banvi wrote:

I love ONE PIECE!!!!!
It's great!
Especially, I like this opening song!

I think, add (TV Size) in title name.
So title name is "We Are (TV Size)" ?
If you change this, delete "TV Size" in Tags?

You've done all this , I'll come to see again.

Mianki wrote:

saymun's Normal:

Suggestion: 01:21265 (3) Make this slider 2 ticks shorter (as short as the two previous) and put spinner to 01:21:622 and lenghten it nah, doesn't sound too good

Gladi's Normal+

Suggestion: put notes on these points, 00:33:411, 00:34:124 i'm guessing Gladi was following vocals, so no

Hard+:

Suggestion: 00:34:323 (1) remove this circle, 'cause if you're following the lyrics, there's nothing there it's not ALL lyrics
Suggestion: 01:20:908 (4.5) remove these circles and replace them with a slider why? :/
01:47:681 (5) this circle seems almost too much out of the screen to me, wanna move it under the slider or something? You can keep it as it 'cause it's not out of the screen so i'll leave it ._.

Anywas, nice map ^^
Star~

Kabi wrote:

get a better quality of the video, and maybe it was me but a few notes seemd a bit out of timing

hime_nikki04 wrote:

~ Star

Easy:
Add a note on 00:34:501. disagree
Add a note on 01:02:715. disagree again
Add a note on 01:39:827. spin recovery will be too short imo
Retract the slider at 01:41:969 a bit... it didn't sound right. ...what do you mean?

MarioBros777 wrote:

Write it on my record book and I still forget. Told you I would. i pm'd you as well :/

[Easy]
You know how to bore someone really well. thanks

[saymun's Normal]
01:21:97 (1) - I don't like how short that spinner is for a Normal. not that short...

[Gladi's Normal+]
Just call this a Hard. Geez. what no it was originally meant to be Normal

[aru's Taiko]
01:30:72 (2) - I didn't like this note here. Move it 1/4 forward? sure

[Insane]
Fine. Surprisingly. thank you

It's alright.

Shulin wrote:

General

-- What is onepiece11 skin? If the skin is important you should include it with the map? (And I got default skin elements but no onepiece skin =S) made it optional, because it was an in progress skin, so just letting people know about it is fine.
-- Delete .osb and full submit. done a while ago
-- Do you have an mp3 that doesn't suddenly cut off? (and without sound effects) nope, they're all like that (with the cutting off), cause that's what they did in the anime as well, i guess

saymun's Normal

01:21:259 (3) - Extend to 01:21:795 imo. imo, no D:

Gladi's Normal+

01:17:152 (x) - Note. eh, okay, unless Gladi slaps me.

aru's Taiko

Fun taiko diff, but the spinner looks out of place here. Maybe force taiko skin for this diff. isn't that option already optional in options?

Insane

Fun difficulty, but those normal whistles are irritating (to me). Maybe reduce the overall volume or use less whistle, I think it will sound better that way. sure, but could you possibly tell me by how much i should? because i've adjusted my audio settings in options with music at max and effects at 60% ish.

Nice maps, except the parts where I could hear more whistle than song. Star!

arien666 wrote:

[General]
Delete tag 'arken1015' :3 ok
Add tag 'GladiOol' :3? ok

[Easy]
01:10:723 - Delete this break? nah
01:25:187 - ^ nah

[saymun's Normal]
00:57:330 (5) - [Suggestion] http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/85025 :3? i prefer how it is now
01:10:902 - Delete this break keeping it

[Gladi's Normal+]
[Suggestion] Tick Rate = 1 :3? nah

[Hard]
00:43:759 (4) - Consider moving this note since different timing stacking on [Hard] orz i think it's fine
01:09:830 (3) - [Nazi] How about move 1 grid left? ok
01:35:545 (2,3) - [Nazi Suggestion] How about move 4 grid down for making the distance same :3? ok



Some old-mapping-style but whatever :3
2 more other modding for this and I'll re-check for bubbling :3

Gonzvlo wrote:

[General]

1. Tags: "1" is too generic, you should remove it. (y)
2. Folder seems clean~

[Easy]

1. 01:09:116 (1,2) - This part of the song returns to the soft voice so you should use the soft override again for these objects. i gave it a shot but i think it sounds better the way it is now~
2. 01:25:009 - This break is too short IMO, plus it's completely unnecessary, nobody is going to lose during this 2 secs.

maybe, but otherwise it feels really empty here. i only leave no breaks here if there's nothing going on with the music kinda thing

[saymun's Normal]

1. 00:36:437 (1,2,3,4,5) - This combo is more than 4 stanzas long, I suggest to use New Combo on (4) omg it was originally meant to be like that but then i lost the file so i had to redownload from the thread >.<
2. 01:01:973 (4) - That last repeat was a bit unexpected. I suggest to split slider, perhaps something like this i think it's fine ^.^
3. 01:10:723 - This break is too short and completely unnecessary, remove it please. nooo
4. 01:15:545 (2,3) - These copy-pasted kick sliders are not following the rhythm correctly. I suggest to use a single slider instead, sounds way better. could i please have the .osu code for this?
5. 01:19:473 (4,5) - Same here, those sliders are not following any noticeable rhythm, try this instead.

