Cyllinus wrote:

I feel like the circle at 01:13:024 should be moved forward to the blue tick on hard and insane. Other than that I think the map is fine.

Estellia- wrote:

Lezzgo~

Mako

00:15:622 (1,1) - Either you don't start this early, or put something between here - no it's fine.no change
00:28:378 (3) - Don't find the need for this - I actually think that is quite necessary
01:58:142 (1,2,3) - Weird flow - no change

This Easy seems very symmetry orientated, which can be rather boring. Amp it up with some style? - not necessary. I would like to respect the guest difficultly and I actually quite like the symmetry for an easy difficulty

Normal

00:39:480 (1,2) - Align - fixed
00:49:165 (1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3) - Frenzy of these sliders may be boring - I disagree, its completely different from the first 50 seconds and it emphasizes the new section of the song
01:09:953 (1,3) - These 2 sliders can be made the same - I don't understand. They are the same. Just flipped.
01:19:401 (1,2,3) - Weird flow - fixed
01:21:291 (1,2) - ^ - no change
01:23:890 (3,4,1) - ^ - no change
01:27:905 (2) - Looks forced - no change
01:28:850 (1,2,3) - Flow - no change
01:43:024 (2,3,1) - ^ - fixed

Essentially, well blanketted in the beginning, but it starts to get bad during the chorus. Do fix up. - I believe everything is already well blanketed in the chorus.

I'm sorry but I'm not modding your Hard and Lunatic, because I feel that it's too old-style and I might take too long on this. Sorry I'm not really sure what you mean by old style

Garven wrote:

fyi, you still need a center point in your spinner for rankability - fixed

01:49:047 - You should fade this thought bubble in instead of having it magically appear all at once. - fixed
02:19:283 - Same thing with the Mukyu. Also a pity that you couldn't get a blushing version and non-blushing version to match the previous one. - That's a good idea, did some photoshopping and added it in ^^
02:20:346 - Try to have all your SB code end around here so you don't get stuck with a skip button for the rest of the song - fixed

Garven wrote:

Alright then, time for an actual mod.

[Easy]
00:15:622 (1) - Way too soon after a spinner for an Easy. You want to give around 4 beats of recovery time. You might be best off either ending the spinner at 00:15:622 - or just deleting the circle - fixed. I deleted the circle and extended the spinner
00:19:283 - Add a silent soft-sliderslide2.wav so that you can't hear the slider track during these custom ticks. -added
Felt rather slider heavy. Otherwise this was alright.

[Normal]
00:15:622 (1) - This also is too soon after a spinner for a Normal. It'll usually be halved recovery time from the Easy, so 2-3 beats would be preferable for this level of difficulty. That said, this might be similar to Easy in that just removing beats until 00:17:512 (1) - or so would work best if you want to keep the spinner. - fixed
02:02:394 (5) - Slider end is unsnapped - fixed

[Hard]
01:22:236 (2) - This slider shape is a little odd - fixed
02:17:984 (1,2) - Was strange to have these stacked. I guess you were going for emphasis for the final parts of the song, but then following up with the regular spacing at 3, it just felt out of place over anything else. - fixed

[Lunatic]
01:26:961 (1) - Missing a finish - fixed

Awesome set.

1. As said on IRC, nuke soft-hitclap.wav and use soft-hitclap2.wav
   
   Warning: after you do this, you will not need to use S:C2 on Lunatic, Hard and Normal at all. Remove unnecessary offsets, since all you use them for is swtching between C1 and C2. Then remove also all the C2 files except for soft-slidertick2.wav, because Mako's Easy uses it!
   
