i try to mod in chinese
wan an!
[General]
Try to play with the kiai times a bit, just 3/8 of the map being kiai is so bland imo.
[Easy]
00:04:631 (1) - That slider looks quite odd to me, why not making it a bit more even? (like a thunder shape)
00:26:886 (3) - I suggest a straight slider to get some variation. http://puu.sh/cQAUo/4e82f0e27c.jpg
00:37:220 (3) - bad blanket
00:58:552 (2) - I find this rhythm really questionable, as it follows nothing major ; try this please: http://puu.sh/cQC4B/16246b4122.jpg
01:02:218 (4) - I don't like how this is almost overlapping, please try to rotate 4 a bit to the left.
01:07:552 (4) - overlap with 2, little arrangements should do the trick.
01:09:718 (2) - Please stick to a simple rhythm. What you've mapped to is so silent, nobody can really hear it.
01:17:885 (4) - That's probably really misleading, as the beginners will probably lead to the reverse, and not the head. Try rearranging please, and while you're at it, eliminiate the blue ticks, I think that would probably be an unranking reason.
01:24:385 (1) - I strongly suppose this should end 1/2 earlier.
[Normal]
00:11:011 (1,2) - Try to get the lines paralell, nazi
00:14:887 (1) - 1) This is 1/3 2) Don't use 1/3, it's too difficult for normal. Stick to 1/1 please.
00:18:886 (3) - 1) This is 1/3 2) Well, you can leave it here, seeing it as something special.
00:22:886 (1) - ^, but use 1/1
00:29:553 (3) - idk what this is.. lol
00:33:553 (1) - 1/3, but use 1/1
36220,-100,3,2,1,60,0,0 < this green line is unnecessary 00:36:220 -
00:36:220 (1,2,3) - a pattern like that will be more awesome! http://puu.sh/cQCxl/3364fcb590.jpg and also flow better.
00:40:719 (2) - not following anything major, try again
00:42:719 (2) - same
01:00:885 (3) - moving this to somewhere like 124 212 will improve the flow drastically!
01:07:218 (5) - try 232 248 for a better flow too
01:18:885 (1,2,1,2,3) - I'm honestly not sure about it.. Try to get the blue tick on a repeater, it'll be better I strongly suppose.
Please get someone to check the divisor snap (1/3, 1/4), as I've originally told you; I'm a bit unsure, so it would be better to be on the save side. The normal is okay otherwise, but sometimes you could improve how the slider compliment each other (for instance, 2 curves like 00:17:553 (1,3) - look quite odd)
[Hard]
00:11:011 (1) - I'd suggest a straight slider which goes upwards instead of a curve like this, it's the same as in my comment @normal.
00:20:220 (1,2,3) - That spacing is quite big.. hmm.. mind lowering it a bit?
00:22:886 (1,2,3,4,5) - Hmm.. I think you could make this more appealing.. i mean.. following the vocals better, it seems a bit plain for me at the moment.
00:24:886 (7) - get rid off the overlap
00:31:886 (3,4,5) - Flow can be improved here, try to move 4 below 3, so you get a less circulare but more zig zag flow, which, imo, flows better
00:33:553 (1,2,3,4) - ? I don't think that can be enjoyable to play for a hard diff, it seems rather random to me.. i'd stick to the vocals again
00:37:220 (3) - same problem as in normal, maybe it's just me, but i think a straight slider works better here (or an opposite curve)
00:37:720 (4,5) - put the same spacing? I think a stack doesn't make much sense here.
00:38:720 (2,3) - ^
00:40:219 - Mhh, about this rhythm, I can see improvement. Try this: http://puu.sh/cQDoN/e1566fb198.jpg It flows better with the vocals! Also, your spacing atm is a bit messed up and proportionally too big.
01:23:052 (1) - overlap
01:16:552 (2,3,4) - Again, this combination looks weird to me.please don't use a curve downwards here!
01:24:052 (4) - I guess people will miss that one, because it's pretty not guessable that it's 3 repeats instead of two. What do you think?
The kiai was pretty cool, the rest could use some polishment, the rhythm seems a bit messed up at some points.
[Irie's Insane]
People keep thinking Irie = Irre ..
00:10:211 (4,5) - That extended slider does not fit at all. Please remove it.
00:38:220 (3,4,5) - omg i love that
00:47:219 (4) - You should indicate that with NC imo
00:38:220 (3) - same
00:49:219 (3) - same
00:51:553 (5) - same
00:54:219 (1) - I think a normal-whistle hitsound would fit way better than ~nothing~ . Please try!
Sometimes quite overmapped, but well, 2014. I'm a bit sceptic about 01:09:718 (4) - this technique, as it plays pretty unintuitive and misleading.
[Insane]
Begin - Kiai: The rhythm is made quite bad. I'll talk to you IRC about it, so I can explain a bit better (it is .. uhm.. correct, but it can be done way better.. 1/3 is a thing for itself, i assume)
Kiai:
01:16:552 (2,3,4,5) - Try to use a bit more spacing here? It will look less clustered.
I really like the kiai, so, good job on that!
[HW's Insane]
00:02:964 (2,3) - ..delete 2.. that doesn't fit at all, can't even hear it on 25%
00:06:164 (3,4) - I can sadly hear this on 25%, so I guess you can leave that one.. although I think it's quite odd.
00:27:720 (4,5,6,1) - Use equal spacing here? Can't see why you lowered the spacing from 6 > 1.
00:52:219 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - party time
01:02:718 (9,1) - really strong voice here, why did you use so less spacing for 9 > 1?
good map o.o looks hard, but good
So, after we've improved the rhythm on insane, I'll think what to do next ~
wan an!
