mancusojuanmattos wrote:

IRC Recheck in Epic

20:17 mancusojuanmattos: Hi (?
20:25 Kyshiro: hai
20:26 mancusojuanmattos: I have some little things to say you, can I talk it them here?
20:26 Kyshiro: oh yeah sure
20:27 mancusojuanmattos: in Epic
20:28 mancusojuanmattos: 00:12:077 (2,3,4,5) - Flows awkwardly to me, looking the jump i think that plays better  1/4 sliders
20:28 mancusojuanmattos: instead of single notes
20:28 Kyshiro: hm yeah, that works too
20:29 Kyshiro: fixed
20:30 mancusojuanmattos: 00:18:224 (3) - looks better if you move this 1 grid down (yeah, nazi xD)
20:30 Kyshiro: naziiii
20:30 Kyshiro: but yeah, you're right lol
20:30 Kyshiro: fixed
20:31 mancusojuanmattos: 01:28:060 (4) - Reduce the slider length in 1/4, and add a note in 01:28:429 -
20:32 mancusojuanmattos: I think the beat in 01:28:306 needs a note
20:32 Kyshiro: yeah it does
20:33 mancusojuanmattos: done?
20:33 Kyshiro: fixed yeah
20:34 mancusojuanmattos: 01:30:519 (5) - This should be a single note instead of a 1/4 Slider, I listened the music in 25% and I couldn't percive any sound in 01:30:642-
20:34 mancusojuanmattos: 01:30:519 (5) - This should be a single note instead of a 1/4 Slider, I listened the music in 25% and I couldn't percive any sound in 01:30:642-
20:35 Kyshiro: okay fixed
20:35 mancusojuanmattos: 01:38:388 (1) - Same thing here, there is no sound in 01:38:511 -
20:36 mancusojuanmattos: so, I'd use 2 Notes over the downbeat and the next red tick
20:36 Kyshiro: meh 
20:36 Kyshiro: this kind of works as a tripple though
20:36 mancusojuanmattos: it doesn't to me.. It sounded kinda weird the 1st time that I played the map
20:36 mancusojuanmattos: I thought that it was just me..
20:37 mancusojuanmattos: but listening the music in 25% I could find this bad usage of 1/4 :/
20:37 Kyshiro: well okay, fixed it
20:39 mancusojuanmattos: 01:54:126 (1,2) - Just wondering if this overlap is intentional, because looks a bit weird.
20:39 Kyshiro: wtf
20:39 Kyshiro: idk what happened there, not intentional
20:39 mancusojuanmattos: I thought so xD
20:40 Kyshiro: alright fixed
20:41 mancusojuanmattos: that's should be all in this diff.
20:41 mancusojuanmattos: I rechecked the other diffs, and they looks in order too
20:41 mancusojuanmattos: so, you can update
20:41 Kyshiro: alright :3
20:42 Kyshiro: updated

I really want to rank this map, but I think we had to make important changes especially in 'Superior' (and some in Epic too).
So, here is your Bubbled restored!
Hope to see this map ranked soon!

Ayu wrote:

mancusojuanmattos wrote:

IRC Recheck in Epic

20:17 mancusojuanmattos: Hi (?
20:25 Kyshiro: hai
20:26 mancusojuanmattos: I have some little things to say you, can I talk it them here?
20:26 Kyshiro: oh yeah sure
20:27 mancusojuanmattos: in Epic
20:28 mancusojuanmattos: 00:12:077 (2,3,4,5) - Flows awkwardly to me, looking the jump i think that plays better  1/4 sliders
20:28 mancusojuanmattos: instead of single notes
20:28 Kyshiro: hm yeah, that works too
20:29 Kyshiro: fixed
20:30 mancusojuanmattos: 00:18:224 (3) - looks better if you move this 1 grid down (yeah, nazi xD)
20:30 Kyshiro: naziiii
20:30 Kyshiro: but yeah, you're right lol
20:30 Kyshiro: fixed
20:31 mancusojuanmattos: 01:28:060 (4) - Reduce the slider length in 1/4, and add a note in 01:28:429 -
20:32 mancusojuanmattos: I think the beat in 01:28:306 needs a note
20:32 Kyshiro: yeah it does
20:33 mancusojuanmattos: done?
20:33 Kyshiro: fixed yeah
20:34 mancusojuanmattos: 01:30:519 (5) - This should be a single note instead of a 1/4 Slider, I listened the music in 25% and I couldn't percive any sound in 01:30:642-
20:34 mancusojuanmattos: 01:30:519 (5) - This should be a single note instead of a 1/4 Slider, I listened the music in 25% and I couldn't percive any sound in 01:30:642-
20:35 Kyshiro: okay fixed
20:35 mancusojuanmattos: 01:38:388 (1) - Same thing here, there is no sound in 01:38:511 -
20:36 mancusojuanmattos: so, I'd use 2 Notes over the downbeat and the next red tick
20:36 Kyshiro: meh 
20:36 Kyshiro: this kind of works as a tripple though
20:36 mancusojuanmattos: it doesn't to me.. It sounded kinda weird the 1st time that I played the map
20:36 mancusojuanmattos: I thought that it was just me..
20:37 mancusojuanmattos: but listening the music in 25% I could find this bad usage of 1/4 :/
20:37 Kyshiro: well okay, fixed it
20:39 mancusojuanmattos: 01:54:126 (1,2) - Just wondering if this overlap is intentional, because looks a bit weird.
20:39 Kyshiro: wtf
20:39 Kyshiro: idk what happened there, not intentional
20:39 mancusojuanmattos: I thought so xD
20:40 Kyshiro: alright fixed
20:41 mancusojuanmattos: that's should be all in this diff.
20:41 mancusojuanmattos: I rechecked the other diffs, and they looks in order too
20:41 mancusojuanmattos: so, you can update
20:41 Kyshiro: alright :3
20:42 Kyshiro: updated

