1. Futsuu (3.54 stars, 195 notes)
2. Kantan (1.43 stars, 140 notes)
3. Muzukashii (4.8 stars, 279 notes)
4. Oni (4.98 stars, 358 notes)

Colin Hou wrote:

just let the source be 'Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood' and remove it from the tags. Changed

[Futsuu]'s slider velocity is a bit high, turn it down if possible, others are fine. ;_;. I wanna keep velocity then :3...

so have a kudosu star~

DJPop wrote:

~Kantan~
Fine.

~Futsuu~
00:19:844 (3,4,5,6,7) - make them more symmetry

~Muzukashii~
00:21:058 (7) - unsnapped
01:07:564 - remove break time

~Oni~
00:21:058 (5) - unsnapped, end on the center


+Star

lepidopodus wrote:

maybe modding practice? lol anyway

Kantan
00:51:231 (2) - one grid up Yes
00:58:564 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Maybe this part is a bit hard for very beginners, but it's just my opinion. Umm... I don't think so ;_;

Futsuu
Well a bit high SV for normal, but this is taikosu, so I'll just pass.

Muzukashii
OD=8, maybe a big high for taiko muz & osu standard hard? (Well I'm not good at standard so I don't know about that, but taiko muz, OD=8 seems quite high) Reduced to 8
00:52:397 (7) - one grid right & one grid up? Yes
01:23:897 (5) - one grid right? Yes

Oni
I think OD=8 is kinda high for Oni., but whatever, it's ONI!!
Couldn't find any unauthentic issue with Oni

Star~

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Kantan:
Combo mod:
01:17:230 (6) - new combo to make 2 combos that are 8 whole notes long like the previous few combos
01:21:897 (5,6) - put a new combo on one of these notes (5 for lyrics or 6 for 8 whole notes)

Futsuu:
Normal mod:
slider speed seems a little fast in comparison to the spacing
01:30:230 (3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - you might want to lower stack leniency to make these straight lines

Combo mod:
00:04:584 (4) - new combo for new line of lyrics
00:34:564 (5) - new combo to make 2 combos of 8 whole notes long

Muzukashii:
Normal mod:
01:44:564 (7,8) - these are the only sliders and notes in the song that are stacked under the end of a slider in the whole song, so they look strange. As a result, I advise changing the pattern here

Combo mod:
01:06:564 (7) - new combo for 8 whole notes?
01:17:230 (6) - ^

Timing section mod:
01:29:230 - a quarter note before this timing section add a inherited timing section with the same hitsound settings, but with kiai

Oni:
Timing section mod:
01:29:230 - a quarter note before this timing section add a inherited timing section with the same hitsound settings, but with kiai

======================
Nice map. Star.

Shinxyn wrote:

This is authentic, right..? so I won't check hitsounds and note placement
Should whichever taiko game this came from be added to tags..? (maybe even in source instead of tag... the anime did come first, but this version is from a game... ) Umm... I cut this song from Original J-POP file, not cover vocal
I think the first offset... -12? (1798) Yes

Kantan-
Maybe make circle size larger? (or does that effect taiko, I really don't know) Size +2
00:01:810 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - totally against stacking theses so early in the song for the easiest diff Changed
@.@

Futsuu-
01:47:564 (4,5) - this is a part of the authentic-ness right? could you make this a 1/2 slider... the notes before this are all 1/1, so this ending felt trap like xD Changed

Muzukashii-
don't like 0.4 spacing! makes some parts seem a bit hard to read cuz they're all relatively close together D: Respaced as x0.65~0.66
Refrained from asking for note timing changes.. D;

Oni-
00:37:064 (10) - nazi- left a grid, unless you're trying to have this under (5)'s end, then center 9 a bit without grid snap? Changed
00:47:230 (9,10) - don't like this, 1/4 slider + note @ 180bpm x.x same goes for all the other parts like this D: ;_; I think ddk and kkd seem good with these pattern on [Oni] or harder diffs
01:05:064 (4,6) - maybe new combo both of theses? makes the jump a bit easier to read.. sorta Fixed
Could use more new combos here and there, no big deal x-x; Umm... followed as blissfulyoshi's suggestion so... ;_;
How come theres only one major section with jumps D: hardest part of map >_< So, song name is Uso = Lie lol

Go Go!

1. The fast slider velocity doesn't match the distance snap used...

Gens wrote:

Why doesn't [Kantan] have the preferred skin set to Taiko? Fixed orz

[Kantan]

01:21:897 (1) - This single combo stood out for me... any special reason for it? Umm? Nothing, so offed New Combo

[Futsuu]

1. The fast slider velocity doesn't match the distance snap used...

Umm... Slider velocity considers Taiko speed ;_;

[Muzukashii]

01:47:564 (1) - New combo...? No due to spacing change

Well yeah, the new combos are of no importance. Fix the preferred skin thing though!

lepidopodus wrote:

Bubbled and sending to the graveyard? No, I'll gonna stop this XD
(last updated in May 29th, seems not bumped, hmm....)

EDIT: Maybe I screwed up this XD

ztrot wrote:

Ranked! Very nice! I like this song alot, not bad on making this work for both modes :p