forum

Unknown Artist - Set Fire to Villages

posted
Total Posts
11
Topic Starter
yuruyuri_old_1
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2015年4月12日 at 下午 07:34:28

Artist: Unknown Artist
Title: Set Fire to Villages
Tags: Set Fire to Villages
BPM: 185
Filesize: 2307kb
Play Time: 01:15
Difficulties Available:
  1. Hard (3.32 stars, 158 notes)
  2. Normal (1.59 stars, 86 notes)
Download: Unknown Artist - Set Fire to Villages
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
your humble servant...... looking for your precious modding ;)
Yuthuil
General: Untick Widescreen Support and Letterbox during breaks. You need to hitsound the map in order to rank it.The gap in difficulty between normal and hard is too big, either make normal harder, hard easier, or make a new diff. Offset is wrong, you'll have to retime that. Preview point is unsnapped. Add Kiai somewhere?

Normal: I don't think the SV fits a normal diff :/

00:00:944 (2) - Such harsh shapes are not really popular in Osu.
00:00:944 (2,1) - Overlaps - they are unsightly as well as hard to read for beginners.
00:03:539 (2,1) - ^
00:07:836 (1) - You can't have the spinner so close to the slider in a Normal diff.
00:11:647 (1) - More than 1 repeat in Normal is not advised.
00:15:863 (2) - ^
00:51:863 (6,1) - I think you should delete 6 and move 1 to it's former position.

Hard:

00:01:431 (7) - NC? (New Combo)
00:02:404 (1) - I don't think you should let the reverse part do the job of such a heavy beat, you should make it something clickable.
00:04:025 (7) - NC
00:04:512 (1,2) - Blanket properly.
00:05:323 (3) - NC
00:14:242 (1,4,5) - Not a nice overlap
00:19:998 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Streams at such BPM are not recommended in hard.
01:14:890 (2,4) - Stack properly.

Overall: Mapset could use a little bit of work, but good luck!
_handholding
Hi from my M4M queue

Hard


00:01:431 (1) - NC here
00:05:971 (7) - ^
00:12:944 (4) - This slider isnt really pleasing to the eye because of the positioning of your points. I think you should keep it as simple as possible here. Something like this
00:23:809 (8,9,10,11,12) - This is extremely hard to read. Maybe rework it and change the triplet to a reverse slider?
00:25:917 (1) - This breaks up the flow. I think it would be better to make this into a slider
00:41:161 (5) - Re-position it so it doesnt overlap with 00:40:998 (4)
00:46:350 (1,1,2,3,4,5) - You went from following the flute-like instrument to the bass midway through the slider. It makes it very hard to follow by ear. I think you should change up the rhythm of your notes in this section
00:48:944 (1) - If this slider is suppose to be following the bass then it should start at 00:48:782
00:49:593 - Add a note here
00:53:971 (2,3) - Swap the position of these 2 on the timeline, so that the slider starts at 00:53:971 and move the circle to 00:54:620
00:58:188 (4,5,6) - Fix the stack
01:04:836 (8,9,10,11,12) - Same as my comment from 00:23:809
01:15:215 (4) - Move this slider so it doesnt overlap any of the other notes

Normal

Overall I think you should rework some of your sliders. I
know some people like edgy sliders but when they start to overlap with others it looks less pretty
00:07:836 (1) - This should finish at 00:09:052
00:12:944 (3) - This would look alot better if it was made more simpler.
00:15:863 (2) - ^
00:16:836 (1) - Make this slider finish at 00:17:809
00:18:458 (2) - Make this slider start at 00:18:133 and finish at 00:19:106
I think the next section would have much better flow if you did this
  • 00:22:025 (2) - Make this slider finish at 00:22:512
    00:22:998 (4) - Move this slider to 00:23:161 and finish at 00:23:647
    Then add a note at 00:22:836 and 00:22:998
00:42:133 (2) - How about moving this to (96x , 184y)
00:46:350 (2) - Move the slider to 00:46:674 and finish at 00:46:998. Then add a circle at 00:46:350
00:55:755 (3) - Make this the same shape as 00:55:106 (2)
00:58:350 (3) - ^
01:09:701 (5) - This should start at 01:09:539

Hope this mod was helpful. Good luck
Topic Starter
yuruyuri_old_1

Yuthuil wrote:

General: Untick Widescreen Support and Letterbox during breaks. You need to hitsound the map in order to rank it.The gap in difficulty between normal and hard is too big, either make normal harder, hard easier, or make a new diff. Offset is wrong, you'll have to retime that. Preview point is unsnapped. Add Kiai somewhere?