I really want to rank this map, but I think we had to make important changes especially in 'Superior' (and some in Epic too).
So, here is your Bubbled restored!
Hope to see this map ranked soon!

damnit.. Why not just rank it? The map is obviously ready and definitely good.

Kyshiro wrote:

idk but i'll stop asking bats, they'll just pop for the lulz and rebubble

Mashley wrote:

Audio quality sounds really low. It's technically 192kbps but it sounds a lot lower to me and the mp3 filename suggests to me that it was ripped from a youtube video. It's not up to standard and you should find a better one.

Mashley wrote:

Audio quality sounds really low. It's technically 192kbps but it sounds a lot lower to me and the mp3 filename suggests to me that it was ripped from a youtube video. It's not up to standard and you should find a better one.
As for the mapping, I'm not doing a proper mod but your spacing on [Epic] is frustratingly inconsistent; for example, why is 01:30:519 (5) - different from the usual pattern of putting the 1/4s closer?

Kyshiro wrote:

Mashley wrote:

Audio quality sounds really low. It's technically 192kbps but it sounds a lot lower to me and the mp3 filename suggests to me that it was ripped from a youtube video. It's not up to standard and you should find a better one.
As for the mapping, I'm not doing a proper mod but your spacing on [Epic] is frustratingly inconsistent; for example, why is 01:30:519 (5) - different from the usual pattern of putting the 1/4s closer?

The audio really sounds fine to me with headphones as well as speakers, I'll try and look for a better quality and see if there's any difference though.

At the spacing: This one is a bit different indeed although I don't see how it'll cause any problems, however the rest is put the way it is on purpose, and I repeatedly used the same spacing for the same pattern the notes are put in.

Thanks for the reply

Gonzvlo wrote:

For some reason I couldn't analize the mp3, which is not a good indicator. Just in case, I'm leaving a 192kbps iTunes encoded version of the 320 kbps single

192kbps

320kbps

About the map, I actually like this song that's why I was looking forward to checking this map, sadly I'm not fond of many of those 3/4 sliders, that's why I'll pass this time.

Roddie wrote:

Let me state my opinion about Epic:

At first, knowing that Drive By by Train is being mapped, I was excited over it. I tried out Epic; finished afterwards and to be frank... it's not really a fun difficulty to play because of the rhythm it's put into. Too much use of 3/4. A couple of random rhythm placement that don't seem fitting to the song. I'm not very impressed by this honestly. Consider giving some thought when you're gonna get your map ranked. Well, good luck, man.

mancusojuanmattos wrote:

Changed some things over IRC. He still has a lot of 3/4 but at least most of them sound fitting
Rebubbled

1. Clear~

1. 00:15:886 - Add a circle here. Inconsistant with your next and previous rhythm.
2. 00:26:213 - Please add a circle here since you miss a clap sounds in this spot. If you want a bit break, do it at 00:25:722 - so it will be consistant with 00:20:803 (1,2,3,4) - and 00:27:197 (1,2,3) -
3. 00:44:902 (1,2) - Please don't. Shape like this can be extremely confusing to beginner.
4. 01:29:656 (5,1) - Switch NC here. The new stanza start at 5 not 1.
5. 02:25:721 (4) - Current combo is too long, there should be a NC here.
6. 03:06:049 (1) - Remove the whistle. It sounds weird, imo.

