BLYTHEDiamondCrash wrote:
For example?TKiller wrote:
I had a lot to say about September's chart map pick, can't say that much about this one, but I'm pretty sure there were some better maps in September which didn't make it here.
forum
October 2010 Monthly Chart
posted
Total Posts
63
mrtn wrote:
MATs and BATs combined suggest maps and agree on a final list before Cyclone posts it.
holaJames2250 wrote:
Main reason is because the list was basically completed by the time anyone mentioned that~
SIN > BLYTHE imo
Unfortunately both were ranked in the same month @_@...
Unfortunately both were ranked in the same month @_@...
You know, there's already a MoonFragrance map on the charts, people already complained about having the same mappers on all the charts, don't you think one map is enough?ouranhshc wrote:
BLYTHE
Sure, there are a lot of good maps, but not all of them can enter the charts...
I don't think that's a valid reason, considering there were 3 maps by Sushi on said chartBeuchi-chan wrote:
You know, there's already a MoonFragrance map on the charts, people already complained about having the same mappers on all the charts, don't you think one map is enough?ouranhshc wrote:
BLYTHE
Sure, there are a lot of good maps, but not all of them can enter the charts...
Beuchi-chan wrote:
You know, there's already a MoonFragrance map on the charts, people already complained about having the same mappers on all the charts, don't you think one map is enough?ouranhshc wrote:
BLYTHE
Sure, there are a lot of good maps, but not all of them can enter the charts...
Topic Starter
"Thank you for playing" would have been on if any other map was not. (aka it was number 19)
As I said I tried something new for selecting songs. Based on what I've seen people are not happy with this month's picks? What are people's opinions of the selection from last month?
As I said I tried something new for selecting songs. Based on what I've seen people are not happy with this month's picks? What are people's opinions of the selection from last month?
Then why there's 2 maps by James and 2 maps by RJ? By the way there were 2 Sushi maps in the previous chart.Beuchi-chan wrote:
You know, there's already a MoonFragrance map on the charts, people already complained about having the same mappers on all the charts, don't you think one map is enough?ouranhshc wrote:
BLYTHE
Apparently they are better than the alternatives.Natteke wrote:
Then why there's 2 maps by James and 2 maps by RJ? By the way there were 2 Sushi maps in the previous chart.Beuchi-chan wrote:
You know, there's already a MoonFragrance map on the charts, people already complained about having the same mappers on all the charts, don't you think one map is enough?
I think we may need to start reserving slots for 'up and coming' maps from new mappers.
weeeeeeeeeeeee I got two maps in XD
Not a bad idea. Or perhaps something along the line of regional sections? Best of North America, Europe, etc. That might not be as consistent though depending on what gets ranked within the month though...Ephemeral wrote:
I think we may need to start reserving slots for 'up and coming' maps from new mappers.
Our usual trio of winners are back in full force! Cookiezi, 3UNI, and mikhe have been awarded another 1 month on their supporter status. Congratulations!Lol...
shoot, that has nothing to do with it.Ephemeral wrote:
Apparently they are better than the alternatives.Natteke wrote:
Then why there's 2 maps by James and 2 maps by RJ? By the way there were 2 Sushi maps in the previous chart.
I think we may need to start reserving slots for 'up and coming' maps from new mappers.
I support this idea. Maybe not most of the charts, but a part reserved to new mappers would be good.Ephemeral wrote:
I think we may need to start reserving slots for 'up and coming' maps from new mappers.
Actually there were 3...Natteke wrote:
By the way there were 2 Sushi maps in the previous chart.
I understand the feeling, though.
I never get any of my maps into the charts, so what I should say? :V
Lunah_old
My only complaint (so far, since I haven't actually downloaded and played any of the maps yet) is that every month I have to go and download each song individually. I'm a fan of being able to download multiple charts at once. And my folder is so large at this point (I have just about every Osu! song released since its inception until about august of this year) that searching through my folder for the charts is rather laborious. I know it would be asking a lot but after the songs are selected, would it be possible for someone to rar them, toss them up on the site you guys use for hosting, and post it under the "beatmap pack" section of the website? That way, I don't have to use your precious bandwidth to download all the charts for the month! Win win, right? Anyways, once I get all the charts and play them all I'll come back with more feedback.
Gens or another packer does this every month, actually. :pvirus73 wrote:
My only complaint (so far, since I haven't actually downloaded and played any of the maps yet) is that every month I have to go and download each song individually. I'm a fan of being able to download multiple charts at once. And my folder is so large at this point (I have just about every Osu! song released since its inception until about august of this year) that searching through my folder for the charts is rather laborious. I know it would be asking a lot but after the songs are selected, would it be possible for someone to rar them, toss them up on the site you guys use for hosting, and post it under the "beatmap pack" section of the website? That way, I don't have to use your precious bandwidth to download all the charts for the month! Win win, right? Anyways, once I get all the charts and play them all I'll come back with more feedback.
From looking at the beatmap pack page the only one that is in there recently is from september. I don't know if they're removed monthly (if so, bravo to whoever does that) but this months is not up yet. My apologies, I didn't see it when I went, not trying to rush anyone or anythingDerekku wrote:
Gens or another packer does this every month, actually. :p
Just returning to the game after a long hiatus and trying to get back into the swing of things Oh snap, looks like I'm doing it this month, thanks for indirectly reminding me virus73 I'll try to get it up within 48 hours maximum...
that would be an epic failOdaril wrote:
I support this idea. Maybe not most of the charts, but a part reserved to new mappers would be good.Ephemeral wrote:
I think we may need to start reserving slots for 'up and coming' maps from new mappers.
