B r o k e n wrote:

My Modding Queue STD only

I rarely Mod easy so I'll only mod normal

Normal

00:39:151 (2) - bring this slider down a bit more for better flow Nice catch!
00:50:589 (1) - I wouldn't consider this kiai time It's intense part ) and my style tho
00:56:589 (1) - blanket this around the note 4 ok
01:01:651 (4) - so much space right after this note, and right before kiai mode, I suggest 2 full beat slider b4 kiai mode starting at 01:02:589 and another one on next white tick Nope, providing a break for normal player.
01:16:651 (2) - I would move this slider down a bit more Sure.
01:33:141 spin should start around here Rejected as the sound start here.
to me hit sounds are a bit loud on areas where the vocals were a bit weaker, consider making hit sound lower

Hope this helped, Good Luck Thanks for your mod!!

5urface wrote:

M4M for https://osu.ppy.sh/s/433022

General & Timing
While playtesting the Taiko diffs I was consistently hitting late. Please take a look at the timing again and try moving all red timing points up by 9ms (starting offset would be 2580 then). With that timing offset my average timing error went from 10ms down to 0 to 1.
I would remove the short Kiai section from 00:50:589 (152) - 00:56:589 (178). It doesn't really add much tbh. It's intense in 1st kiai, and I'm not really sure for the offset setting.

Futsuu
Not much to say about this one, looks fine as is Property dam Futsoo again :^)

Muzukashii
00:38:589 (120) k? no, because it's for better spread.
01:07:089 (209) K no, because it's a lower pitch.

That's it from me, good luck with your map =)

5urface wrote:

M4M for https://osu.ppy.sh/s/433022

General & Timing
While playtesting the Taiko diffs I was consistently hitting late. Please take a look at the timing again and try moving all red timing points up by 9ms (starting offset would be 2580 then). With that timing offset my average timing error went from 10ms down to 0 to 1.
I would remove the short Kiai section from 00:50:589 (152) - 00:56:589 (178). It doesn't really add much tbh.

Nardo's Kantan
00:08:589 (8,9,10) K? fixed the first two notes.
00:14:776 (13) please move this one to 00:14:589 Guitar sounds are at 00:14:214 - 00:14:401 - 00:14:589 - , so I think it is more correct to put the note at the stressed sound afterwards.
00:21:714 (22) d? Nope, the pitch of guitar is quite high.
00:30:901 (34) While this is mapped to the vocals please save the offbeat notes (especially the ones standing alone with no reference frame) for the higher difficulties. Move this back 1/2 to the next white tick at 00:31:089 This would be alright if it was only once or twice but it happens regularily throughout the map. No, it sounds really off to move the note to the white tick.
The same applies to the following notes:

• 
  00:36:901 (39) same as ^
  00:42:901 (44) ^
  00:48:901 (49) ^
  01:01:651 (62) ^
  01:07:651 (71,72) These two could stay here I think...
  01:19:651 (87,88) Same, as it is in the Kiai time

00:53:214 (52,53) Ctrl + G k d would fit the background snare at 00:53:214 - well.
01:22:089 (89,90,91) same as 00:08:589 (8,9,10) That change would also be more consistent with 01:28:089 (94,95,96) same as 00:08:589 (8,9) -

Nardo's Oni
This Oni feels too easy for the song. I found myself shadowtapping at various places while testplaying. You might want to revisit this Oni and slightly raise the difficulty throughout the map, especially in the vocal section and the kiai time. Nope, spread-wise it is fine as it is.

That's it from me, good luck with your map =)

-S a I k A- wrote:

from pm
[Nardo's kantan]
01:05:964 (68) - 01:17:964 (84) - delete? no vocal here Retained for a better spread with Futsuu.
nice bg >3 ww

[Nardo's Oni]
00:14:776 (50) - this finish plays weird I mapped this according to the background stressed sound.
00:25:557 (101) - k and 00:25:651 (102) - delete? Skipping the obvious beat at 00:25:651 - sounds strange.
01:35:311 (362) - consider place a 1/12 doubles? Hmm... Are you serious about this?

