1. Easy (1.37 stars, 75 notes)
2. Hard (4.83 stars, 213 notes)
3. Normal (3.35 stars, 118 notes)

AeonWing wrote:

Oh wow you were fast. Lol thanks, I'll add this link to our thread.

Mod:
Overall: For the sound changes, you should use 1/4 forward or back just in case people click the slider/circle earlier. You mean the timing sections? Yeah I should fix the offset on those.

Easy:
00:59:570 (?) Might want to add some notes here and there. Done.

Normal:
no problems found.

Hard:
00:55:498 (1): Slider goes out of map a lil bit. Done.


star~

happy30 wrote:

[Easy]

I wasn't really impressed with the hitsounds sorry, they were kinda random. But, no flaws here. Now that you mention it, I agree. XD I made them more reasonable.

[Normal]

Basically the same as for [Easy] Made them better.. I hope.
I would put a soft hitsound for the very last spinner here. Done

[Hard]

Spacing was very well done, good job ^^ Thanks ^^
just the ending spinner could use a soft hitsound. Done

osu_CN_yaya wrote:

[easy]

sorry . i think normal hitsound is not fix this song . Especially the normal finish. Removed.

[normal]

like easy Removed

[hard]

00:40:71 (9,10,11) - distance . Moved (10)
also . hitsound I fixed the majority of it.

not bad map . hitsounds are little noisy Turned down the volume.

babble wrote:

Heya Senbon, I really appreciate you looking over my map ^_^ So I decided to look at your part for the Klonoa 2 OST Oh, no prob. ^^

Easy and Normal

Perfect. I can't find anything wrong at all

Hard

00:18:855 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I don't understand why you changed to sound volume to normal here. Makes the circles I listed sound ugly and loud compared to this part of the song. IMO, it sounds great if you change normal to soft and add whistles on 1-8, but don't remove the finish from 4 and 8. All Fixed

00:39:213 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) Same thing here, change timing to soft on the point right before here and add whistles on all the notes, but keep claps and finishes on the ones that have them Done, and fixed hit sounds

Wingin It

I don't see anything wrong per se, but then again I'm no good at anything harder that the average hard difficulty

Yoshi348 wrote:

I can only personally see issues with Hard at the moment, so this is going well. As a personal style issue, I really don't like it when the song starts fading out DURING play, but I don't know if that's easily fixable without messing up the map in other ways. Might as well fade it out with it then...

[Hard]

00:39:21 (1-11) - The extra spacing throughout this combo compared to the rest of the map isn't intuitive at all. Sorry, no change
00:59:78 (1-12) - ^second verse, same as the first ^

minyeob wrote:

Well, there were many things to make a fault with but they're not major issues.
Ex) You have to use more "New combo"s on Normal. 15 is too high fixed

Map looks fine for me.

Kytoxid wrote:

[All]

Preview point not set. Done

01:16:07 (1) - I'd remove the finish, and possibly silence it, since the music is fading out. Done

[Easy]

00:08:78 (4,5,1,2) - 1-2 is a bit closer than 5-1. Maybe move these so that 5 is right to the left of 4, and then 1-2 form an equilateral triangle above it? done
01:04:49 (4,1,2) - Slight nazi, but up to this point, 1/1 haven't had any overlap, so maybe space these out a bit. Done

[Normal]

00:20:35 (1,2) - Consider turning 2 so that it's parallel to 1. Done
00:30:64 (5) - Move this down a grid, for better spacing? Done
00:33:64 (4,5) - A bit closer than the others. Done
01:06:21 (2,3) - A bit farther than the others. Done

[Hard]

00:13:71 (10) - I think it sounds better without this note. Nonetheless, if you keep the note, shift the timing section for it a bit earlier (1/4 should do) in case the player hits the note early. shifted the timing
00:10:92 (2,3,4) - 2-3 don't overlap, but 3-4 do. (not going to pick on this for the rest of the song) fixed
00:22:28 (5) - Move this upwards to line it up with 4? no
00:37:92 (8) - Maybe shift this note to where the 6 was before. Done
00:39:21 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'd make this not-lopsided. nope
00:57:85 (4,5) - Quite an unexpected jump. fixed

[Wingin' It]

00:10:49 (12) - New combo?
01:19:92 (1) - Maybe end this a bit earlier.

Cool maps/songs.

Essien wrote:

Easy:
01:16:927 (6): Maybe new combo? Done
01:19:927 (11): Move a grid up. Done

Normal:
00:01:070 (2): Move a grid right to align with (1). Done
00:23:355 (6): Align with (4). Done
00:46:498 (1): No need for new combo. Done
00:55:498 (3): Move a grid up to align with (1). Done

Hard:
00:55:498 (1): Weird shape.
01:00:855 (6-12): Spacing (unless it's a jump).

