1. Believe (3,31 stars, 268 notes)
2. Easy (1,26 stars, 64 notes)
3. Hard (2,82 stars, 226 notes)
4. Normal (1,51 stars, 104 notes)

Firewest wrote:

Warning (unrankeable): mp3 bitrate is higher than 192kbpsm, please, change it
BPM offset will change too, so resnap all diffs

Firewest wrote:

[Normal]

00:24:670 (2) - remove back arrowRemove
00:25:162 - add circle maybe Not Added

[Believe]

00:37:457 (6) - move to x:256 y:304Fixed
00:37:703 (1) - move to x:360 y:272Fixed
01:18:031 (5) - move to x:296 y:224Fixed
01:17:785 (4) - move to x:344 y:48Fixed
01:18:276 (6) - move to x:168 y:88Fixed
01:24:424 (7) - move to x:124 y:40Fixed
01:24:670 (8) - move to x:56 y:192Fixed
01:27:621 (3) - move to x:264 y:144Fixed
01:28:358 (6) - move to x:312 y:224Fixed
01:28:604 (7) - move to x:160 y:336Fixed
01:28:850 (8) - move to x:108 y:240Fixed
I recommend you use grid snap: Small for a better symmetry (ctrl+2) I'll think about it :3
change od to 7 Change

good luck (don't fonget the kds)

naoe dami wrote:

from #Modreqs
[General]
Tags : absolute duo ending Believe×Believe 山本 希望
and also you compress the video so the total size of map not more than 24MB I'll try to do something about it
[Easy]
Actually this diff doesn't need too many objects, just make long sliders. imo. Just reduce that, that's too hard for begginer's player I made sure to make it easy much simpler
[Normal]
00:10:162 (1) - blanket Fixed
00:28:850 (3) - keep the spacing Fixed
00:56:637 (1,2) - make it into slider 2/1 Ok
01:00:080 (2) - blanket Fixed

sorry if my mod doesn't help you >< Np :3

[ Madoka ] wrote:

CAME FROM MODREQUEST. never thought i'd do this..

Video file format should only either be flv or avi, not mpg, mp4, etc. i tried downloading the no video option, it gave me the video too, so you better change the format of the vid lol, it's unrankable, and i'll just mod Believe, because that's what I'm good at, I believe. ha
I know I will change this as soon as possible

Believe

00:09:178 (3) - fix this blanket. Fixed
00:10:162 (1) - make this that it has one flow with the previous slider because right now, it looks like you copy pasted it, and the triple before the slider can be placed better. u can move it to x324,y152 and rotate by 18 degrees. play around with it :> make sure you change the placements for the rest of the objects followed by the slider Like this ?
00:12:129 (1) - fix this blanket Fixed
00:29:834 (1) - make this a blanket Ok
00:29:834 (1) - add whistle to the head Ok
00:50:981 (7) - remove whistle from head Ok
00:52:457 (3) - add whistle Ok
01:12:744 (7) - why is this 1/12? remove it, put a circle, then a 1/8 repeat slider plays, and sounds better.. there's nothing from the song that sounds 1/12. example: http://puu.sh/f84qv.png 1/12 What O_O i'm so bad >.< Fixed
01:27:375 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - this can be made better... as in, tidier. :3Ok

Overall, I think this needs a little bit more work. I found the hitsounds very faint. There should be a constant normal-hitnormal and normal-hitclap hitsound through out most of the map, and of course, with custom hitsounds....
I'm pretty bad in regard to the Hitsound but I'll try to improve this

The placements could be done tidier too imo :3

Good luck and hope it helps!

My english sucks

chomelisgod wrote:

Hey there, heres my list of modifications:
Easy:
No problems regarding this map that have not been covered already

Normal:
00:56:637 - I halved the length of this slider to match the lyrics more accurately. Making it start halfway of its original length. It also gives a little more reaction time after the spinner. Fixed
01:25:654 - Personally I don't particularly like the slider placed here. Although its still in rhythm it still kinda puts me off, but theres no harm in keeping it. No Change

Hard:
00:31:801 - This slider has a unique shape, whilst most of the other sliders surrounding it are all straight or slightly bent. I would make the shape more original for consistency ( like a long bend or line). Fixed

Believe:
01:12:867 - This slider repeat is a little unnecessary I prefer to leave if the other person says the same thing as you, I would remove this slider :3

