I don't really remember but if I have to be honest, Hamtaro was my starting point but I wasn't ANY interested.
Until I took my first real step and went through the gateway to the Anime world but I went STRAIGHT to Little Busters!...it was back then.
I could mention three of my first Anime:
Little Busters!
Love Live! School Idol Project
Acchi Kocchi
Again, I was aiming STRAIGHT at Little Busters! because it's the first Anime that I thought of. Followed by Love Live! then Acchi Kocchi.
I won't accept negative comments against Little Busters! tho