Hi! From my modding queue
I'm sorry if I repeat anything from CelsiusLK's mod, that one was posted while I was writing this and I'm too lazy to read the whole thing
[General]
- There's only 1975ms of audio lead-in, while the minimum is 2000ms (I know it's picky but it isn't that hard to change :p)
- Try to make your background have a 16:9 or 4:3 aspect ratio (In this case it would be best to crop it to 1024x768)
- You need to skin the full set of elements when skinning something out of one. (https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Ranking_Criteria#Skinning)
- The diff names "Hard" and "Mei's Hard" don't clearly indicate which one is harder. I'd rename Mei's diff to something like "Mei's Advanced".
[Easy]
- AR2 and OD2 would be better I think
00:26:725 (1,2,1) - 1/2 beats seem too fast compared to the rest of the diff (there's no change in the music, so no reason for that)
00:48:100 (4) - I think it would be better if you just deleted this slider and left a gap here (since there's nothing happening in the song at that part except for the vocals)
[Normal]
- There's a pretty huge gap on the difficulty settings between this and Hard. I'd either make this one a bit harder or Hard a bit easier.
00:38:537 (1) - The notes after this spinner are already visible right after it appears, which is confusing. I'd replace this with a slider.
00:44:725 - Small SV changes are probably okay on a Normal, but halving it is too much. Set it to around 0,80x here.
[Hard]
00:25:600 (4,1) - These overlap kinda awkwardly
01:07:787 (3,4) - ^
[Mei's Hard]
01:24:475 (1) - Start this spinner at 01:24:287 (to match the vocals)
Can't find anything in the Insane, so that's it. Good luck with the map!
I'm sorry if I repeat anything from CelsiusLK's mod, that one was posted while I was writing this and I'm too lazy to read the whole thing
[General]
- There's only 1975ms of audio lead-in, while the minimum is 2000ms (I know it's picky but it isn't that hard to change :p)
- Try to make your background have a 16:9 or 4:3 aspect ratio (In this case it would be best to crop it to 1024x768)
- You need to skin the full set of elements when skinning something out of one. (https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Ranking_Criteria#Skinning)
- The diff names "Hard" and "Mei's Hard" don't clearly indicate which one is harder. I'd rename Mei's diff to something like "Mei's Advanced".
[Easy]
- AR2 and OD2 would be better I think
00:26:725 (1,2,1) - 1/2 beats seem too fast compared to the rest of the diff (there's no change in the music, so no reason for that)
00:48:100 (4) - I think it would be better if you just deleted this slider and left a gap here (since there's nothing happening in the song at that part except for the vocals)
[Normal]
- There's a pretty huge gap on the difficulty settings between this and Hard. I'd either make this one a bit harder or Hard a bit easier.
00:38:537 (1) - The notes after this spinner are already visible right after it appears, which is confusing. I'd replace this with a slider.
00:44:725 - Small SV changes are probably okay on a Normal, but halving it is too much. Set it to around 0,80x here.
[Hard]
00:25:600 (4,1) - These overlap kinda awkwardly
01:07:787 (3,4) - ^
[Mei's Hard]
01:24:475 (1) - Start this spinner at 01:24:287 (to match the vocals)
Can't find anything in the Insane, so that's it. Good luck with the map!