I tried not to repeat what other people are already saying, but overall the placement and structure is smooth and relatively easy to play. I've noticed that the start of your combos start with a finish hitsound, but it is very faint. I can hardly differentiate it from the claps. You should work on those and choose a different hitsound or turn up hitsound volume.
Hope I helped a little. Good luck I try with other Hitsound but I can not do something good (I need help for this >.<)

SoGa wrote:

[General]

1. Delete アブソリュート・デュオ in tags since u already have it in source
2. Delete Believe×Believe in tags,the reason is same as above ^
3. Delete 山本 希望 in tags , ^
4. The Blue combo colors , i would change it to

   Combo3 : 0,153,77

   instead All Fixed

[Easy]

1. 00:11:637 (2) - Fix this one ,the whole map ds is 1.0 and this one turn to 0.8 ,fix it for consistency Fixed
2. 00:11:637 (2,2) - Actually i dont recommend this kind of overlap ovo Fixed
3. 00:16:063 (1,2,1) - not recommend to put it like this way , i think it is a little bit hard for newby to react and read Fixed
4. 00:21:965 (1,2,3) - I think this kind of rhythm is a little bit hard for newb to read lol , just delete the note ,don't be so meanie with an Easy diff.And also the ds u have to fix it Fixed
5. 00:23:932 (1,2) - why sudden jump , too heavy Fixed
6. 00:25:899 (3,4) - just fix this kind of DS Fixed
7. i would like to move this one a little bit up 00:26:883 (4) - and then stack this group 00:25:899 (3,1) - Ok
8. 00:33:768 (4,5) - Fix the blanket Fixed
9. 00:38:686 (3,4) - Just change this into a note is ok Fixed
10. 00:48:522 (2,3) - Fix the ds for consistency Fixed
11. 00:52:457 (2,1) - ^ Fixed
12. 00:55:408 (1,1) - I think this is UNRANKABLE due to the rule issue , a note after a spinner should left 4 gaps of white ticks in an Easy diff ,fix it pls Fixed (Im so bad >.<)
13. 01:11:145 (1,1) - ^ Fixed
14. 00:57:375 (1) - Delete clap and change Finish instead Ok
15. 01:04:260 (2,3) - Fix DS for consistency Fixed
16. 01:13:113 (1) - Whistle on Slider-tail Ok
17. 01:19:014 (1) - NC , since u r putting NC every 2 groups Fixed
18. 01:26:883 (1,2) - Swap Nc,Actually i prefer to change a Spinner here for the end. Spinner add

[Normal]

1. 00:10:899 (2,3,4,5) - Spread it out pls I add a reverse slider has the square
2. 00:18:031 (3) - NC Fixed
3. 00:24:670 (2,3,4) - i would like to change this one to a 1/1 slider , i think this way fir the song better example Fixed
4. 00:46:801 (2,3,2,3) - Maybe try to stack this group Ok
5. 00:54:424 (1) - NC Fixed
6. 00:55:408 (1,1) - This is the same as i mentioned in the Easy diff , Unrankable stuff tho , in Normal has to left 2 gaps of white ticks .example : Fixed
7. I rather not map this part 00:56:637 - 00:57:129 , i will not map this part tho ,then it fits the song better and resolve the question above ^I did not understand everything, but it should be fine... Maybe
8. 00:57:375 (1) -
9. 01:20:981 (1,1) - i think this is also consider as Unrankable stuff , u gotta ask someone else idk I add a slider instead
10. 01:24:670 (1,1) - what with this NC ,fix it Fixed x)

[Hard]

1. 00:13:973 (5) - Delete this note Ok
2. 00:14:588 (2) - ^ Ok
3. 01:12:621 (4,5,6,7) - Stack it maybe ? It's very rare to see this in a Hard diff I add a slider reverse instead
4. 00:17:908 (5) - Delete this note Ok

[Believe]

1. 00:17:047 (3) - try this ? I keep :3
2. 00:17:908 (6) - Delete this note Ok
3. 00:18:522 (2) - Ctrl + G Ok
4. 00:19:014 (3) - Ctrl+G if u change the above one Ok
5. 00:31:801 (1,2,3,4) - How about this ? flow better and looks better I keep too :3
6. 00:53:440 (1,2,3,4) - Try this maybe I keep The second choice :3
7. 01:00:203 (5) - Delete this one Ok
8. 01:11:145 (1,2,3,4) - Chnage this one like this one 01:11:637 (1) - Ok