   
2. I think there are tiny mistakes in lyrics that could be corrected:
   
   1. e0-2: "Their numberless calculations really are ingenious [comma missing] aren't they?"
   2. e0-9, e1-7 and e2-7 have "i" instead of a capital I ("i like things to be overdecorated"), is this intended?
3. 01:49:638 is a perfect moment for a fountain
4. Move the offset to 00:00:031. It won't break snapping, but the cookie in osu!'s main menu will pulse right when the music starts

1. 00:25:307 (3,4) - it bothers me that a) they are alighed differently and b) 2's end looks poor; consider the following: http://puu.sh/baaZ7/74251292ae.jpg
2. 00:39:480 (1) - mind bending it? I have to return back to 2's beginning anyway.. http://puu.sh/babuA/2a8c591db1.jpg
3. 00:49:165 (1) - it's funny how you skip cymbals that appear in the music here, although you were using finishes very often just seconds before that note
4. 01:09:716 (1) - add some space here: http://puu.sh/babIi/20995762fd.jpg
5. 01:10:661 (4,5) - same
6. 01:13:024 (4) - I understand you wanted to make this more readable, but it had an opposite effect, because the actual 'dot' is 1/4 later at 01:13:142. Don't forget to fix the storyboard!
7. 01:13:496 (5,6,7) - the spacing is incorrect and can be misread
   
   Speaking of spacing, you are limited on space horizontally, but not vertically. You are free to move each of four patterns that stand for L, O, V and E vertically, and that could give you some better results and help avoid overlapping: http://puu.sh/bb3I3/4f9ccc7a9e.jpg
   
   
8. 01:15:386 (12) - the fact that you skipped the very next downbeat to follow vocals can be masked if you start the spinner right after the note. Do so!
9. 01:20:701 (4) - you skipped a strong beat there, and the slider sounds like it's not following anything (and it really doesn't). It could be better if you start it on 01:20:819; remove 01:21:055 (5) - but keep the blue tick at 01:21:173 busy, if you wish. Don't forget to connect the sliders if you do so
10. 01:22:590 (4) - pretty much the same. This slider starts nowhere; fix this by moving it 1/4 forward and also shortening by 1/4
    
    I think I'll just list all the slider you need to fix in such a manner at once:
    
    1. 01:20:701 (4) -
    2. 01:22:590 (4) -
    3. 01:41:252 (4) -
    4. 01:47:157 (4) -
11. 01:32:984 (2) - please, reverse it! Gives such a good, nice movement. Also, move it a bit further from 1 and, if necessary, rotate a bit: http://puu.sh/bacEH/6247ed2128.jpg
12. 01:40:543 (2) and 01:40:898 (3) - same as above, reverse each for a better flow
13. 01:46:567 (3) - ah! This is a tricky one. To warn players about a slider under the other slider (it needs a warning, because they're both of the same colour and share the same track), shift it a little: http://puu.sh/bacUZ/06e5c43522.jpg Now it's more noticeable and will cause less breaks
14. 01:55:661 (2,3) - I'd reverse these too and remapped a few beats ahead, but you better increase the spacing here
15. 01:59:087 (1,2,3) - they will look better if you un-bend each: http://puu.sh/badoL/de3da8dc83.jpg
16. 02:03:575 (3) - there's a clap missing on the tail
17. 02:09:244 (3) - I'd replace it with two notes to follow vocals! Stack them on next slider's head or something

1. 00:27:669 (4,5,1) - the movement here is kind of bad, because a player has to interrupt his movement from 5 to screen's bottom and rush to the right instead; consider the following:
2. 00:29:087 (4,5) - that feels easier somehow; maybe because I am right-handed
3. 00:36:882 (4,5) - should be 1.5x
4. 00:52:945 (1) - missed finish?
5. 01:04:283 (1,2) - could be misread; please reduce the spacing
6. 01:13:024 (4) - (copied from Lunatic) I understand you wanted to make this more readable, but it had an opposite effect, because the actual 'dot' is 1/4 later at 01:13:142. Don't forget to fix the storyboard!
7. 01:15:858 (1) - start it right after the note
8. 01:49:283 (7) - move it a bit closer to the next slider
9. 02:00:505 (3,1) - could use a bigger spacing! Just for consistency
10. 02:09:953 (3) - I'd reverse it, 02:09:953 (3,1) - will play a little better

