1. llkey's Carousel (3.72 stars, 207 notes)
2. Relaxing (1.8 stars, 139 notes)
3. Speeding (4.49 stars, 206 notes)

Kurai_ wrote:

Hi

[Relaxing]
01:23:506 (1) - New combo

[llkey]
00:07:306 (x) - Add note ?
00:46:306 (5) - Remove and put 00:46:606 (1) 1/2 earlier and extand by 1/1

[Speeding]
Nice

Good Job‼ You get my star ^o^

Garven wrote:

Modding as per request:

[Skin]
It's hard to see the notes. Transparent circles on a bright background. :/
You need a hit0.png
The bg looks really low quality compared to the polish of the skin. It's due to the 400x300 resolution. Find at least a 800x600 one, considering you found a 1024x768 one for your fail image...
I have looked for this photo for 3 days! I searched hundreds photos in filcker, google, picasa etc, I found this place call "brighton pier", but i still can't find this photo!..

[Relaxing]
Sooo slooooow, hehe.
The only thing I see with this diff is that the notes after the spinners feel a little too soon.

[Carousel]
In general, a lot of your sliders need work. They all look lop-sided and not very appealing to the eyes. They kind of work in some spots, but for the most part, they just look bad. Try touching them up a bit.
00:01:906 (5) - Remove whistle from sliderslide. Also, why so many anchor points for a simple slider?
00:06:106 (3) - This could look a lot better. Try doing something like this with a lot of your stand-a-lone sliders.
02:07:906 (1) - Remove the finish from this. If anything, it should have a silenced finish. :/

[Speeding]
00:01:906 (3) - Remove whistle from sliderslide.
This is a nice difficulty. It plays really nice. Not quite the "speeding" I was expecting, though.
I think it can be called 'speeding' as a 'carousel'

A nice basic set of maps. Carousel just needs some good polishing up on the sliders, really. Everything else is fine.

RandomJibberish wrote:

General
I don't really like the yellow star2.png. Make it pink to fit better?

Relaxing
01:09:106 (3) - Point downward for readability?
01:49:906 (3) - ^

llkey's Carousel
00:34:306 (5,6,7) - Shorten these jumps a little, and move 5 closer to 4
02:04:906 (5) - Add a beat where this starts, move forward half a beat and shorten so it ends where it did before. I presonally don't like the slowdown but meh
02:07:906 (1) - End a beat earlier?

Speeding
00:16:606 (4,5,2) - I don't like this overlap
00:24:706 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3) - AH THE WHISTLES

Great map.

Frill wrote:

These are suggestions, you don't have to change anything.


[Relaxing]

00:49:306 (2,4) - remove finish?
00:51:106 (1) - maybe add finish
01:31:906 (1) - umm.. add finish? but suggetions.

[llkey's Carousell]

00:04:306 (5) - Perhaps, add whistle in start and end
00:25:306 (5) - remove whistle?
00:27:106 (3) - add whistle

[Speeding]

00:08:506 (3) - add whistle
00:51:106 (1) - same relaxing
01:10:306 (4) - hmm.. this is to make it beautifull vertically?
01:43:906 (2) - add whistle in start and slider?

Good

Mafiamaster wrote:

[General]
Change the lead-in time to 2 seconds instead of 1. This should give people a little more time to get ready (just in case).
Remove countdown on all difficulties.
comboburst-0,comboburst-2,comboburst-3 all exceed the max width of pixels. Max width being 500 so please reduce!

[_likey]
00:57:406 (5,6) - Move exactly under the endpoint of 4.

osuplayer111 wrote:

Heart fixed.