1. 00:14:656 (4) - Add a whistle here? Feels empty without it.
2. 01:37:526 (3) - You miss a whistle at this circle.
3. 02:11:460 (1,2,3) - Why not following vocal here? It's a bit weird, since you following vocal on previous combo, but switch to basic beat on this combo.
4. 02:42:935 (1,2,3,4) - Ugh, same. Please follow vocal on this combo too.
5. 03:06:542 (1,2,3) - Same ^

1. 00:12:197 (3) - Add a whistle here? Feels too empty without any whistle on this combo.

1. 00:07:526 (3,4,5) - Use 0.4x spacing here please like you do on almost 90% of your 1/4 spacing. It's feels that just a few 1.1x spacing that you use on entire diff. Better to make all the spacing on 1/4 rhythim same and consistant.
2. 00:13:919 (4,5,6) - ^
3. 00:36:296 (3,4,1) - ^
4. 00:38:263 (4,5,1) - ^
5. 00:56:214 (1,2,3) - ^
6. 02:33:099 (3,4,5) - ^

Miya wrote:

Hello~

General

1. Clear~

Superior

1. 00:14:656 (4) - Add a whistle here? Feels empty without it. Okay
2. 01:37:526 (3) - You miss a whistle at this circle. Added
3. 02:11:460 (1,2,3) - Why not following vocal here? It's a bit weird, since you following vocal on previous combo, but switch to basic beat on this combo. It's a normal diff after all, a simple rhythm every now and then should be fine, this would also increase the star rating drastically
4. 02:42:935 (1,2,3,4) - Ugh, same. Please follow vocal on this combo too. ^
5. 03:06:542 (1,2,3) - Same ^

Exquisite

1. 00:12:197 (3) - Add a whistle here? Feels too empty without any whistle on this combo. Okay added

Epic

1. 00:07:526 (3,4,5) - Use 0.4x spacing here please like you do on almost 90% of your 1/4 spacing. It's feels that just a few 1.1x spacing that you use on entire diff. Better to make all the spacing on 1/4 rhythim same and consistant. I did this because moving from a slider to a note is extremely simple, the spacing differences are consistent depending on the way the notes/sliders are put together, I haven't seen anyone that had a problem playing this either
2. 00:13:919 (4,5,6) - ^
3. 00:36:296 (3,4,1) - ^
4. 00:38:263 (4,5,1) - ^
5. 00:56:214 (1,2,3) - ^
6. 02:33:099 (3,4,5) - ^

I wonder why a lot of people dislike 3/4 o.o
It's fine to me, i can play it well and without any problem.

Miya wrote:

Hello~


Fine

1. 00:15:886 - Add a circle here. Inconsistant with your next and previous rhythm. No ;_;
2. 00:26:213 - Please add a circle here since you miss a clap sounds in this spot. If you want a bit break, do it at 00:25:722 - so it will be consistant with 00:20:803 (1,2,3,4) - and 00:27:197 (1,2,3) - ^
3. 00:44:902 (1,2) - Please don't. Shape like this can be extremely confusing to beginner. Changed
4. 01:29:656 (5,1) - Switch NC here. The new stanza start at 5 not 1. k
5. 02:25:721 (4) - Current combo is too long, there should be a NC here. k
6. 03:06:049 (1) - Remove the whistle. It sounds weird, imo. k

1. 00:25:721 (3) - I'm still suggesting this since if you skip a drum sound without any clear reason. Move this note to 00:26:213 - then add a clap.If you still don't want to fix this. It's okay, i can't stop you.
2. 01:46:869 (4) - Woops, i miss this one. Add a NC here, combo is too long.

1. 02:22:280 (4) - I suggest to delete this circle since there is no vocal on the music at this spot. So it's a bit overmapped.

1. 00:48:591 (1,2) - Nazi, but this slider end doesnt stack perfectly.

1. 00:16:870 (1,2) - According to your NC pattern, the combo should be on 2. Switch NC?
2. 00:19:083 (6,1) - Same, switch NC here.

Miya wrote:

Recheck~
Superior

1. 02:22:280 (4) - I suggest to delete this circle since there is no vocal on the music at this spot. So it's a bit overmapped. Alright

Exquisite

1. 00:48:591 (1,2) - Nazi, but this slider end doesnt stack perfectly.Fixed

Epic

1. 00:16:870 (1,2) - According to your NC pattern, the combo should be on 2. Switch NC? Yeah, done
2. 00:19:083 (6,1) - Same, switch NC here. Fixed

That's all. Kd's or No, it's up to you :3

Kyshiro wrote:

[ But I can't give kudosu for a recheck right?

Miya wrote:

Kyshiro wrote:

[ But I can't give kudosu for a recheck right?

You can, there is no rule about it :3

Rechecked again, and i think it's enough.

Enjoy :3

Zero__wind wrote:

oh this finally got ranked. really nice rhythm