Normal: I don't think the SV fits a normal diff :/

00:00:944 (2) - Such harsh shapes are not really popular in Osu.
00:00:944 (2,1) - Overlaps - they are unsightly as well as hard to read for beginners.
00:03:539 (2,1) - ^
00:07:836 (1) - You can't have the spinner so close to the slider in a Normal diff.
00:11:647 (1) - More than 1 repeat in Normal is not advised.
00:15:863 (2) - ^
00:51:863 (6,1) - I think you should delete 6 and move 1 to it's former position.

Hard:

00:01:431 (7) - NC? (New Combo)
00:02:404 (1) - I don't think you should let the reverse part do the job of such a heavy beat, you should make it something clickable.
00:04:025 (7) - NC
00:04:512 (1,2) - Blanket properly.
00:05:323 (3) - NC
00:14:242 (1,4,5) - Not a nice overlap
00:19:998 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Streams at such BPM are not recommended in hard.
01:14:890 (2,4) - Stack properly.

Overall: Mapset could use a little bit of work, but good luck!
thx! many things going to change!
Topic Starter
yuruyuri_old_1

Hi Im Nathan wrote:

Hi from my M4M queue

Hard


00:01:431 (1) - NC here
00:05:971 (7) - ^
00:12:944 (4) - This slider isnt really pleasing to the eye because of the positioning of your points. I think you should keep it as simple as possible here. Something like this
00:23:809 (8,9,10,11,12) - This is extremely hard to read. Maybe rework it and change the triplet to a reverse slider?
00:25:917 (1) - This breaks up the flow. I think it would be better to make this into a slider
00:41:161 (5) - Re-position it so it doesnt overlap with 00:40:998 (4)
00:46:350 (1,1,2,3,4,5) - You went from following the flute-like instrument to the bass midway through the slider. It makes it very hard to follow by ear. I think you should change up the rhythm of your notes in this section
00:48:944 (1) - If this slider is suppose to be following the bass then it should start at 00:48:782
00:49:593 - Add a note here
00:53:971 (2,3) - Swap the position of these 2 on the timeline, so that the slider starts at 00:53:971 and move the circle to 00:54:620
00:58:188 (4,5,6) - Fix the stack
01:04:836 (8,9,10,11,12) - Same as my comment from 00:23:809
01:15:215 (4) - Move this slider so it doesnt overlap any of the other notes

Normal

Overall I think you should rework some of your sliders. I
know some people like edgy sliders but when they start to overlap with others it looks less pretty
00:07:836 (1) - This should finish at 00:09:052
00:12:944 (3) - This would look alot better if it was made more simpler.
00:15:863 (2) - ^
00:16:836 (1) - Make this slider finish at 00:17:809
00:18:458 (2) - Make this slider start at 00:18:133 and finish at 00:19:106
I think the next section would have much better flow if you did this
  • 00:22:025 (2) - Make this slider finish at 00:22:512
    00:22:998 (4) - Move this slider to 00:23:161 and finish at 00:23:647
    Then add a note at 00:22:836 and 00:22:998
00:42:133 (2) - How about moving this to (96x , 184y)
00:46:350 (2) - Move the slider to 00:46:674 and finish at 00:46:998. Then add a circle at 00:46:350
00:55:755 (3) - Make this the same shape as 00:55:106 (2)
00:58:350 (3) - ^
01:09:701 (5) - This should start at 01:09:539

Hope this mod was helpful. Good luck
thx! it is detail and helpful!
Topic Starter
yuruyuri_old_1
The map will have a large fix~but i am going to exam :( so...it will update later ;)

I have fix something by both of your modding,however i will reply later since i am preparing exam

i already modded for Yuthuil, before i going to deal with the exam, i will mod for Hi Im Nathan ;)
Topic Starter
yuruyuri_old_1

Yuthuil wrote:

General: Untick Widescreen Support fix and Letterbox during breaks fix . You need to hitsound fix the map in order to rank it.The gap in difficulty between normal and hard is too big, either make normal harder, hard easier fix , or make a new diff. Offset is wrong fix , you'll have to retime that. Preview point is unsnapped fix . Add Kiai somewhere? song too short hard to add Kiai

Normal: I don't think the SV fits a normal diff :/ @@

00:00:944 (2) - Such harsh shapes are not really popular in Osu. fix
00:00:944 (2,1) - Overlaps - they are unsightly as well as hard to read for beginners. fix
00:03:539 (2,1) - ^ fix
00:07:836 (1) - You can't have the spinner so close to the slider in a Normal diff. fix
00:11:647 (1) - More than 1 repeat in Normal is not advised. fix
00:15:863 (2) - ^ fix
00:51:863 (6,1) - I think you should delete 6 and move 1 to it's former position. pattern change

