Wow 2 mods in one day ahah
Thanks for modding guys!
Smug-
Smug- wrote:
hi, sorry for taking so long :3 No hurry, we all have things to do :3
From my (dead) m4m queue
Only modding 4 diffs since it's a long song And 4 is awesome already
[General]
Maybe grab a custom hitclap, the default one is boring Working on it, trying to find the perfect one
Offset +4 sounds much better to me Me and a couple of people checked the offset in the beginning and this seemed the best one, I might look at it better if more people think this too
[Easy]
00:56:187 (1) - Position so it doesn't overlap This one is on purpose, I really wanted this slider to be straight, I can change if it becomes a problem though
01:11:029 (2) - Move NC to here Oh waw, I never noticed the fail here xd changed!
01:13:556 (2) - ^ ^
01:16:082 (2) - ^ ^
01:22:082 (2,3,4,5,1,2,1,2,1,2) - This whole pattern is really squarish and looks ugly to me Squares are patterns too
01:32:503 (2) - Move NC to here Done
01:42:608 (2) - ^ ^
01:43:871 (4,1) - This looks a bit iffy, maybe change keeping
01:47:661 (4) - Heavily consider moving This is a rare exception for the stacking rule, I use 2 on the whole map, hopefully it can be acceptable because it isn't hard to read / play at all
02:29:345 (1) - Maybe make these shapes a bit cleaner: http://puu.sh/gg5cS/82a534f93a.jpg I will consider this, since I like both shapes xD
02:33:135 (3) - Reposition so it doesn't overlap (nazi) This too, because if I move this I have to move 4 which can break flow
02:53:345 (2,3,4) - This also looks a bit squarish Same as ^
03:04:082 (3,4,1,2,3,4) - ^ ^
03:14:187 (2) - You could probably move this down a bit so it's not a straight line I don't dislike squarish patterns in easier diffs (as you can see xD) keeping for now
03:28:714 (4) - Again, heavily consider moving Same as ^
[Normal]
00:31:871 (1) - You could make this slider more interesting True, I'll see what I can do
00:33:135 (1,3,5) - These could also be different as not to repeat the same shape too much mhm they're not so bad
01:13:556 (2) - Move NC to here Same as easy lol
01:16:082 (2) - ^
01:18:608 (2) - ^
01:21:135 (2) - ^
01:30:924 (3) - This shape isn't really that great, to me at least. It looks like a wonky boomerang :3 I love it D:
01:39:450 (2) - You could move this to like x:312 y:196 y coordinate would be too much and ruin DS, changed it to center with the slider however
01:41:029 (3) - This isn't a perfect circle the curve seems fine though (a perfect circle wouldn't allow to build a pattern around it)
02:01:556 (7) - Move NC to here Done
02:06:608 (7) - ^
02:10:398 (1,2,3) - You could probably avoid this straight line here You really don't like square patterns :b
02:17:345 (2) - You could add a curve to this, it might look a bit nicer Ok, I'll think about this one
02:20:503 (2) - Remove NC Allright
02:25:556 (1) - ^
02:28:082 (4) - NC Mhmhm
02:34:714 (2,3,4) - This seems like the perfect opportunity for some blankets I have some right after, it looks good both ways imo
02:44:503 (5) - Move NC to here Okay
02:47:029 (2) - ^
02:51:766 (3) - Again, consider changing, if not for the shape, but for some difference between the two kiais I change the shape in the second repetition of the chorus (2nd kiai)
02:59:661 (1) - Curve maybe? would ruin flow
03:00:608 (1) - Blanket 2 perhaps ^
03:01:871 (3) - To me it looks like you're trying to blanket 1, and it looks really off it's not a blanket itself, but I'm centering it yes
03:16:082 (2) - Move NC to here Done
03:23:661 (2) - ^ no need because combo would be too small
03:24:924 (4) - ^ Done
[Hard]
Very cramped. You're not covering very much space despite having a very high note density and that makes it look messy. Here are some examples:
00:30:135 (4,5,1,2) -
00:34:398 (1,2,3,4) -
00:38:661 (5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5) -
00:44:819 (3,4,5) -
00:47:029 (1,2,3) -
There's a lot more I can highlight, but essentially you should opt for moving your objects in a direction that doesn't cluster them up. As for a few other things
00:37:556 (1) - Since this is the same as the previous two that are supposed to highlight the special part of the song, it makes it seem less special
00:37:871 (2) - Make sure you change this so you can hit the downbeat
00:49:398 (4) - I think a tiny overlap like this is just kinda messy. You can increase the DS here temporarily
00:57:135 (3) - Also make sure you don't do tiny accidental overlaps like this 00:56:503 (3) -
01:03:450 (1) - And even if it's the slidertail, you should try to maximise the space between it and the previous object if you're not trying to use the two objects together (01:03:135 (5) - )
01:10:714 (1) - Make sure you let us hit the downbeat. That goes for the rest of this section too
01:23:661 (1,2,3,4) - I would recommend you change these to sliders (and change some of the next ones to circles if you want) Because the speed up isn't readily apparent due to them being stacked
02:03:135 (1,2,3) - Make sure these don't overlap each other like this
02:14:187 (1) - You can improve this slider look by adding a point before the red one
02:29:345 (2) - NC
02:30:293 (1,2,3) - These are pretty ugly. Change them so they're not so dramatic
02:35:661 (1,2,3,4,5) - I also feel like this is another cramped spot
02:41:661 (9) - Again, make sure you're not doing overlaps like this
02:45:450 (5) - ^
02:45:766 (6) - Maybe add NC here
02:47:029 - For this section, add NC for every two objects: http://puu.sh/ggc1Q/3b9c08040f.jpg
03:39:450 (3,4) - Copy paste 4 and use that for 3
Anyway, this diff is a bit cramped and pretty object heavy; you're probably gonna have to put in a bit of work to polish this up a bit.