I have no complaint about this month's chart, last month was great as is this one [although i've played like half the songs and they are lacking difficulties, most have two/three]
As far as mapping goes...I agree, there should be room for 'up and coming' mappers. I think that there should only be ONE map per person on the chart, unless the 2nd map is extremely exceptional and you absolutely MUST have both maps in there. No more than two max though.
Just my two cents. ~
As far as mapping goes...I agree, there should be room for 'up and coming' mappers. I think that there should only be ONE map per person on the chart, unless the 2nd map is extremely exceptional and you absolutely MUST have both maps in there. No more than two max though.
Just my two cents. ~
Topic Starter
I'm just going to throw this out there. I almost never have looked at the mappers names when selecting maps.
EDIT: aka, map quality > mapper quantity.
EDIT: aka, map quality > mapper quantity.
Thanks to Larto the October Monthly Chart pack should be getting onto the official pack listings.
here's the link just in case if anyone checks the thread instead.
http://www.mediafire.com/?0jad6brzb6p50vt
here's the link just in case if anyone checks the thread instead.
http://www.mediafire.com/?0jad6brzb6p50vt
They can win anytime if they want. Any maps doesn't matter to them.Cyclone wrote:
Tired of the same 3 people winning every month?
ykcarrot wrote:
They can win anytime if they want. Any maps doesn't matter to them.Cyclone wrote:
Tired of the same 3 people winning every month?
ykcarrot wrote:
They can win anytime if they want. Any maps doesn't matter to them.Cyclone wrote:
Tired of the same 3 people winning every month?
Why not a price for 2nd place?
(impossible to beat the usual 3)
(impossible to beat the usual 3)
why impossibleSilentWings wrote:
Why not a price for 2nd place?
(impossible to beat the usual 3)
For osu, because Cookiezi is Chuck NorrisdNextGen wrote:
why impossibleSilentWings wrote:
Why not a price for 2nd place?
(impossible to beat the usual 3)
SilentWings wrote:
For osu, because Cookiezi is Chuck Norris
Couldn't agree moreSilentWings wrote:
For osu, because Cookiezi is Chuck Norris
He is currently 5 notes away from FCing Haya Saitama2000... o_o
You are not why this idea has been thrown around. I doubt you would go, "OH HEY I KNOW THIS MAPPER LET'S ADD THEIR MAP" anyways.Cyclone wrote:
I'm just going to throw this out there. I almost never have looked at the mappers names when selecting maps.
EDIT: aka, map quality > mapper quantity.
However, many of the people suggesting maps for the list have not played every single map ranked this month and mainly play maps of their favorite songs or mappers. This is because of natural bias towards playing maps that they think they'll enjoy as opposed to taking gambles on random songs/mappers. Because of this they sometimes don't discover gems made by mappers that aren't popular (yet), or are maybe new.
Basically, space reserved for non-popular/newer mappers would likely end up with the people making suggestions going out of their comfort zones; ATM they are often afraid they'll waste time playing a bad map. We're out of the hell known as 2009, might as well embrace it. Do consider the idea, at least. I'd give it a shot for a month or two. If it turns out as a disaster then you could just ditch it.
In this case, wouldn't the BAT who bubbled or ranked the song nominate it?Ekaru wrote:
This is because of natural bias towards playing maps that they think they'll enjoy as opposed to taking gambles on random songs/mappers. Because of this they sometimes don't discover gems made by mappers that aren't popular (yet), or are maybe new.
Played the songs in the chart for October (about half at least, school work and all that keeping me away) and I must say that I'm enjoying them. I don't, however, like the trend that appears to be happening with all of the higher difficulty songs. I understand that when you play the more difficult ranks of songs you sign up for difficult patterns and what not, but it seems to me that a lot of the more difficult maps are making the notes faster, harder to hit, and more stream indicative, rather than more imaginative or following the off-beat of a song or any of the other various of things you can do to make a song more difficult. I don't say this because I can't clear the songs, I used to be fairly good at taiko and plan to get back there again despite having to learn all of the new "popular" patterns that mappers are uses these days, but its just reminiscent of a trend I noticed back in Stepmania where mappers would just throw as many "difficult" maneuvers into a song in order to increase the difficulty rather than doing something imaginative.
just my two cents. Lovin' some of the easier difficulties though, they're really fun and looking to be really competitive.
P.S. Sorry about the wall of text, I get passionate about my rhythm games =
P.P.S Thanks for uploading and posting the chart pack to the beatmap pack section of the site Much appreciated!
just my two cents. Lovin' some of the easier difficulties though, they're really fun and looking to be really competitive.
P.S. Sorry about the wall of text, I get passionate about my rhythm games =
P.P.S Thanks for uploading and posting the chart pack to the beatmap pack section of the site
Much appreciated!So November chart is dead?
I just've understood that Cookiezi didn't participate this month. Such a chance and I missed it, aaaaaaa D:
They will be out soon, be patientwuliang wrote:
So November chart is dead?
James2250 wrote:
They will be out soon, be patient
For this I almost never played October map
cyclone is slow times three
if only the maps were more interesting
yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:
if only the maps were more interesting
I can't even remember what the fuck I was talking about. I don't even remember writing that post. Chances are it's full of crap. Just ignore it. /lateMetalMario201 wrote:
In this case, wouldn't the BAT who bubbled or ranked the song nominate it?
That said, the November chart will hopefully come soon. I know they've been doing nominations and stuff for quite a while now due to talking to a BAT about how it was going.
That is once we solve the drama crap that's been going on lately in there ._. (I honestly don't know what the hell's been happening there)
Topic Starter
I apologize for the delay. The November Monthly chart will be available before i go to sleep tonight.
Fine...Cyclone wrote:
I apologize for the delay. The November Monthly chart will be available before i go to sleep tonight.
Worth the wait