1. 00:11:370 (1) - should have finish
2. 00:29:323 (3,1) - cool!
3. 01:13:496 (5) - this repeat falls on nothing. It will be better if you split this slider into two 1/2 ones: http://puu.sh/bb4sI/b5578929c5.jpg
4. 01:15:858 (1) - start it right after the note
5. 01:25:779 (3,4) - feels really weird to play, probably due to low note density. I'd shorten the slider by 1/4

1. 00:11:370 (1) - add finish, please, and insert a break right after
2. 00:46:331 - the slidertick sound should appear 1/1 later, earlier or both, but not there; don't use it on this slider
3. 01:49:638 - as I said to truonant, this is a good opportunity to use a fountain
4. 02:13:732 (2) - you can improve this by using note + slider: http://puu.sh/bb4Xy/9b2514b2f1.jpg (don't forget to move finish)

TicClick wrote:

Hey!

[General]

1. As said on IRC, nuke soft-hitclap.wav and use soft-hitclap2.wav - used "softhitclap2.wav for "softhitclap.wav" However Easy sounded weird since the claps didn't have much of a punch so I found a new softhitclap (now known as softhitclap2.wav) and used that for the majority of Easy. I also used some different whistle sounds to compliment the change
2. I think there are tiny mistakes in lyrics that could be corrected:
   
   1. e0-2: "Their numberless calculations really are ingenious [comma missing] aren't they?" - I actually fixed some of the lyrics (I found an alternate source of translated lyrics which were more concise and accurate.
   2. e0-9, e1-7 and e2-7 have "i" instead of a capital I ("i like things to be overdecorated"), is this intended? - fixed - This is actually is intended. With the font face that I used, the capital "i" looks like an "o". But since I was fixing the lyrics, I fixed the "i' by combining with other fonts
3. 01:49:638 is a perfect moment for a fountain - added

[Lunatic]

1. 00:25:307 (3,4) - it bothers me that a) they are alighed differently and b) 2's end looks poor; consider the following: http://puu.sh/baaZ7/74251292ae.jpg - fixed
2. 00:39:480 (1) - mind bending it? I have to return back to 2's beginning anyway.. http://puu.sh/babuA/2a8c591db1.jpg - fixed
3. 00:49:165 (1) - it's funny how you skip cymbals that appear in the music here, although you were using finishes very often just seconds before that note - added a finish
4. 01:09:716 (1) - add some space here: http://puu.sh/babIi/20995762fd.jpg - fixed
5. 01:10:661 (4,5) - same - fixed
6. 01:13:024 (4) - I understand you wanted to make this more readable, but it had an opposite effect, because the actual 'dot' is 1/4 later at 01:13:142. Don't forget to fix the storyboard! - fixed
7. 01:13:496 (5,6,7) - the spacing is incorrect and can be misread - remapped the section with 1.5 spacing
   
   Speaking of spacing, you are limited on space horizontally, but not vertically. You are free to move each of four patterns that stand for L, O, V and E vertically, and that could give you some better results and help avoid overlapping
   
   
8. 01:15:386 (12) - the fact that you skipped the very next downbeat to follow vocals can be masked if you start the spinner right after the note. Do so! - fixed. although it does cut off the last dot of the storyboard
9. 01:20:701 (4) - you skipped a strong beat there, and the slider sounds like it's not following anything (and it really doesn't). It could be better if you start it on 01:20:819; remove 01:21:055 (5) - but keep the blue tick at 01:21:173 busy, if you wish. Don't forget to connect the sliders if you do so - fixed
10. 01:22:590 (4) - pretty much the same. This slider starts nowhere; fix this by moving it 1/4 forward and also shortening by 1/4 - fixed
    
    I think I'll just list all the slider you need to fix in such a manner at once:
    
