.
But I don't think I could be a CPR doc because on N1 scum have no reason to not kill a conf town.
Not voting Zexion because I have work to do and still want to review the night actions just in case I am wrong about only me and Chamelo targeting Navi N2

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T02:19:16+00:00

N1 (Frosting Dies)

Xiz -> Blank
Zexion -> Jess
Lincolm -> Beeboy
Navi -> Chamelo
Chamelo -> Nothing
- Magic Bomb -> Beeboy
Beeboy -> Frosting
Jess -> (subbed out so no night action)

N2 (- Magic Bomb -, Jess Modkill)
Beeboy -> Navi
Chamelo -> Navi
Zexion -> Lincolm
Lincolm -> (No one)
Navi -> No one
Xiz -> No one

N3 (Xiz, Navi)
Navi -> Xiz
Beeboy -> Navi
Zexion -> Chamelo
Chamelo -> Beeboy

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T03:01:16+00:00

So I am confirmed Quack/CPR since if I was a real doctor Frosting would have survived and if I was a do nothing doctor Navi would not have died since scum have no reason to target Navi for a nightkill since there is too much evidence to support me being a Quack/CPR doc and logically no one would risk me being a CPR and scum being a terrible since I would have protected Navi making it 4 town -> 1 scum day phase. Using the logic I am a confirmed CPR/Quack Doctor Chamelo must have protected Navi N2.

Now if I am a CPR frosting would have lived N1 if scum targeted him or scum targeted me(town was pressuring me so dumb), jess(he wasn't doing anything dumb), Chamelo(Chamelo conf town)
Now if I am a Quack doctor Chamelo is confirm town doctor.
Using the logic Chamelo is town with me in all reasonable situations.

Vote: Zexion

Zexion why did you pressure Lincolm but when he got on the hot seat you completely ignored his existence until he got lynched?

Your night actions also make literally no sense to me, why target Jess he was a non-factor during d1 and after confirming you weren't a kill role why target one of your scum reads? They don't add up at all.

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-25T03:14:06+00:00

Speaking logically, yes, Navi survived N2 because I also targeted him.

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-25T03:26:51+00:00

That makes N3 actions:
Zexion -> Xiz
Navi -> Xiz
beeboy -> Navi
Chamelo -> beeboy

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T03:31:40+00:00

If I was scum I wouldn't have killed Magic Bomb since he either agreed or never denied to not protect me N2 which is the night he died. He also can't be a weak doctor or he would have died targeting me N1. No one else targeted magic bomb so we know his death was from scum.

Not only are my scum intentions incredibly weird and do little to nothing in regards to making me win as scum.
Zexion's night actions and suddenly switching from pressuring Lincolm to ignoring him and pressuring Xiz are very pro scum intentions.

Also not hammering Lincolm would have given me as a scum a very high chance if any town messed up and accidentally killed a fellow towny to win and not hammering him is totally town so I would have little to no reason to not do it since Lincolm was my town read. I only voted him because I decided if he was town and we lynched no one we would lose anyway because of what I said above.

If I am scum my actions are so bad I should probably be banned from this sub-forum for trolling.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T03:32:13+00:00

Chamelo_Th wrote:
That makes N3 actions:
Zexion -> Xiz
Navi -> Xiz
beeboy -> Navi
Chamelo -> beeboy

Xiz -> Zexion I forgot that one.

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Zexion 2016-01-25T03:57:31+00:00

I was inactive most of Day 3 due to personal stuff so that's why I never returned to vote. I voted Lincolm at Day 2 btw, in case you're worried about that.

Besides, Lincolm's wagon really lost strenght after D1. If I was scum I could have easily turned things arround. I didn't pay much attention at my night targets and prefered to target inactive people (Jess) or in this case my scumread (Lincolm) in order to see what my role was, it was just a way to see what my role was.

There's one thing I don't like about your analysis tho, and that is assuming everyone (but Lincolm) said the truth about their targets. It's rather dangerous to try to resolve the game via actions.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-25T04:20:23+00:00

Town has no reason to lie about night targets o.o because it would make us lose pretty hard towards the end of the game.
If you targeted Jess as a Quack or a CPR he would have died as scum have no reason to target an inactive player. I don't believe it is that hard to come up with that conclusion if you are trying to find out what your role is.

