pieguy
Claimed cop. No CC's. Has no results due to being roleblocked, and his first check was a bit strange.
Shouldn't have claimed that early. Pieguy KNEW there was a roleblocker in the game because his first action got blocked. HE shouldn't have claimed when he did, with only two or three votes on him.
- Town in my book, though not playing very well
Quaraezha
Odd phrasing of terms: "I don't want an innocent to die," "defend the innocent,"
I took the liberty of going through the filipino werewolf game. On day one of the six-player game, Quaraezha votes off Nadeko under the reasoning that he's the least experienced. He also says he is thinking of a good strategy that way. That was Quaeza's town play, as an aux role. Right now, he's playing super cautious, and tripping on scumisms like using the word innocent too much.
- Definitely on the top of my list
Kokizi
Odd for Kokiziloid to protect Quaraezha lilke that, calling him a townie, when his playstyle seems to perfectly contradict that last Tagalog game. If Quaraezha is innocent and has learnt from his mistake in that last game, at least Koki's reaction here is incredibly off.
But on the other hand, later in game Mimi outright attacks Kokizi in a very long post. This is a common mafia tactic, but usually those don't arouse a great response because the subject knows the accuser is in their team. Kokizi defended vibrantly, Mimi responded, etc. Doesn't seem to be a team.
- Sort of scummy, but I'm thinking town.
Mashley
Mashley has been actively following the thread, but when it came to contributing, he hasn't done much. Most of his posts don't really show him being active, they create the illusion of activity. He overreacts against adam's jokevote, posts a TF2 quote, and then some "I'm still around!" posts.
Delving deeper on that first vote, he unvotes adam soon after the moment he strikes supicion with it.
- I don't know, really. Can very well be mafia, laying low.
iMuffin
Interesting fact Mimi raises on Day 1:
Kitsunemimi wrote:
Dude, they have a week to post, they just want to see how stuff plays out for the first little while, so they don't make a dumb decision on the first day. Either that, or they actually don't know for some reason, but it's not like it really matters that much.
In reaction to Quaraezha laying bare the people who haven't spoken: pieguy1372, dkun, 0_o, and iMuffin
One of those is our cop, the others are dead, sans iMuffin. Does this mean anything? Is iMuffin the worst mafia player of the worst mafia mafia player? I think it could. It seems scanning with Mimi's general attitude to protect fellow mobsters from suspicion.
- I don't like his face, but seeing as he's playing while not even caring and generally mucking everything up for town I dunno lynch him when we get the chance.
E-Hooker
I have to admit my intuition on the first day is starting to seem off. E-Hooker has been actively contributing, posting regularly, and chipping in on a recurring basis with her thoughts and foses. Still, reading through the thread two separate post of her boil down to "Wojjie, I'm a townie, don't suspect me." That was odd, I guess, though one was provoked by a cop report and the godfather is dead. Still, pieguy could be an insane cop, and E-Hooker is really clinging to that report.
- Town-y? I'm not going to trust that cop report too much.
Wojjan
Nothing but towntells, and active scumhunting. Townie and best player ever.
In general I am inching towards Quaraezha and Mashley for these reasons:
- The mafia cover for one another. Mimi hadn't been accusing Mashley, Mashley hadn't been accusing Mimi. Mashley did suspect Quarz at some point, but that was only a meek FOS.
- These two are FOSes of a dead aux role, 0_o, who has been playing actively. I know I shouldn't be blindly following him, but someone who has been confirmed by death said to keep an eye out for these two.
I keep getting the feeling I'm contradicting myself and forgetting a whole lot. Oh well, incomplete analysis then.
