Hi you Japan Guys!
Mod from TNA Spec Queue.
Hey i played this map on taiko no tatsujin at the Arcade. I'm don't remember how it is mapped on TnT
Lel
If you have any troubles by understanding me -> PM me
[TNA]
Let's see what TNA said.
Spread does not work out: Kantan needs to be harder, Futsuu and especially Muzukashii need to be easier (in some spots Muzukashii is very similar to Oni). Overall Futsuu's kiai should be reconsidered and some Muzukashii patterns refined to suit the spread to Oni better.
Ok. I won't consider what has been done from the previous mod i'm too lazy for that.
[General]
HP a bit too high? Well that's a short song it may be ok. But charlotte's Oni should be 6.5 too imo.
00:37:585 : D? Legit with the music. It's also a new section.
[Kantan]
1.15 SR... seems legit.
You also have many unused green lines. Up to you to deleted them, that makes your diff more clean. But who cares lel.
00:08:710 : I don't feel a good reason to keep it. You can keep the k for the piano. This d is more for vocals, well ok there's piano too but that's not the main notes. So yeah... delete?
00:10:210 : I'm more for a k because of the piano.
00:14:335+ (3,4,6) : k? The guitar is Up. Seems legit in this way.
00:33:835 : The way you structured this section make this not non sense, this k should be at 00:34:585, so you should delete it or move it at the position i mentioned and move the spinner by 1/1.
00:36:835 : Is it a legit place for a don? Maybe but i don't feel it good. You should delete this note and end your spinner here. In that case you can make your next note a D (maybe you forget to change 00:37:585 into D? Because that's way better). With the changes that's more "taiko like" i guess \o\
00:51:647++ : Imo you shouldn't go with finish on the 1/2 notes. It's a bit "too much" and we cannot compare these notes as 00:52:585 in terms on intensity.
Overall it's a good kantan. I found no reason to lower it more. Imo the pre-kiai section is harder than the kiai itself because of these 3/2 patterns and 1/1 ones. Maybe hard to differ for new players.
After that : Downed to 1.12 SR. Ok.
[Futsuu]
Current 1.86 SR. Seems correct.
00:03:085+ : Hmmm ok... didn't look on the previous mod and what BN said. Not feeling confident tho to see this on futsuu. Imo it really safer to move 00:03:366 to 00:04:210. You avoid the 3/4 which can cause trouble and you put the d on a piano note. Sound better imo?
00:10:397 : Why no k? Why still a doublet here?
00:14:335+ (6,7,8,10) : Same argues as Kantan -> k
00:18:085 : You should also go as k here. If you listen the back melody.
00:28:210 : I would like to respect a 3/1 break and your structure you did further. So whu not add a k here.
00:33:835 : And to compensate and respect the breaks. Delete.
00:49:585 : I've some trouble with the structure, i know it's the most complex part of the music but this doubles D and K i don't felt they are placed well. If we take as example at 00:45:272. This might be 1/1 earlier if we take in consider the piano intensity. Asgasga i don't know wut to think. But yee.
01:04:866 : Same as way above. You know what to do.
Up to 1.93~ A bit higher but i don't felt i make the futsuu harder.
[Muzukashii]
00:12:835 : These are the only triplets of this section and they are together. That's a bit too much and i'm not sure they fit the music. Imo they have sense if they are put at 00:11:898, but here... ok there's battery at 00:13:210, but before... the guitar? Ye maybe but for a muzukashii.. asgasgasgasag. At least remove the first triple k.
00:13:585 : Swap with next note. Imo the k should be on the guitar. Also because i hate kdkdkdk stuff asgasga.
00:14:710 : Imo this is too much dkdkdkd stuff wich is boring. How about doing stuff like this? :
NB : (11) = 00:14:710
00:18:085 : There you can go for a triple k here.
00:21:647 : Imo kddk is worth, more accurate with the guitar.
00:43:210 : This is such a legit place for tripple k meh.
00:44:710 : Damn i would so much to get triple k + D after. Dunno why, it fits so well with the previous triple!
00:53:710 : This this only kd/dk pattern on this section (well there's another one after but it' on the end). It may be ok, but also a bit strange. It's still decent on the music tho. But in this case i recommend you to switch to D the next note, the piano have quite the same sound. Or also put the previous and next first doublets as kd.
01:06:460 : Why don't you follow the vocals here? Btw i prefer to see ddkdk for normal 1/2 pattern here or ddk k dk d d if you follow the vocals for the complete pattern.
01:10:960 : Vocals down, so go d?
The next section is quite the same. Maybe it is copy/paste?
01:26:710 : Why d? k makes more sense, you keep the last d for the new section.
01:31:116 : This is the only 1/4 of the last section. That's not really logic. Maybe you should add at least a 1/4 before or after, but don't let him alone
Well that's not a bad muzukashii but... the SR is sooo low i don't know how much it was when TNA said to go down but imo if you have to get a good spread i'm afraid that you have to do a light oni because you've a lack of triplets. That's why the SR is ~2.50 on a 160 DPM song (i got 2.3 on sky dance with 124 BPM (3.06 with 186 BPM on DT)).
[Oni]
NB : All the pattern style mentions on Muzukashii can be applied on Oni too. The structure is quite the same.
I've also tested your map and i consider this as a light Oni. So the muzukashii is more legit.
00:13:116 : For a smother spread with muzukashii. I recommend you to split the stream into 2 and delete this note.
00:15:647 : Swap with next. Makes more sense with the piano.
00:17:522 : kkd? You've guitar between these notes. Well you got a D after, so it's up to you.
00:24:647 : You should also swap the next 2 notes.
00:38:897 : You combo is quite long imo. Maybe take a break and delete this note?
00:41:522 : ^
00:41:335 : For the vocals, you should probably go for k.
01:14:335 : This stream is not a good idea. Currently you streams are no really longer than triples (ok you got a quint before but in total we have 5 quints), and here you go for a 9 note stream witch include some alternative way. You should at least split this stream into 2 equal part and try to get common quints (such as kkddk - kdkdk - ddkdd etc...)
01:26:335 : ^
[Charlotte's Oni]
OD 7.5. How rude.
00:13:585 : Maybe you should swap, you got piano not here so it's worth to go for k here.
00:17:991 : Add d? This previous double is so alone :'( . That may be weird too.
00:30:647 : Add d. Definitevly worth and makes sense with the next k.
01:06:085 : This is quite and uncommand pattern here. Imo it doesn't fit well your common structure. Maybe go for kkddk or kk dk?
01:25:585 : Eww i was so close to clear this pattern.
This is what i expect more to see on an Oni. The pattern are logic. Different section visibles by the music and shown by the intensity of the patterns. Some long patterns but on decent place and a "bit" harder than the normal one. Gj.
That's all i can say. Gl hf for rank.