刚刚po错图了好尴尬啊QAQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

-S a I k A- wrote:

from pm

[Futsuu]
00:16:839 (28) - move to 00:16:651 (28) - no, it's following 00:19:464 (33,34,35,36) -
00:19:839 (34) - delete? same as above :3
00:21:526 (37) - delete? same as above :/
01:26:964 (160) - leave blank for rest? no, it's enough.

[Muzukashii]
00:24:714 (80,81,82,83,84) - kkk d？Moved to red ticks before, and no change about coloring
00:53:776 (164) - better delete to reduce density I'll consider about this :3
01:23:026 (262,269) - ^ following to 01:23:964 (267,268,269,270,271,272) -


刚刚po错图了好尴尬啊QAQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

Regraz wrote:

[Normal]
CS4太小了。CS3.3-3.5还可以。3.5 CS
OD3 ok!

00:02:589 (1,2) - 这种blanket一定要做好 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4928782 对比 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4928785 还有很多，自己挑一挑改一改 picked second one.
00:38:214 (7,1) - 间距过大。应该是0.9
00:40:089 (4,5) - 做成平行的两个滑条。 I forgot copy and paste X_X
00:42:151 (2,3) - 间距过小，应该是0.9
还有很多间距问题，00:48:714 (3,4) - 01:19:089 (1,2) - 等等 I always not noticed about Grip Snap is enabled. X_X
首先做图的时候，无论是什么时候都要开着Distance Snap。其次做完了要检查一下间距。右上角有间距指示，可以对照那个进行修改。I use Ctrl+Shift+A and become x1.1 and I don't know this baka editor will change the DS
00:56:589 (1) - Normal难度中不要做这么大的滑条速度改变。推荐不要做滑条速度的改变。Removed :3
00:59:214 (2,3,4) - 改成如图所示的节奏 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4928808 ok!
01:27:339 (4) - 这种的不行，首先折返两次这种的滑条Normal中就不常用，其次这里的间距也出了问题。Reverse one times instead.

Good Luck！ww, thx Regraz <3

• [Normal]

1. 00:02:589 (1,2) - Blanket
2. 00:40:839 (5,1) - ^
3. 01:00:339 (4,5,6) - ^
4. 01:13:839 (2,3) - Note 1 and 3 it's too nearby ;w;

Regraz wrote:

我上次的mod发给你对比的那张图就是正确的blanket了，按照那个修一下就行了，用AR圈作参考。

Regraz wrote:

STD diffs are fine for me now. Leaving a std icon here.

WHAT I DIDN'T CHECK: Metadata

game rock wrote:

Hi!

From PM

d
k
D (Big d)
K (Big k)

• [ Nardo's Kantan]
  
  OD: 2 -> The current setting would be fine since the difficulty is pretty easy.

1. 00:55:089 (55,56,57) - Change to D in the note 55 and put a finish in these notes because the voice and sound are increasing in this part. The same for 01:00:339 (60,61,62) - Also, you can see those finish in all the difficultys and in this part the voice and the sound is in order crecient, from low to high. It's a good idea, but I would prefer keeping this as simple as possible owing to spread concerns.

[ Nardo's Oni]

HP: 5 -> same as Kantan

Perfect! Thanks :3

Amazing Beatmap! I hope my mod has been helpful you, Good luck!

Canner wrote:

Hi, from my queue.

[Nardo's Kantan]
00:14:776 (13) - move to 00:14:589 - ?there is no sound. There is a sound if you listen carefully at the point after 3 guitar strokes.
00:19:089 (20) - move to 00:18:901 - ?^ This would be rather complicated imo.
00:24:339 (26) - move to 00:24:151 - ?^ same as ^

[Nardo's Oni]
00:14:776 (50) - move to 00:14:964 - and change into d? there is no sound. same as Kantan

That's all. Good luck!

Deppyforce wrote:

oh its circle'd
im too late to mod have a star instead

gl mr prophecy

Stefan wrote:

Kinda late, derp.

[Kantan]
00:14:776 (13) - Are you sure with the note placement? That looks like it got moved accidentely. it doesn't sounds well to me at least.
Moved the note to 00:14:589 - after some considerations.
00:24:339 (26) - It lacks on dense/effect since the song sounds more like following the beat on 00:24:151 - . Either I would use the red tick here or move to 00:23:214 - to emphasize the beat here. fixed the former.
01:05:589 (67,68,69) - The effect (68) has here doesn't really work like 01:12:339 (76,77,78) - . Maybe you want to remove it completely or move to 01:06:714 - ? I really don't know. I think it would be a bit difficult when the 1/1 is too close to the big note complex. Retained as there is also a noticeable instrumental beat in the background.
01:17:589 (83,84,85) - ^ same as ^

It's good, nothing to complain.

[Oni]
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Yeah, it's good. I don't want to be nitpicky for shit.


I intentionally didn't mod one of the Standard Difficulties since they're apparently fine, and honestly said: I don't think I will find anything there (I played both and didn't found anything at first view). Good Luck!

Chocola_2287 wrote:

Hi, from modding queue.
R.I.P. all my GDs

Disclaimer

I think this song should use a certain amount of slider because a lot of long SE are in this song, therefore most of my points will be changing circles to sliders or spinners.

Time lines

01:31:080 onwards: try to reduce white lines here(Check "Omit 1st bar line". It is quite disturbing(i mean gameplay) to see so many white lines coming suddenly.

Nardo's Kantan

00:13:089 (12) - spinner. I would prefer using a big note rather than a short spinner for proper emphasis of the vocal.
00:30:901 (34) - slider. The music is so calm that a slider could not fit well.
00:36:901 (39) - spinner. I think it is not suitable to use spinner as this would break the flow of the notes.
00:42:901 (44) - slider. same as 00:30:901 (34) -
00:35:589 (38) - d, compared to last note, it has a lower pitch, therefore d Its pitch is higher than 00:29:589 (33) - , so k would fit.
00:42:901 (44) - spinner. same as 00:36:901 (39) -
00:57:339, 00:58:089 - add notes here? Vocal sound is heard here. The 8/1 break is intentional to reflect the halt of music there.
01:08:401 (72) - slider. Retained the break for beginners to rest a bit.
01:20:401 (88) - ^ same as ^
01:26:589 (93) - spinner. same as 00:13:089 (12) -

Nardo's Oni

HP 7, Oni should have higher HP than Muzu Well, this is not a must. 6 is already high enough imo.
00:14:589 (49,50) - so weird Would you mind elaborating it more?
->00:14:776 (50) - move 1/2 later, 00:15:339 (52) - delete ;00:15:901 (55) - d This sounds more awkward to put a note at a tick without a beat.
00:23:214 (88) - d, low pitch 00:22:839 (87,88) - sound more powerful than 00:23:589 (89) - and the K K D pattern still works pitch-wise.
00:30:714 (122) - d, pitch dropped compared to last note same as ^
00:30:901 (123) - slider same as Kantan
00:36:901 (139) - ^ ^
00:41:214 (149) - ^^^ k is well-supported by the background instrument.
00:42:901 (155) - ^^^ same as 00:30:901 (123) -
00:48:901 (171) - spinner. Retained to keep the break consistent with the previous ones.
00:56:026 (197,198,199,200) - 100% Weird for me. I don't know what are you mapping here(sorry for bad attitude). Prefer spinner Electric guitar, obviously.
imo, 01:04:089 (225) - 01:22:089 (315) should be more dense. If you don't know what I mean, refer to my deleted inner oni and you will know why. I would like to keep this Oni simple as it is.

Overall : OK . Still, it is hard for me to mod because I have very different mapping style in this song with you 2. Good luck on ranking this song!

Chocola_2287 wrote:

Nardo's Oni

00:14:589 (49,50) - so weird, SE is heard at 00:14:964 but u put the note at 00:14:776 which does not fit the SE at all.
In addition, i think 00:14:589 should add finisher. amd the pattern at 00:14:589 (49) - should be d_kd_dkkd (1/2 interval)
->00:14:776 (50) - move 1/2 later, 00:15:339 (52) - delete ;00:15:901 (55) - d I still think that the current placement of notes fits the music more. If you listen carefully, you will find that the guitar rhythm falls on 00:14:214 (47,48,49,50) - , which supports the use of finish at 00:14:776 - rather than 00:14:964 -

Skylish wrote:

Hi, from long long time ago promised mod. I am still not satisfied that you did not use my Kantan, but still you can choose which one you would like to submit because you are the mapper, right ?

[General]

> 00:50:589 - This kiai session is abused. It is not a part of chorus.