End

1. Please, make combo colors consistent. You use similar colors, but never the same, each diff is different while there is no real need for the inconsistency. Just replace them in .osu file with this:
   Combo1 : 17,136,255
   Combo2 : 255,136,196
   Combo3 : 255,113,113
   Combo4 : 255,94,255
2. Background might be a bit better, current resolution is 4:3 and that is not really the best support for widescreen users. It's just detail, but you might cut for examplethis to 1366x768 so it supports widescreen better and so it's higher quality.
3. Both website and blu-ray proves the song title is wrong. It is not supposed to be Believe X Believe (TV Ver.) but Believe×Believe. Firstly, (TV Ver.) has nothing to do there and there are NO spaces + the X is not X, but a cross (×). Thus the normal title is Believe×Believe and because we have no romanisation for the cross, use BelievexBelieve as a romanised title. Here are two proofs of it being wrong, firstly their website and then the screenshots bellow. Obviously, they might decide to change the title with release of soundtrack, if they feel like it needs to have some difference, but till it is officially released, you are not allowed to alter the title.
   SPOILER

   
4. A detail, but Japanese names should not use spaces in original language. You might check website above to see all Japanese names are without spaces.
5. Romanised artist must be Yamamoto Nozomi as there is ranking critera which tells you to use 'surname firstname' form.
6. Current video is not really best. Quality is not messy or something, but it is just encoded with no CPU optimization, thus the game might lag in some places. You can use this to make almost everyone able to play with video without big loads, just the functions which have no usage in the video are disabled, that's all what changes at all. You might get the video here. Also don't forget the file size limit was increased, so if you wanted, I might even provide higher quality.
7. Applies to all diffs. You should try to use lower base volume, for example 60 or 65 instead (previously it was 75%) and change it back to 75% when the music really becomes louder, so the new inherited timing point would be on 00:23:932. That is just to avoid the map having same volume in parts which have significantly higher volume.
8. You might want to add these tags: 斎藤悠弥 (Composition & Arrange), N@oki (Arrange) and also ユリエ＝シグトゥーナ as a character who 'sings' the song.

1. 00:29:834 (3,4,1) - You changed spacing from 1.0x to 0.9x and thus broke consistency which easy is required to have.
2. 00:18:031 (1) - Same as above
3. 00:21:965 (1) - 1.2x is certainly really high and again, it is same issue as above.
4. 00:27:867 (1,2,3,4) - Look how big difference there is. Same speed, but 00:29:588 - is 0.8x, while 00:28:604 - is 1.3x, you are actually adding jumps into an easy difficulty.
5. 00:57:375 - 01:28:850 - Firstly, the distance snap should really not be inconsistent on easy, check the inconsistencies and fix them. Secondly, it is a kiai and has mostly 0.9x spacing, while rest of map had around 1.0x. That just lacks some sensibility. If it was higher, then it would make sense, however it is easy, where should not be these changes, so you should just make it 1.0x as rest of a map.
6. 00:23:932 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Hitsounds are always 1/1 note later. There's drum of similar sound to hitsound on 00:24:424, but the clap is on 00:24:916. However you swap it to correct on 00:31:801, so you should fix these 9 seconds, that would not hurt much.

1. Please, remove the overused claps from start and start hitsounding them on 00:23:932. There are no notes which are really worth emphasizing with this kind of hitsound, so it only sounds loud and out of place.

1. 00:10:162 (1) - Remove the whistle and put it on the slider start. Currently it is also on a body, you forgot to click the circle, or didn't click it properly. If it is on body, it gives the slider weird noise in a background, which is not really fitting the song.
2. 00:31:801 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2) - While no change was in music, instead of putting clap each 2nd 1/1 note, you used it on every 1/1 note. Before you put it just on a real clap in music, but in this part you are really overusing it. It's most likely out of place.
3. 00:57:375 - Kiai's claps are also a bit out of place. You use them on some places when they are, but you miss many of them. Try to go through this kiai and fill the missing ones.

Wafu wrote:

Random mod

Red - Unrankable
Blue - Highly recommended
Black - Suggestion

General

1. Please, make combo colors consistent. You use similar colors, but never the same, each diff is different while there is no real need for the inconsistency. Just replace them in .osu file with this:
   Combo1 : 17,136,255
   Combo2 : 255,136,196
   Combo3 : 255,113,113
   Combo4 : 255,94,255
2. Background might be a bit better, current resolution is 4:3 and that is not really the best support for widescreen users. It's just detail, but you might cut for examplethis to 1366x768 so it supports widescreen better and so it's higher quality.
3. Both website and blu-ray proves the song title is wrong. It is not supposed to be Believe X Believe (TV Ver.) but Believe×Believe. Firstly, (TV Ver.) has nothing to do there and there are NO spaces + the X is not X, but a cross (×). Thus the normal title is Believe×Believe and because we have no romanisation for the cross, use BelievexBelieve as a romanised title. Here are two proofs of it being wrong, firstly their website and then the screenshots bellow. Obviously, they might decide to change the title with release of soundtrack, if they feel like it needs to have some difference, but till it is officially released, you are not allowed to alter the title.
   SPOILER