P.S. Chamelo is conf town so you might as well vote me because you don't lose anything.

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Zexion 2016-01-25T21:41:50+00:00

Which is why I didn't target last night. Obviously town have no reason to lie, but scum?

Vote: beeboy123

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-26T22:04:56+00:00

Picking up prod waiting on chamelo still

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Zexion 2016-01-26T23:02:45+00:00

Same.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-27T01:12:58+00:00

While we wait we should play a forum game inside this game of mafia

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-27T01:13:22+00:00

Like count until the mod makes a post then we have to restart
I will start.

1

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-27T02:37:57+00:00

Wow this is hard >.>

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-27T02:45:14+00:00

I mean you got 2 options, me who has legit evidence following the claimed night actions or zexion who looked towny on D1. <.<
Do you have any questions or anything that could make this easier for you?

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-27T02:49:22+00:00

Right now I'm looking into the case the you're lying
I mean, no offense, but what if

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-27T03:05:36+00:00

what if what? how coincidental would it be that I claimed to try a vig the same person you targeted if i was trying to be a fake town vig messing up like that would cost me the game.

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-28T01:48:37+00:00

beeboy123 wrote:
Like count until the mod makes a post then we have to restart
I will start.

1

I'm itching to assert my dominance after this post with a modkill but my superego isn't letting me.

Vote Count 4.02

[0] Zexion --
[1] beeboy123 -- Zexion
[0] Chamelo_Th --

[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- beeboy123, Chamelo_Th

3 alive makes 2 to a lynch.
Deadline for the day is January 29th, at 7:30PM. This is roughly two days from now.

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-28T02:12:21+00:00

Vote: Zexion

boop boop waiting on chamelo

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-28T06:56:25+00:00

really

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-28T07:13:24+00:00

Let's say beeboy really convince me to pick a choice (which, in his mind, wants me to pick Zexion) but Zexion's post hit me hard.

So I'll just YOLO

Vote: beeboy

Chamelo

Joined July 2013

Chamelo 2016-01-28T07:15:33+00:00

There are a lot of scenarios that if I replace vig beeboy with scum beeboy it still makes sense.
And a chance that Jess was vig but never got a chance to speak.

No. I will not regret my decision.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-28T07:27:11+00:00

You could have let me restate my opinions we had 3 more days I was waiting on you because I wanted to know why you thought I was lying not to force a lynch so I could clarify some of my statements.
Me being scum doesn't make sense because it doesn't explain magic bombs death and on the same night it would have been a major coincidence that I happened to guess that someone targeted Frostings because if no one claimed to have protected him I would have been outed as scum immediately.
Also Zexion's night actions made no sense there was literally no rhyme or reason to support them.

Although this is largely my fault because I was being scum read for a majority of this game and I could have done a better job from stopping that from happening so I can't blame you for thinking I am scum. Also Zexion played this game well because I only thought of him as scum when he was literally the only option. (hence why I voted him so early in the day to give us more time to talk)

GG This was a fun game but we lost town.

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-28T12:15:55+00:00

Vote Count 4.03

[0] Zexion --
[LYNCH] beeboy123 -- Zexion, Chamelo_Th
[0] Chamelo_Th --

[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- beeboy123, Chamelo_Th

Going to school now. Lynch scene when I get the chance.

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-29T02:09:01+00:00

The remaining interns corner beeboy. As he slowly tried to back off, he began to try and negotiate his life.
"Guys I can't be a phony doctor, you saw me do the procedures! I'm for real! It's Zexion who's the phony!"
"That's impossible," shouted Chamelo, "Zexion has been proven legit since Day 1!"
Immediately following this, Zexion rushes beeboy as he pauses to think up a retort for this statement.
He takes a scalpel and drives it towards beeboy's face. Beeboy tries to dodge, but his jugular has been nicked. He begins to bleed out rapidly...
"I...was...legit..."
He was a veritable Doctor.
Zexion begins to cackle and turns around to look at Chamelo with a murderous look in his eyes.
"You can't be... No wa-"
Zexion has already closed the difference, but this time has a gun.
He points his gun directly at Chamelo's heart, point-blank.
He fires and the bullet pierces Chamelo's Superior Vena Cava.
Done with his serial killing spree, he calls the don as he begins to exit the building.
"Yeah. The job is done. Lincolm didn't make it though. Yeah I set the bomb. No one messes with the Genovese family and gets away with it. Not even hospitals."
SCUM WIN

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Sakura

osu! Alumni

Joined March 2010

Sakura 2016-01-29T02:23:15+00:00

Gotta love how the game was in Night 2 all game.

