updated
entah kenapa saya setuju oke terserah Harez deh '3'Momochikun wrote:
Harez tambahin "easy" dund ke guest diff lu..
entah kenapa saya setujul bukankah itu terlihat menarik? ahuehuehue, terserah mapper sih, kan saya hanya seorang guest mapper 8^)AlpacaCokelat wrote:
entah kenapa saya setuju oke terserah Harez deh '3'Momochikun wrote:
Harez tambahin "easy" dund ke guest diff lu..
kalo aku sih oke2 aja, gausah diganti juga ga apa2Harez wrote:
entah kenapa saya setujul bukankah itu terlihat menarik? ahuehuehue, terserah mapper sih, kan saya hanya seorang guest mapper 8^)
thanks~!Neiji Razuiya wrote:
hai owo/
i want say your map almost perfect~
easy and normal is perfect o3o)b
i giving you kudos star .w.
i'll give you suggest only ok?
Hard:
03:27:795 (3) - added NC nope i want to make it in a same combo with 03:26:081 (1,2) -
03:31:009 - added NC fix
this only my suggest :3
GET THIS RANKED!!!!!!
Mystyk wrote:
Hi! Your requested mod (from a long time ago ( I'm sorry >.<) it's okay :3
Normal:
01:15:795 (1,1,2) - I think you should replace these 01:17:509 (1,2) - for better flow (try to flip it vertically and play around with it[ color=#800080]fix[/color]
01:25:224 (2,3) - why don't you use a slider instead of 2 hit circles? his singing is long so it would fit better fix
02:20:938 (1,2) - I think this would flow better: http://puu.sh/4jGDs.jpg - because http://puu.sh/4jGHm.jpg --> http://puu.sh/4jGFl.jpg fix
02:31:224 (1,2) - I think something like this would look a lot better: http://puu.sh/4jHz9.jpg fix
02:41:509 (1,2) - I think this might be confusing for players - http://puu.sh/4o4kL.jpg - so I would suggest something like this: http://puu.sh/4o4n5.jpg nah, i guess intermediate players won't get confused with this
03:10:652 (2) - ctrl+G on this for better flow fix
Hard:
00:12:367 (1) - try a nicer shape: http://puu.sh/4o4zq.jpg (this is only a bit different, but still nicer) fix
00:13:224 (2) - same ^ fix
00:20:938 (1) - flip this vertically, it will flow better: http://puu.sh/4o4JU.jpg fix
00:22:652 (3) - flip horizontally? better flow - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/977274 fix
00:24:367 (1) - after the previous suggestion, flip this one horizontally too: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/977277 fix
00:29:509 (1) - try to make this nicer too, just like in the first 2 suggestions - http://puu.sh/4o55k.jpg i prefer the current one
00:34:652 (1,2,3) - why is the distance different? - http://puu.sh/4o5hR.jpg - make them equal i want to make a jump between (2) and (3), but i might reconsider about this
00:36:152 (4,5) - same as above ^ ^
00:38:081 (1,2,3) - same as 00:34:652 (1,2,3) - especially that I think it's copy paste >.< ^, and yes it's a copy paste lol
00:49:652 (2) - this has 1,00 spacing, then why does this have 00:50:081 (3,4) - 1,62? that is too big and it doesn't look nice that it's different, so please fix the spacing fix
01:25:224 (3,4,5,6,1) - here it would fit better if you put hit circles instead of the reverse slider and used a long slider instead of hit circles, because of the way he is singing - http://puu.sh/4oay1.jpg i'm not really following the vocal in this part
01:40:652 (3,4,5) - spacing issue again fix
01:46:652 (1,2,3) - fix the spacing please: http://puu.sh/4oaXo.jpg fix
03:04:652 (2,3) - I think this would be more enjoyable to play: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/979984 fix
03:12:152 (4,1) - put them closer i want to keep the symmetry
03:12:367 (1,2) - make a blanket? - http://puu.sh/4ptOh.jpg fix
03:13:224 (2,3) - same as above ^ fix
MAX:
00:03:795 (1) - add clap, you can clearly hear it in the music fix
00:14:938 (5,6) - the flow breaks here in my opinion, something like this would flow better: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/979997 fix
00:22:867 (2,3) - I think you could make this more fun, if you used shorter sliders to make it fit better to the lyrics, just an example: i prefer the current onehttp://puu.sh/4pu2h.jpg
00:56:724 (4,5) - placing a hit circle at the end of a slider is not good in my opinion, it is confusing, so I would replace (4) will consider, yeah
01:53:509 (1) - it would be nice if you made a triplet instead of that long reverse slider, and if you made a short reverse slider out of 01:54:367 (3) - like this: http://puu.sh/4pDt2.jpg - it fits better to the lyrics will consider about this
02:04:652 (2,3,1) - spacing is bad here, you put (1) too far (or (2) is too close) so you should fix it fix
02:15:367 (3,4,5,6) - spacing is weird again, you put jumps when it it not necessary, put them closer fix
02:19:759 - add hit circle because of the lyrics kinda confusing to play if i add a circle there
Also please check AiMod, because it seems like letterbox is different in some difficulties. Good Luck!
