Xexxar wrote:

z12031203120321's Insane: 01:30:884 (5) - this note isnt snapped. It 2 MS early. √

Ayaya's Extra: 00:25:552 (3) - this note is snapped to 1/16th for its slider end. √

Yuii- wrote:

top diff: 00:40:718 (2) - should be 1/6 instead. this is unsnapped completely, there's nothing in the background music that supports the 1/2

aya's difficulty has that snapping as well, would be nice if you could make it consistent

imoutosan wrote:

Yuii- wrote:

top diff: 00:40:718 (2) - should be 1/6 instead. this is unsnapped completely, there's nothing in the background music that supports the 1/2

aya's difficulty has that snapping as well, would be nice if you could make it consistent

This snapping was talked in Lasse's first mod before. For the whole map aya's diff has different style of rhythm choice and placement from the top diff (most rhythm and placement are simplified in this one), so it's not necessary (and not very practical) to make up with that consistence.

Shiirn wrote:

I'm sorry, did you really just say "Another diff does it correctly, so why should another diff do it right?"

Xexxar wrote:

ya im sorry yuii but following the song is subjective

in all seriousness, why not do a pattern like this:



this objectively follows the song better and is still quite playable.

Xexxar wrote:

It's quite easy to hit the 1/6th double if you were to do it how I suggested since it's just a quick double tap of two fingers. It's not overly intense if its mapped this way. It's not "hard", but relatively hard. For this part I'd like to make players feel relaxed, so even a little raise of difficulty is counterproductive to the overall arrangement of the map.

If your complaint is readability, know that you switch between 1/3 and 1/4th streams without passive rhythms and with spacing that is extremely unintuitive as well. I'm don't mind it at all. It's some player's feeling.

As for "slider in a circle only part" being "too bulky", the song didn't decide for you to map this as circles only. Yeah, it's just my own aesthetics. The song decided that it should be a relatively calm part here, and as the mapper I think a 1/2 circle only part is a good way to tell that. Different people cam get different preference in expressing a same thing, and this should not be discouraged (if they work, of course), isn't it?

Natsu wrote:

or ask someone to add a sound in 1/2 at the mp3 /hides

Lasse wrote:

your custom snapped breaks on e/n/h got a bit broken by the offset change

dq things and the 1 /6 have been fixed so it should be fine to rebubble after that

1. 00:09:053 (1,2) - The spacing between these feels too low, because of the strong cymbal on 00:09:553 - and how small it is compared to 00:08:053 (5,6,7) - for example.
2. 00:15:053 (4,5,1) - This transition feels really awkward to play. It requires a huge slow down while moving further in the same direction, which is uncomfortable and shouldn't be used as an introduction for the fast part, especially. It would be better to place (5) closer to the previous object, for example http://puu.sh/w8TyL/8653d0d360.jpg
3. 00:16:886 - In this section, what's up with the high amount of soft hitclaps? I don't think they fit to the song very well in general (the other difficulties also use much more fitting custom claps) and they really overused here. Also sometimes they seem to be placed on random beats, atleast I can't recognize a pattern on how they are used. Imo the best solution would be to apply a similar hitsounding to the highest difficulty. The same applies to the similar section later in the song.
4. 00:39:719 (6,1,2,3,4,1) - Confusing pattern. The slider that starts on 1/6 is hard to read imo, because the spacing is the same as 00:39:885 (1,2) - visually, also I don't understand why the NC is placed here 00:39:885 (1) -in the middle of the pattern.
5. 00:49:552 (1,2,3) - The angle of this triplet was very uncomfortable to play. After this zig-zag movement 00:48:885 (1,2,3,4,1) - I expected the triplet to lead downwards from 00:49:552 (1) - to continue the movement, however it's placed in an unintuitive angle that leads to the left right now.
6. 00:50:219 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4) - Really nice pattern, but what is up with those clap hitsounds again? They suddenly appear here although there are no new sounds in the music compared to the rest of the section.
7. 00:55:552 (1,2,3,4,5,1,1,2,1) - The density (and spacing) in this part feels way too low. The undermapping doesn't fit here because in the music there is such a high contrast between this section and the previous / following section. This part is very intense so it should be mapped with a lot of emphasis on the particular beats, imo.
8. 01:04:219 (1,1) - It sounds strange to hear the drum hitnormal sounds on the end of these sliders. Would be better to silence those.
9. 01:04:885 (1,2,3,4) - Those patterns are interesting, but the amount of overlapping between the two sliders is different each time (compare 01:05:552 (3,4) - 01:12:885 (1,2) - 01:15:552 (1,2) - ) so they feel pretty sloppy in that regard. Especially the last example I gave looks odd because the blanket isn't perfect while the other blankets were.
10. 01:12:552 (2,3,1) - It looks pretty messy to have the circle at the tail overlap and the one at the head stack with it. Generally, a lot of the overlaps in the chorus end up looking messy because of combinations like that. Though it might depend on taste, I think this is a pretty major issue in this map as the issues are present very often and players will notice this for sure.
11. 01:17:885 (2,3,4) - Another linear slow down movement that doesn't feel comfortable to play. Also the stronger beat is 01:18:219 - so it would make more sense to have a larger jump leading into that note.

Desperate-kun wrote: