so faceman was the doctor? hmmm well I'm going to vote: Bakaloid or whatever his new name is as i was reading back and there really isn't anything backing him as townie.

Before we go and point fingers at random again, this day is still lylo. Don't lynch unless we got something.

We should look for those who defended Mimi more than others, I guess? Although he was a mafia godfather, we already have a cop claim, and I doubt there being two cops in such a small game. The story of a cop defending an overnight inno result, therefore, falls flat.

That said though if there IS any smart cop that has been trying to stay hidden in fear of getting roleblocked (and is playing a TERRIFIC game) now's about your time to come out and say it. Especially with the GF down.

Muffin, "he didn't prove he's town" doesn't mean "he's mafia." Nobody can prove they're town unless they get cleared by a cop. Who is now getting roleblocked days on end, I presume?

pieguy

Claimed cop. No CC's. Has no results due to being roleblocked, and his first check was a bit strange.
Shouldn't have claimed that early. Pieguy KNEW there was a roleblocker in the game because his first action got blocked. HE shouldn't have claimed when he did, with only two or three votes on him.
- Town in my book, though not playing very well

Quaraezha

Odd phrasing of terms: "I don't want an innocent to die," "defend the innocent,"
I took the liberty of going through the filipino werewolf game. On day one of the six-player game, Quaraezha votes off Nadeko under the reasoning that he's the least experienced. He also says he is thinking of a good strategy that way. That was Quaeza's town play, as an aux role. Right now, he's playing super cautious, and tripping on scumisms like using the word innocent too much.
- Definitely on the top of my list

Kokizi

Odd for Kokiziloid to protect Quaraezha lilke that, calling him a townie, when his playstyle seems to perfectly contradict that last Tagalog game. If Quaraezha is innocent and has learnt from his mistake in that last game, at least Koki's reaction here is incredibly off.
But on the other hand, later in game Mimi outright attacks Kokizi in a very long post. This is a common mafia tactic, but usually those don't arouse a great response because the subject knows the accuser is in their team. Kokizi defended vibrantly, Mimi responded, etc. Doesn't seem to be a team.
- Sort of scummy, but I'm thinking town.

Mashley

Mashley has been actively following the thread, but when it came to contributing, he hasn't done much. Most of his posts don't really show him being active, they create the illusion of activity. He overreacts against adam's jokevote, posts a TF2 quote, and then some "I'm still around!" posts.
Delving deeper on that first vote, he unvotes adam soon after the moment he strikes supicion with it.
- I don't know, really. Can very well be mafia, laying low.

iMuffin

Interesting fact Mimi raises on Day 1:

Kitsunemimi wrote:

Dude, they have a week to post, they just want to see how stuff plays out for the first little while, so they don't make a dumb decision on the first day. Either that, or they actually don't know for some reason, but it's not like it really matters that much.

In reaction to Quaraezha laying bare the people who haven't spoken: pieguy1372, dkun, 0_o, and iMuffin
One of those is our cop, the others are dead, sans iMuffin. Does this mean anything? Is iMuffin the worst mafia player of the worst mafia mafia player? I think it could. It seems scanning with Mimi's general attitude to protect fellow mobsters from suspicion.
- I don't like his face, but seeing as he's playing while not even caring and generally mucking everything up for town I dunno lynch him when we get the chance.

E-Hooker

I have to admit my intuition on the first day is starting to seem off. E-Hooker has been actively contributing, posting regularly, and chipping in on a recurring basis with her thoughts and foses. Still, reading through the thread two separate post of her boil down to "Wojjie, I'm a townie, don't suspect me." That was odd, I guess, though one was provoked by a cop report and the godfather is dead. Still, pieguy could be an insane cop, and E-Hooker is really clinging to that report.
- Town-y? I'm not going to trust that cop report too much.

Wojjan

Nothing but towntells, and active scumhunting. Townie and best player ever.

In general I am inching towards Quaraezha and Mashley for these reasons:
- The mafia cover for one another. Mimi hadn't been accusing Mashley, Mashley hadn't been accusing Mimi. Mashley did suspect Quarz at some point, but that was only a meek FOS.
- These two are FOSes of a dead aux role, 0_o, who has been playing actively. I know I shouldn't be blindly following him, but someone who has been confirmed by death said to keep an eye out for these two.

I keep getting the feeling I'm contradicting myself and forgetting a whole lot. Oh well, incomplete analysis then.

you were right i was far too hasty in my voting unvote for now. You have done a very thorough analysis of each living player and it's got me really thinking about things.

Also, are we saying there was only 3 mafia now? or are we still saying we started with 4?

Mm, I didn't realise I was coming cross as not contributing, sorry. I just don't like typing massive long posts. Anyway, this has probably been said before but it's essential that we evaluate someone heavily before the lynch today. Hammering another townie would be a disaster.

Requesting prods for pieguy, Quaraezha, E-Hooker and Kokizi.

roleclaim : townie

I prefer lurking, but I got prodded, so yeah XD

sorry guys, was insanely busy the past couple of days

/posting to say i'm alive

will be back in a bit to actually contribute

We're really not getting anywhere with this...

Kokizi wrote:

roleclaim : townie

I prefer lurking, but I got prodded, so yeah XD

Especially on lylo lurking is worse than useless. Why did you protect Quaraezha?

Sorry, I've been busy lately. I'll probably do an analysis soon...

Wojjan wrote:

Kokizi wrote:

roleclaim : townie

I prefer lurking, but I got prodded, so yeah XD

Especially on lylo lurking is worse than useless. Why did you protect Quaraezha?

On all the mafia games I played w/ him(played a couple of irc games w/ him too) that's how he always reacts to stuff(referring to the day 1 posts) and seeing as how he always ends up being lynched(pro-town role), he looked like town to me, so yeah.

Although of course, that doesn't mean that he's not mafia, I know metagaming is bad but tbh I just wanted to say how he reacts to things.

I think what I said, didn't make sense.

Kokizi wrote:

On all the mafia games I played w/ him(played a couple of irc games w/ him too) that's how he always reacts to stuff(referring to the day 1 posts)

how does this

Quaraezha wrote:

Vote Nazeko-chi
I was just thinking that if someone's gonna die, maybe the least-experienced person would do.

relate to this

Quaraezha wrote:

I'm really more of a "defend the innocent" than a "prosecute the guilty" kind of guy.
So that's how I roll~

in any semblance of way possible?

pieguy, I take by your short post that you were roleblocked tonight as well?

I'm getting the feeling you suck at mafia in general, Quaraezha, whatever your allignment.

I know you suck Quae, I was wondering more why you had our sudden change of heart regarding mafia play. And why Kokizi didn't realise it, having already played with you.

playing mafia with sucky people is annoying

not that i'm outright saying Quae sucks [also you can argue that I suck], but just one person can bring you to a total roadblock.

You've been avoiding my question. Maybe it wasn't as apparent enough.
Why are you sucking in all different ways in this game?

so is this just question Quaraezha hour oooorrrr what?

Quaraezha is really dodging all these questions. Tempted to vote on, but I want to wait and see what wojjan says.

Go well ahead, my sheep. Vote: Quaruazauhuhuaehuheuhehueu

No offense, Quar, but if you ain't gonna give us straight answers, you ain't worth keeping around.

Vote: Quaraezha

might as well bandwagon vote i guess but if he turns up townie then Wojan is next on my list
vote: Quaraezha

The is one mafia left, two at worst. There was no night kill, so there's probably a replacement doctor. Speak up. This is where you claim.

Prods for everyone. Time to end this game.

as my previous roleclaim. ima claim as townie.

I'm sure you are. I was actually only interested in the doc claim.

Wojjan wrote:

This is where you claim.

God, Wojjan, you're so pushy. But yeah, I suppose this is where I claim. Roleclaim Nurse. I don't have anything else to say right now, but feel free to ask if you have any questions, I guess?

Mashley wrote:

Wojjan wrote:

This is where you claim.

God, Wojjan, you're so pushy. But yeah, I suppose this is where I claim. Roleclaim Nurse. I don't have anything else to say right now, but feel free to ask if you have any questions, I guess?

uh i'm going to counterclaim Nurse. and then I am going to vote Mashley as he's now top of the list.

Who did you both protect?

I protected you wojan lol

I proted Wojjan, simply because you're a valuable player.

So the good news is I am a cleared and confirmed townie. Both of the docs protected me, and nobody died last night.

Oh right. I forgot to vote iMuffin for obvious reasons.

Jeez, that was a quick Night phase.

Wellp...suspicious that iMuffin counter-claims Mashley, then votes for him.
Not gonna jump the gun yet, but...I got my eye on you, brah.

You raise a good point. The night phase was indeed too quick. If there were two mafia I think they'd take a lot more time to work out the best plan. There has to be only one mafia left.

We just need to kill the counterclaimers (one of them is BOUND to be mafia) and we win!

good game, folks. I guess a roleclaim is in order as celebration.