Based on yours and CB's mods I will rework this diff, I will still have this mod in mind when remapping though
[Lunatic]
00:31:871 (1) - I don't mean to spoil your slider artwork, but I think a slow down is more suitable for this part
00:39:135 (6,4,8) - Let's try to switch this up I think
00:47:029 (1,3) - Ctrl G these maybe
00:49:556 (5) - Change this one to be the same as 00:49:871 (6) - since you're doing these sliders in pairs
00:53:582 (2) - I don't think this is necessary
00:54:608 (6) - Move so it doesn't overlap 4
01:11:029 (3) - NC
01:13:398 (2) - You could probably move this; with the way stacking works I don't think this will look pretty
01:13:556 (3) - ^
01:27:766 (2) - I think you oughtta make this one different from 1
01:29:503 (5) - make symmetrical to 4
01:29:977 (7) - NC; for my sake. Big combos scare me ;w;
01:31:240 (2) - NC goes here
01:32:503 (7) - NC
01:33:766 (3) - Move NC to here
01:36:135 (3,4,5) - Don't see a reason why these should be on red ticks
01:40:086 (8) - NC
I also noticed there's some triplet inconsistency within your kiai times, and to my knowledge it's not different in the two halves of the first kiai. Make sure that you keep a consistent rhythm inside kiais (at least this makes sense to me)
01:48:928 (9) - NC
01:59:033 (1) - Again, I think these suit slow downs, not speed ups
02:00:612 (6,7,8,9) - These should be sliders to indicate to the player there's a BSD change in the music
02:09:139 (1) - This is all uneven. You can make nicer looking ones by using a red point in the middle of them
02:18:612 (7) - Don't overlap this
02:23:033 (5) - You can achieve these with one point in the middle
02:29:349 - I can see where the 5.23 star rating came from
For the second kiai, please just remember to put your NCs on downbeats. I think you can also afford to put more of them so the numbers don't get so high, but that's just my personal preference.
This diff will also be target of a slight rework, I have to finish Hard first so I can't reply to this right now, sorry but all will be had into account
Maybe I'll come back and mod the other diffs as well, but for now I'm pooped This was a great mod, thanks! It's a huge song so no need for more :3
Good luck! PM me in game if you want any more help
Jewelery
Jewelery wrote:
Not Mion but np WHAT? even the hair is the same ; ; sorry
Request from t/306264
Easy:Normal:
- 00:51:766 - you skip this beat everywhere ): I see what you mean, I wanted to put a note there too but for an easy it would make it a bit too hard and dense, I might add if I discover a way of putting it there somehow lol
- 01:29:345 - i dont think that its a good idea to skip this because you add claps in other moments like this
- 01:39:450 - ^
- 02:23:029 (3) - i'd like to make this slider symmetrical with (1) sure thing, done
- 02:50:187 - yes i'm adding every this moment to this mod ): :'c
- 03:00:293 - ^
- 03:28:714 (4) - i dont think that stacking on the easiest diff is good but i like this one It's an exception, if it's not too hard to read and not too fast I think it's acceptable if I don't overuse it
- 03:50:187 - i dont think that one spinner is good, i'd recommend to add spinner in the end I might take a look at this, but it has to be when all diffs receiver their reworks
HardV2:
- I dont think that speedchanges in normal is good idea. if it's not too sudden and not too many times, it's fine
- 00:59:977 (4) - i suggest to make this parralel with (3) Why? because of this moment 01:04:398 (3,4) - agreed, Done (I was stacking it with 5, but the stack wasn't noticeable in game so)
- 01:09:766 (3) - imo better way is ctrl+g this slider Would ruin flow imo
- 01:30:924 (3) - hello from 2011 I'm only playing for 10 months ; ;
- 02:08:503 (5,6) - i think you can place repeating slider here I did have one, but in another mod I was told to remove it due to difficulty rules so.. (he was a nominator eheh)
- 02:51:766 (3) - hello again :3
- 03:50:187 - what do you think about spinner here? Same as easy, will be considered
Hard:
- unsnapped as hel This is a rework of Hard, so just a temporary diff xD
Lunatic:
- 01:03:135 (5) - i suggest ctrl+g
- 01:23:661 (1,2) - dont think that these stacks is good, but cant find better solution
- 01:24:608 (6) - you didnt ctrl+g it but 01:25:871 (6) - was ctrl+g'ed D:
- In my point of view you have to look at this diff and make it more neater, some sliders almost makes me cry, you can use copypaste to make patterns clear Agreed, this is why I am currently reworking it, the chorus has too much note spam which can be quite hard and confusing
All these points will be had into account when reworking this diff too, as I have to finish Hard first, sorry I can't reply to it now :c
- i'm weak in extras so this will be short mod no problema, thanks for modding still :3
- 00:36:924 (1,2,3,4) - i guess you can reduce spacing for a bit
- 00:45:450 (4) - ctrl+g because of next moments
- 01:04:398 (5) - i think you can make it symmetrical to (4)
- 01:38:187 (5,6,7,8) - i'm not sure that this sliders fit the vocal
- 01:39:608 (5) - ctrl+g
- 01:46:714 (2) - ctrl+g
- 02:12:924 (5) - i think it can be symmetrical with (4)
- 02:39:450 (1,2) - this stack isnt good idea in my opinion
- 02:40:082 (2) - you can copypast and rotate (1)
- 02:40:714 (4) - you can copypast and rotate (3)
- 02:52:556 (4) - confusing slider, really
Good luck. tyvm
Feel free to ignore most part of my mod. This is my subjective opinion.
Thanks for modding guys!