    1. 01:20:701 (4) - - fixed
    2. 01:22:590 (4) - - fixed
    3. 01:41:252 (4) - - fixed
    4. 01:47:157 (4) - - fixed
11. 01:32:984 (2) - please, reverse it! Gives such a good, nice movement. Also, move it a bit further from 1 and, if necessary, rotate a bit: http://puu.sh/bacEH/6247ed2128.jpg - fixed. I tried something different
12. 01:40:543 (2) and 01:40:898 (3) - same as above, reverse each for a better flow - fixed
13. 01:46:567 (3) - ah! This is a tricky one. To warn players about a slider under the other slider (it needs a warning, because they're both of the same colour and share the same track), shift it a little: http://puu.sh/bacUZ/06e5c43522.jpg Now it's more noticeable and will cause less breaks - fixed
14. 01:55:661 (2,3) - I'd reverse these too and remapped a few beats ahead, but you better increase the spacing here - fixed
15. 01:59:087 (1,2,3) - they will look better if you un-bend each: http://puu.sh/badoL/de3da8dc83.jpg
16. 02:03:575 (3) - there's a clap missing on the tail - fixed
17. 02:09:244 (3) - I'd replace it with two notes to follow vocals! Stack them on next slider's head or something - added

[Hard]

1. 00:27:669 (4,5,1) - the movement here is kind of bad, because a player has to interrupt his movement from 5 to screen's bottom and rush to the right instead; consider the following: - no change. I actually think this is fine
2. 00:29:087 (4,5) - that feels easier somehow; maybe because I am right-handed
3. 00:36:882 (4,5) - should be 1.5x - fixed
4. 00:52:945 (1) - missed finish? - fixed
5. 01:04:283 (1,2) - could be misread; please reduce the spacing - stacked 01:04:756 (2) - on slider tail
6. 01:13:024 (4) - (copied from Lunatic) I understand you wanted to make this more readable, but it had an opposite effect, because the actual 'dot' is 1/4 later at 01:13:142. Don't forget to fix the storyboard! - fixed
7. 01:15:858 (1) - start it right after the note - fixed
8. 01:49:283 (7) - move it a bit closer to the next slider - fixed
9. 02:00:505 (3,1) - could use a bigger spacing! Just for consistency - fixed
10. 02:09:953 (3) - I'd reverse it, 02:09:953 (3,1) - will play a little better - fixed

That kiai part is just great!

[Normal]

1. 00:11:370 (1) - should have finish - fixed
2. 00:29:323 (3,1) - cool! :3
3. 01:13:496 (5) - this repeat falls on nothing. It will be better if you split this slider into two 1/2 ones: http://puu.sh/bb4sI/b5578929c5.jpg - fixed
4. 01:15:858 (1) - start it right after the note - fixed
5. 01:25:779 (3,4) - feels really weird to play, probably due to low note density. I'd shorten the slider by 1/4 - fixed

[Mako's Easy]

1. 00:11:370 (1) - add finish, please, and insert a break right after - fixed
2. 00:46:331 - the slidertick sound should appear 1/1 later, earlier or both, but not there; don't use it on this slider - fixed
3. 01:49:638 - as I said to truonant, this is a good opportunity to use a fountain - added
4. 02:13:732 (2) - you can improve this by using note + slider: http://puu.sh/bb4Xy/9b2514b2f1.jpg (don't forget to move finish)- fixed

Don't be afraid! Although my post came out a bit longer than you might've expected, I posted mostly suggestions and cosmetical improvements (apart from things on Lunatic). Apply as many as you can ("all" is preferable, but not necessary), then call me for a recheck ❤

Full Tablet wrote:

Isn't the name of the song " ・－・・ －－－ ・・・－ ・"? (Which means LOVE in morse code)

TicClick wrote:

Congratulations on your first ranked beatmap! I enjoy it.

Unsfamiliar wrote:

Grats

It's great to see some shibayan!

Nozhomi wrote:

Gratz ! Patchouli forever ! ♥
Mukyu~

10nya wrote:

3Love

kirigherkins wrote:

Love love love how heavy the slider finishes feel.
Also, stealing your spinner-metre and using it as the spinner-bottom in my skin, it looks phenomenal like that.

emmy wrote:

oh wow

Mako Sakata wrote:

Shibayan and 3L !
Congrats truonant

Celizavia wrote:

Congrats on your first ranked map!

i think i just found my mapping teacher hiyyah
(=ﾟωﾟ)ﾉ

Dailycare wrote:

00:37:827 (1) - ?!?!