SURVIVOR

mafia, if you let me live overnight in case we lynch wrong today, I'll joint with you against the remaining townie so we both win.

Vote: Mashley

Eh, i'm waiting on BakaloidSky.

I s'pose I should Role claim: Townie now.

edit: lol sniped, why so bandwagon Bakaloid?

Me thinks that Bakaloid and Muffin are in cahoots in some way.

E-Hooker wrote:

Me thinks that Bakaloid and Muffin are in cahoots in some way.

Then why was the night so short?

That's true.

Either way, i'm suspicious of the both of them more than i'm suspicious of Mashley.

Actually, I've been leery of Mash long beforehand, mostly because he was so standoffish towards Mimi's lynching. He was llike "meh I'll see what the others do first" and then never did anything. When I called him out on filler talk which he wasn't doing at all - contribution as a townie is usually only theories speculation and contemplative hmms - he apologised and said he'll pay attention not to do it anymore.

iMuffin has been suspicious, but I suspect he's more suspicious because he's bad than because he's mafia.

unvote

using my laptop keyboard this time which has some dead keys, 5 minutes before I sleep. Guess which key is not working.

reason for unvoting is because I just realized that imuffin didn't vote for kitsunemimi either after looking at the previous posts.

I'm actually wondering if there are masons in this game.

sorry guys, will be adding the missing letters later.

Edit : Added the missing "a"

I only counter claimed mashly cause he was on before me and is trying to assume my identity.

Wojjan wrote:

He was llike "meh I'll see what the others do first" and then never did anything.

I didn't have time to do anything, the hammer had already been done by the next time I checked the thread.

PRODS

PRODS FOR EVERYONE

GOSH WOJJIE, TAKE IT EASY, PEOPLE LIKE ME ARE STILL IN SCHOOL WHEN YOU REQUEST PRODS AND HAVE BEEN BUSY ALL DAY.

well what else can i do to prove that I am the nurse? and ofcourse vote against mash for trying to steal my role, it's pretty obvious why i would vote him

Has Bakaloid roleclaimed yet?

i don't think so.

it was brought to my attention that he roleclaimed townie.

Since, I figure, there isn't anybody left to counterclaim...he's not lying.
I haven't come to any conclusions that make sense, so vote: Mashley

Roles:

Role PM's:


Actions:

Link to Dead Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/BH2g7Mwj4JJcW

You can't prove I'm the serial killer, I haven't killed anyone!
Bakaloid's new name makes me think of cocks.

\:D/

inb4 my irl name is Koki, so you could guess how used I am to that pun.

Oh, we won, yaaaay.

congrats

lol we failed

Nice job guys.

Is there a mafia discussion thread too or did they communicate via PM?

So why me, Mafia? :(

It seems like everyone lost.

Oh yeah Wojjan, what was up with you claiming survivor?

0_o wrote:

Oh yeah Wojjan, what was up with you claiming survivor?

So Mafia won't kill him just in case?

Edit: Mafia Chat

I was actually hoping to fish out if there was two mafia or one. Had there been two mafia, one of them would have definitely gone along with my plan, and would have hoped to force nolynch with the survivor. I also wanted a safeguard to pick apart the last town/mafia in case we had a mafia between E-hooker and Kokizi. But I was going to be the likeliest target since both cops regarded me as a clear townie. Mafia can't afford having those around.

NoHItter wrote:

Quaraezha wrote:

Yeah, I'm fine with killing adam. lol

Guess who's getting nightkilled night 1 next time.
It's me again...

Anyway. I'm glad I hosted this first to see how everyone else plays.
TBH I suck at Mafia.

Good game, guys.

good game guys and also wooo i was right in protecting Wojan!

surprised that I never popped up in mafia PMs, hahaa.

I, on the other hand, get mentioned like every night.

iMuffin wrote:

good game guys and also wooo i was right in protecting Wojan!

and it was pretty darn lucky as well thinking of that 50% chance woah

bmin11 wrote:

iMuffin wrote:

good game guys and also wooo i was right in protecting Wojan!

and it was pretty darn lucky as well thinking of that 50% chance woah

I know right? also sorry i was not very active this game, first time i posted i was pretty tired and lazy and if i suddenly got too involved i'd raise suspicion. So i'll be more active next time guys

For reference, that's not a good way to go about that. It's better to apologise for your lazy post and contribute more afterwards than not saying anything the entire game.

thanks for the advice, i will remember that next time