Hard:

00:01:431 (7) - NC? (New Combo) pattern change
00:02:404 (1) - I don't think you should let the reverse part do the job of such a heavy beat, you should make it something clickable. no change, big impact to the pattern
00:04:025 (7) - NC pattern change
00:04:512 (1,2) - Blanket properly. pattern change
00:05:323 (3) - NC pattern change
00:14:242 (1,4,5) - Not a nice overlap pattern change
00:19:998 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Streams at such BPM are not recommended in hard. pattern change
01:14:890 (2,4) - Stack properly. fix

Overall: Mapset could use a little bit of work, but good luck!
Thank you!
Topic Starter
yuruyuri_old_1

Hi Im Nathan wrote:

Hi from my M4M queue

Hard


00:01:431 (1) - NC here pattern change
00:05:971 (7) - ^ pattern change
00:12:944 (4) - This slider isnt really pleasing to the eye because of the positioning of your points. I think you should keep it as simple as possible here. Something like this
pattern change
00:23:809 (8,9,10,11,12) - This is extremely hard to read. Maybe rework it and change the triplet to a reverse slider? pattern change
00:25:917 (1) - This breaks up the flow. I think it would be better to make this into a slider fix
00:41:161 (5) - Re-position it so it doesnt overlap with 00:40:998 (4) pattern change
00:46:350 (1,1,2,3,4,5) - You went from following the flute-like instrument to the bass midway through the slider. It makes it very hard to follow by ear. I think you should change up the rhythm of your notes in this section pattern change
00:48:944 (1) - If this slider is suppose to be following the bass then it should start at 00:48:782 fix
00:49:593 - Add a note here pattern change
00:53:971 (2,3) - Swap the position of these 2 on the timeline, so that the slider starts at 00:53:971 and move the circle to 00:54:620 pattern change
00:58:188 (4,5,6) - Fix the stack fix
01:04:836 (8,9,10,11,12) - Same as my comment from 00:23:809 pattern change
01:15:215 (4) - Move this slider so it doesnt overlap any of the other notes fix

Normal

Overall I think you should rework some of your sliders fix. I
know some people like edgy sliders but when they start to overlap with others it looks less pretty
00:07:836 (1) - This should finish at 00:09:052 fix
00:12:944 (3) - This would look alot better if it was made more simpler. fix
00:15:863 (2) - ^ fix
00:16:836 (1) - Make this slider finish at 00:17:809 no change, pattern change
00:18:458 (2) - Make this slider start at 00:18:133 and finish at 00:19:106 pattern change
I think the next section would have much better flow if you did this
  • 00:22:025 (2) - Make this slider finish at 00:22:512 pattern change
    00:22:998 (4) - Move this slider to 00:23:161 and finish at 00:23:647 pattern change
    Then add a note at 00:22:836 and 00:22:998
pattern change
00:42:133 (2) - How about moving this to (96x , 184y) pattern change
00:46:350 (2) - Move the slider to 00:46:674 and finish at 00:46:998. Then add a circle at 00:46:350 pattern change
00:55:755 (3) - Make this the same shape as 00:55:106 (2) pattern change
00:58:350 (3) - ^ pattern change
01:09:701 (5) - This should start at 01:09:539 pattern change

Hope this mod was helpful. Good luck
Thank you!
Setsurei

sorry for the wait
[General]
tags: remove "Set Fire to Villages"
tags doesn't need to repeat the title, as it is on title, you can search it without putting it on the tags

and are you sure there's no clear information about this song?
where do you find this song? or where does this song originated from? put it on source

BPM on the end is not exact.
change BPM to 184.971, offset remains 134
don't forget to snap everything
** take note that I'll use this BPM on copy pasting the correct timing for the mod
[Normal]
00:00:134 (1,3) - overlapping, you should avoid this kind of placements
00:09:540 (1) - overlap to itself
00:11:649 (2,4) - avoid this stack, I suggest when using repeat sliders like 00:12:460 (3) - , is to make something clear as path, something like this (you can ignore the placement I set here, since this is only an example. just elaborate it yourself)
00:16:190 (4,5) - overlap
00:24:624 - strong beat here, add slider up to 00:25:273 -
00:25:921 (6,7) - slider stack on end like this might confuse people, undo the stack
00:28:192 (8,9) - anti flow is for a higher diff
00:33:544 (3,4) - overlap, repeat sliders can be maneuvered to other direction so it will not overlap
00:59:332 (6,2,4) - overlap
01:05:333 (5,1) - ^
01:15:389 (1) - imo this is no need, delete
[Hard]
00:01:431 (4,6,7) - stack properly
00:04:999 (2,4) - overlap
00:12:946 (3,1,2,3) - overlap, if you want to stack them, stack properly
00:15:704 (2,3) - stack properly
00:23:164 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - a multiple hitcircle sets will be hard to be hitted if you place them curving like this, do a zig zag
00:25:921 (2,1) - overlap
00:29:571 (1) - shift to 00:29:652 - , and ends still at
00:34:355 (6,7) - stack properly
00:40:194 (1,5) - overlap
00:41:654 (6,7,8) - ^
00:45:384 (1,2,3) - stack properly
00:54:953 (5,8) - overlap
00:57:224 (2,4,5,6) - stack properly
00:58:845 (7,1) - ^
01:02:089 (7,1) - overlap
01:03:549 (2) - shift to 01:03:711 - because of strong beat
01:05:414 (12) - why a sudden blue tick? shift it to 01:05:333 -