Thank you very much!! :'>UnitedWeSin wrote:
Hi^^
[General][MAX]
- Seems good.
mostly fix all
- 00:03:795 (1) - Clap on end
- 00:08:081 (4,5) - This is kind of unfitting and difficult to understand since the 5 isn't really following the part in the music that it represents. Try instead a 1/2 slider with a repeat. Here's the idea:
Example
Or you could even try a triplet, but if you did you'd probably want to add more notes through the rest of the section:- 00:20:509 - I think if you add a note here to follow the vocals it will make the triplet 00:20:724 (1,2,3) much easier to catch.
- 00:25:224 (3) - (400,312)? Make perfect triangle.
- 00:26:938 (3,1) - I'd suggest that you reduce this jump a bit. Raw jumps to triplets like this can be difficult to catch, especially on a first playthrough. You do some later in the map also that could use some reduced spacing imo.
- 00:40:652 (1,2,3) - Try this setup instead for a more natural flow from the 00:40:224 (8).
- 00:42:259 (4) - Delete this is better imo. The vocals don't make a triplet here like they did at 00:41:831 (2) so it's uncomfortable.
- 00:44:081 (1,2,3) - Really confusing spacing. The spacing between 1-2 is the same as spacing between 2-3, but between 1-2 is 1/3 while between 2-3 is 1/2. Try to move the 2 closer to the 1. Make it more like the 00:09:795 (1,2,3).
- 00:49:224 (2,3) - The gap is awkward to play imo because the vocals are holding, and I can't hear a specific bass beat in the music for 00:49:652 (3,4) to be following. It would be better if the 2 were a 1/2 or 1/1 slider, similar to 00:52:652 (2).
- 00:50:938 (6,7,8,9) - Try to use a slightly smaller and more even spacing here.
- 00:56:081 (2,3) - Same as 00:49:224 (2,3). The anti jump here isn't fitting very well imo.
- 01:03:152 - Try adding a note to follow the music. i'm following the dominant guitar here
- 01:04:867 - ^ ^
- 01:06:581 - ^ ^
- 01:10:224 (12) - Try moving it to 01:10:009. It seems much more fitting with the guitar.
- 01:11:938 (10) - ^ Move it 1/2 earlier.
- 01:13:438 - Try adding a note.
- 01:20:938 (1) - The repeat of this slider isn't really fitting with vocals. I suggest remove the repeat from here and extend the slier by 1/4. Then add a circle at 01:21:581.
- 01:26:938 (4) - Try changing to 1/2 slider and adding a circle at 01:27:367. The gap isn't really fitting with vocals here.
- 01:37:974 (8) - Delete this seems much better for me because the vocals do not sound in 1/4 here. Then you can increase spacing to the 01:38:081 (1). Right now the 1/4 jump you have doesn't play very nice imo.
- 01:59:509 (3) - 1 grid left so that it's placed on the center line.
