Starrodkirby86 wrote:

[Hard]:
00:41:97 (1,2) - Move (1) a little more left to make symmetrical? Done!
01:11:97 (8) - What an interesting cute little slider. Maybe you can have some alert with that? Subtle Storyboard Effect for the win? This goes for subsequent sliders like that. It's planned. I'm getting around to it.

[Hard]:
00:41:97 (1,2) - Move (1) a little more left to make symmetrical? Done!
01:11:97 (8) - What an interesting cute little slider. Maybe you can have some alert with that? Subtle Storyboard Effect for the win? This goes for subsequent sliders like that. It's planned. I'm getting around to it.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Storyboard:
Can you please add a higher quality bg if you can find one? This was the best I could find. I lied. Widescreen for everyone!!
Also, I guess try to remove the white outline around the Earth again. D: Done, thanks Starrod!!

Hard:

Normal mod:
01:11:97 (8.10) - Are these legal in a ranked map? If you want to keep these, I advise you sb a warning Planning to. Done.
02:13:14 (1,2) - this jump is quite large compared to the rest of your diff Shortened the jump!

Combo mod:
00:34:97 (1,2) - since the lyrics start on 2, remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2 "and leave tear drops everywhere <3"
01:13:14 (9) - new combo? Mmmm... Hard to say.
01:19:97 (2) - new combo because the vocals don't start till 2? "A discoball..."
01:24:80 (4) - new combo for end of vocals? Nuh, uh.
01:45:64 (7) - new combo? Long combo on purpose
02:52:30 (7) - new combo? ^
03:13:64 (7) - ^ ^

I also don't want to change the combos since I've SB'd some stuff based on those colors.

Timing section mod:
01:54:97 - move back a quarter note I could've sworn I never put a section directly on a note. o.o Fixed.
02:05:64 - ^ Fixed.
03:14:80 - move back a half note Moved forward instead

Nexy wrote:

Nice storyboard you got there <3! <333

Normal:
Hope you finish this o.o! -_-'

Hard:
Too much copy and pasting in here D:! Think of other patterns! I planned the chorus to be C&P'd. >_>

00:29:47 (1) - Not a good jump. Made a little closer to the right. Wanted to keep symmetry as much as possible.
01:10:97 (6) - Make the start of this aligned with 01:11:97 (8) end. I half agree, half don't. Agree to make the sliders not overlap. Not agree because of spacing and symmetry. I'll wait this one out.
01:11:97 (8) & 01:13:30 (10) - Are these rankable o.o? SB'd warning.
01:24:80 (4) - Restack properly. Oops. Fixed.
01:45:80 (1) - Finish. Done.
01:54:97 (1) - Bad jump. Doesn't flow with the music. Keeping symmetry. -_- Must fix?
02:05:64 (1) - ^ ^
02:15:64 (1) - ^ ^
02:25:97 (6) - Restack properly. I fail. >_< Fixed.

Unless you are mapping more of the song; end the storyboard a second or two after 03:14:80 (11). It was hard to see during the previous "hitcircle expansion" SBs, so I wanted this to be noticable.

rust45 wrote:

[Normal]
00:35:14 (4,5) - Offscreen D:
Why is this so similar to Hard? Maybe because it's not done yet? >_>

[Hard]
01:22:80 (1,2,3) - These got me on first couple tries, maybe SB a warning? Is the huge discoball a good hint? >_< Suggest me an SB warning.

YoshiKart wrote:

rust45 wrote:

01:22:80 (1,2,3) - These got me on first couple tries, maybe SB a warning? Is the huge discoball a good hint? >_< Suggest me an SB warning. Maybe an arrow pointing to the start of the next slider?

Zerostarry wrote:

02:09:974 (1,2,3,4) Fixed? Check it!
02:15:641 (1,2,3) I don't know how I'd change this. I used many a newcombocolor jump, so this should be fine? Suggest something, Zero.