still need more improvements
good luck
Bara-


[General]
Remove Set Fire to Villages from tags, as it's already in title
Are you sure there is no artist? Ask a few masters in metadata for confirmation
If it's from a game, look at the credits of that game

[Normal]
00:00:134 (1,3) - These two sliders are overlapping, which looks ugly. As the flow between (1) and (2) can be improved, I recommend you to redo this part
I recommend. Place (1) somewhere under (3), Ctrl G (2) and keep (3)
00:03:539 (3,3) - These 2 sliders are also overlapping, but it's barely noticable. so it can stay (there is also no real way to fix this unless you do other changes, which would ruin the Original flow of the map
00:09:052 - It's recommended to have a circle here, as there is a strong sound here. Remember that you need to have even spacing, so put it in a space where the distance with the next note is 1.00
00:16:188 (4,5) - Bad overlap, but it also has a lowered distance which is not allowed. A newbie would think it's faster (for me it seems like 1/2 when I first saw it. Please increase the distance, and change the shape of (5) to something so it wil not overlap with (4) anymore
00:19:106 (8) - This slider looks pretty ugly, because it's so curvy, make it less curvy, and thus make it longer (so the head and tail wouldn't overlap that much)
00:24:620 - there is a strongbeat here, so I recommend you to add a circle here, or even better, a slider
00:27:215 (7) - Stacking isn't really nice here, imcrease the distance between this one and (6). Also, give this a NC, because the combo is quite long
00:28:188 (8,9) - This looks ugly, as the notes are badly overlapping each other. Move (9) to the right of (8) to make it looks better, it'll also increase the flow
00:45:377 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - Redo this part. A map must have a consistent DS (spacing) in the diff. This part suddenly moves to 0.6 which is REALLY confusing, make it all 1.0 distance and move objects further apart
00:51:052 (9,10,11) - Stacks... Please... Don't... Just Redo
01:02:079 (5,1) - Slight overlap, move (1) a little to the right
01:05:323 (5,1) - A bigger overlap, move (1) away so they don''t overlap (but keep the spacing consistent)
01:15:377 (1) - Delete, and extend the spinner to the end (this note feels weird and awkward, as there is no strong sound

[Hard]
00:02:242 (6,7) - Move both to 304:303 to improve the stack
00:04:998 (2,4) - Overlap, move (4) to the right to improve it
00:05:647 (4,8) - What the heck, this looks ugly and confusing, start (8) at 367:194, andmove the red point to 356:268 to improve the looks
00:13:755 (1,2,3) - Move to 220:88 to improve the stack
00:15:701 (2,3) - This looks ugly, I suggest you to redo this, and add some curves to the sliders. The circle on the sliderhead also feels really weird
00:18:944 (4,5,6) - These jumps are too fast for just a hard difficulty. They are probably even too fast for an insane, an they make no sense. Give them normal spacing
00:23:809 (8,9,10,11) - This should be at a 1/3 divisor instead of 1/4. Set the divisor to 1/3 and resnap these notes (and give proper spacing)
00:27:215 (1,2,3) - Flows bad, ctrl H, and move to the current position for a better flow. It also helps, because there is a bad overlap
00:40:188 (1,5) - These sliders overlap a little ugly, move (1) more to the right, but keep distance the same
00:46:188 (2,3) - Move to 496:60 to improve blanket
01:02:079 (7,1) - Bad overlap, move (1) closer to (8) (on the right) as the distance is also quite high
01:04:674 (7,8,9,10,11) - Like the previous part, here it's 1/3 as well, no 1/4. Change it like in the previous part
01:15:701 - It feels like there is a sound here, try adding a circle, as it feels better to me

Good luck!
rhalp10

Sorry My Queue For STDHas Been Closed I Can't Handle That Mode Anymore .. :(
Please sign in to reply.

New reply