Wingin' it:
no probs.


star~

Nharox wrote:

[Wingin' It]

00:28:070 (10) - Too close to the previous note.
00:43:070 (6) - This slider looks like out of place.
00:50:784 (1) - Remove combo

[Hard]

00:29:355 (1) - Too close to the previous note. fixed
00:34:498 (9) - New combo fixed
00:34:927 (1) - Remove old combo fixed
00:35:784 (5) - New combo fixed
01:04:498 (6) - New combo fixed
01:05:355 (1) - Remove old combo fixed
01:13:070 (1) - Move this one closer to (2) fixed

Sorry for the combo corrections but otherwise some players might find them confusing then (lol weird sentence).

[Easy & Normal] are fine.

Tanmak wrote:

Sorry to late modding T.T

[General]
I suggest that set preview time to 00:41:355. (All difficulty) Done

[Hard]
Some part, distance of between note and note is different in somewhere. @.@
I think you need to place note again with keeping spacing rule generally.

00:35:141 (1) Why new combo? Dissolve new combo. Done

The other difficulty is fine.

Starred.

tmokb93 wrote:

Mod's Info:
Mine are all suggestions. You're free to follow or not this mod :3 I'll just mod the beats in your map, in all its forms, will not tell you to add or remove the beat <3

[General]
Add some other tags. I guess I should add AeonWing

[Easy]
00:50:355 (5) Move it 1/1 before and extend it by 1/1 moved it, but added note

[Normal]
Increase Circle Size by 1 (on the tick in the middle to Large and Normal) nah
Seems fine afterall ^^

[Hard]
00:04:070 (4,5,6) Move them 1/4 before and, if you like, add a hitcircle in 00:04:498 added a note in the space..

[Wingin' It]
Spacing is wrong! Recheck.

And that's all for your map. I hope you will ask again for a mod x3 Starred.

Shulin wrote:

General:

-- Make sure the preview point is the same on all difficulties. Done
-- Make sure tags are the same on all difficulties, also you don't need Klonoa in the tags since it's in the source. Done
-- Generally I didn't like the claps, imo you could use whistles instead but that's up to you. I removed a lot They do sound nasty

Easy:

00:25:927 (5) - New combo. Done

Normal:

-- Set a preview point (make it the same as Hard) I changed it for all before reading this part. XD
-- Why is Aeonwing in tags only in this difficulty? Deleted ;-;

No major problems

Hard:

00:04:927 (8) - Just make this soft, it's the only place you go normal hitsounds and it sounds a little silly. Done
00:12:641 (6) - New combo? Done
00:15:213 (1) - Remove new combo? Done
00:16:070 (2) - New combo? Done
00:20:784 (1,2,3) - Align this, make it like 00:27:642 (5,6,7) - Done
00:28:285 (7) - Move down one square for symmetry. Done
00:33:213 (6,7) - Arrange these notes so they don't overlap? dONE
00:49:070 (9) - New combo? Done
00:49:927 (10) - Remove finish from the start. Done
00:52:927 (6,7,8) - Move up two squares to align, adjust notes after if you take this suggestion. Done
00:53:355 (9) - Move this to the right with distance snap. Done
00:55:498 (1) - Remove new combo? Done

Overall: Check for combo consistency and alignment, in Hard you seem to use shorter combos towards the end (not sure if it was intentional.) Also are you still waiting for a guest difficulty? If not make sure to update the beatmap description. Anyway, all the maps are good so let me know about changes and then I'll give a proto bubble.

Well... this has been pending too long, and he hasn't been on in months. So I guess no more.

~ Star + Kudos Star. Thank you

[DBF] wrote:

[Easy]
00:46:498 - maybe add a bit?
1:19:927-1:21:213 - maybe add spinner?[/color] done
[Normal]
all good.
[Hard]
00:09:641 - remove clap.
00:45:641 - ^[/color] done
1:15:213 - spacing? done

SPOILER

Relax good map, star~

Larto wrote:

Folder:
Remove the .osb from the folder, then full submit. removed

Timing:
Offset: 202 applied and snapped!

Hard:
Good!

Normal:
Good!

Easy:
01:02:784 (2,3) - I dislike how 3 overlaps 2 a bit. It's just a bit ugly, so if you don't really want to change it, you don't have to spaced accordingly

Great map! Keep up the good work!

James2250 wrote:

easy:
00:10:059 (1,2) - I would switch new combo to 2 done
00:46:487 (6,1) - switch new combo? done

normal:
looks good

hard:
00:53:773 (1,2) - make new combo on 2? done

*star*