[General]
Try to play with the kiai times a bit, just 3/8 of the map being kiai is so bland imo.
[Easy]
00:04:631 (1) - That slider looks quite odd to me, why not making it a bit more even? (like a thunder shape)
00:26:886 (3) - I suggest a straight slider to get some variation. http://puu.sh/cQAUo/4e82f0e27c.jpg
00:37:220 (3) - bad blanket
00:58:552 (2) - I find this rhythm really questionable, as it follows nothing major ; try this please: http://puu.sh/cQC4B/16246b4122.jpg
01:02:218 (4) - I don't like how this is almost overlapping, please try to rotate 4 a bit to the left.
01:07:552 (4) - overlap with 2, little arrangements should do the trick.
01:09:718 (2) - Please stick to a simple rhythm. What you've mapped to is so silent, nobody can really hear it.
01:17:885 (4) - That's probably really misleading, as the beginners will probably lead to the reverse, and not the head. Try rearranging please, and while you're at it, eliminiate the blue ticks, I think that would probably be an unranking reason.
01:24:385 (1) - I strongly suppose this should end 1/2 earlier.
[Normal]
00:11:011 (1,2) - Try to get the lines paralell, nazi
00:14:887 (1) - 1) This is 1/3 2) Don't use 1/3, it's too difficult for normal. Stick to 1/1 please.
00:18:886 (3) - 1) This is 1/3 2) Well, you can leave it here, seeing it as something special.
00:22:886 (1) - ^, but use 1/1
00:29:553 (3) - idk what this is.. lol
00:33:553 (1) - 1/3, but use 1/1
36220,-100,3,2,1,60,0,0 < this green line is unnecessary 00:36:220 -
00:36:220 (1,2,3) - a pattern like that will be more awesome! http://puu.sh/cQCxl/3364fcb590.jpg and also flow better.
00:40:719 (2) - not following anything major, try again
00:42:719 (2) - same
01:00:885 (3) - moving this to somewhere like 124 212 will improve the flow drastically!
01:07:218 (5) - try 232 248 for a better flow too
01:18:885 (1,2,1,2,3) - I'm honestly not sure about it.. Try to get the blue tick on a repeater, it'll be better I strongly suppose.
Please get someone to check the divisor snap (1/3, 1/4), as I've originally told you; I'm a bit unsure, so it would be better to be on the save side. The normal is okay otherwise, but sometimes you could improve how the slider compliment each other (for instance, 2 curves like 00:17:553 (1,3) - look quite odd)
[Hard]
00:11:011 (1) - I'd suggest a straight slider which goes upwards instead of a curve like this, it's the same as in my comment @normal.
00:20:220 (1,2,3) - That spacing is quite big.. hmm.. mind lowering it a bit?
00:22:886 (1,2,3,4,5) - Hmm.. I think you could make this more appealing.. i mean.. following the vocals better, it seems a bit plain for me at the moment.
00:24:886 (7) - get rid off the overlap
00:31:886 (3,4,5) - Flow can be improved here, try to move 4 below 3, so you get a less circulare but more zig zag flow, which, imo, flows better
00:33:553 (1,2,3,4) - ? I don't think that can be enjoyable to play for a hard diff, it seems rather random to me.. i'd stick to the vocals again
00:37:220 (3) - same problem as in normal, maybe it's just me, but i think a straight slider works better here (or an opposite curve)
00:37:720 (4,5) - put the same spacing? I think a stack doesn't make much sense here.
00:38:720 (2,3) - ^
00:40:219 - Mhh, about this rhythm, I can see improvement. Try this: http://puu.sh/cQDoN/e1566fb198.jpg It flows better with the vocals! Also, your spacing atm is a bit messed up and proportionally too big.
01:23:052 (1) - overlap
01:16:552 (2,3,4) - Again, this combination looks weird to me.please don't use a curve downwards here!
01:24:052 (4) - I guess people will miss that one, because it's pretty not guessable that it's 3 repeats instead of two. What do you think?
The kiai was pretty cool, the rest could use some polishment, the rhythm seems a bit messed up at some points.
[Irie's Insane]
People keep thinking Irie = Irre ..
00:10:211 (4,5) - That extended slider does not fit at all. Please remove it.
00:38:220 (3,4,5) - omg i love that
00:47:219 (4) - You should indicate that with NC imo
00:38:220 (3) - same
00:49:219 (3) - same
00:51:553 (5) - same
00:54:219 (1) - I think a normal-whistle hitsound would fit way better than ~nothing~ . Please try!
Sometimes quite overmapped, but well, 2014. I'm a bit sceptic about 01:09:718 (4) - this technique, as it plays pretty unintuitive and misleading.
[Insane]
Begin - Kiai: The rhythm is made quite bad. I'll talk to you IRC about it, so I can explain a bit better (it is .. uhm.. correct, but it can be done way better.. 1/3 is a thing for itself, i assume)
Kiai:
01:16:552 (2,3,4,5) - Try to use a bit more spacing here? It will look less clustered.
I really like the kiai, so, good job on that!
[HW's Insane]
00:02:964 (2,3) - ..delete 2.. that doesn't fit at all, can't even hear it on 25%
00:06:164 (3,4) - I can sadly hear this on 25%, so I guess you can leave that one.. although I think it's quite odd.
00:27:720 (4,5,6,1) - Use equal spacing here? Can't see why you lowered the spacing from 6 > 1.
00:52:219 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - party time
01:02:718 (9,1) - really strong voice here, why did you use so less spacing for 9 > 1?
good map o.o looks hard, but good
So, after we've improved the rhythm on insane, I'll think what to do next ~