I will be referring to the following phrase in the ranking criteria:
Right now it is unclear what is considered "primarily known", and also which sources are not allowed for the Source field.
I will be referring to this map which has recently been ranked: beatmapsets/1702760#taiko/3479183
Initially when it was uploaded it had "Indihome" as the source as the song came from a commerical from this company. However, Faputa marked a Problem with it and it got removed, stating that "Use source when its directly tied to video game, movie, series, event, etc., Indihome is a company and their advertisement campaign isn't "Indihome" either"
However, I feel that the Source field should be used here, the song clearly would be "primarily known" to anyone who knows of it, specifically Indonesians I'm assuming. Faputa mentioned that it's a similar case for FA songs using the osu! source. In this case, in which osu! is one of or the only media the song is featured in, I feel it should not apply, unless it is widely known as an "osu! song".
As a song being directly tied to a brand, I think the Source field should apply here, it did for another recently ranked song: beatmapsets/1777816#osu/3640854 in which the Source was "Student Finance England" which similarly does not fall under Faputa's proposal of Source only applying for "video game, movie, series, event, etc.".
Would like some clarification on this in the RC if possible, here are my proposed changes:
You must use the Source field if the song comes from or is directly tied to another media such as a video game, movie, series, event, etc. This also applies if the song was featured or tied to a media after it was released, but is primarily known due to that source. If a song has multiple potential sources, any option is valid.
Right now it is unclear what is considered "primarily known", and also which sources are not allowed for the Source field.
I will be referring to this map which has recently been ranked: beatmapsets/1702760#taiko/3479183
Initially when it was uploaded it had "Indihome" as the source as the song came from a commerical from this company. However, Faputa marked a Problem with it and it got removed, stating that "Use source when its directly tied to video game, movie, series, event, etc., Indihome is a company and their advertisement campaign isn't "Indihome" either"
However, I feel that the Source field should be used here, the song clearly would be "primarily known" to anyone who knows of it, specifically Indonesians I'm assuming. Faputa mentioned that it's a similar case for FA songs using the osu! source. In this case, in which osu! is one of or the only media the song is featured in, I feel it should not apply, unless it is widely known as an "osu! song".
As a song being directly tied to a brand, I think the Source field should apply here, it did for another recently ranked song: beatmapsets/1777816#osu/3640854 in which the Source was "Student Finance England" which similarly does not fall under Faputa's proposal of Source only applying for "video game, movie, series, event, etc.".
Would like some clarification on this in the RC if possible, here are my proposed changes:
You must use the Source field if the song comes from or is directly tied to another media such as a video game, movie, series, event, brand, etc. This also applies if the song was featured or tied to a media when or after it was released, but is primarily known or associated due to that source. If a song has multiple potential sources, any option is valid.