I bloom in spring

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-29T02:32:13+00:00

I'm obviously best mod.

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Frostings

Joined May 2013

Frostings 2016-01-29T02:33:37+00:00

I don't even know what happened in Day1

Lincolm was so obviously siding with beeboy and beeboy was playing an idiot town

????

1. Beeboy and Lincolm should have both died by Day 3
2. We have 4-5 people left with 1 scum
3. VCA and PoE for the next 2 days until Lylo.
Game should have been easy

Frostings

Joined May 2013

Frostings 2016-01-29T02:37:01+00:00

Also I think moving moving forward, future game should impose faster deadlines, because less time makes people actually participate and achieve lynches, without the game repeatedly dying after every night phase

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-29T02:38:37+00:00

Frostings wrote:
I don't even know what happened in Day1

Lincolm was so obviously siding with beeboy and beeboy was playing an idiot town

????

1. Beeboy and Lincolm should have both died by Day 3
2. We have 4-5 people left with 1 scum
3. VCA and PoE for the next 2 days until Lylo.
Game should have been easy

Yeah, it was kind of like ????

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-29T02:40:08+00:00

Frostings wrote:
Also I think moving moving forward, future game should impose faster deadlines, because less time makes people actually participate and achieve lynches, without the game repeatedly dying after every night phase

ye, blitz game rules, 96 hour days, 36 hour nights, 12 prod timer.

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-29T03:05:38+00:00

I can't get over how i was the only one who tried to save our conf town.

Also if town was active I would have no reason to believe Lincolm was town because I was town reading him for contributing in a dead game where he could have just done nothing like 50% of the player base.

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-29T03:09:09+00:00

you were a naive doc lmao

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2016-01-29T03:12:05+00:00

and I'm a quack. Surprise.

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2016-01-29T03:13:45+00:00

oh well. goddamn beeboy is acting so scum.

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

-[Jess]-

Joined March 2014

-[Jess]- 2016-01-29T03:16:30+00:00

and now i am the only one who do nothing.
good.

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-29T03:23:58+00:00

Navizel wrote:
and I'm a quack. Surprise.

how did Chamelo live o.o

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2016-01-29T03:33:18+00:00

Ace said MB targeted me

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-29T03:33:59+00:00

Yeah... I just decided assuming he targeted me since it helped my claim lol

edit: I still don't get how Chamelo lived o.o I knew I wasn't necessarily Quack/CPR but I still don't get that. Or did you lie about targets?

Last edited by beeboy123 2016-01-29T03:37:11+00:00, edited 1 time in total.

Navizel

Joined April 2011

Navizel 2016-01-29T03:36:42+00:00

basically we fucked ourselves up. fake claims and modkill plus inactivity. like I'm one to talk

MyAnimeList | lastfm | Steam | PSN | RYM

beeboy123

Joined June 2013

beeboy123 2016-01-29T03:39:50+00:00

I could have played worse for my first game in 1 year every game is winnable it doesn't matter that much

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Zexion 2016-01-29T04:24:05+00:00

Well... this was surprising I guess.

Night actions really worked in our favour.

Zexion

Joined May 2012

Zexion 2016-01-29T04:26:05+00:00

As beeboy said my claims made no sense. I just didn't put any thought into them, to be honest I was really lazy too, so yeah, I'm gonna step up in my next game as scum.

Honestly it's just so hard for me to play scum that I often panic and do stuff like these, I don't even know how to properly interact with my partner x_x

Ace Timing

Joined October 2014

Topic Starter

Ace Timing 2016-01-29T15:43:29+00:00

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing
night actions. You guys didn't send any most of the time lol

Also known as Nosferatu

Keeping the lights on while you sleep...

Please sign in to reply.

302 / 352

›

›

›

›