forum

Nakagawa Shouko - Namida no Tane, Egao no Hana

posted
Total Posts
27
Topic Starter
Licnect
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2010年12月28日 at 下午 11:37:49

Artist: Nakagawa Shouko
Title: Namida no Tane, Egao no Hana
Source: Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Tags: movie crimson lotus ragan hen
BPM: 110
Filesize: 9292kb
Play Time: 04:33
Difficulties Available:
  1. Hana (3.21 stars, 285 notes)
  2. Namida (4.88 stars, 587 notes)
Download: Nakagawa Shouko - Namida no Tane, Egao no Hana
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
9th map
The movie [Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann(Lagann Hen)]
Enjoy !!!!!
-----------------------------
Namida(Hard)------Finished
Hana(Normal)------Finished
-----------------------------
Thanks modded list
10/09/29 kioukiou (Timing and SB)
10/10/02 yongtw123
10/10/02 James2250
10/11/14 orioncomet
10/12/06 Garven
10/12/21 kioukiou
f0012979
Star/ ~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
kioukiou
IRC modded(Timing、SB).

star.
Topic Starter
Licnect

kioukiou wrote:

IRC modded(Timing、SB).

star.
good!! love you XD

QQ姐 <= :D
Kotone
>,<
AngelHoney
>~</
gto461013
>_</
yongtw123
Let's go:

Skin/SB:
In both difficulties, bg suddenly changes at 04:42:151, put a transition there.
Spinner background can be a little obtrusive. Maybe simplify the gauge part of the spinner? So many spirals @@~~~

[Hana]
Except for some sliders touching the top edge, this diff is solid.

[Namida]
Oooh very nice. I don't do too well with those little streams though lol


Good map~
James2250
I suggest you resize the first background to 800x600
I agree about spinner comment
No spinner clear?
02:24:722 kiai time would fit more at 02:25:711
Kiai time doesn't really fit the places where the song fades out (01:41:551, 02:58:351) in my opinion
Kiai time doesn't really fit on the end of the final spinner

Hana:
25 second break...I would shorten it slightly
AR -1 for easiest difficulty?
(some combo modding that fits the music more, but ignore if you disagree)
00:09:174 (4) - new combo
00:47:791 (7) - ^
00:50:191 (1) - remove new combo
00:51:631 (7) - new combo
01:03:151 (5) - ^
01:16:591 (6) - ^
01:24:271 (8) - ^
01:25:231 (1) - remove new combo
03:24:751 (1) - ^
03:25:231 (2) - new combo
03:30:991 (3) - slightly high up
03:59:791 (5) - new combo

Namida:
OD +1
01:33:871 (7) - new combo for new pattern
03:37:111 (9) - ^

Nicely done maps
*star*
Topic Starter
Licnect
thanks

:D
-IZUMI-
Star
Garven
As per your request:

[General]
Think you could find an image for comboburst-0 that doesn't have an edge cut off like the other two? It sticks out against them a bit.
The first red timing section should be at 110 BPM. Don't forget to readjust your sliders (I'd just set the entire section to .5 for an easy fix, hehe)

[Storyboard]
Your strobes seem to be going off a little early. Please double check these so they they occur right on the beat instead of a little before it.
It'd be cool if you cut along the gray line instead of straight down for 5, 5-1, and 5-2. :<

[Hana]
In general, your combos run fairly long. Here are some suggestions:
SPOILER
00:09:174 (4) - New combo?
01:03:151 (5) - New combo?
01:16:591 (2) - New combo
01:24:271 (8) - New combo.
01:25:231 (1) - Remove new combo
01:35:791 (3) - New combo
01:40:351 (1) - New combo
Anyway, maybe try to follow that pattern of new combos and see what you can find.

There are a lot of soft finishes you could have used throughout the difficulty that you missed out on. Maybe give it a listen and see where you can add them?
04:32:431 (2) - Eeh, just delete this, and add a note at 04:33:871. Do the added note as a new combo. Hrm, although the slight ritardando makes things a bit iffy... maybe do the added note and the last note as a slider?

A nice normal diff here.

[Namida]
01:25:951 (1) - Remove new combo
Your combo usage is so weird to me, haha. Well, nothing else to really pick at really except the lack of finish usage.