Derekku Chan wrote:

[General]
woo kirby map Kirbyyyyy <3
woo sexy sb (I love it <3) Thank youuuuu.
*soft-hitfinish is delayed. Intentional? O_O *checks*

[Normal]
No problems here~ >_> Darn you, Kirbyyyyy~!

[Hard]
01:54:097 (1) - Too far from the last note. Yeah, yeah, moved 5 down a little.
02:05:064 (1) - ^ ^
02:15:064 (1) - ^ I usually don't mind jumps like these, but because of the big notes and close spacing, they're really hard to tell D: I need like a third opinion and a way to change it. X_X
02:43:080 (4) - Could be a little closer to the end of (3), but that's just naziing probably =x Yupp. So, no, you. D:<
03:05:014 (4) - ^ ^_^

YoshiKart wrote:

Derekku Chan wrote:

woo kirby map

Kirbyyyyy <3

Azure_Kyte wrote:

Here's my mod

Blue = Suggestion Red = Check this

[Normal]
00:40:014 (3) - 1 grid to the left so that it's symmetrical with (1) Done.
00:41:047 (1) - Change this to a clap? [color=#FF0000]Kirby and I work "interchangeably" with hitsounds. Check out what we did here when compared to Normal. :O
00:42:047 (2) - Whistle-finish?[/color] ^
01:25:047 (1) - Lifting the two slider points at the bottom up by a grid makes the beginning and end of the slider line up Doing it, but I'll ask Kirby if he likes it later.
01:36:014 (1) - Lifting the two slider points at the bottom down by a grid makes the beginning and end of the slider line up ^
01:38:014 (3) - finish?
01:39:080 (1) - (slider end) finish? Sure.
01:42:080 (2) - (slider start) finish?[/color] ^
02:06:080 (3) - Move forward 1/4 beat and shorten by 1/4 beat Fixed, but kills the symmetry. Check it later, Kirby!
02:55:080 (1) - Try using this slider point layout here I'll let Kirby see to this. Keeping it the same for now... >_>
03:14:080 (1) - Do the final note SB like you did in [Hard] It was so awesome But I did. O_O Sometimes the SB dies in the editor, but it's fine anyway, even after a save. So, yeah, I already did this.

No problems found

[Hard]
00:38:097 (2,3) - Line up in the centre, but raised a little?(if you do this reverse 4) Okay!
01:25:047 (1) - Maybe add a slider point and move them out like this? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/497 (the third one must be off grid snap) Yupp!
02:13:030 - Note in the centre? That'd be a bit painful. Nah. >_>'
No problems found

Awesome SB, Awesome Beatmap, not starring this should be punishable by death.

Derekku Chan wrote:

D: I totally meant to write "woo yoshi map" XD

so uh... WOO kirby/yoshi map

supergarlic wrote:

Normal:
01:56:014 (1,2,3,4) - spacing feels wide compared to other areas of the map *looks for Kirby* I think it's fine, though...

Hard:
00:34:047 (1) - sort of covers the reverse in slider 3 Suggestions?
00:39:014 (3,4) - spacing is pretty wierd here ;[ Tried to be symmetric and properly spaced as much as possible D:
01:11:097 (8,10) - i doubt you are going to change these sliders so at least stack their endpoints. Got it.
01:22:080 (1,2,3,4) - i really dont like this :/. Try 1/2 speed sliders here instead of these overlapping sliders Fixed!
02:34:014 (5,1) - you don't need to but i suggest making the reverse more visible. Ehh. Can't.
02:53:047 (11) - you realise the sb shoots a green #1 instead of a #11? Surprisingly fixed!
02:55:047 (5,1) - you don't need to but i suggest making the reverse more visible. ^
03:14:080 (11) - you realise the sb shoots a blue #1 instead of a #11? ^

consider mapping the end of the song o.0 Thinking of an SB.

starred Thanks!

eee wrote:

simply amazing
almost every aspect of the map is fine, not just because it's storyboarded.
I like the song as well
STAR!!