> 01:32:869 - The timing of the retard end is not accurate. You have to fix that. I am not good at timing though.

Check Nardo's Oni if you have any doubt. 01:32:869 (354,355,356,357,358,359) - the first sixth notes are slight drawn back by the incorrect timings.

[Nardo's Oni]

> 00:14:214 (47) - change to k, for a k d k pattern at 00:14:214 (47,48,49) - according to the pitch No change as the pitch of guitar is the same at 00:14:214 (47,48) -

> 00:14:964 - The joint looks extremely weird. This should be the start of a new phase and I do not see a reason why you mapped 00:14:776 (50) - with a D and did not add any note on this timing.

- Remove 00:14:776 (50) - because it is a ghost note.
- 00:14:964 - put a k here and change 00:15:151 (51) - to d.
- 00:15:339 - remove it for a cleaner pattern fixed

> 00:25:089 (97) - change to d, and 00:25:276 (98) - change to k? for a better movements of patterns. Keeping these notes as k d would accompany the instrument in a way better.

> 01:01:089 (210,214) - use Finish? I feel pedals stepped at these two notes. 00:59:589 (205,206,207,208) - Of course you can say that you would like to map Finish while there is solely appearance of base drum. This would weaken the emphasis of 00:59:589 (205,206,207,208) - considerably.

> 01:13:839 (271) - use D here. 01:07:089 (239,241,243) - you used K K K before. Nope, the vocal here is much weaker than the previous spot as you mentioned.

> 01:32:869 (354,355,356,357,358,359,360,361,362) - The timing is wrong. The notes are out of track then. 01:32:869 (354,355,356,357,358,359) - the first sixth notes are slight drawn back by the incorrect timings. The first six notes sound a bit early, so it should be timed again.

[Nardo's Kantan]

> SV= 1.2? 1.4 looks a bit too fast for Kantan level players. As the song BPM is low, 1.4 would be no problem for beginners.
> 00:14:589 - umm... This note is still belong to the starter of the main melody which starts on off-beat. It can be omitted imo. Add a K at 00:14:964 - instead I think the current placement would be more intuitive to play.

> 00:16:839 (16) - shift it 1/2 backwards to match the melody. I used to add a d at 00:17:214 - for the completion of that phase but I found that 1/1 would be overwhelming. If you add a d at 00:17:214 - , delete 00:17:964 - . This would be too complicated for beginners.

> 00:19:089 (20) - shift 1/2 backwards, same reason. I really think that an off-beat pattern is needed here because on-beat one is kinda weird. same as ^

> 00:25:464 (28) - it can be deleted. Leaving 00:25:839 (29) - standing should be good. Retained for a better spread with Futsuu.

> 00:54:339 (53) - shift 1/2 backwards? same as 00:16:839 (16) -

> 00:58:089 - add a d here. The next phase is too heavy if the previous one keeps too clean. The 8/1 break was made intentionally for the halt of music there.

> I feel unwell in Kiai session. Those on-beat patterns make me feel sick. same as 00:16:839 (16) - . If you keep everything landing on the vocals accurately, this would not be a Kantan at the end.

I hope my mod is helpful! Good luck!

Canner wrote:

irc mod

19:14 Prophecy: Cannnnnnnnnnnnn
19:14 Prophecy: er
19:15 Canner: hi
19:15 *Prophecy is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/945423 Shoujo Fractal - Samayoi no Mei (MV Short)]
19:16 Prophecy: M4M
19:16 Prophecy: or NM
19:16 Prophecy: :^)
19:17 Canner: 你已經給過我一次這譜的req了 o.o
19:17 Prophecy: O_O
19:17 Prophecy: I forget X)X
19:17 Prophecy: *X_X
19:18 Prophecy: ww
19:18 Canner: o.o
19:22 *Canner is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/922533 CosMo@BousouP - Oceanus]
19:22 Canner: m4m o.o
19:23 Prophecy: okok
19:23 Prophecy: I will skip all GD (runs, jk)
19:23 Canner: o.o
19:24 Canner: mod hell oni please
19:24 Prophecy: I am dem Property Futsoo
19:24 Prophecy: you know :^)
19:24 Canner: :^
20:35 Canner: PRO o.o
20:38 Prophecy: O_O
21:54 Canner: o.o
21:54 Prophecy: ok
21:57 Canner: start from kantan o.o
21:57 Prophecy: sure :^)
21:58 Canner: 00:06:209 (6) - this note can be delete o.o
21:58 Prophecy: ok
21:59 Canner: 00:17:084 (9,10) - finish?
22:00 Prophecy: Sure :^)))
22:04 Canner: 00:25:709 - add k?
22:04 Prophecy: ww
22:04 Prophecy: I forget this X_X
22:04 Canner: 咁空住好似有D奇怪orz
22:04 Prophecy: orz
22:05 Prophecy: yea
22:06 Canner: 00:36:209 (42) - move to 00:36:584 - here?
22:06 Canner: sounds little better (
22:06 Prophecy: no because I'm following senya
22:06 Prophecy: XP
22:07 Canner: ok :3
22:09 Canner: 00:39:584 (45,46,47,48,49,50,51) - a little long for kantan? idk whether 160bpm kantan can use it
22:09 Prophecy: 5 plet ok
22:13 Canner: ok好似無咩大問題
22:13 Prophecy: wa
22:13 Prophecy: I am noob
22:16 Canner: orz掉線
22:16 Prophecy: orz
22:18 Canner: 21:13 (Canner) 仲有我覺得offset好似快左d (
22:20 Prophecy: `o, IDK
22:20 Prophecy: Regraz send me the offset
22:20 Canner: o.o
22:22 Prophecy: 0.0
22:23 Canner: MuZuKaShii o.o
22:24 Prophecy: ok
22:24 Prophecy: Muzu 1/2 spam
22:26 Canner: 00:14:459 (34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41) - o.o
22:26 Prophecy:
22:26 Prophecy: 1/4 :^)
22:26 Canner: 1/2spam+1/4 (
22:26 Prophecy:
22:26 Prophecy: rankable is ok
22:26 Prophecy: not 1/4 spam lol
22:27 Canner: :3
22:27 Prophecy: :3
22:29 Canner: so many 1/2spam (
22:29 Prophecy: yea
22:30 Canner: but idk how to delete them is better lol
22:31 Prophecy: ]xD
22:33 Canner: 00:38:271 (120,121,122) - dont suggest using ddk in 1/2 spam :3
22:33 Prophecy: I use ddd
22:33 Prophecy: same at 00:51:771 (175,176,177) -
22:33 Canner: can change into kkk
22:33 Prophecy: kkk/ddd
22:34 Prophecy: kkk better :O)
22:35 Canner: ok :3
22:35 Canner: 00:41:271 (134) - this can be delete
22:36 Prophecy: o
22:38 Canner: network broken orz
22:38 Prophecy: orz
22:40 Canner: 00:44:084 (144,145,146,147,148,149,150,151,152,153,154,155,156) - this can delete as o ooo ooooooo imo orz
22:40 Canner: 00:47:084 (158,159,160,161,162,163,164,165,166,167,168,169,170) - these are the same :3
22:41 Prophecy: kek
22:41 Canner: or you can change into ooo ooo ooooo (
22:41 Prophecy: ok
22:46 Canner: 我覺得服務器有問題orz
22:46 Prophecy: xDD
22:46 Prophecy: ..!report
22:46 Canner: 174 175 176 ddk
22:46 Prophecy: no
22:46 Prophecy: monotone color or DQ
22:46 Prophecy: by Dake
22:47 Canner: o.o
22:48 Prophecy: 0.0
22:48 Canner: 192~204 can change as 144~156 as the same pattern
22:48 Canner: 0.0
22:49 Prophecy: wow nice catch
22:49 Canner: 206~218 also :3
22:51 Prophecy: all same
22:51 Canner: 01:03:959 (225,226,227,228,229,230,231,232,233,234,235) - qwq
22:51 Prophecy: QwQ
22:52 Canner: can change into ooo o ooooo? qwq
22:53 Prophecy: ok QwQ
22:55 Canner: http://puu.sh/olBBM.png qwq
22:55 Canner: ok this is better i think
22:57 Prophecy: wow
22:57 Prophecy: nniceee
23:00 Canner: orz this is finish
23:00 Prophecy: orz
23:00 Prophecy: thanks <3