i think this is fine this time~

[Gladi's Normal+]

1. "Normal +" looks awful, this diff seems like an "easy [Hard]" so I suggest to rename it to [Hard]. okay
2. It would be great if you add that last kiai to keep the consistency with the other diffs. okay then
3. 01:10:723 (1) - This spinner seems longer than it should, you should make this spinner end here: 01:11:973 - then add some objects in the empty space. o/~
4. 01:49:116 (3) - Use New Combo here to re-mark the slider speed change. (The inherited at the end of the slider is not snapped correctly.) okay

[Hard]

1. The slider speed used in this diff plus the high AR makes this diff look like an [Insane] so consider re-naming it. yep okay
2. Perhaps OD +1? >:D
3. 00:43:759 (4) - I suggest to remove this circle to keep the consistency with all the other diffs. i'd agree with you but playing this diff. without that makes it feel empty
4. 01:15:009 (2,3) - These 2 circles feel kinda "extra", I see that you're mostly following the vocals but these 2 objects are not following the vocals or any other noticeable rhythm. I suggest to remove them. (If you don't want to remove both, removing (2) should be enough. (3) sounds OK with the "clap") too empty :/
5. 01:50:187 (1,2) - I kinda expected a little jump for these last circles, consider increasing spacing a bit. good idea

The map doesn't have major problems, it looks great.

kanpakyin wrote:

M4M here

[General]
Please snap the green line when the kiai start and end. ok done

[Easy]

1. 00:40:545(x)-IMO..You should remove whistle here. nah
2. 01:10:902(x)-Remove this break or add a spinner here?No need to add break there when the last part has heavier HP rape. nah
3. 01:25:187(x)-^ Same. nah
4. 01:27:687(x)-Please snap this green line properly due to kiai started. yeah done already
5. 01:39:116(x)-This also snap it properly please. ^
6. 01:40:187(x)-Add a note here? no
7. 01:47:687(x)-IMO,This part is not appropriate to add a kiai time.

i disagree

[saymun's Normal]

1. 01:10:723(x)-Remove this break or add a spinner here?No need to add break there when the last part has heavier HP rape. ~
2. 01:16:616(3)-Remove whistle from this whole slider? nah
3. 01:21:973(x)-IMO.This spinner is too short for Normal you know what? me too
4. 01:30:545(3)-lol The rhythm is obvious 3/4 place...

uh...
Cool!

[Gladi's Hard]

1. 01:16:080(x)-Follow the vocal here?so please add a note here.

i think it's fine
Good.

[Insane]

1. 00:43:759(4)- unstack it? noo
2. 01:00:634(x)-Add a note here to make a 2-2plet pattern. but i don't want it like that
3. 01:19:830(1.2.3)-It's quite hard to read.Some people will misunderstand to 1/2 rhythm. it's following distance spacing, so it should be fine
4. 01:26:527(3)-Add a finish here?

yeah ok

Well fairness map..Insane is easy to play too <3 because old map is old D:

Gens wrote:

I'm a One Piece otaku...

...well no, I wouldn't call myself an otaku...

...maybe just a follower, not even a fan...

...well anyway this song is retarded (I mean the lyrics) but I kinda got hooked to it, damn you repetition. Let's get this show on the road...

[General]

1. Not moving the metronome all the way back to 1973ms? Or did I miss something while reading the thread? i have no idea what i was thinking back when i made this, but sure okay.
2. Obligatory 'it would be better if you remove the audio track from the video' suggestion. Pretty sure it isn't a silly mistake this time~ b-but the video has no audio... maybe if i full submit @.@
3. Very whistle happy I see. ^.^

[Gladi's Hard]

1. I'd increase the AR a wee bit to safely call this a Hard. good pooting idea

01:05:366 (7) - Hidden repeat arrow, oh no. Consider making this clearer. hmm i think it's fine, considering that it still follows with distance spacing to the (1), so...

I'll pop it to keep things tidy for now, and I'll bubble ASAP when you decide what to do.

Gens wrote:

Okay I'm just being silly with the video again sorry for making you full submit I am an idiot and I need to be slapped several times you're welcome to do so if you want to. we all make mistakes, and i've made worse. dw about it (:

About the hidden repeat arrow... it certainly it a tough call, since even if you moved it elsewhere the arrow still takes you by surprise. What I would do would be transform the slider to a 1/1 slider (1 beat of length) and add a note 1/2 after, to keep the spacing somewhat equal. Something like this, if you're not getting my drift. It does follow the music better and all. since it's really pointless to argue over this, i'm just going to go with this and hope Gladi doesn't kill.

Anyway, working under the "hidden stuff is unrankable" principle, I cannot let it pass just like that; you gotta move it somewhere else at least~

Oh and Insane's offset hasn't been changed, apparently. fdsaf