GolemdX wrote:

May I suggest making the speed of the firefly(ies) at the beginning a little less linear? The speed it moves at doesn't really 'fit' the path it's moving. Other than that, it's great!

Ephemeral wrote:

Offset should be 10,802 (slightly audible difference on the chorus chord progression at .75x speed) Got it.

Why is soft-hitfinish delayed? Fixed. >_>

Absolutely amazing ambient storyboard - though I think you could probably find a better set of rotating earth sprites. I've also never seen a white firefly before - aren't they usually orange? Will consider.

CheeseWarlock wrote:

I nazi because I care. Uh, oh...

[General/Storyboard]
The Earth sprites could stand to be less pixellated, or at least fixed up so there's not that little bit of white around the edges. Thanks to obey_the_soapbubble.
I don't think it's necessary to go back to the Fireflies background at the end. I'll consider it; I was really going for a scale in and out effect with two backgrounds.

[Hard]
00:36:968 - I feel like there should be another hitcircle here. This is more focused on vocals, so I dunno...
01:22:802 (1,2,3,4) - This is the only 0.5x section in the map, so it feels out of place, and I find it doesn't work that well anyway. I'm going back to 1x then, but I'll need a pattern that people like that wasn't the previous one.
01:38:802 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - Nothing wrong, per se, but I wish this were mapped more to the vocals. I guess Starrod and I mapped this part of the chorus for background rhythm and the following two choruses for vocals.
02:14:802 (5,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - This part doesn't flow like the rest of the map does. The spacing is strange, and some of the "down-hits" (hitcircles and slider starts) land on weak notes in the music. Looks like I'm changing this.

[Normal]
01:38:802 (1,2,3,1,1,2,3,4) - Ditto the comment on [Hard], but it's less of an issue here.^

Xgor wrote:

[Hard]
01:20:063 (4,5) - Quite low down Moved up a bit.

Superb map so a Big star for you :3
Why is it is WIP??!! SB! xD
*star*

obey_the_soapbubble wrote:

The white around the earth really bugged me though so I made a version without it, I hope that's okay? This helped a bunch. Thanks!!

Derekku Chan wrote:

*Sprites look much better.
*soft-hitfinish is no longer delayed.
*I see that the SB is moved up to compensate for the grid being moved up (orz). orz
*I don't really like the comboburst sound that's in the folder. For people like me that don't use combo bursts, it just sounds out of place and distracting. Could you delete it or force osu! default skin or something? =X I'm not really sure what to say about this... D: Removed

EDIT: Whoops, dunno how I missed this. Max bg res is 1024x768, and yours is 1228 width. Please resize it and resubmit, thanks. :3 Resized, and adjusted SB to account for resize.

LuigiHann wrote:

While I'm in favor of weird things like that in general, those "dance" sliders probably shouldn't have been ranked in their current condition. They're just a tad too unpredictable and the SB warning doesn't particularly help. The main problem is that the SB warning doesn't give any indication of when to release the slider, which is a severe issue. Not unranking the map because it's been up for long enough that too many people have played it by this point.

Larto wrote:

To inform the mapper about it so he can think about it and maybe improve his mapping/storyboarding based on LH's criticism.

greenpoint0 wrote:

I have a couple qualms about this version.
1) It's easy to get caught up in the lyrics and then you start hitting notes that aren't there. In other words, I don't know what rhythm you're mapping.
2) You do some painful cookie cutter patterns which really miff me.

On the other hand, your saving graces:
1) Clever Storyboarding
2) Unique "unrankable" sliders. Took me a bit to get used to them, but they were actually clever as hell.

It's aesthetically very nice... the content might actually need some work on to not bore/deceive.

E-Hooker wrote:

and you're commenting on this 9 months later because...?

Jarby wrote:

E-Hooker wrote:

and you're commenting on this 9 months later because...?

It's always good for a mapper to receive feedback.