Nice and relaxing pair of maps here~
Topic Starter
Licnect

Garven wrote:

As per your request:

[General]
Think you could find an image for comboburst-0 that doesn't have an edge cut off like the other two? It sticks out against them a bit.
The first red timing section should be at 110 BPM. Don't forget to readjust your sliders (I'd just set the entire section to .5 for an easy fix, hehe) good idea :D

[Storyboard]
Your strobes seem to be going off a little early. Please double check these so they they occur right on the beat instead of a little before it.
It'd be cool if you cut along the gray line instead of straight down for 5, 5-1, and 5-2. :< :( poor SB

[Hana]
In general, your combos run fairly long. Here are some suggestions: thanks your suggestions :D
SPOILER
00:09:174 (4) - New combo?
01:03:151 (5) - New combo?
01:16:591 (2) - New combo
01:24:271 (8) - New combo.
01:25:231 (1) - Remove new combo
01:35:791 (3) - New combo
01:40:351 (1) - New combo
Anyway, maybe try to follow that pattern of new combos and see what you can find.

There are a lot of soft finishes you could have used throughout the difficulty that you missed out on. Maybe give it a listen and see where you can add them?
04:32:431 (2) - Eeh, just delete this, and add a note at 04:33:871. Do the added note as a new combo. Hrm, although the slight ritardando makes things a bit iffy... maybe do the added note and the last note as a slider? ok.

A nice normal diff here. :D

[Namida]
01:25:951 (1) - Remove new combo ok
Your combo usage is so weird to me, haha. Well, nothing else to really pick at really except the lack of finish usage.

Nice and relaxing pair of maps here~
thanks your mod fixed :)
orioncomet
[Namida]
01:19:831 (2) - sound wrong to me (listen to the drum), move this note 1/4 toward (01:19:951) and replace sound whitle with clap, dont forgot about spacing change.
04:06:871 (7) - ^ (04:06:991)
04:34:431 (1) - this note sound 1/8 to me lol T_T 1/6 is a bit late, use beat snap divisor 1/8 and move it to 04:34:411

+_+ Hana is fine ~
Topic Starter
Licnect

orioncomet wrote:

[Namida]
01:19:831 (2) - sound wrong to me (listen to the drum), move this note 1/4 toward (01:19:951) and replace sound whitle with clap, dont forgot about spacing change.
04:06:871 (7) - ^ (04:06:991)
04:34:431 (1) - this note sound 1/8 to me lol T_T 1/6 is a bit late, use beat snap divisor 1/8 and move it to 04:34:411

+_+ Hana is fine ~
fixed all
thank you orion >M<
Garven
Sorry for the delays. ;_;

[Storyboard]
The strobes are still going off a little early. If you fixed this, you need to do a full resubmit for it to be changed here. Same goes with any skin changes and such.
02:25:711 - Make the image transition here instead of the really early point where it's at right now.
02:48:751 - And the last transition should be here instead of where it's at now. Feels unnatural right now.
03:40:591 - Image transition here
03:48:271 - ^

[Skin]
The comboburst-0 is the same... did you change it like you said you did and forget to full-resubmit?

[Hana]
03:38:191 - Remove the kiai here and move it to 03:40:591 -
03:56:431 (1) - Way too soon after a spinner.
04:17:071 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - <3 this pattern btw
04:26:191 - Maybe add a note here? The way the slider before this spot ends sounds odd.

[Namida]
01:00:991 (6) - That overlap. :< Lower the 6 1 grid, and raise the 7 one grid, 8 right two grids
03:38:191 - Kill this kiai, move it to 03:40:591 -
03:58:231 (7) - Raise one grid? The overlap is still bad, but it looks better there.
04:34:831 (1) - Hrm, maybe start this at 04:35:071 - ?

Get the storyboard fixed up. :<
Topic Starter
Licnect

Garven wrote:

Sorry for the delays. ;_;

[Storyboard]
The strobes are still going off a little early. If you fixed this, you need to do a full resubmit for it to be changed here. Same goes with any skin changes and such.
02:25:711 - Make the image transition here instead of the really early point where it's at right now.
02:48:751 - And the last transition should be here instead of where it's at now. Feels unnatural right now.
03:40:591 - Image transition here
03:48:271 - ^

[Skin]
The comboburst-0 is the same... did you change it like you said you did and forget to full-resubmit?

[Hana]
03:38:191 - Remove the kiai here and move it to 03:40:591 -
03:56:431 (1) - Way too soon after a spinner.
04:17:071 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - <3 this pattern btw
04:26:191 - Maybe add a note here? The way the slider before this spot ends sounds odd.

[Namida]
01:00:991 (6) - That overlap. :< Lower the 6 1 grid, and raise the 7 one grid, 8 right two grids
03:38:191 - Kill this kiai, move it to 03:40:591 -
03:58:231 (7) - Raise one grid? The overlap is still bad, but it looks better there.
04:34:831 (1) - Hrm, maybe start this at 04:35:071 - ?

Get the storyboard fixed up. :<
thank you all fixed :D
Cyril Scarlet
:D
Garven
[Skin]
Crop the unnecessary transparency from comboburst-1 and comboburst-2

[Storyboard]
Okay, with strobes, you want them to START on the beat, not peak on the beat. So:

01:08:911 - Strobe starts here
01:16:591 - ^
01:24:271 - ^
01:31:951 - ^

01:06:991 - Maybe start the bg transform here? Feels really early at it's current spot.