- 02:07:009 (1,2,1) - Try to make spacing consistent between these since the vocals switch on the end of the slider 02:07:009 (1). It would feel nicer if you had consistent spacing between these. Also you could remove NC from the beginning of the stream imo.
- 02:14:081 (1) - Try a finish on the head because the chorus resets here.
- 02:31:224 (1,3) - Try to rotate the 3 a bit and avoid the overlap with the 1.
- 02:35:509 (1,2,3) - It's easy to read these as 1/4 sliders. I'd suggest to just use sliders with repeat so that the player does not have to click in 1/3. It will feel more natural, and you can make nice jumps between the sliders like you have: will consider, though, i really like these 1/3 sliders, and i don't want to make it the same with earlier 1/3 reversed sliders
- 02:39:795 (1,2) - Imo it would play better as a slider with a repeat and then a circle to click since her vocals spike at the end of the phrase.
- 03:25:867 (4,1,2) - You can make a more even flow if you move these more downwards:
I think this diff could use a lot more work. As this is an Insane diff, try to fill the rhythm sets more using sliders/triplets/circles when they fit. Try to use more consistent spacings and work more on flow also.
[Hard][Normal]
- 00:03:795 (1) - Clap seems more fitting than finish imo. fix
- 00:14:938 (4,5) - I think it would be nicer to unstack these. When they are stacked, it's more difficult to read the rhythm on the 5, and it might confusing players because the 5 is mapped here on the red tick but at 00:08:724 that same sound wasn't mapped.
- 00:34:652 (1) - Finish on the head. fix
- 01:34:545 (2,3) - Try to use a much smaller spacing on these like you do in the MAX diff. fix
- 01:39:795 (1,2,3,4) - The 1/4 spacing on the sliders is a bit much for hard imo. Better to use 1.0 spacing through this whole combo. This is mapped in a much more difficult way here than you mapped it in the Insane diff. fix
- 02:10:224 (8,1,2) - I highly suggest unstack all of these. It's a trap and will frustrate players because it's very difficult to understand, especially when you're stacking sliders of different lengths with repeats. fix
- 02:14:081 (1) - Finish on the head is nice because the verse starts again here.fix
- 02:38:081 - Useless green line. fix
- 03:23:509 (3) - It seems much nicer to end the slider at 03:24:367. I think you could shorten the slider and still make a neat shape with an arm that blankets the head. Then add a circle at 03:24:795. fix
Anyways, I think the mapset could use a lot more work, especially the MAX diff. As it is an Insane diff, I don't think you've mapped enough notes. There are lots of gaps in rhythm that break the flow of the map and would have been much nicer if there was a slider or something to fill it.
- 01:02:081 (1,2,3) - This rhythm feels weak with the constant 1/4 in the music here, I think it's difficult for the player to follow. I'd prefer that you use long sliders like at 01:08:938 (1,2) and then have a circle to click with the loud claps like at 01:02:938. Try using that rhythm here also. i guess no, because i don't want to make a long repetition of this rhythm 01:08:938 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
- 01:08:938 (1) - Finish on the head. fix
- 01:36:367 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Feels like too much 1/1 and it starts to feel a bit monotonous. I suggest replace the 3 and 4 in each combo with a slider instead. fix in my own way
- 02:00:367 (1) - Finish on the head. fix
- 02:03:367 (6,1) - Watch your spacing there. fix
- 02:06:795 (6,1) - ^ fix
- 02:14:081 (1) - Try a finish on the head as in the other diffs. fix
- 03:22:652 (1) - Just a general suggestion for the whole mapset really. Sliders like this would look much better if you made them symmetrical in the center of the grid first before placing them. Place the middle slider tick in the center of the red anchors: fix, but i'm mixing it with my own style
Good luck, I hope this is helpful to you. c: this is more than helpful!! >w< i was planning to remap some old parts on MAX and Hard since i mapped them when i wasn't really good at playing std, but i hesitated a bit. But now i realized this map has a loong way to go, so yeah