forum

pumpkin pie: yay or nay?

posted
Total Posts
13

do you like pumpkin pie?

yes
7
41.18%
no
2
11.76%
never had it
8
47.06%
Total votes: 17
Topic Starter
Jonarwhal
greetings

i was considering opening a pumpkin pie stand for that American holiday thing
but upon searching cute pumpkin pie pics i found that there is a vocal minority who despises pumpkin pie
I'll start by acknowledging a few things

1) this is irrelevant for the vast majority of you because said holiday is an American tradition. you are probably laughing from a distance wondering why Americans fight over such silly things. But some of you I'm hoping have had the chance to try it and in which case I'd like your thoughts.

2) The question is not "is pumpkin pie your favorite pie?" but rather "do you like pumpkin pie?" Since there are plenty of pies the odds of this particular pie being your favorite get lower as more pies are thought of. My favorite traditional pies are cherry and blueberry, and then I like chocolate pies but whether or not these art actually pies is another debate entirely. Don't say you hate it just because you like apple pie a lot more.

now votevotevotevotevotevotevotevote
ClevelandsMyBro
never had one lol
Winnyace

ClevelandsMyBro wrote:

never had one lol
Phantonym

ClevelandsMyBro wrote:

never had one lol
same
Nuuskamuikkunen
I have had pumpkin pie, but not specifically the american variation, but rather made from another curcubitaceae called Cabell d'angel (which its procediments are considerably distinct, as it's made from caramelized pumpkin), so I can't tell you clearly.



I generally don't like pumpkin, but I love pumpkin cake, so I might give pumpkin pie a chance if I manage to eat it someday.

Jonarwhal wrote:

you are probably laughing from a distance wondering why Americans fight over such silly things
These kind of fights happen in literally every country xp
Foxi
As long as it has whipped cream on it, it's always a yay from me.
Topic Starter
Jonarwhal

eblf2013 wrote:

I have had pumpkin pie, but not specifically the american variation, but rather made from another curcubitaceae called Cabell d'angel (which its procediments are considerably distinct, as it's made from caramelized pumpkin), so I can't tell you clearly.



I generally don't like pumpkin, but I love pumpkin cake, so I might give pumpkin pie a chance if I manage to eat it someday.

Jonarwhal wrote:

you are probably laughing from a distance wondering why Americans fight over such silly things
These kind of fights happen in literally every country xp
lo quiero
Nuuskamuikkunen

Jonarwhal wrote:

eblf2013 wrote:

I have had pumpkin pie, but not specifically the american variation, but rather made from another curcubitaceae called Cabell d'angel (which its procediments are considerably distinct, as it's made from caramelized pumpkin), so I can't tell you clearly.



I generally don't like pumpkin, but I love pumpkin cake, so I might give pumpkin pie a chance if I manage to eat it someday.

Jonarwhal wrote:

you are probably laughing from a distance wondering why Americans fight over such silly things
These kind of fights happen in literally every country xp
lo quiero
Espero que mi mamá lo prepare pronto, acabo de traer una calabaza de cabello de ángel >w<
samX500
I have never had a pumpkin pie but I did eat some pumpkin one time when I was very young and I remember that I thought it tested like carrot. If pumpkin pie is similar to carrot pie (or rather cake) I would probably love it as carrot cake are among my favorite sort of cake.
Nuuskamuikkunen

samX500 wrote:

I have never had a pumpkin pie but I did eat some pumpkin one time when I was very young and I remember that I thought it tested like carrot. If pumpkin pie is similar to carrot pie (or rather cake) I would probably love it as carrot cake are among my favorite sort of cake.
I find their taste considerably different, yet both cakes are delicious.
Hydreigon
tried it once, didn't really like it, as I'm not a huge fan of pumpkins

still prefer tree trunk's apple pie
Yukanna
yea i like it.
sadave
pumpkin taste like yo grandma hairy crack
Please sign in to reply.

New reply