   
4. A detail, but Japanese names should not use spaces in original language. You might check website above to see all Japanese names are without spaces.
5. Romanised artist must be Yamamoto Nozomi as there is ranking critera which tells you to use 'surname firstname' form.
6. Current video is not really best. Quality is not messy or something, but it is just encoded with no CPU optimization, thus the game might lag in some places. You can use this to make almost everyone able to play with video without big loads, just the functions which have no usage in the video are disabled, that's all what changes at all. You might get the video here. Also don't forget the file size limit was increased, so if you wanted, I might even provide higher quality.
7. Applies to all diffs. You should try to use lower base volume, for example 60 or 65 instead (previously it was 75%) and change it back to 75% when the music really becomes louder, so the new inherited timing point would be on 00:23:932. That is just to avoid the map having same volume in parts which have significantly higher volume.
8. You might want to add these tags: 斎藤悠弥 (Composition & Arrange), N@oki (Arrange) and also ユリエ＝シグトゥーナ as a character who 'sings' the song.All change and fixed (Except for the background)

Easy

1. 00:29:834 (3,4,1) - You changed spacing from 1.0x to 0.9x and thus broke consistency which easy is required to have.
2. 00:18:031 (1) - Same as above
3. 00:21:965 (1) - 1.2x is certainly really high and again, it is same issue as above.
4. 00:27:867 (1,2,3,4) - Look how big difference there is. Same speed, but 00:29:588 - is 0.8x, while 00:28:604 - is 1.3x, you are actually adding jumps into an easy difficulty.
5. 00:57:375 - 01:28:850 - Firstly, the distance snap should really not be inconsistent on easy, check the inconsistencies and fix them. Secondly, it is a kiai and has mostly 0.9x spacing, while rest of map had around 1.0x. That just lacks some sensibility. If it was higher, then it would make sense, however it is easy, where should not be these changes, so you should just make it 1.0x as rest of a map.
6. 00:23:932 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Hitsounds are always 1/1 note later. There's drum of similar sound to hitsound on 00:24:424, but the clap is on 00:24:916. However you swap it to correct on 00:31:801, so you should fix these 9 seconds, that would not hurt much. I will remap this diff

Normal

1. Please, remove the overused claps from start and start hitsounding them on 00:23:932. There are no notes which are really worth emphasizing with this kind of hitsound, so it only sounds loud and out of place. Fixed

Believe

1. 00:10:162 (1) - Remove the whistle and put it on the slider start. Currently it is also on a body, you forgot to click the circle, or didn't click it properly. If it is on body, it gives the slider weird noise in a background, which is not really fitting the song. Fixed
2. 00:31:801 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2) - While no change was in music, instead of putting clap each 2nd 1/1 note, you used it on every 1/1 note. Before you put it just on a real clap in music, but in this part you are really overusing it. It's most likely out of place. I don't understood
3. 00:57:375 - Kiai's claps are also a bit out of place. You use them on some places when they are, but you miss many of them. Try to go through this kiai and fill the missing ones. I don't understood

Conclusion: Rankable

Basically, the map has quite no-problem flow, shapes and other structure stuff. Spread is also nice, but however something is wrong there and that is difficulty settings. Firstly I think easy and normal could be a little bit less, but that's not the point, you don't have to make the easiest easy and the easiest normal, this is just little harder, but that doesn't matter that much. Anyway, difference between easy, normal and hard in settings are all around 1.3 - 2.3, what's pretty fine gap, on the other hand, difference between hard and believe diff is 0.7 - 1.0. That's almost no settings difference and should be higher, definitely. You cannot really feel anything, while the map itself is quite harder than hard, thus you should decrease hard's settings by a bit and increase believe's settings a bit too and it shall be okay.

For easy, you should care about the conistency a lot, because there were like 0.6 spacing differences and that's nothing what should pass through qualification.
Also, you should be more careful about hitsounds, many things were hitsounded different on each diff, you should just make it a bit more consistent and try to not miss something, but everyone can do such a mistake.

Overally, I think it is nice attempt for a ranked and you can make it if you polish the map a bit. Good luck and have my star when I can give
Feel free to catch me in-game if something is unsure or you need something.