[Hana]
Okay, massive combo mod coming your way here:
SPOILER
00:25:711 (1) - Remove new combo
00:26:671 (2) - New combo
00:28:591 (5) - New combo
00:47:791 (7) - New combo
00:50:191 (1) - Remove new combo
00:51:631 (4) - New combo
01:02:431 (4) - New combo either here or on the next slider
01:16:591 (6) - New combo
01:23:311 (6) - New combo
01:25:231 (1) - Remove new combo
01:35:791 (3) - New combo
01:40:111 (4) - New combo?
02:04:591 (6) - New combo
02:06:031 (1) - Remove new combo
02:06:511 (2) - New combo
02:21:871 (4) - New combo
02:48:031 (1) - Remove new combo
02:48:751 (2) - New combo
02:52:591 (7) - New combo
02:53:071 (1) - Remove new combo
03:24:751 (1) - Remove
03:25:231 (2) - New
03:36:751 (4) - New
03:59:791 (5) - New
04:02:191 (1) - Remove
04:03:631 (4) - New
04:10:111 (4) - New
04:12:271 (1) - Remove
04:15:151 (1) - New
04:17:071 (1) - Remove
04:23:071 (6) - Remove
It's kind of inconsistent still, but the way you mapped some parts made it kind of impossible without making things a bit too long.

[Namida]
01:00:991 (6,7,8) - I'm not sure what it is about these, but it never feels right to me. No need to change it, but I thought I'd mention it in case you agree.
01:33:871 (7,8,9,10) - I keep wanting to play these with the big vocal hits.

Anyway, I mostly want the strobes fixed. They still just look wrong to me.
Topic Starter
Licnect

Garven wrote:

[Skin]
Crop the unnecessary transparency from comboburst-1 and comboburst-2 fixed

[Storyboard]
Okay, with strobes, you want them to START on the beat, not peak on the beat. So:

01:08:911 - Strobe starts here
01:16:591 - ^
01:24:271 - ^
01:31:951 - ^ all fixed

01:06:991 - Maybe start the bg transform here? Feels really early at it's current spot. OK ~

[Hana]
Okay, massive combo mod coming your way here: ;_;
SPOILER
00:25:711 (1) - Remove new combo K
00:26:671 (2) - New combo K
00:28:591 (5) - New combo K
00:47:791 (7) - New combo K
00:50:191 (1) - Remove new combo K
00:51:631 (4) - New combo K
01:02:431 (4) - New combo either here or on the next slider K
01:16:591 (6) - New combo K
01:23:311 (6) - New combo K
01:25:231 (1) - Remove new combo K
01:35:791 (3) - New combo K
01:40:111 (4) - New combo? NO
02:04:591 (6) - New combo K
02:06:031 (1) - Remove new combo K
02:06:511 (2) - New combo K
02:21:871 (4) - New combo K
02:48:031 (1) - Remove new combo K
02:48:751 (2) - New combo K
02:52:591 (7) - New combo K
02:53:071 (1) - Remove new combo K
03:24:751 (1) - Remove K
03:25:231 (2) - New K
03:36:751 (4) - New K
03:59:791 (5) - New K
04:02:191 (1) - Remove K
04:03:631 (4) - New NO. but new combo in 04:02:671
04:10:111 (4) - New K
04:12:271 (1) - Remove K
04:15:151 (1) - New K
04:17:071 (1) - Remove NO
04:23:071 (6) - Remove NO
It's kind of inconsistent still, but the way you mapped some parts made it kind of impossible without making things a bit too long.

[Namida]
01:00:991 (6,7,8) - I'm not sure what it is about these, but it never feels right to me. No need to change it, but I thought I'd mention it in case you agree. OK
01:33:871 (7,8,9,10) - I keep wanting to play these with the big vocal hits. hmm...ok

Anyway, I mostly want the strobes fixed. They still just look wrong to me.
Thank you Garven :)
kioukiou
5-1.jpg跟5.jpg 5-2jpg的接縫問題還是存在

但不知道是不是只有我這邊才這樣,待確認

lead-in [Namida]跟[Hana],兩個都統一用2.5 sec吧

先star.
qinche
i found no error with the sb, star =3

Topic Starter
Licnect

qinche wrote:

i found no error with the sb, star =3


thanks qinche

Fixed Lead-in
kioukiou
Bubbled.
Mafiamaster
Looking great!
Ranked.
yongtw123
Oh yay congrats!
Topic Starter
Licnect
thank you Mafia >M<
and thanks yongtw123 :D
Please sign in to reply.

New reply